11 Ups & 5 Downs From AEW Dynamite (Oct 9)
The Young Bucks & Private Party raise the roof; Chris Jericho blows it off.
AEW Dynamite roared into existence with a strong debut show last week, with Jon Moxley Paradigm Shifting Kenny Omega through a glass table, Jake Hager's debut, and Riho's coronation as Women's World Champion highlighting a crowd-popping episode that trounced NXT in the Wednesday Night War's first round.
Round two was a similar story. A combination of hot angles, good matches (for the most part), and one particularly stellar promo, Dynamite's second episode hit even harder than its first.
This show promised much, with The Young Bucks and Private Party set to collide in the tag team tournament, Chris Jericho promising an explanation after last week's apparent stable formation, a Darby Allin vs. Jimmy Havoc number one contender's match, and Jon Moxley's bout with Shawn Spears all on deck. There were mishits, but that's fine. Not everything is going to work all of the time and growing pains were inevitable. The next few weeks are about ensuring that the problems of the first two episodes don't become lingering habits, and AEW deserves our trust in that regard.
On the positive side, AEW knocked everything that mattered right out of the park last night. Let's break it down...
Downs...
5. Jake Hagar
Chris Jericho calling Hangman Page "The Hang Man" at Fight for the Fallen worked. It came off like the future AEW Champion was deliberately getting his All Out opponent's name wrong as an in-character burial, as if he had so little regard for Page that he didn't even know his proper ring name. That worked.
Jericho calling stablemate Jake Hager "Jake Hagar", however? Not a good look. At all.
The AEW Champion should, at the very least, be able to get his Inner Circle buddy's name right. Hager made a massive impact to close last week's Dynamite and is now tied to Jericho's hip. If this is an in-character thing, it doesn't make any sense, and if Chris is just straight-up making a mistake, it's a really bad look.
A nitpick? Perhaps, but little things like this matter.
4. Stop F*cking Squealing
Please, Isiah Kasidy, for the love of God, stop squealing in the ring. It might be the most obnoxious thing in American wrestling right now.
Thank you.
3. Fix The Music
This has been a constant complaint on every AEW show so far, so it certainly isn't exclusive to this episode of Dynamite, but it's about time the promotion fixed the way they mix entrance themes. Like, seriously.
While things have improved since AEW's first few events, themes are still way too low in the mix. They aren't hooked straight into the desk and therefore sound thin and quiet when watching at home. This is a particularly notable production flaw because it's something that WWE do really, really well, so if AEW aren't hitting the same standards, they almost come off second-rate by comparison. It's something they need to look at tweaking ASAP.
This audio issue is the one thing holding AEW's production back at the moment, as every other aspect give the impression of a company that's far more major-league than NXT and it's tiny little building. Fingers crossed AEW gets it together.
2. Wins & Losses Matter?
For a promotion that keeps going out of their way to push the idea that wins and losses matter, the booking of Darby Allin vs. Jimmy Havoc as a number one contender's bout was curious.
Allin and Havoc had both wrestled four times for AEW when the match with announced. Each had only one singles victory to their name, with Havoc's triumph coming over Allin and Joey Janela in a Triple Threat. While Darby's draw with Full Gear challenger Cody almost justifies his spot, this is nullified by Jimmy's win over him, as the booking rendered their All Out outcome irrelevant.
Meanwhile, PAC is sitting on a 2-0 record. What gives?
Perhaps AEW don't want to burn PAC's first loss yet. Regardless, he had more of a case to be in the bout than either Allin or Havoc, thus giving AEW their first booking conundrum with these win/loss records. Here's hoping they figure it out going forward.
1. Havoc Vs. Allin Falls Flat
Jim Ross noted in his introduction to Jimmy Havoc vs. Darby Allin that neither wrestler likes the idea that they'd been typecast as a "hardcore guy" and each was keen to show they can do more, though JR didn't think this would hinder their craziness.
It did, to the match's detriment.
Havoc and Allin got the layout wrong here. Though they incorporated a couple of big-hitting spots (Havoc's suplex over the top rope and to the outside was nasty), they nullified many of Darby's strengths by having him work from beneath against an unengaging controller for 80% of the runtime. Allin is a good selling, can bump like a maniac, and draws sympathy, but his trademark propulsiveness was neutered as Havoc ground him down. Jimmy, meanwhile, isn't a convincing enough dominator to keep the crowd invested when working a conventional control sequence; he's grimy (biting hands and twisting fingers), but no ring general.
While this number one contender's bout didn't need to be an all-out spotfest to succeed, it was desperately lacking in energy. This is a shame, though the warning signs were there in JR's framing and Havoc's ghastly inset promo, and while it's hard to call the contest outright bad, a more popping clash would've sent Allin towards Jericho with more momentum.
Ups...
11. A Good Sign
Private Party going over The Young Bucks in the tag team tournament was the right choice and bodes well for how The Elite will book themselves going forward.
Being cynical about The Bucks, Cody, and co.'s pushes was easy early on, as wrestling history tells us that most stars find it extremely difficult not to favour themselves when they're got the pencil. On top of this, many an eye was rolled when the tourney brackets were revealed and pointed towards another Bucks/Lucha Brothers clash in the second round. Both concerns were averted with Marq Quen and Isiah Kasidy's triumph.
There's obviously a long, long way to go yet, but the Jackson brothers haven't won since Double Or Nothing, Omega is on his own three-match skid, and so is Hangman Page. While Cody is the exception, the crowd receives him like the biggest star in the universe. His positioning is justified.
Let's hope this continues.
10. Recovery Job
Britt Baker and Bea Priestley had a lot of ground to recover last night.
The AEW Dark tag match pitting Baker and Allie against Priestley and Penelope Ford was a clunky, disappointing plodder for which the feuding duo were most culpable. The 10-minute runtime felt like at least triple that. It was therefore imperative that Dynamite's tag bout delivered at a higher level, and while Priestley and Emi Sakura vs. Baker and Riho was no home run, it was a marked improvement on Dark's disarray.
Sakura proved herself a strong show-woman in the early stage, grinding down on trainee Riho with veteran efficiency. That she was able to hoss the AEW Women's Champion around despite standing at just 5'2" was impressive. Upon tagging in, Bea went straight after Britt on the apron and they brawled on the outside, with Baker's Thesz Press drawing a decent response from the crowd before the heels wore her out, leading to the inevitable Riho recovery.
Riho looked good offensively and defensively and her opponents worked well as a team, executing flurries of convincing tandem offence. Baker tapping Emi out, meanwhile, secures her a Women's Title shot for next week. That could be fun, though there's still work to be done if the Priestley feud is to heat up.
9. Starting Hot
AEW Dynamite kicked straight into a fire match for the second week running last night - and it ruled.
While main roster WWE shows tend to begin with a big talking segment, AEW roll straight into a hot bout featuring over stars to take advantage of the fired-up crowd from Dynamite's first minute. It's a smart tactic for now. The quality of the action is key, of course, but if you're trying to market yourself as a more wrestling-centric promotion, it makes great sense to get straight to it.
There will come a time when AEW need to start switching things up with these show openings, but this will never be a major concern unless the matches start to wane. If they deliver, it's fine.
8. A Shot Of Moxley
Jon Moxley vs. Shawn Spears was the weirdest match on Dynamite's card because, well... what the hell could anyone have reasonably expected from it? Mox is one of the hottest things in wrestling but coming off a staph infection. Spears, meanwhile, should be hungry, fired up, and determined to prove his former employers wrong, despite losing at All Out, though he has never been the most colourful performer between the ropes. Really, the bout's quality could've gone either way.
It ended up towards the lower end of the scale. This was a solid, enjoyable clash that fit its positioning, but not necessarily anything anyone needs to catch up on.
Spears performance was languid, which is a real shame after the Cody bout. It looks increasingly like that "good hand" comment was an accurate appraisal of his most appropriate role going forward. Fortunately, Mox is an instant bolt of energy to any ring he steps into and, clad in his New Japan tights, he entered a strong performance, particularly when interacting with the weaselly Tully Blanchard. His Paradigm Shift victory was the right move, too.
7. Violent Delights
Is Kenny Omega and Jon Moxley's Full Gear match about to get some kind of hardcore stipulation? It certainly seems that way, as 'The Cleaner' walked out in grimy plunder clothes with a set of barbed wire wrapped weapons following Mox's win over Shawn Spears: a bat for the 'Purveyor Of Violence,' and a mop for himself. Later, Omega wrestled Joey Janela in a 27-minute (!) Lights Out match taped for Dark.
'The Beast Bout Machine's' posturing didn't last long as PAC jumped him from behind, knocking his All Out opponent to the deck with a steel chair. There's still beef there, clearly, and Moxley let 'The Bastard' leave before striding past Kenny himself.
Effective in furthering the Moxley/Omega rivalry, re-establishing Kenny vs. PAC, and setting up a potential PAC/Mox relationship, this post-match worked.
6. PAC Is P*ssed
PAC came out for a guest commentary spot on Shawn Spears vs. Jon Moxley, using the opportunity to vent at AEW fans and management without detracting from anything going on in the ring.
Full of p*ss and vinegar, 'The Bastard' claimed that he refused to be denied opportunities by All Elite Wrestling, calling the promotion, its supporters, and Moxley ungrateful for what they'd done for him. These comments were sandwiched between a direction complaint re: the Darby Allin vs. Jimmy Havoc number one contender's bout. PAC wasn't pleased about the hardcore duo getting that opportunity before him at all, and neither should he be. The man was overlooked. Yes, he cheated to defeat Hangman Page, but he's 2-0 against a couple of AEW's top stars. His rage was entirely justified.
AEW were smart to capitalise on the confusion surrounding the Havoc/Allin justification here. They've now made it part of PAC's character arc, and the sneering Geordie did a grand job of getting this over.
5. Darby Allin Vs. Chris Jericho
The Jimmy Havoc match was a letdown, but holy hell, Darby Allin vs. Chris Jericho is going to be a sh*tload of fun.
Allin has already been established as a potential spoiler thanks to his draw with Cody. He pushed Jericho's Full Gear opponent to his absolute limit, with 'The American Nightmare' unable to defeat him within the allotted time limit, making him a credible opponent for the AEW World Champion. He's going to lose, of course he is, but just like Cody, Jericho is going to do everything in his power to get Darby over in defeat, and will batter, bludgeon, and throw the crazy bumper all across ringside with his new, brawling style.
This was absolutely the right choice for next week's show and Allin's crowd response in the closing angle shows people are into it, with the Jericho match now set to establish Darby as AEW's biggest rising star.
4. Fire & Thunder
Dynamite's Dustin Rhodes and Hangman Page vs. Chris Jericho and Sammy Guevara main event was set up on this week's Being The Elite, during which Page was criticised for not helping Cody, Dustin, and the Young Bucks as Chris Jericho's new stable beat them down. Conceding he was in the wrong, Hangman vowed to step up.
This one started hot, with Dustin, the crowd's sentimental favourite, absolutely furious with Jericho. He beat the AEW Champion's arse right away, knocking him all over the place to the point where 'The Painmaker' was neutralised on the outside. Dustin's focus then turned to beating young Sammy into shape. He worked with fire, passion, and conviction, and so did Page, whose performances have gone up since Fight for the Fallen's wet fart of a bout with Kip Sabian.
An extended heat segment saw Page work the face-in-peril spot before firing back with a starchy discus clothesline on Guevara. The babyfaces couldn't muster enough momentum to win, though: that was cut off when Jake Hager interjected as Sammy occupied the referee, allowing Jericho to nail Dustin with the Judas Effect for the W.
A great tag bout with a classic formula and two compelling veteran/up-and-comer combinations, this hit the spot.
3. Le Champion's Address
Everything from this Up onwards was absolutely outstanding. Seriously, ranking these points was tough, but here's Chris Jericho's promo.
'Le Champion' strutted out with his new gang of pals soon after The Young Bucks vs. Private Party. This was promised in a post-show video uploaded to social media, and the segment began with the AEW Champion crediting himself for last week's show being the highest-rated TNT premiere. "Thank you Jericho" chants broke out. Fortunately, 'Y2J' was quick to tell the audience to shut the hell up, turning the reaction all the way around.
"We are next, we are now," Jericho said, revealing his new stable as the Inner Circle after putting every individual member over. Things got particularly interesting when he came to Jake Hager. The former Jack Swagger inspired "we the people" calls immediately, prompting Jericho to once again demonstrate his mastery of crowd control: "'We the People' sucks and it's dead and buried. It was a stupid idea from bad creative and all that is gone."
Jericho's focus then shifted to Cody, who he promised to "beat the ever-living sh*t out of" at Full Gear before roaming around Baltimore, "having a little bit of the bubbly in celebration."
Impeccable delivery, great crowd control, putting his friends over, naming the stable, hyping the Cody match, popping the boys: the number of things Jericho achieved in this relatively short space of time should be studied by any aspiring promo artist. He's a master.
2. One Angle, Many Stories
Speaking of accomplishing lots of different things in a short period, how about that show-closing angle? This did everything it needed to - and more.
It began with a straightforward three-on-one attack on Dustin Rhodes before Hangman Page fired back, throwing a chair in Jake Hager's face, then brawling with him to the back. Cody got the arena blackout spot before the lights came back on to a massive pop. His Cross Rhodes decked Sammy, leaving him alone with Jericho, but in came Santana and Ortiz for another momentum shift.
Cue: MJF. Cody's apparent "best friend" was brilliant here. Armed with a steel chair, he teased the big heel turned as the Inner Circle held 'The American Nightmare' at his mercy, with the 'Salt of the Earth's' inner conflict etched on his face. He didn't cave, though. Instead, MJF crushed the heels to a big pop... and then f*cking Darby Allin SKATED DOWN THE GODDAMN RAMP to attack Jericho. Good lord.
A list of things this pushed forward/established:-
- Hangman Page vs. Jake Hager.
- The Young Bucks vs. Santana and Ortiz.
- Cody vs. Chris Jericho.
- The MJF heel turn.
... and it played out to the loudest reactions of the night. Perfect professional wrestling.
1. Welcome To The Party
The Young Bucks might be the most underrated in-ring storytellers in the world on account of the volume of people who still write them off as no-selling flippydoos. If that's your take, you aren't paying attention to matches like last night's with Private Party.
Yes, the bout possessed all kinds of fluid, fast-moving, athletic spots, but the psychology was sublime. Matt Jackson spent much of 2018 selling a back injury. It came up in almost every match, with the elder Buck coming up with new, creative ways to work it into his performances each time. Against Isiah Kasidy and Marq Quen, Jackson proved that he'd learned from those experiences by putting his pain on Kasidy. His Powerbomb on the ramp established the injury. Kasidy was hindered thereafter, cringing with every movement, and Matt worked over his back like many an opponent did to him in 2018. He has evolved.
Framed as something of a passing of the torch (with the announcers comparing Private Party to the Bucks of 10 years ago), the match was fantastic. Quen and Kasidy worked babyface against the Jacksons, who were in full-on New Japan d*ckhead mode from their entrance onwards, it shot forward with great energy and adrenaline yet still found room for important story beats. The finish was key, too, with Quen rolling Matt up as the Bucks attempted the Meltzer Driver, with Kasidy decking Nick on the outside.
Private Party celebrated in the crowd afterwards. This win might prove to be the making of them.