15 MORE Wrestling Gimmicks That Got Weird Rip-Offs

Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, unless WWE, AEW and TNA are paying you for it...

Blue Tilly
TNA

Blake Monroe's getting mixed reviews in her WWE/NXT run, as much for the fact that it feels like a lightweight follow-on from her time as Mariah May in AEW.

Her character is understandably similar to the one she portrayed for just under two years on the challenger brand, but she's filled in the gap by borrowing much from Timeless Toni Storm's work against her. It might be nothing more than affectionate tribute, but those standards were so high that she's found herself considered lesser-than as a result. She won't be the first or last, and really how much can ever be truly original anyway? Monroe's borrows are nothing compared to some from yesteryear. 

WWE effectively tried to rebuild its tag division not with rip-offs but by cloning a singles wrestler to split one gimmick across two men. Skip introduced a shaven-headed Tom Prichard as his BodyDonnas partner Zip, babyfaced Henry Godwinn brought Phineas along for the ride, Barry Windham and Justin 'Hawk' Bradshaw temporarily revived their flagging fortunes with a New Blackjacks gimmick, and even Al Snow's latest attempt to get over in WWE came via sporting a colourful singlet and tagging with Marty Jannetty as The Rockers were rebooted some four years after their famous disbanding.  

It wasn't the first time Marty was being accused of a rehash, though the first attempt went a lot better than the second... 

15. The Rock & Roll Express (The Rockers)

The Rockers Shawn Michaels Marty Jannetty
WWE

Shawn Michaels and Marty Jannetty were both so athletic, so good looking, and so vital to WWE's mid/late-1980s expansion that there was never a chance they'd be confused for lesser-thans even when positioned right next to the originals.

Ricky Morton and Robert Gibson were era-defining babyfaces in the 1980s, but with WWE's promotional machine and a day-glo update, The Rockers were able to use the template to find a global audience beyond the originals.

Ricky and Robert won countless titles and engaged in fantastic blood feuds - things Shawn and Marty never managed during their 1987-1991 stint with the market leader. But suddenly, those things had never mattered less to a brand new audience. In WWE's land of the giants, The Rockers were something entirely different, and lit up shows with matches so far beyond the quality of most of their contemporaries that they looked as though they'd descended from an alien planet rather than very same territories the Rock & Roll Express had previously owned.

Superbly produced and executed, their Barber Shop split is fondly remembered by wrestling fans of all stripes as one of the greatest in the history of the industry. Just six months earlier, Ricky had turned on Robert in WCW in a story that mostly passed without mention and was undone a year later. Was this evidence that one were always more solid as a unit than the other, or a reality check that the imitators has ultimately out-stripped the originals?


14. Ultimate Warrior (One Warrior Nation)

One Warrior Nation
youtube.com/@onewarriornationllc

Not always the brightest bulb when asked to speak on certain issues publicly, Ultimate Warrior was nonetheless protective of his intellectual property for a very good reason - it was very easy for people to rip it off. 

Powered to the very top of the industry thanks in-part to the unmatched marketing of his gimmick and its various properties, Warrior was still a cultural phenomenon even if he couldn't match the connection or longevity of the man he was supposed to replace. Hulk Hogan had taken his spot back at WrestleMania VII having only "passed the torch" a year earlier, but 12 months on from that, fans genuinely believed that somebody else had stepped into the Warrior gimmick. A haircut and smaller physique convinced many that the Warrior that returned wasn't the one that had left, and perhaps this temporary confusion convinced others they could lift the aesthetic and manage it too.

Renegade was WCW's shameless knockoff (billed as an "Ultimate" surprise before he debuted), but on a lower scale, Dominick Yaniero's 'One Warrior Nation' take gained its own reputation for the imitation being half-decent but the matches being fully awful. Of his 26 (documented) matches between 2008 and 2013, none have drawn any kind of acclaim other than through an ironic lens on YouTube. Naturally, Warrior and others with a handle on licensing made sure to get the cease-and-desist paperwork together before Yaniero could take the poached gimmick beyond VHF halls and high school gyms. 


13. Ric Flair (Buddy Landel)

buddy landel sparky plugg
WWE.com

Shane Douglas' hatred of Ric Flair was used to comical effect when 'The Franchise' was at the top of his game in ECW in 1994. 'The Nature Boy' had booked Douglas in a less-than-favourable fashion during their time together in WCW, and by the time Shane had his finger on the trigger and the pulse, Flair was the one getting both barrels to generate pops. 

It was a strange paradox for the time - a company that used Terry Funk to an expert extent and paid selective respect to wrestlers from the past elected not to include the mid-40s multi-time Champion Ric Flair in their praise. His personal alienation of Douglas drove the new ECW Champion in his quest against those that controlled pro wrestling, but workers gonna work, and less than a year after he threw down the NWA belt to formally launch Extreme Championship Wrestling, he threw his signature on a WWF contract.

The run was a mess, riddled with lost political battles and matches that didn't support the growing argument that he was one of the best all-rounders in the world. By December 1995, he was ready to return to ECW, but not before introducing Buddy Landel as his replacement for an In Your House 5 match with Ahmed Johnson. Landel, with flowing blonde hair and beautiful sequin robe, entered to the famous WWE knockoff of Also Sprach Zarathustra, and was nicknamed 'The Nature Boy'. Landel's time with the market leader was to be even briefer than Douglas', but at least he wasn't forced to endure it with such gritted teeth. 


12. Scott Steiner (Little Petey Pump)

Scott Steiner Petey Williams
TNA

Even at its creative mid-2000s peak (not coincidentally when they were furthest away from WWE in style and tone), Total Nonstop Action was still rarely able to unleash a single good idea without a list of caveats.

Such was the case with 'Little Petey Pump', an almost-devastatingly patronising nickname for Petey Williams when he embraced the aesthetic of Scott Steiner save for a few inches in height and arm width. The two were put together as unlikely allies on television after both found themselves in possession of "Feast Or Fired" briefcases for title shots in 2007. They traded cases, giving Petey a World Title shot, but Steiner eventually won possession of both in a match at Against All Odds 2008. 

Rather than marking the end of the X-Division star's union with 'Big Poppa Pump' though, the positive feedback to the story from all sides resulted in them working a mutual respect angle until Steiner bequeathed his signature look (chainmail headwear included) onto the innovator of the Canadian Destroyer. The relationship was ultimately doomed by Steiner's inclusion in the heel Main Event Mafia, but it felt as though Petey had found a missing piece of the puzzle from the most unlikely of places.

'Maple Leaf Muscle' gradually became its own thing as a persona, and so it should have - having a body (and body of work) like Williams' was absolutely something to toast on its terms rather than just in the shadow of an even more preposterously jacked "freak".


11. Randy Savage (Black Machismo)

Black Machismo Jay Lethal
Impact Wrestling

From the ridiculous to the sublime, never was Jay Lethal more over in wrestling than when he was presenting his own take on another wrestler that had once been incredibly over.

Borne out of the cult classic Paparazzi Production sketches featuring Lethal dicking about with the likes of Alex Shelley, Sonjay Dutt, Kevin Nash and others, the future ROH World Champion's dead-on Randy Savage impersonation was revealed during a talent show bit that stopped all the fictional judges in their tracks. Nash convinced Lethal to try the act again in the ring, and even supplied him with some colourful Macho Man attire to boot.

Announced then as "Black Machismo", Lethal was able to go about incorporating Randy's offence into his own to make a perfect clash-of-ages character. He didn't need to drop the stuff he'd refined over years, but the famous and familiar work of an all-time great was a fantastic library to liberally poach, not least when audiences expected it.

The concept peaked with a victory over Kurt Angle for the X-Division Championship at No Surrender 2007, but TNA simply couldn't not be TNA about it, and Lethal's Savage-and-Liz bond with So Cal Val morphed into a lousy programme with former friend Sonjay Dutt over Val's affections. When she joined Dutt for a double heel turn and the whole thing eventually fizzled, so too did any chance of Lethal breaking the glass ceiling.

In a better-than-nothing outcome, the now-normalised bit did at least keep him relevent in TNA until he chose a hard and ultimately success reset for himself in ROH in 2011.


10. Road Warriors (Demolition)

Demolition Ax Smash
WWE

Wrestling is the medium that's stupid enough to send wrestlers out as imitations of more famous acts, but smart enough to actually monetise them on their own terms. This was categorically the case with Demolition, and never was that more apparent than in the exact moments they finally came face to face with their authentic inspirations.

When a rebadged Road Warriors finally gave Titan a go in 1990, it was curtains for Ax and Smash (and new member Crush) as the dominant duo for the market leader. The Legion Of Doom were the original painted-up monsters, and with spikes and that famous ear-splitting pop, an entire audience that may have been closed off to anything other than WWE suddenly saw who the Demos had been based on all along.

Demolition had three-peated with the Tag Team Championships to a euphoric reaction at WrestleMania VI, but were hurriedly turned heel to make towns with Hawk and Animal, losing the gold to The Hart Foundation along the way. It was inevitable that the pairs had to fight, but there was no way back for the WWE creations now the actual ones were here. It was strange - the treatment might have been befitting of typical wrestling imposters, but Ax and Smash were never that.


9. Dave Meltzer (Little Davey Meltzer)

Dr Death Davey Meltzer
UWF

A pasty jobber with a mullet called Dave(y) Meltzer getting monstered by Dr. Death Steve Williams for Herb Abrams' UWF long before the vast majority of people who watched wrestling knew that the Wrestling Observer even existed?

Vintage wrestling pettiness, literally.

The fun squash took place in 1990 when the sheet did the rounds in the locker room and only the most hardcore of fan circles, but it didn't stop Abrams deciding to poke fun at one of the few pre-eminent journalists in the game by having his biggest killer smash through him just so he and co-commentator Bruno Sammartino could reference "Meltzer" taking such a beating and having absolutely nothing to offer in response. 

Not a place for the most nuanced symbolism most of the time, the group doubled then trebled down on the bit as Williams shoved a sheet of paper into his mouth, then heaped literal dirt on him after the three was registered. The real Dave took it in his stride and continued to get more prominence thanks to his extremely diligent coverage of a medium with a notoriously tough beat. Adam Michaels was the wrestler that took the payday to mock him, though ironically you'd have to dig deeper through Meltzer's own archives to find what became of his career.  


8. Penta (Penta Oscuro)

Penta Oscuro
AEW

There's not the time nor the word-count on this slide to explain the full lore of Pentagón  within the context of his Lucha Underground run, which is not to patronise nor mock the product but to put over just how much the company favoured being a television show about wrestling rather than a wrestling television show.

The long story short though, is that the man later to go by several other names was known most as a total killer. One of the standout stars (in a stacked field), Pentagón started life with a couple of difficult defeats so set about claiming fellow wrestlers' arms as trophies in some grisly and gripping matches and beatdowns that helped establish the uniquely specific and dangerous tone LU sought to set. With Lucha icon Vampiro revealed to the "Master" behind all of Pentagón's terrible deeds, Pentagón worked further killer displays as Pentagón Dark, his most sadistic manifestation.

Years passed, and in the time following the unceremonious conclusion of Lucha Underground as a concept, Penta and brother Rey Fenix had established a reputation as one of the best tag teams and touring matches in all of wrestling, and were naturals for AEW when the challenger brand launched in 2019. After a few years entering in celebrated displays, it was felt a reboot of Penta El Ziero M was required after the pair lost the doubles straps in 2022. Penta Oscuro (Dark Penta) was born, but as he emerged pulling funny over a grave, Alex Abrahantes dressed as a druid in tow, he was doomed from moment one.

This was wrestling's version of forced darkness, which is to say the brightest stupidest lightweight nonsense known to man. Not that the relationship was ever set to hit prior heights, but it was the slow, lingering beginning of the end of both brothers' relationship with AEW. 


7. The Blue Meanie (Blue Tillie)

Blue Tilly
TNA

Perhaps best known for his runs in Total Nonstop Action as one half of undercard tag team Phi Delta Slam and later Rocco (one of the Main Event Mafia's heavy-set security guards/goons-for-hire during the last days of Kurt Angle's group) James 'Big Tilly' Tilquist got to play the role of somebody else's lifetime when TNA embraced ECW's history at Hardcore Justice 2010.

The poor guy was one of the few to get booed all night thanks to the unique (and very TNA) situation where the talent were presented with copyright-proof ring names while encouraging the audience to chant the original ones. This match was a case-in-point; Tilly flanked Stevie Richards as part of a revived Blue World Order, but the bWo name and logo was for the crowd only alongside the "Justin Credible" chants that greeted Richards' opponent PJ Polaco. Tilly was billed as 'The Blue Tillie' for the night in nod to the Meanie, but also as "personal security" as a little nudge towards his more familiar role.

Like everything on the card, it was a bit of mishmash of ideas, broadly affectionate even when it was ineffective, and provided one extra payday to those that weren't otherwise guaranteed to get one. In opposition to wrestling's typically more cynical nature, this was a relatively inoffensive swing.

As was the original...


6. New World Order (Blue World Order)

Bwo blue world order
wwe.com

By 1996, Extreme Championship Wrestling had lost a little bit of the creative magic that had drawn almost universal critical acclaim in the years prior, but with the very real chance of the long-mooted pay-per-view on the horizon (and the doors that could theoretically open), the juices were still flowing in Philadelphia for the talent that wanted it enough.

Stevie Richards and The Blue Meanie were textbook examples of those exact talents. As Raven's goons, they were on permanent interference duty for his feuds with The Sandman and Tommy Dreamer, but it was while they were locked in parody mode for half of the show that they stumbled on the idea that would serve them long beyond the very existence of ECW.

After riffing on KISS, The Fabulous Ones and others, the New World Order were next to get skewered. 'Da Blue Guy' and 'Big Stevie Cool' were joined by 'Hollywood' Nova and other hangers-on, getting over to such a degree that the homage mirrored WCW's own as something of phenomenon - albeit more localised to the south side of Philadelphia. It propelled Richards especially to a headline spot, babyfacing him and and the group to such an extent that he was part an ECW Title double main event at Barely Legal when the company finally made it to the 'The Dance'. 


5. Sunny (Tammy Lynn Bytch)

ECW Impact Players Jason Justin Credible Lance Storm Dawn Marie
WWE

The most Paul Heyman idea with the most Paul Heyman name and even the most Paul Heyman spelling, Dawn Marie's introduction into Extreme Championship Wrestling as "Tammy Lynn Bytch" was just about as of-the-time as wrestling could be.

Her 1998 ECW debut positioned her as Lance Storm's valet and a direct rival of TAFKA Sunny, Tammy Lynn Sytch, who was back alongside Chris Candido in Philadelphia after her WWE run fell off a cliff amidst all manner of personal problems. 

Extreme Championship Wrestling was many things, and misogynistic in its treatment of women was one of them, down to how both were portrayed here. For better and worse behind the scenes, Sunny had been a transcendent discovery in the mid-1990s, while Dawn Marie's charisma was instantly obvious and would eventually power her far beyond the "catfights" and race-to-the-bottom edgelord comedy inserted to buffer Candido and Storm's often-excellent work.

The painfully 90s and naff name thankfully wasn't to last. "Tammy Lynn" was soon shifted to Dawn Marie, and the overdue removal of "Bytch" eventually freed her of having to be thought of as just a parodic figure rather than a key component in the presentation of the critically lauded Impact Players. 


4. Razor Ramon HG

Razor Ramon HG
HUSTLE

The image above would reveal no clue that what you are looking at is a Razor Ramon imposter. Primarily because you're not, but the 'Bad Guy's name can be found if you Google the comedian Masaki Sumitan, who somewhat inexplicably lifted the name wholesale before adding "HG" (latterly to stand for Hot Guy, if only following a 2022 change to bring it up to more contemporary standards of acceptance) for his run in the positively deranged HUSTLE promotion in the mid-2000s.

Decked out in PVC, entering to Ricky Martin's Livin' La Vida Loca and endlessly flexing an almost inhuman ability to thrust his groin with the speed of a Bron Breakker spear, there was absolutely nothing that linked the gimmick to the moniker, which was another reason why it was so funny.

A fondly-remembered comedy wrestler for the most part, Sumitan's legacy is a mixed one. Racking up 70 matches between his 2005 debut and 2024, his ring-time reveals that he was more than just a dated one-note-joke with an incongruous label. Discovering eventually that Sumitan was actually straight resulted in the persona being one that realistically punched down rather than embracing any sort of culture. 


3. Shane Douglas (Triple H)

Triple H Kangol
WWE

As creative overlord in WWE who makes no secret of his spot or anything he can gloss up as a success story, Triple H is mostly thought of as an insufferable bore now. Not ideal, but at least a trait that actually feels close to Paul Levesque's real personality as opposed to the times he attempted to be anything else in an endless quest to actually get over. He was booked as, variously, the hardest guy, the funniest guy, the coolest guy, the roster's best sex-haver, the best wrestler alive; there wasn't a hat he didn't wear in his near 20-year run at the top of the card.

And about that - the leather biker/Kangol hat Hunter wore backwards during 1998 and early-1999 wasn't just an of-the-time fashion statement, but a direct lift from Shane Douglas alongside 'The Franchise's wet-look long hair and stubbly beard co-opted by 'The Game' on his ascendency. 

It's a strange bit of thievery from somebody who was part of The Kliq by the time they were instrumental enough to harm Douglas' cursed WWE run, but a recent tidbit unearthed by the Vault YouTube channel revealed how it might not just have been Fed business the group were discussing on the long van rides. While filming footage on the Titan Tower roof for new Raw credits in 1995, Shawn Michaels directly references ECW. The group were all-too-aware of their noisy neighbours in Philadelphia, to the extent that Hunter probably permanently kept enough of an eye on the show when it came to needing inspiration for his tweaked act. 


2. Kane (Imposter Kane)

imposter kane
WWE.com

2000s/2010s WWE is not without passing moments of brilliance, but there are good reasons why so much from the decades is paint-brushed as the worst mainstream wrestling ever promoted, and Kane feuding with a weird doppelgänger of himself in 2006 goes on the long list. 

'The Big Red Machine' had lost his mind again, this time resulting in him splitting with former and future partner Big Show. The cause? The constant repetition of "May 19th", the date of WWE Films' See No Evil's release and, in kayfabe, the date of the fire that killed his parents. After week of scarcely believable acting from big Glenn, he was greeted with the sight of his old self - the Kane that first arrived in WWE in 1997.

In the weeks that follows, the mystery man in the old mask got the better of the original in a series of brawls that very loosely scanned as the "mind games" the company typically pitched when they didn't really know what they were getting at. The future Luke Gallows did a passable job in the old attire too, though a ridiculous wig undermined the look. The eventual match was, conveniently, exactly as good as a Kane Vs Luke Gallows match sounds, but WWE seemed just as bored as everybody else with it. Despite the phoney getting the win in their pay-per-view bout, Kane destroyed and unmasked him 24 hours later and the never-once-hot story was dropped cold.

A tribute within a tribute, it was in itself a weaker knock-off of a similar angle on the same family tree...


1. The Undertaker (The Undertaker)

undertaker underfaker
WWE.com

A gimmick lift so famous it was used to try and sell a pay-per-view main event, WWE's replication of its own intellectual (?) property in 1994 wasn't as dumb and low quality as the actual match that paid it all off.

When Yokozuna and the rest of the heel roster hurled The Undertaker into a casket at the shocking conclusion of their WWE Championship match at the Royal Rumble, the real goal behind the kayfabe one was to give Mark Calaway time off to heal some physical and personal wounds after nearly four years working the company's Killer Kalendar. It was one last big push to get Yokozuna over the top before he lost the belt to either Lex Luger or Bret Hart at WrestleMania, and a major - albeit silly - moment in 'The Deadman's career to date.

As his SummerSlam return loomed, it was Ted Dibiase rather than Paul Bearer that promoted his return after Elvis-style sightings from members of the public, but the Undertaker Dibiase unearthed wasn't all he first semed; an imposter motivated not by the love of his "creatures of the night" but cold hard cash. For a couple of months, there really were two Undertakers!

Well, there was one, but the other one played by Brian Lee did as good a job as necessary of playing the phoney 'Demon Of Death Valley' until he was actually nose to nose with the original. The contest was brutally boring - a mirror match in which every reflection was slower than the last. It killed the concept to such an extent that any positivity around Lee's portrayal was completely flushed. Whispers of a continued run in the gimmick stayed just that, and the "Underfaker" never again materialised. 


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.