6 Ups & 4 Downs For AEW Collision (Oct 7 - Results & Review)
A shocking title change, an exceptional match, and Adam Copeland's AEW Collision debut.
Live from Salt Lake City, Utah's Maverik Center, another edition of AEW Collision is now in the books.
Going into this week's Collision, the main talking point was a first appearance on AEW's Saturday show for a certain Rated-R Superstar. Heading out of Collision, though, it may well be a shocking title change that steals the headlines.
As for that title change, Ricky Starks and Big Bill dethroned FTR to become the new AEW Tag Team Champions. Elsewhere, Bryan Danielson and Aussie Open's Kyle Fletcher put on an excellent battle; Bullet Club Gold's Juice Robinson and the Gunns took on Angelico, Gravity and Metalik; 'Switchblade' Jay White continued to present himself as the AEW World Champion; the Acclaimed and Daddy Ass defended the AEW Trios Titles against the Iron Savages and Jacked Jameson; Kiera Hogan went up against 'Timeless' Toni Storm; and the Mad King himself, Eddie Kingston, put his ROH World Title on the line against the high-flying Komander.
A somewhat mixed bag of an episode for Collision, but still nevertheless an episode with plenty of positives.
With all of that in mind, then, Saturday night's alright for fighting...
Downs...
4. Because Who's Watching ROH, Right?
Angelico, Metalik & Gravity have the opportunity to gain a huge victory against Bullet Club Gold tonight!
Watch #AEWCollision LIVE on TNT!#JuiceRobinson | @coltengunn | @theaustingunn | @Mascaradorada24 | @GravityLuchador | @Angelico_AEW pic.twitter.com/pxeWqM9gPR
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) October 7, 2023
Few people are watching Ring of Honor on a weekly basis, but if you're one of those few, you'd be forgiven for thinking you're wasting your time.
Why's that? Well, AEW Collision this week saw Angelico team with Gravity and Metalik to take on Juice Robinson and the Gunns. The problem here is, if you've been keeping up with ROH, Angelico has been working as a heel, while Gravity and Metalik are babyfaces. Not just that, but the past two episodes of ROH television have seen Angelico in matches against Gravity and Metalik. Who was Angelico teaming with on those occasions? That'd be Serpentico, who is also a heel and was also along for the ride as he accompanied this trio to the ring.
Yes, this Collision six-man match was somewhat of a nothing affair designed to give Bullet Club Gold a win and allow for a post-match Jay White promo, but putting the Bang Bang Gang against such a bizarre team totally takes a dump on what's been seen over in Ring of Honor.
Angelico, Gravity and Metalik were merely bodies selected to put over BCG, but could you have not found a trio who are actually already aligned? Or who have at least all been positioned as babyfaces on your other TV? Or even better, haven't been battling each other on that TV?
3. Another Fake Champion
Last Wednesday's Dynamite saw Jay White take possession of the AEW World Championship which belongs to MJF. That's a heel doing heel things, making you want to root for the hero to get their prize back. Okay, fine.
Now though, Collision had Switchblade play up how he's the real World Champion and that his match against Adam Page on Title Tuesday in a matter of days will actually be a Title Eliminator contest for Hangman.
Ordinarily, this would feel a little bit naff, but making this even worse is that AEW has just literally run a couple of months of programming where someone else was falsely claiming to be a champion and acting as if he'd partaken in title defences. Of course, that was Christian Cage and the TNT Title, which at that time actually belonged to Luchasaurus.
Tony Khan seems to have a strange habit of undermining his own product by repeating things. For instance, how often do we see open challenges used to set up matches rather than, y'know, getting to those matches by storytelling? Or how about when when we get #1 contenders matches on simultaneous weeks? Or what about running a tag team blind eliminator tournament at the same time that you're running your men and women's Owen Hart tournaments?
For Tony to pivot to another 'fake champion' story just two weeks after Christian Cage's similar antics came to an end, that just feels so lazy and uninspired.
2. A Little Too Competitive
Full disclosure, your writer here sees a whole bunch of upside in the Iron Savages. The problem is, after 'Dirty Bulk' Bronson and 'Sauce Hoss' Beefcake Boulder were beaten by FTR in a three-minute squash match just a matter of weeks ago, that firmly established the Savages place in the food chain.
So, to have Bronson, Beefcake, and Jacked Jameson go nearly ten minutes against the Acclaimed and Daddy Ass felt a little off in how audiences have been conditioned to view the Iron Savages right now. An even stranger decision was having the Savages and Jameson take so much of the match, dominating the AEW Trios Champions for substantial periods.
The champs did get the win, but this could've been over in half the time.
Still, props to Nigel McGuinness for some divine commentary lines featuring "posterior on the menu" and the "Ricca-bone-zone".
1. Same Old Problems
It would be great to have one week where the AEW women's division doesn't land on the Downs side of these articles. Well, technically there was one week - where Kris Statlander retained the TBS Title against Dr. Britt Baker, D.M.D. - but again the company's women were given short shrift in their usual way on Collision.
To highlight the numbers once more, this two-hour Collision broadcast featured just one women's match, which clocked in at just over eight minutes. Of those eight minutes, three of them were spent in a picture-in-picture commercial.
What will it take for Collision to feature maybe two women's bouts? How about another 15-minute battle between two major names? Or an appearance from the AEW Women's Champion? Clearly, the frustrating use - or lack thereof - of the promotion's female talent is nothing new and nothing exclusive to Collision, but this continues to just be absolutely baffling.
As for the match between Toni Storm and Kiera Hogan, it was fine for what it was. Hogan looked good on offense, Storm is always great, but there were a few spots were the timing was a smidge off. And speaking of time, there were several points where you could audibly hear referee Mike Posey giving the two wrestlers time cues.
Ups...
6. Pre-Titles Promos
As ever, AEW Collision will always get an Up whenever they use pre-titles promos as a way to whet the appetite for what's about to come.
This time out, it was Bryan Danielson, Kyle Fletcher, Ricky Starks & Big Bill, Eddie Kingston, and FTR who all got to throw some short, sharp barbs in the direction of their opponents.
So simple, so effective.
5. An 'Absolute' Shocker
Ricky Starks and Big Bill are your new AEW Tag Team Champions, and likely not a single person saw this coming.
The match itself wasn't particularly up to much, but it wasn't designed to be. Cash Wheeler was immediately left laying on the outside, Dax Harwood essentially found himself in a handicap match, Wheeler was then put through the announce table, Harwood was hit by three chokeslams, before Starks hit a spear to pin Dax and secure the 1-2-3 in less than five minutes.
This was dominant, this was shocking, and it certainly shakes up the AEW tag team ranks.
Starks may have come up short in his quest to secure the Real Worlds Championship, but the Stroke Daddy now has his first piece of official AEW gold; the FTW Title not being formally recognised, of course. So much of this match was once again about making Big Bill look like an absolute monster here, and Ricky Starks looked simply, well, Absolute.
Given how many were presuming we'd soon be getting another FTR vs. Young Bucks match for the AEW Tag Team Titles - with the Bucks having recently won a title shot - it remains to be seen where this now leaves Dax and Cash. Interestingly, Fightful Select notes there's been speculation that Wheeler could well be injured, although that has yet to be confirmed. As per Starks in a later backstage promo, FTR purportedly will not be getting an immediate rematch either.
4. Danielson And Fletcher Excel
Given how good he's been during his time in NJPW and nowadays in AEW/ROH, it's easy to forget that Kyle Fletcher is just 24 years of age. That was something that was noted at several points on this week's Collision, tying into the fact that Bryan Danielson has actually been wrestling for 24 years.
Bryan was obviously Bryan here, bringing the intensity, technical wizardry, and selling he forever brings to the table, but Fletcher deserves so much credit for making the most of an opportunity to be spotlighted in a big singles match against arguably the best wrestler on the planet.
In particular, the Aussie Open man's selling was on point, with an early surfboard from the American Dragon being a highlight. That in itself was shortly followed by an extremely scary dive to the outside from Fletcher, but that ropey landing didn't seem to shake the former IWGP Tag Team Champion too much.
Fletcher also went toe-to-toe with Danielson in terms of bringing an impressively aggressive edge to his offense, whether that be strikes, suplexes, or submissions. Obviously the Australian would come up short against Bryan, yet Kyle showed more than enough to indicate he'll be absolutely fine should he be utilised as a singles act while his part Mark Davis recovers from a broken wrist.
After Bryan had scored the 1-2-3 with a majestic reversal, a post-match Gates of Agony attack on the Blackpool Combat Club grappler was thwarted by Claudio Castagnoli and Wheeler Yuta - as Swerve Strickland is up next for Danielson.
Obviously Nigel McGuinness gets plentiful praise once again for his continuous utter disdain for Bryan Danielson, with each passing week of McGuinness commentary only furthering the appetite for one more Danielson vs. McGuinness match down the line. AEW All In 2024, anyone?
3. Timeless Toni Time
Despite the aforementioned, painfully familiar issues with the positioning of the company's women on this week's Collision, 'Timeless' Toni Storm deserves an Up for just how darn entertaining she is.
This is nothing new, of course, and this character tweak for Toni has received praise plentiful times on Ups & Downs in recent weeks. But just everything about Storm right now is clicking in a major way.
The former AEW Women's Champion has long been great between the ropes, but now she has a stunning entrance, a magnificent demeanour, and only continues to add to her overall package by doing things like bringing out scripts, throwing to ad breaks, and making sure to pose before hitting her hip attack that's the beginning of the end for an opponent.
Not just is this the best ever iteration of Toni Storm, but it's a character who is one of the most engaging and entertaining figures in the entire industry.
2. A Solid ROH Title Match
Whether ROH titles should be defended so regularly on AEW programming is a topic for another day, but that aside, Eddie Kingston defending his ROH World Championship against Komander was solid enough.
In other circumstances, this match going ten minutes might have seemed a little too much when considering how Komander has long been positioned as an afterthought, an enhancement talent, a body to be disposed of within minutes.
However, this issue was nicely navigated by Ian Riccaboni noting how Kingston has historically always struggled against high flyers and luchadors, dating back to his Chikara days. The Mad King got the win, as he should do, with the Uraken, and Komander had enough moments to showcase his always impressive athleticism.
Not spectacular, not awful, but just fine for what it was as a way to round out the competitive in-ring action of this week's Collision.
1. Copeland's Collision Course
Nowadays #AllElite, this weekend saw Adam Copeland make his AEW Collision debut. All as Jim Ross, Nigel McGuinness and Ian Riccaboni did their absolute best not to refer to the 11-time World Champion as Edge.
Continuing to push towards an inevitable Copeland vs. Christian Cage bout down the line, here we had the WWE Hall of Famer call out his on-off BFF as he highlighted how they both had their careers put on hold due to supposedly career-ending injuries.
Of course, Adam only got a video screen response from smug prick Cage, and the TNT Champion soon sent Luchasaurus and Nick Wayne to do his bidding. That two-on-one beatdown was briefly halted by Darby Allin, before Allin himself was likewise left laying.
All of this nicely set things up for Copeland and Luchasaurus' match on Tuesday, while adding a nice slice of viciousness to the recently-turned Wayne and sparking more fire to the brewing rivalry between Nick and Darby.
As an aside, it was also nice to see Copeland address Jim Ross, with JR clearly moved by the Canadian's kind words.