11 Ups & 1 Down From AEW Dynamite (Jun 14 - Review)

CM Punk has some scores to settle, The Elite have more problems & MJF has another Match Of The Year.

Jon Moxley Eddie Kingston
AEW

Despite the largely unfavourable reviews for May's Double Or Nothing pay-per-view (and indeed the build towards it), Tony Khan was typically enthusiastic about all there was to follow for All Elite Wrestling in June.

The promoter has to promote, but truthfully the optimism felt a little forced. Yes, Fight Forever was finally being released, yes Forbidden Door was something to get buzzed for after 2022's show-of-the-year effort and yes Collision kicking off on TNT was as great for AEW as all the great matches we get every week on great episodes of Dynamite and Rampage and Dark and Dark: Elevation featuring all the great wrestlers and great stories. But great's in the eye of the beholder, and not many were sharing Khan's vision.

Were.

Dynamite roared back into form following the pay-per-view, CM Punk buzz/confusion/bewilderment began in earnest, clips of the game drew raves from those hyped to bloody up their opponents with kickflips, and Khan's claims of Forbidden Door being the best show in the history of both AEW and NJPW didn't seem that wild when the double main event of Omega Vs Ospreay and Okada Vs Danielson were announced out the gate.

Maybe the power is back? The only way to check is to light the fuse...


Downs…

1. Wardlow Vs Jake Hager

Jake Hager Wardlow
AEW

In a pre-match hype video, TNT Champion Wardlow discussed the upcoming outing against Jake Hager as if it was the latest chapter in a legacy feud.

By the strictest definition he was correct, but chapters as inconsequential as this and some of the ones that came before it only feature in books nobody chooses to read. An odd call-back to long-gone time, this bit of matchmaking was only ever cute at best and Hager's limitations stood firm in the way of 'The Wardog's growth as a babyface in the years that passed.

This was dull and formulaic and would have been far better had Wardlow soundly defeated any number of dynamic talents backstage or, if looking for another monster, Big Bill. It was made no better for the post-match either. Christian Cage and Luchasaurus bloodied up Arn Anderson backstage just like they'd done to Brock seven days ago. Well, not just like it, 'Double A' looked actually bludgeoned rather than stained with a used teabag. The magnitude of the moment was plagued by some trademark sound and production issues and the creeping sense in the building that the programme already peaked at Double Or Nothing.


Ups…

11. MJF Vs Adam Cole

Adam Cole MJF
AEW

It’s always chess match first, wrestling match second with MJF.

Yes, he’ll try and cheat three moves ahead rather than wrestle them, but the methods remain the same and the examples of just how effective his style is continue to pile higher than just about all of his contemporaries.A sublime master strategist within the fairly strict confines of kayfabe his character adheres to, the ‘Salt Of The Earth’s eventual babyface turn will be so earned because he’s everything he says he is and then some.

In the meantime, he’s rebooted Adam Cole’s own heroic return after it had badly stuttered in his programme with Chris Jericho.He might have chased every shortcut when his traps to set them up worked, but that’s the sort of guile and gumption that’s too admirable to despise. His constant avoidance of the Boom, his constant targeting of Cole’s arm and his constant desire to “dance with what brung him” (the ring, the belt, the table spot from Revolution) were sublime in the moment and even better when he’d successfully ran down the clock.

Time limit draws rule anyway, but they go even harder when the matches are good enough to have fans begging for the extra five minutes as much as the babyface. Cole will get every minute he needs against the Champion down the road, this much is clear. But the former NXT Champion was presented with a more sophisticated challenge here, and he’ll need to tap into that beautiful mind of his to solve the puzzle second time around.


10. Return Of The Punker

CM Punk
AEW

CM Punk has scores to settle.

CM Punk doesn’t know what he’s going to say until he’s in the ring with a microphone in his hand.

CM Punk has a lot of things to get off his chest.

The only thing for certain about CM Punk, is that nothing's for certain.

Alls he’s saying right now is that Saturday’s Collision is unmissable stuff. There was quite the sharp contrast between FTR and Bullet Club Gold building the match later on the show, which served as yet another reminder of how much more captivating the facts are than any kind of fiction, but few have walked the line better in the history of the industry than CM Punk.

He’s back, and love him, hate him or no-longer-even-know-what-you-want-from-him, he made it impossible not to want to tune in to watch him.The clobberin’s already been promoted. What else will it be time for on Saturday night?


9. Are Le Sex Gods Shagged Out?

Sammy Guevara
AEW

One of the (many) problems with the Four Pillars AEW Championship match build ahead of Double Or Nothing was how difficult it was to suddenly back Sammy Guevara out of the blue.

Various attempts to get him over as a face had failed in the past, and this looked like it was going the same way, but might it have actually worked now there’s no threat of him dethroning MJF?

Suddenly the aw-shucks Father-to-be stuff felt real enough to resonate, especially when the mask slipped at Chris Jericho’s expense rather than Darby Allin’s. The Pillars shared a mutual respect that felt absent between Le Sex Gods, and old head Jericho set up next week’s really cool tag match to harness that.

A word on Jericho/Sting too - yet another wonderful use of industry icons in a company with a very, very good track record, getting Tony Schiavone to quickly confirm that they’d never even crossed paths in WCW let alone anywhere else was such a great detail for the viewers at home. Those in the building didn’t needed it - Jericho and Sting going bat-to-bat was more than enough.


8. Mogul Embassy Vs Sting, Darby Allin, Orange Cassidy & Keith Lee

Swerve Strickland Darby Allin
AEW

A luxurious and rare television party match best summed up by Brian Cage literally working in fancy dress as one of his opponents from thirty years ago, the eight-man tag match pitting Mogul Embassy agains Sting, Darby Allin, Orange Cassidy and Keith Lee was a wonderful addition to a show that already had a special atmosphere.

All four babyfaces got shine in what, regrettably, might have been the most entertaining way to pay off what remains of Swerve Strickland Vs Keith Lee as AEW yet again used ‘The Stinger’ impeccably ahead of another tantalising tag next week.

All Elite Wrestling is often at its best when it takes the basics and does them better than anywhere else. Bastardised in WWE for far too long, the company launched in 2019 with the ethos of trying to do what the market leader refused to, and here was a perfect example of why. The good guys bested the bad guys, just the way you’d like, just the way you’d want, and restored enough justice for another seven days.

Tony Schiavone couldn’t hide how much he loved pro wrestling on commentary, and nor should he when it can still be this pure.


7. Open Challenge, Closed Mind

Jack Perry Sanada
AEW/NJPW

IWGP Champion SANADA offering an open challenge for Forbidden Door was already an “Up” before it was very neatly folded into one of the uneasier ongoing storylines in AEW at present.

The Champion offered it up to anybody, but rather than waiting for a surprise on the night, Jungle Boy Jack Perry jumped to the front of the queue…immediately after trumpeting that it was going to be the Summer Of Jungle Hook.The hours with Christian Cage were clearly well spent - Perry dripped with a brand new sense of insincerity here, simultaneously patronising Hook for having the FTW Title and jealously pining for something just like it or better as soon as he could.

The match sums up the uniqueness of a night like Forbidden Door, affords SANADA a relatively high profile retention on a North American stage, and gives AEW regulars a significant next chapter in Perry descent towards the dark side.


6. Nightmare For MJF Sets Up Another Forbidden Door Dream Match

MJF Hiroshi Tanahashi
AEW/NJPW

Hiroshi Tanahashi was so charming in his video messaging challenging MJF for Forbidden Door.

'The Ace' was as endearing as always, making the match even more appealing before the 'Salt Of The Earth' even had time to reject it.

The AEW Champion's unfiltered disdain for New Japan Pro-Wrestling has been a joyous character detail for years, and his worked shoot absence last summer left the bit untouched for the inaugural pay-per-view. A completely different proposition to the Will Ospreay/Kenny Omega and Kazuchika Okada/Bryan Danielson encounters, this third main event tier outing could and should be a psychological masterclass and inch-perfect portrayal of how best to do hero vs villain in 2023.

Tanahashi's amazing body of work has caught up with his actual body over the last few years, and it's that degradation that disgusts MJF so much in the first place. He already holds one of the most beloved wrestlers in the world in contempt and they've not even locked up. Pro wrestling magic resides here, and MJF trying to break the spell before its even been cast in the build will only strengthen the bout on the night.


5. The Finest In-Ring Performer In The World...And Zack Sabre Jr

Orange Cassidy Zack Sabre Jr
AEW

Orange Cassidy and Zack Sabre Jr set the table for yet another tantalising Forbidden Door offering as the two came face-to-face and belt-to-belt in a knowing backstage segment that got away with how contrived it was for the outcomes and the quality of the bullsh*t on display.

An exasperated Cassidy stood alongside new best bud Renee Paquette wearily awaiting his next interruption, and was duly rewarded with ZSJ barging into shot to call him "Orange B*llocks" and pave the way to the pay-per-view. Daniel Garcia was none-too-pleased with this and also had strong words for ROH Pure Champion Katsoyori Shibata.

'Freshly Squeezed' knows fightin' words when he hears 'em, but in his typically sardonic fashion just put the tag team match together on the spot for next week's Dynamite. Not one but two potentially great singles matches appear certain to occur off the back of a very-AEW tag team affair en route. This particular Dynamite fostered so much about what people love about Tony Khan's booking that it was almost too easy to overlook these developments. The four wrestlers won't care about that when they're kicking the a*se out of their tag match next week.


4. Toni Storm Vs Skye Blue

Toni Storm Skye Blue
AEW

Toni Storm made a solid argument for being the best AEW Women's Champion ever in 2022, and she picked right back up where she left off in her first defence of her second run against Skye Blue.

A phenomenally-agented effort got the response it deserved, with Blue's recent babyface fire being given free rein to set the building ablaze before she ultimately succumbed to The Outcasts' chicanery and Storm's experience and skill.

Such was the occasion for the challenger that her mother was sat in the front row, and Mrs Blue became key to the chaos when Storm and Soho attacked her with spray paint for major heat. A dive took them both out and opened the door for the most unlikely of hope spots - blue spray paint to counter the green! Fans were molten for the title change, manipulated as they were by Storm's fantastic selling and Skye Blue's suddenly-epic-feeling babyface charisma. Soho taking the referee after a Code Blue was cruel to the emotions of the locked-in crowd, but the kick out by Blue from a wicked Storm Zero was received like a gift from the heavens.

It wasn't to be - Storm wrapped it up with a Cloverleaf but a post-match beatdown was interrupted by Willow Nightingale to set up a strong Collision undercard attraction.

Speaking of which....


3. Collision Takes Shape

Miro Collision
AEW

It was odd hearing Excalibur tee up Collision in the spot once occupied by Rampage (that card was put together on the proverbial napkin as the show was going off the air - more on that later), but Saturday's debut is set to offer more than just CM Punk's return.

Andrade taking on Buddy Matthews was almost snuck on the card but could steal the whole show. The aforementioned women's tag team match could be setting the stage for a Thunder Rosa return (and swerve turn?), and Miro's first match of 2023 and first AEW contest since September 2022's All Out pay-per-view stands to be a squash so gnarly that he'll probably be back in title contention by the end of the night.

Tony Khan is under immense pressure not to see his new vehicle go the way of Rampage, and though no such judgments can be arrived upon from the debut alone, the stage has been extremely well set for Things Being Different This Time.


2. The Elite Vs The Blackpool Combat Club

The Elite Wheeler Yuta
AEW

A quality main event afforded The Elite a measure of revenge against The Blackpool Combat Club, with the latter crew absorbing their first loss alongside Jon Moxley since last year's Anarchy In The Arena.

Bryan Danielson spouted propaganda on commentary about exactly how reunited Hangman Page and The Young Bucks were, but his arrogance was undone by a tight and assured offering from The Hung Bucks. They had too much speed, too many ariels, and an abundance of answers to the questions The BCC were asking with their attacks. Danielson raged at the quality of pinfalls as usual, but for a change he was missing the point - all that sweaty gym training didn't account for the strengthened bond between the "heart, soul and spirit" of AEW.

Anarchy In The Arena 2 may prove to be a pyrrhic victory for the heels if losing this fairer fight is anything to go by. Not that fair fights were even considered part of the conversation following events that took place after the bell...


1. "This 2023 Dynamite Ending Was GOATed Flame Emoji"

Kenny Omega Will Ospreay
AEW

...is what engagement accounts will type on 2043's version of social media if the amount of play that SmackDown 2001 conclusion gets is anything to go by.

A chaotic end to the show brought about four shock run-ins, three of which were totally unannounced, two of which were surprise returns to AEW and one of which left a major question heading into a blockbuster Blood & Guts match that continues to take shape.

Eddie Kingston was first to arrive back on the scene, charging for Claudio Castagnoli to resume hostilities from their ROH Championship match at Supercard Of Honor earlier this year. Saving The Young Bucks in the moment, he was suddenly face-to-face with Jon Moxley and an entire crowd switched from roaring their support to holding their breath. No conclusive outcome was forthcoming before Konosuke Takeshita broke up the moment by attacking 'The Mad King' from behind to seemingly draw brand new battle lines.

He wasn't safe for long. Kenny Omega - thought to still be in Japan calling on help from friends - stormed the ring, but before he could V-Trigger Takeshita into the waiting arms of Don Callis on the floor, Forbidden Door opponent Will Ospreay struck. Getting the better of Kenny with the Stormbreaker, he got the last word in-ring as Excalibur rushed to get his out before the show rushed off the air. The gist there was that Ospreay would be work Rampage in a trios match, which slightly broke the immersion on screen even if fans in the building remained unglued.

The power, like the Punker, appears back. On the evidence of another outstanding Dynamite, it'd be brilliant to see both stick around this time.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.