5 Biggest Winners & Losers From WWE In 2025

Which WWE stars had a great and prosperous 2025, and which ones struggled and failed this year?

WWE Survivor Series: WarGames 2025 Liv Morgan Dominik Mysterio John Cena
WWE

The WWE roster in 2025 was so big that it is easy for any one wrestler to get lost in the shuffle, so it's a big deal if they're able to stand out.

On the positive side of things, making a bigger star out of yourself and accomplishing some career highlights to work toward a Hall of Fame legacy can come with accumulating championships, scoring key victories on major shows like WrestleMania, and having a breakout performance which puts the spotlight on you.

But there were also wrestlers this year who stood out in a negative way, becoming great examples of what not to do.

These unfortunate souls were either never put in the position to succeed or had the opportunity and messed it all up. Some suffered injuries. Others got handed their release forms.

Let's take a look at this year's biggest winners in WWE who will look back on the last 12 months with joy and pride, as well as the biggest losers who would definitely like to put 2025 behind them and not revisit those memories.

10. Winner: Oba Femi

NXT Deadline 2025 Oba Femi
WWE

NXT has its fair share of options for the "biggest winners" category, including new acquisitions who already became champions like Blake Monroe and Ricky Saints, to double champions like Ethan Page, Jacy Jayne, and Sol Ruca, standouts like EVOLVE Women's Champion and Iron Survivor Kendal Grey, and those who even won TNA titles like Trick Williams and Kelani Jordan.

But if you're going to pick just one name from this group, it's hard to argue it shouldn't be The Ruler of NXT himself, Oba Femi.

Femi ended 2024 by winning the Iron Survivor Challenge match at NXT Deadline, going on to start 2025 at New Year's Evil by dethroning Williams for the NXT Championship.

For 262 days, Femi fought all comers and retained that title, keeping up his nigh-unstoppable track record of having only lost twice in 2024 to Tony D'Angelo.

Femi eventually suffered his third true loss at No Mercy, dropping the NXT Championship to Saints. But after taking a month or so off, Femi returned and promptly won the title back from Saints 69 days later.

Femi is ending his year working John Cena's retirement event, facing the Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. You can't get much better than that.


9. Loser: Jordynne Grace

Stephanie Vaquer Jordynne Grace
WWE

Who on WWE Creative thinks the best way of booking Jordynne Grace is to have her be an ineffective loser over and over again? How is that the right way to put over someone who was the face of the TNA Knockouts division and someone who could have gone straight to the main roster and won a women's world title and no one would have batted an eye?

Since joining the roster officially, she has an overall losing record, especially when it matters most.

Every time she's put in a position to fight for the NXT Women's Championship, she's made to look like a fool. In some ways, that's by just losing to talent that are presented as lesser than her, such as "the most beatable champion" Jacy Jayne or how she just lamented on the December 9th edition of NXT that she can't even beat "rookies" like Kelani Jordan (multiple times, mind you).

In other cases, she's flat out embarrassed and humiliated, like her rivalry with Blake Monroe, where she was meant to look stupid in trusting her, lost matches, and was also called ugly, as if a win at No Mercy offsets all that character damage.


8. Winner: Stephanie Vaquer

WWE Crown Jewel 2025 Stephanie Vaquer
WWE.com

There are way more than five options for biggest winners this year, even within the women's division alone, so it was tough to narrow it down to Stephanie Vaquer narrowly beating out the others.

For the record, right in contention with her would be talent like Naomi—who was a tag team champion, won Money in the Bank, cashed in to win a world title and vacated it due to happy news of pregnancy.

Tiffany Stratton was another contender with her Money in the Bank cash-in and over 300 day title reign, with a major victory over Charlotte Flair at WrestleMania 41.

A case could be made for other champions and big stars like Jade Cargill, Chelsea Green, Becky Lynch, Iyo Sky, Rhea Ripley, and so on.

But Naomi's been gone for months, Stratton only really ever fought three people most of the year, and so on, while Vaquer has an over 80% success rate while wrestling in the top 10 most matches in 2025.

Those wins, mind you, include beating Giulia to become the first-ever double champion in NXT women's history before going on to win the Women's World Championship, which she still holds, in an absolute breakout star-making year.

The cherry on top that makes her get this spot is beating Stratton herself for the Crown Jewel title as well.


7. Loser: Bianca Belair

Bianca Belair
WWE

This is another painful one to admit, considering how amazing Bianca Belair is. You could make a case that she's already etched her name in the record books as one of the top women to ever step foot in World Wrestling Entertainment. When she's on, she's on fire. The problem is that 2025 was a year she was very much "off" instead.

The EST of WWE had a win-loss record of 67-11 in 2024—her best yet. But in 2025, she only wrestled 11 matches total and lost 7 of them.

Among those seven losses were dropping the WWE Women's Tag Team Championship titles in February right.

Naomi being revealed as Jade Cargill's attacker came at the worst time to derail Belair's attention on the Road to WrestleMania, wherein she was focused partially on being torn between her two friends, but managed to win the Elimination Chamber to earn a shot at the Women's World Championship.

Belair lost that match, ending her previously undefeated streak at WrestleMania and breaking a finger in the process.

That injury has yet to heal, so she's sat out the remainder of the year with no announced time table of her possible return.


6. Winner: Dominik Mysterio

Liv Morgan Dominik Mysterio
WWE

Every year, Dominik Mysterio gets better, and he reached a point in 2025 where he crossed the threshold separating "having a lot of potential" to "being one of the guys" in many ways.

While there may not be a true "leader" among The Judgment Day, Dirty Dom became the de facto focal point of the group and asserted his commandeering of that spot even more when he won the Intercontinental Championship at WrestleMania 41.

That in and of itself is huge, given the prestige of that title and the show to win it on, especially taking it from someone as prominently featured in 2025 as Bron Breakker.

Mysterio suffered a setback when Liv Morgan was injured, but the group rolled on, finding new allies in El Grande Americano and strengthening the bond of newcomer Roxanne Perez.

In September at Worlds Collide, Mysterio won the AAA Mega Championship from El Hijo del Vikingo to become a double champion.

Though he lost the Intercontinental Championship to John Cena, Mysterio won it back a few weeks later at Survivor Series in his hometown. A win over Cena, in his penultimate match, to become a two-time champion while getting his girl, Liv Morgan, back? What a way to end a great year!


5. Loser: Zoey Stark

WWE Raw Zoey Stark Injury
WWE

It was tempting to put someone like Tatum Paxley on this list to call out how she lost both of her Chemical X tag team partners (Gigi Dolin and Shotzi) and her husband (Javier Bernal) to releases, and had to have a mental breakdown with her character losing all her friends only to be betrayed by yet another friend in Izzi Dame, but here's the kicker: she won the NXT Women's Championship.

It was the shortest run in the belt's history, but it still counts, which is a major bonus.

You can't say anything of the sort for Zoey Stark, who is another victim of having both her tag team partners fired in 2025. It took all three members of Pure Fusion Collective to only eliminate Maxxine Dupri in the Women's Royal Rumble, back when Dupri was the weakest member of the Raw roster.

By May, both Sonya Deville and Shayna Baszler were released, and Stark would follow that up with a terrible leg injury a few weeks later that has put her on the shelf the rest of the year. This is not to make light of her situation at all, but to simply point out that in and out of character, Stark simply suffered some of the biggest losses of anyone in 2025.

Hopefully, once she's healed up, she can turn things around and make 2026 that much better in comparison.


4. Winners (Tie-Split): Jey Uso, Gunther or The Vision

Jey Uso World Heavyweight Champion
WWE

There was an odd split this year where three more contenders for "biggest winner" could be argued between Gunther, Jey Uso, and The Vision as a whole, but who you'd pick depends on what time frame you're looking at.

Gunther has the retirement matches of Goldberg and John Cena under his name, as well as walking into WrestleMania 41 with the World Heavyweight Championship, but he lost that title to Uso, who should get lots of credit for levelling up from tag team and midcard wrestler to "Main Event" Jey for real.

Uso did so by eliminating John Cena of all people to win the Royal Rumble and make The Ring General tap out at WrestleMania to win that world title.

Unfortunately for Uso, he lost the title back to Gunther two months later, so who wins out between them? Uso has been prominently featured and nearly won the title again, but is now back in the tag team division.

Meanwhile, The Vision is worth discussing as the primary focal point, Seth Rollins winning at WrestleMania and cashing in Money in the Bank to win the world title, only to get injured and derail the whole story, putting even Bron Breakker's ascension on hold until at least January 2026, all while dominating nearly every episode of Raw and winning at WarGames.

Those three options are effectively balanced out and tied for a spot.


3. Loser: Chad Gable

Chad Gable
WWE.com

It's never good to see someone like Chad Gable on a list of losers, as he doesn't deserve to be. Unfortunately, he keeps being dealt unlucky cards and being stuck in a rhythmic cycle of being overlooked and under-appreciated.

2024 was already rough with the amount of teasing that was done revolving around him being a fan favorite to win the Intercontinental Championship, only to never achieve that goal.

In 2025, he's had won of the worst win-loss records, standing at 2-13 (or an 86.7% loss statistic).

Surely, that record should be higher, right? Well, technically, it both is and it isn't, as "Chad Gable" scored two wins on WWE Speed - a show nobody watched and was eventually cancelled, but "El Grande Americano" won nine matches, including winning that WWE Speed Championship.

The problem is that he could only win by cheating while under the mask (losing as Gable to El Hijo del Vikingo and Penta, for instance) and just as the gimmick was getting red hot, he suffered a torn rotator cuff injury that has had him on the shelf since June.

His stable, American Made, disappeared for most of that time as well, and the El Grande Americano gimmick was given to Ludwig Kaiser, who has gotten over with the crowd so much better to the point that even when Gable is able to return, WWE may not want to give him that moniker back.


2. Winner: CM Punk

WWE Survivor Series 2025 WarGames CM Punk
WWE.com

CM Punk started off the year hot, winning a dream match against Seth Rollins on the January 6 premiere of WWE Monday Night Raw on Netflix. This was an immensely important show, and for the main event to revolve around him as the winner gives him lots of points.

He then carried that into WrestleMania season wherein he finally managed to check off one of the few things he was not able to do in his career, and a sticking point that made him bitter in his previous run, wherein he was part of the main event of the first night. Headlining The Grandest Stage of Them All is something not many wrestlers can say they've ever done, and while he wasn't victorious in that match and was turned on by Paul Heyman within the storyline, having his friend accompany him to the ring for his entrance was a big deal.

Punk did suffer some other losses this year, such as the unfortunate passing of his beloved dog, Larry, but he also scored some other big wins, such as being able to fight alongside his wife, AJ Lee, upon her return.

While one was short-lived with a Money in the Bank cash-in, Punk did capture the World Heavyweight Championship twice and is now walking into January as said champion.


1. Losers: Karrion Kross and Scarlett

Karrion Kross Scarlett Bordeaux
WWE

A good number of releases from this year could be in contention for biggest loser. 

Veterans like Carlito were brushed aside to make room for the younger generation, of which dozens in EVOLVE, LFG and NXT were only given a few months to be hired and fired almost immediately anyway.

Andrade is waiting a year to wrestle elsewhere, dreams were shattered for people like Cora Jade, and Ridge Holland's injury and release is perhaps the worst situation out of anyone.

But one of the more interesting cases of WWE just refusing to let talent succeed and forcing them into the loser category has to go to Karrion Kross and Scarlett. Kross wrestled primarily on WWE Main Event and could still only beat enhancement talent like Akira Tozawa.

Kross had a big moment after WrestleMania with his crash out, which could have been the jumping point for a push, but only led to a 2-1 losing effort to Sami Zayn in a storyline that proved Kross, who lost his entire faction this year, also was wrong about his ability to corrupt people. Effectively, everything about him screamed "loser" to WWE.

Come August, their contracts expired, and even though so many fans made such a fuss over them, the buzz has died down and they haven't been signed to any other big promotion or done anything impactful since.


Contributor
Contributor

Founder of pro wrestling site Smark Out Moment (https://www.smarkoutmoment.com) and geek culture site Fanboys Anonymous (https://www.fanboysanonymous.com).