6 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE SmackDown (13 Feb - Results & Review)

Love was in the air for some segments/matches on this week's WWE SmackDown. SOME.

Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Cody Rhodes is one step closer to a WWE Title match at WrestleMania 42. That sentence will either delight or horrify you, which perhaps shows the weakness in Triple H's booking during the road to the big dance this April. Indeed, management has held meetings with staff to try and galvanise the push towards 'Mania, but they're ignoring the elephants (plural) in the room.

Ticket prices remain insanely high, and the creative has been a little all over the place across both major brands lately.

This week's SmackDown had 2 goals: Lock in some more names for respective male and female Elimination Chamber matches and bolster some on the undercard who are honestly making the best of limited screentime. In that sense, it was a success, but your patience may be running out on some of these formulaic Triple Threat qualifiers. Being fair, the roster is strong enough to offset that rinse and repeat style, and only one of the bouts on this week's show could be considered a slight struggle (which wasn't even champ and challenger's fault!).

Top names like Cody, Drew McIntyre and more are shining brightly in the face of lacklustre storytelling, which should clue everyone in about just how good these guys are as performers. Elsewhere, the likes of Kit Wilson, Tama Tonga, Carmelo Hayes and Trick Williams deserve a ton of praise for how they're going about business.

Here's all the good and bad from this week's SmackDown. Fun-packed matches galore, some logical storytelling and more await you.


Downs...

3. Babyface Talking Isn’t Tiffy’s Strength

Tiffany Stratton
WWE.com

The opening promo on Friday's show existed just to get to the Women’s Tag-Team Title match, and it felt like a total waste of time for Tiffany Stratton. Honestly, she'd be so much more effective as a heel - literally Tiffy's whole ‘me, me, me’ act is heelish. Also, how many times are we gonna see Stratton and Nia Jax at one another’s throats around this place?!

It was a standard promo train to kick things off, but nobody really had anything important to say. WWE needs to stop sending top stars out there with nothing to talk about other than things fans already know. Stratton was rudderless, and that's a problem when she's only just returned during the Royal Rumble over in Saudi Arabia.

Maybe the upside to these 3 hour SmackDowns is that Triple H will always be able to find spots for everyone on the booking sheets, but...'The Game' still needs to make sure their appearances are worthwhile and interesting. This one wasn't. Tiffany's entire promo could've been boiled down to a line on commentary from Joe Tessitore or Wade Barrett, and that speaks volumes about how pointless it was.

She wants to win the Elimination Chamber match after qualifying last week. Who knew?!

WWE would be doing themselves a massive solid by turning Stratton heel and moving her over to Raw sooner rather than later. It felt like she completed SmackDown last year, and now it's blatantly obvious she doesn't have a meaningful spot as a babyface on the blue brand roster.


2. The Threat Is Gone

Aleister Black Zelina Vega
WWE

Sorry, but Aleister Black’s foreboding, threatening promos are hitting Wyatt Sicks territory now. He says a lot of things without coming through on them. Even when he did take the fight to Damian Priest, he lost their blowoff ‘Ambulance Match’, so why he was prattling on about Randy Orton after losing last week’s Elimination Chamber qualifier is anyone’s guess. It just has to be said: WWE doesn’t know what to do with Black.

They either acknowledge him as a midcarder or don’t. This creative purgatory and middle ground he’s constantly stuck in is jarring when he’s making grandiose promises about being a big shot without ever living up to that. One minute, the promotion decides they want to push him. The next? He's reduced to doing this sort of thing - talking a lot then getting his teeth knocked down his throat before coming back for more.

It's tedious as all hell by this point, and WWE's booking style with guys like Al makes it impossible to properly invest in anything they're doing on programming. As the subheading says, the threat really is gone with him. The bloom is off the rose, the horse has bolted. There are so many variations on the same theme, which is ironic given how he does the same stuff over and over again without building too much momentum.

This promo is clearly building towards a singles loss to Randy so Orton has that momentum Black craves heading into Chamber. It'll be a solid match, but Aleister needs so much more than that right now.


1. Double Downsides For This Title Match

Jade Cargill Jordynne Grace Liv Morgan Dominik Mysterio Raquel Rodriguez
WWE.com

How on earth did they manage to book a title match that directly failed to get anybody involved over?! Jade Cargill vs. Jordynne Grace suffered for Liv Morgan, Dominik Mysterio and Raquel Rodriguez being around ringside. That Judgment Day trio dominated the conversation. Not only that, but Liv still isn’t coming across as a big enough deal following her Royal Rumble win.

Plus, everyone knows she'll challenge for the Women's World Championship, not Jade's Women's Title.

It's annoying for Jade and Jordynne that the fans chanted for “Dirty Dom” throughout rather than paying attention to what they were doing inside the ring. Man, there was even a chant for the heart shaped nuggets near the end when Jade and Grace went nose to nose! Genuinely terrible and counterproductive booking here, especially considering the fact that this was Cargill’s first title defence since winning the belt last November.

Way to make champ and challenger look like afterthoughts, people. One of the worst things about that split focus on JD was that Grace and Jade were working some neat power based exchanges between the ropes. Midway through, Jordynne semi-hit a Goldberg-style Jackhammer that should've been the focal point. It wasn't. Liv Morgan munching chicken nuggets was.

Hunter has long viewed Cargill as a pet project, so it's extra irritating that he seems intent on bungling her title reign completely. She mixed it with Michin and B-FAB for too long after beating Tiffany Stratton, then found a viable foe in Grace. Oh wait, never mind. Dominik and Liv need to have a romantic meal during their match, because that's important.


Ups...

6. 10-Man Tag Works

Carmelo Hayes Tama Tonga
WWE.com

Solo Sikoa and his MFTs vs. Carmelo Hayes, Ilja Dragunov, Shinsuke Nakamura, Matt Cardona and Apollo Crews kept things busy and made the MFT crew look good. You've got to like the continued rise of Tama Tonga, and him pinning Carmelo feels big for the dude. This could well lead to a crack at the United States Title for Tama, which would be a significant improvement for him.

Matches like this one are really what guys like Cardona, Crews and Shinsuke should be used for nowadays. Taking a rain check on that US Title bout between Hayes and Ilja wasn’t the worst idea either, because giving those ‘Open Challenge’ bits a break works. Also, Dragunov just wants to fight, so he was never going to turn his nose up at the chance to do just that once the MFT crew attacked.

Fans know what they're gonna get from these kinds of matches, especially once it starts breaking down and racing towards the end, but the brawl was never less than entertaining. Again, it did put Tama in the frame for singles gold, and that double whammy grabbed the match an ‘Up’. No-one will be blown away watching this, no. However, not every single wrestling match ever needs to be some star-hungry spot fest.

Nick Aldis coming out to announce the 10-man tag gave all of these workers something to do on SmackDown, and then they delivered. Best of all, pretty much everyone who matters got some licks in, and now Tonga is up there with Hayes, Ilja and even other United States Title hopefuls like The Miz.

Good work, lads.


5. Kit Wilson Continues To Make The Most Of It

Kit Wilson Nick Aldis R-Truth Damian Priest
WWE.com

There were major (and valid) concerns when Elton Prince got injured and his Pretty Deadly partner Kit Wilson had to move into the singles division, but his anti-toxic masculinity gimmick is getting some good reactions. Kit's segment here with R-Truth, Nick Aldis and Damian Priest was good stuff. It included poems from Wilson and Truth which earned plenty of laughs.

Do not be shocked if Kit hears "camel toe" chants soon.

Later, Wilson read a poem to Oba Femi and that also set up their rematch for next week. Wilson is maximising his minutes, that’s for sure. Yes, he's going to get positively destroyed for a second time by Oba, but that's alright. The most important thing for Kit right now is that he's on TV and showing off his new character. The better, squash-free matches can come later down the line if he keeps getting over.

Aldis, Truth and Priest seemed to have a hard time holding it together during their skit with Kit, but Wilson looked outraged that they were being so *checks notes* "TOXIC". It's amazing how one simple word can catch fire and turn somebody from overlooked tag-teamer into a standalone success story. Keep this up, and Kit has a real chance.

Giving him a win or 2 over veterans like R-Truth or even Matt Cardona wouldn't be the worst idea in the world. That way, Wilson has something to brag about when he's carrying his little book of poems around the place. Genius schmenius. Eat your heart out, Lanny Poffo fans!


4. Women’s Triple Threat Keeps The Energy Up

Alexa Bliss Zelina Vega
WWE.com

On paper, Alexa Bliss vs. Giulia vs. Zelina Vega was a formality that'd see one of the first pair listed there qualify for the women's Elimination Chamber match. Yep, Alexa got the win, which actually makes sense given that her pal Charlotte Flair is in the Chamber lineup herself, but there was way more to this match than first meets the eye.

It marked another good watch on Friday’s card.

Admittedly, Giulia wouldn’t have been a bad choice either, but Alexa has more legacy star power so she goes in. All in all, these women managed to offset the obvious nature of the outcome by working an energetic match that held the live crowd's attention throughout. Special mention to Zelina too, because she got some nice spots out there and that isn’t always the case for her.

Vega has hit her ceiling in WWE circles and everyone knows it. She's never going to be the priority in the division whether she's on Raw, SmackDown or NXT, but the pint-sized veteran can still contribute to matches if she's feeling inspired. Zelina's performance levels rarely dip even if the booking might be considered disheartening, and that's complimentary to her professionalism.

Put it this way: The match was better for her involvement, and better than a Bliss vs. Giulia one-on-one would've been. Even so, she was never winning it and progressing to the Chamber PLE. Alexa got the nod, so expect to see some more miscommunication between she and Flair inside the steel structure at the end of the month.


3. A Vast Improvement For Trick & Fenix

Trick Williams Rey Fenix
WWE.com

Trick Williams vs. Rey Fenix II was a lot better than their first match on the 9 January SmackDown. Personally, this fan thought that was a tad disjointed and it looked like they just wouldn’t have chemistry together, but things were different here. Fenix is lost in the shuffle and has become a go-to jobber to the stars, but he’s still good in-ring. The next step is surely putting Trick in Elimination Chamber over guys like Damian Priest too.

If WWE is serious about building fresh main roster stars, then that’s the kind of thing they need to be doing. Williams has incredible potential. He's a star on the rise, is getting meaty reactions from crowds (people love chanting: "Whoop That Trick" over and over), and 'Trick Willy' looks every bit a main eventer in waiting from head to toe. Why wait much longer with him?

Back to the match at hand. Rey’s double stomp spot from the ring post looked excellent, and he generally got to show off more of his aerials here than in the first match. That was always going to improve things. Fenix is wasted when he's on the mat for 90% of the bout. His strengths? Flying around the place showing nimble footwork on the ropes and coming agonisingly close to making high risks pay off.

Williams seemed to understand how to position himself for Rey's acrobatics this time, and that made the match a much better watch overall. It's legitimately nice to see guys who struggled before get into a groove. Improving on what came before is all you can ask workers to do.


2. Another Success Story For RHIYO

Rhea Ripley IYO SKY Lash Legend Nia Jax
WWE.com

Rhea Ripley and IYO SKY are fabulous together as Women’s Tag-Team Champs. Together, they had another solid match here vs. Nia Jax and Lash Legend. OK, so everyone could’ve done without the opening promo bit beforehand, but the match was tidy, and it’s worth saying that Lash and Nia are building something cool as partners themselves.

Yes, it's only a matter of time before Legend breaks out on her own, but that’s the point - Jax will play that role perfectly and help her mate get there. Here, they did their bit to make the match a stellar in-ring launching pad for SmackDown. The usual heat section on IYO was enjoyable to watch, and the crowd went wild for the hot tag to Rhea just like last week vs. Kiana James and Giulia.

Keep this us, and we might get the best Women’s Tag Title bout at WrestleMania yet.

There was a convincing near fall following SKY’s moonsault on Jax as well, and that prompted a “This Is Awesome” chant from the fans. They’re not always fitting and can feel a bit forced, but all 4 women definitely deserved to hear such glowing feedback on this occasion. The non-finish isn’t a problem either, because these teams could easily go at it again.

Besides, the post-match stuff with Nia’s table bump looked awesome and does suggest there's more coming. Maybe Nick Aldis can point back to that spot and turn RHIYO vs. Nia and Lash into a 'No DQ' effort, or even a tables bout? Don't rule it out.


1. Main Event Keeps Everyone Guessing

Cody Rhodes Jacob Fatu Sami Zayn
WWE.com

Cody Rhodes won Friday's headliner to qualify for the Chamber, but either Jacob Fatu or Sami Zayn could’ve nabbed that spot themselves. The sub-story of Drew McIntyre potentially helping Sami win because he views Zayn as a soft target was logical, and the action was simply marvellous once they got going and worked through the early feeling out process. Credit to Wade Barrett for putting across the urgency of winning matches the closer we get to WrestleMania 42 too.

Nobody wants to risk missing out on the big weekend, after all.

Overall, this proved to be way less predictable than last week’s Triple Threat main event pitting Randy Orton vs. Aleister Black vs. Solo Sikoa. Orton was the stand out headliner from that pack, so he was always going to win. This week, all 3 guys could stake a claim to going after the WWE Title at 'Mania, and that desperation their characters have for gunning down Drew came bursting through the screen.

It was a little odd (at first) to see Zayn clock Drew with a Helluva Kick when the Scot had effectively tried to help Sami win, but then...Zayn didn't really see any of that. He was knocked out cold when McIntyre draped him over Cody, so he might've thought the WWE Champ was there to scupper his title aspirations all over again.

WWE put on a show with this main event. Each man involved had a realistic chance of emerging victorious, and Drew's run in didn't take away from the bout's flow at all.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more like this, check out 11 WrestleMania 42 Card Predictions After WWE Royal Rumble 2026 and The WORST Moment From Every WWE WrestleMania!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.