7 Wrestlers WWE Punished For Getting Over

Brass rings of fire.

Rusev Aiden English
WWE

During a now infamous special edition of the WWE Network's Stone Cold Podcast with Vince McMahon back in 2014, the chairman responded to the host's claim that the modern day roster are more afraid of taking chances than colleagues of his day with two pieces of advice:

1) "Don't p*ss people off!" and 2) "Reach for that brass ring."

What Vince didn't elucidate was that he was describing a Heller-esque logical conundrum, in which trying to do the latter unavoidably accomplishes the former. In a post-Rock era - a man whose own fortunes were predicated on grasping brass - attempts to raid Vince's jewellery drawer are met with swift rebuttal. As a result, the term 'brass ring' has wormed its way into the wrestling fandom, reliable short-hand for the short shrift awaiting performers who attempt to promote their prospects.

It's the sort of whacky-backwards logic which leads to bakers making terrible cakes lest they sell out. The Rock may have left WWE high-and-dry after hightailing it to Hollywood, but there's a reason he remains just about the company's last link to mainstream relevance.

Who will they call upon in ten years time when they need an injection of interest? Based on how they murdered their momentum, it won't be any of these guys.

7. Fandango

Fandango WrestleMania 29
WWE

When Chris Jericho's first-choice of a WrestleMania 29 match against Ryback was shot down - a seemingly asinine suggestion outwith the context of the big man's historical but by-then hemorrhaging popularity - Vince McMahon had a new idea.

Johnny Curtis - now sporting flared leather pants under the sobriquet 'Fandango' - was chosen to dance down the aisle to face Y2J. Against all expectations, he two-stepped his way to a shock 'Mania win.

The next night, inspired by the ineradicable earworm that was Fandango's theme tune, an already ribald post-WrestleMania Raw crowd spent the entire show serenading the roster with the catchy salsa song.

'Fandangoing' soon became a cultural phenomenon, with the craze gradually catching on beyond the auspices of wrestling arenas; incredibly, the chintzy tongue-in-cheek melody nearly managed to crack the UK Top 40 music charts.

For WWE, that was a sign that things had gone too far. Presuming - admittedly, correctly - that Fandango's theme was more popular than the man himself, the company quickly moved to steal his last dance. He lost to Chris Jericho at the very next pay-per-view, and was subsequently relegated back to the undercard.


6. Damien Sandow

Damien Sandow table
WWE.com

Damien Sandow was forced to fight the shovel for years during his second WWE spell, the company seemingly doggedly determined to bury him like a proverbial bone.

By the end, it was simply bone-headed. Sandow had managed to ride out being the necessary concept-saving Money in the Bank sacrifice, not to mention being repositioned as comedy fodder for the likes of an even-then superannuated DX and the actual Hugh Jackman. But surely being asked to imitate The Miz in a series of asinine skits would at last be the final nail in the coffin?

Sandow embraced a gimmick tailor-made to fail, and soon began receiving reactions far outstripping the level of his push. Come WrestleMania 31's Andre Battle Royal, all anybody wanted to see was the rechristened 'Mizdow' eliminate his overbearing employer and claim the trophy.

He did the first bit - to one of the biggest ovations of the night. But seconds later, he was dismally dumped by, of course, Big Show. The obvious and inviting programme never came to fruition, and Sandow became an afterthought. In this scenario, the superstar's popularity was in excess of his potential - but there was still no real excuse for the colossal waste of such a gimme.


5. Bad News Barrett

WWE Battleground King Barrett
WWE.com

Cody Rhodes was always ahead of the curve. Years before shaking up the business with his All In and subsequent AEW ventures, he was making it on his own with a WWE sanctioned act of defiance.

In 2013, The JBL and Cole Show - a WWE YouTube platform for underutilised talent to showcase themselves - quickly became the Cody Rhodes Show. Exhibiting an embryonic preview of his future Being The Elite persona, Rhodes entertaining skits far surpassed anything he was being told to do on actual programming. If they weren't going to use him properly, he'd do it himself.

Others caught on to the idea. His chief sidekick was Wade Barrett, mostly meandering since the miserable dissolution of Nexus. Riling the roster under the alias 'Bad News Barrett', the Brit - and his catchphrase - earned admirers, and the gimmick was soon promoted to Raw.

As it had on YouTube, Bad News Barrett's pristine delivery got over big time. Apparently, Vince McMahon had never seen an episode of The JBL and Cole show; this had not been the intention.

With crowds increasingly cheering his appearances, WWE had some bad news of their own for Barrett: he had to tone the schtick down because it was simply too popular. It subsequently vanished altogether, the gavel replaced with a sceptre for a 'King' gimmick more akin to a court jester.


4. Daniel Bryan

Daniel Wyatt Bray Wyatt
WWE.com

Any 'burial' that culminates in a performer hoisting two prestigious belts above their head at the close of a spectacular commemorative edition of WrestleMania can't exactly be considered chasmic, but there's absolutely no doubt whatsoever Daniel Bryan's apogee was not WWE's intended conclusion to his arc.

An undersized underdog with an independent acumen, Bryan was simply not suited for WWE's very particular predilections during the start of his second run - and he was reminded at every opportunity. Years of mistreatment reached their nadir with an infamous 18 second defeat to Sheamus in the WrestleMania XXVIII opener, and that, they hoped, was that for the pro-Bryan lobby.

Ultimately, it backfired spectacularly. With Bryan as their champion, the 'Resentment Era' kicked off in earnest. The people's hero's popularity couldn't be suppressed even when he was transitioned into a tag team with Kane, and fairly soon the 'Yes! Movement's momentum was unstoppable.

With Batista's big return on the horizon, WWE moved to squash the yes-man for good. Bryan was given a one-day title reign to placate his perceived cultists - in reality, a majority of the audience - before being briefly repackaged in the Wyatt Family.

It was only when Big Dave was so vociferously rejected in the infamous Philadelphia Royal Rumble shambles that WWE's hand was finally forced. Bryan - and the fans - were begrudgingly given what they wanted. Fate snatched it away within a month, so Vince got the last laugh anyway.


3. Rusev Day

Rusev Aiden English
wwe

You get the impression that WWE only intended Rusev Day to be an ephemeral, not quotidian celebration - that's if they ever intended for it to be a thing at all.

In late 2017, Rusev, his early aura all but evaporated following a drastic 'love-square' programme and the insipid League of Nations, found solace in fellow lost soul Aiden English, himself left rudderless following the dismissal of Vaudevillain partner Simon Gotch. Mere days after the period was put on Rusev's prolonged depush via a 10-second squash at the boot of Randy Orton, the Bulgarian totally reversed his fortunes with the aid of English.

Making the most of legitimately being offered the freedom of the city in hometown Plovdiv, Rusev declared the occasion a holiday in his honour. Rusev Day was born - and it was to be observed every day.

With the help of English literally singing his virtues, soon everybody was celebrating Rusev Day, and the phrase began unintentionally interfering with every aspect of programming, as the pair's popularity skyrocketed.

But Rusev's drastic pay-per-view record failed to improve. WWE either didn't realise what they had on their hands - or didn't want to. Tellingly, Rusev revealed that he'd originally devised the whole bit to draw heat; that is was garnering the best babyface reactions in the company probably had his employers' heads spinning.

Though not quite a 'burial', there was little attempt made to capitalise on the self-generated phenomenon. The failure of Rusev's WWE Title tilt at Extreme Rules was gesture more than generosity. The team were eventually disbanded in October last year, leaving them largely back where they were.


2. Cesaro

Sad Cesaro wwe
WWE.com

An annual winner of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter's unwanted Most Underrated of the Year award, Cesaro, the subject of Vince McMahon's infamous 'brass ring' analogy, actually managed to grasp one in 2014 - but it soon began to tarnish.

Wowed not just by his superhuman strength - and dizzying giant swing - but his accomplished wrestling acumen, the groundswell of support for Cesaro soon began to spill over to WWE's mainstream audience, with the 'Cesaro Section' annexing increasing large portions of each arena. Seemingly recognising the fact, the Swiss sensation was quickly excised from comedy team the Real Americans, and handed the then-legitimate honour of winning the first ever Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal at WrestleMania XXX.

The sky seemed the limit for Cesaro, particularly when he was aligned with Paul Heyman on the following night's Raw. Nope. Just as he was getting into the swing of stardom, he was told to stop the move; it was "too popular". The Heyman arrangement was a mere smokescreen for the Swiss to eat pins, whilst not devaluing him. There were more holes in that logic than gruyère; effectively, the 'Cesaro Section' was given an epidural.


1. Zack Ryder

Kane Zack Ryder
WWE.com

WWE's systematic, purposeful spilling of the 'Long Island Iced-Z' has latterly become the poster child for the company's perverse proclivity for punishing talent who dare get over on their own.

Buying into the adage that you write your own success, Ryder embraced the YouTube revolution with a self-directed series years before his paymasters had wrapped their heads around the platform's potential. His Z! True Long Island Story channel drew a flood of followers, endeared by the entertaining, honest portrayal of its host.

Before long, Ryder's new fans were vocally petitioning for an on-screen expansion of his character - much to the chagrin of The Rock, whose post-Survivor Series 2011 oratory was completed drowned out by chants of "We want Ryder!"

WWE had no choice but to relent, and rewarded the self-awarded Internet Champion with a real title run. Unfortunately, it was the United States a strap - a leathery backhanded compliment if there ever was one.

Ryder's new platform was sufficiently visible for a very public disassembly. Girlfriend Eve Torres turned her eye towards John Cena even as her partner became Kane's personal punching bag. When The Big Red Machine wheeled him off the stage, Zack's emergent career revival went over the edge with him.


Watch Next


Editorial Team
Editorial Team

Benjamin was born in 1987, and is still not dead. He variously enjoys classical music, old-school adventure games (they're not dead), and walks on the beach (albeit short - asthma, you know). He's currently trying to compile a comprehensive history of video game music, yet denies accusations that he purposefully targets niche audiences. He's often wrong about these things.