7 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE Survivor Series 2017
Excitement, disappointment, and good old-fashioned nepotism.
Most WWE fans approached Survivor Series 2017 with a great deal of excitement. With one of the most star-studded lineups in modern pay-per-view history perfectly positioned in a compelling series of inter-brand clashes, the stage was set for a real blow-away show, closing the chaotic #UnderSiege arc on a breathtaking high.
Did it deliver?
Yes and no.
WWE peppered Survivor Series with excellence, but there were plenty of moments that illustrated the dangers of succumbing to their remarkably efficient hype machine. Spotlights were stolen as younger stars took the backseat to part-time veterans. Over-booking plagued both traditional elimination matches, though they weren't without high points. The other bouts' quality varied, and while a couple somehow over-delivered, several swung in the opposite direction.
Brock Lesnar, The Shield, AJ Styles, John Cena, Triple H, Kurt Angle, Randy Orton: the show featured every major name WWE could have conceivably called on. They delivered a good pay-per-view, but not a great one, and while the end sum was a net positive, it's hard to shake the feeling that Survivor Series should've been more.
Let's take a journey through the night's many peaks and valleys.
Downs...
5. A Troublesome Layout
While the women's 5-on-5 elimination match wasn't entirely bad, the bulk of the bout was a discombobulated mess with a poor layout.
A considerable portion was built around a monster vs. monster clash between Nia Jax and Tamina. This sounds logical, but the execution wasn't there. Neither is particularly skilled between the ropes, and they were unable to transcend their limitations in the big match setting. Jax's count-out elimination keeps her protected, but we were then forced to watch another 10-15 minutes of Tamina labouring her way around the ring, as she inexplicably made it to the final three.
There was a huge botch on Alicia Fox's elimination, with the official failing to register a three count. Becky Lynch was pinned disappointingly early. Bayley, Carmella, and Naomi were non-factors. With Paige and Nikki Bella looming, Natalya was a flat fifth SmackDown participant.
The bout didn't really heat up until the last five minutes, but the bookers completely failed to make the most of what should've been a high-energy turf war.
4. Kickoff Shows: Still Skippable
The first two matches on Survivor Series' Kickoff Show were much of a muchness. Neither Matt Hardy vs. Elias nor Enzo Amore vs. Kalisto did anything to dispel the notion that this portion of the pay-per-view is entirely skippable, and even though the latter was a title fight, you'd have missed nothing at all by swerving the first 90 minutes of WWE's coverage.
Hardy vs. 'The Drifter' was a textbook limb match, with Elias continually working Matt's arm en route to the finish. Simple, basic wrestling psychology executed competently, but there was little heat throughout, and the offence was as middle-of-the-road as it gets. It was a dull Raw match played out on a PPV pre-show: exactly what you'd expect, basically.
While that bout wallowed in mediocrity, the Cruiserweight Title clash was actively bad. Kalisto is skilled, but not skilled enough to drag a good match from a dud like Enzo Amore, and their battle was in-line with their previous encounters. That means it was sloppy, disjointed, and entirely without merit, and it's about time WWE found new opponents for both.
3. Charlotte Cruises Through Alexa
There was a real risk of Charlotte Flair vs. Alexa Bliss turning into a dangerous botchfest last night. There has always been a haphazard element to the former's work, despite her positive qualities, and Bliss has exhibited poor chemistry with some of the best workers in the company - Becky Lynch, most notably.
This could've been a disastrous cocktail, but while the duo were successful in keeping the match on the rails, it still didn't meet its billing as a first-time champion vs. champion clash.
Charlotte and Alexa worked at a house show-esque pace, keeping things pedestrian throughout the first ten minutes, before opening up towards the end. Flair's sit-out powerbomb ushered in a strong final third that saw Bliss blow several notable opportunities to win, before her opponent blasted her with a big boot, then tapped her out with Figure Eight. A solid conclusion, but the match went on way too long, and the action wasn't consistent enough to compensate.
2. A Complete & Utter Shambles
TLC 2017's main event was an overbooked car crash of a match that featured every bad WWE booking trope, yet still succeeded as a gloriously ludicrous spectacle.
WWE captured lightning in a bottle. Such layouts usually produce unwatchable dreck, and after that bout's success, there was always the risk WWE would make an ill-advised attempt at recreating the accidental magic in last night's men's elimination bout. That's precisely what they did, and it fell flat on its face.
Shinsuke Nakamura's early elimination was the last nail in his waning superstar aura's coffin. John Cena barely stuck around for a cup of coffee. Shane McMahon, a 47-year-old company executive, single-handedly ran Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens off. Bobby Roode was anonymous. Braun Strowman, the supposed 'Monster Among Men,' was neutralised for 20 minutes by a single suplex. The list goes on.
Survivor Series' main event was a clusterf*** of awful booking decisions, and the action wasn't exciting enough to compensate. It was a colossal failure, and while WWE birthed several new stories within its 33 minutes, they were centred around the wrong people...
1. Triple Bloody H
Ugh. Just... ugh.
Six days after inserting himself into the Survivor Series main event, Triple H completely dominated proceedings. He was in and out of the ring throughout, engaging in oddball exchanges with Bobby Roode and Shinsuke Nakamura, but nepotism didn't take hold until the last five minutes, when the match devolved into another twisted McMahon family drama.
The first swerve came when Hunter nailed team-mate Kurt Angle with a Pedigree, then draped a limp Shane McMahon over his General Manager for the elimination. Triple H appeared to aid his brother-in-law moments later, but no: he nailed Shane with his finisher, winning the match for his side, before suffering a decisive post-match beating at the furious Braun Strowman's hands.
WWE set up three individual storylines for 'The Game' during this spell. Meanwhile, Nakamura, Balor, Roode, Cena, and Orton left with nothing. It was exactly the kind of spotlight-hogging booking we've come to expect in such situations, but that doesn't make it any less disappointing, particularly with such a star-studded line-up.
Still, at least he gave us this gem.
Ups...
7. Marginalising Kevin & Sami
WWE fans were quick to bemoan the decision to book Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn on last night's Survivor Series Kickoff Show, but the move made sense.
The main card was already stuffed to the gills with seven big-time matches. Their clash with Breezango wasn't inter-brand, and would've been lost in the sea of Raw vs. SmackDown clashes, and the quality wasn't there either. The bout was fine, but nowhere close to PPV calibre, and therefore had no place on Survivor Series proper.
Aside from this, stuffing the duo on the pre-show also works from a storyline standpoint. Zayn and Owens despise Shane McMahon and Daniel Bryan. In booking them this early on the card, the powers that be are exasperating that tension, furthering the gloriously obnoxious 'them and us' narrative the duo have been pushing since Sami's turn at Hell In A Cell. Honestly, what more could you want?
6. Miz & Corbin Exceed Expectations
While The Miz vs. Baron Corbin wasn't a clash for the ages, the duo produced a tight, compelling bout that was a lot better than it should've been.
They went less than 10 minutes, and there was a solid story throughout, with Miz desperately fighting from beneath to protect his family's honour against a malevolent bully. It didn't work out, and 'The A-Lister' fell, but he deserves major credit for working his backside off. Miz was fiery and energetic, and did everything in his power to drag something enjoyable from Corbin, who usually works with the fluidity of a broken action figure. A loss in one column, but a triumph in another.
'The Lone Wolf' was in solid form by his standards, too. He hammed it up by goading Maryse and going after the Miztourage, which gifted multiple openings to his opponent, but not enough to cost Corbin the match. As odd as it is that WWE are giving him this push after spending most of the summer trying to cool him off, it'll be interesting to see how Baron maintains this moment on SmackDown.
5. Shield & New Day Open On A High
The Shield vs. The New Day wasn't half as great as it should've been.
This was a clash between WWE's two greatest modern stables, and six of the best wrestlers in the company. Their collective chemistry alone should've been enough to guarantee a blow-away match, and the story (with The New Day leading the charge in SmackDown's siege of Raw) would've taken it to the next level in another world, but it wasn't to be. The match was good rather than great, but there was still plenty to enjoy.
Things gradually unfolded from the plodding opening sequences, and picked up when the wrestlers finally decided to move from second to third gear. We got a huge Tower of Doom spot, a double Midnight Drive, and a top-rope triple powerbomb. Big E, the undisputed star of the match, shone throughout, and after watching him tangle with multiple Shield members at once, it'd be a crying shame if he isn't eventually pushed as a main eventer.
The Shield's victory was never in doubt, and even though the bout didn't live up to its colossal expectations, it was still a highlight. Here's hoping they eventually get the chance to deliver the kind of classic we know they have in them, though.
4. Vindication
After spending 33 minutes pummelling their audience with an unrelenting torrent of bulls*** during the night's main event, WWE closed Survivor Series on a satisfying note: Braun Strowman battering Triple H into oblivion.
'The Monster's' motivations didn't make much sense ('The Game' just won Team Raw the match, but Braun reacted like they'd lost), but it didn't matter. Having watched Triple H unapologetically steal the spotlight from several younger, more popular full-time roster members, seeing him fall to Strowman's two running powerslams was immensely satisfying, and ensured Survivor Series closed on a high.
Make no mistake, the night belonged to Triple H, but at least Braun had his moment. He's the most organic star in the company right now. The audience love him, and WWE would be nuts not to build WrestleMania 34 around him, but we all know they're heading towards Roman Reigns vs. Brock Lesnar. Regardless, moments like this remind us how special he is.
3. Tag Teams Raise The Bar
The Bar vs. The Usos was, unsurprisingly, a major Survivor Series highlight. It was one of only a handful of bouts that lived up to the pre-show hype, and while a shade or two below Jimmy and Jey's recent clashes with The New Day, it'll go down as another excellent tag match in a year full of them.
The Usos were as relentless as ever, unleashing a quickfire Superkick party on their European foes. There were some apparent communication issues early on, but they were soon overcome, and the match eventually became the kind of all-action blitz we've come to expect in 2017. The one disappointment is that it felt like both sides were holding back for another match down the line, but it's hard to complain about what we got.
An inventive finish saw Jimmy dive out of the ring, tagging Jey mid-air, and landing on Cesaro. This allowed his brother to hit the top rope and splash Sheamus for the victory, concluding what was the night's best match up to that point, and tying the Raw vs. SmackDown score at 2-2.
2. Asuka Kills Everybody
Last night's women's 5-on-5 match finally presented Asuka in an appropriate light, with 'The Empress Of Tomorrow' running the closing stretches, eliminating Carmella, Tamina, and Natalya to secure victory for her brand.
Finally booked like the dangerous killer she was in NXT, Asuka shone. She was made to face Tamina and Nattie alone following Sasha Banks' elimination, but she was brutally effective, tapping both out in quick succession, and the crowd went nuts. Asuka looked like a bona fide star, proving that the 50/50 nature of her bouts with Emma were entirely destructive, and that this was the direction WWE should've taken all along.
'The Empress' was comfortably the best thing about this mess of a match. If WWE still believed in strong pushes, they'd have her continue down this path, buzzing her way through the rest of the women's division en route to a long, prosperous title reign. Instead, we'll likely get a dopey, go-nowhere feud with Alicia Fox or Dana Brooke. Still, let's enjoy the moment while we can...
1. Predictable Excellence
Professional wrestling really isn't all that complicated. Take two great wrestlers, put them in a spotlight, stay out of their way with regards to the booking, and they'll probably deliver a great match. That's exactly what happened with Brock Lesnar vs. AJ Styles, which was far and away the best thing on the show.
Lesnar looked more motivated than he has since facing Samoa Joe, and Styles was his usual excellent self as he flew around the ring like a madman, taking a number of hefty bumps for his monstrous opponent. 'The Beast' rag-dolled SmackDown's champion, took him to Suplex City, and generally beat the tar out of him, but it wasn't plain sailing. AJ came within a hair of winning on several occasions, and while the outcome was never in doubt, it was hard not to buy into 'The Phenomenal One' and his many pinfall attempts - such was the strength of his performance.
There were a couple of sloppy moments, but each actually added to the match, lending it a gritty, real fight feel. The finish was great, too, with Brock catching AJ's attempted Phenomenal Forearm, hoisting him up, then drilling him with a single F5.
This contest was everything fans could've hoped it'd be, and after a lethargic showing against Braun Strowman at No Mercy, exactly the kind of performance Lesnar needed to justify his lengthy Universal Title reign.