8 Misconceptions About TNA You Probably Believe
Debunking some of the awfulness behind the often-coined "Total Nonstop Awful"
First, the truth: Total Nonstop Awful has been an accurate descriptor for Total Nonstop Action more often than they'd care to admit.
Vince Russo slut-shamed women because he was refused a look at their "breasts, bro" during a time when he served as a member of TNA's creative team and was cast as the puppeteer of the Sports Entertainment Xtreme faction. SEX! Claire Lynch, a supposed addict (who would need to be to trudge through this muck) faked a pregnancy as a Christopher Daniels and Kazarian-orchestrated joke against AJ Styles - itself being the payoff to a rumoured AJ Styles-Dixie Carter affair. The Johnsons -a slang term often used to describe a penis - were a tag team dressed head-to-toe in flesh-coloured bodysuits. They weren't even the worst tag team at the time; that accolade went to The Rainbow Express. Comprising Kwee Wee and Lenny Lane of WCW infamy, they were handed the gimmick of a homosexual couple because lol, could you even imagine being gay.
It was all terrible.
That is true - but these commonly held beliefs are not, and if you consider any of them as fact, then you simply haven't watched the product outside of YouTube lowlight compilations...
8. The Hulk Hogan Era Was TNA's Worst
Nine years before All Elite Wrestling pocketed the phrase for its annual May showcase, TNA went double or nothing when they appointed Hulk Hogan and Eric Bischoff as a creative consultant and an executive producer, respectively, but Hogan and Bischoff had contributed in excess to the death of World Championship Wrestling not even a decade earlier. TNA knew fine well what they were getting themselves into.
So what were they thinking?
Money.
Hogan and Bischoff carried name value. Slapping their faces on a product would draw attention. Their self-booked vanity project of a run was a rehash of the glory days, consistently dominating the spotlight while in-house projects took a backseat. Even Abyss, who was aligned with their latest faux nWo project, failed to benefit by association.
TNA's worst era wasn't with Hogan and Bischoff at the helm, though; it was the omnishambles left in the wake of their exit that marked the company's lowest point. Between late 2013 and early 2018, innumerable factors converged to cast a dark cloud over TNA, the most prolific being their removal from Spike TV, which spurred a five-year spat of channel surfing. With a product that was rotten to the core and a mass talent exodus leaving them without a sniff of an identity, TNA should've - and almost did! - died, so yes, while Hogan and Bischoff tore TNA down from within, it wasn't they who knocked down the final pillar.
7. Women Were Always Treated Like Stars
No wrestling promotion has ever wholly done good by its female employees. It is moronic to believe so because professional wrestling, as in real life, is a deeply sexist environment. A recent study revealed that 73% of online abuse towards wrestlers is directed at women, a statistic that is more unsurprising than it is horrid.
You would like to believe that TNA is the exception to the rule, given how well-presented and highly-lauded its Knockouts division has been - but that is wrong.
Televised evidence which testifies TNA's historical mistreatment of its female talent includes Angelina Love and Madison Rayne taking turns to flash referee Brian Stiffler, a segment which holds the most views on TNA's YouTube channel, the first all-women's match in TNA history being a lingerie Battle Royal to crown Miss TNA, a crown whose second owner was Bruce, a male, because, remember, he's gay(!), and Goldy Locks, the original backstage interviewer for TNA, being subjected to a dwarf beating his meat within touching distance of her, complete with grimacing facial expressions.
That, somehow, was not the worst: the late Shannon 'Daffney' Spruill being subjected to an enforced striptease was. Having drawn the short straw out of four keys, Daffney was marched to the ring and ordered to strip. It was horrendous.
Throwing together a few Knockouts for an Ultimate X match doesn't erase the past.
6. TNA Lacks Originality
To paraphrase a brilliant Matthew Rehwoldt call from TNA's Slammiversary 2025 pay-per-view, "this is the most TNA thing of all time". He was referring to Jeff Hardy having achieved victory in a masterclass of a multi-team Ladder match by summoning a rope ladder from the ceiling.
That was the most recent instance of TNA displaying itself as a promotion which thrives on outside-the-box creativity, though it is essential to strike a balance, given that 70% of it has been drab crap. Near enough every TNA-incorporated match stipulation has been a clusterf*ck of the highest degree. Lockdown was the sort of concept that gets brought up on a Zoom call at 4:59 on a Friday afternoon and never discussed again, except this time, it was discussed again. Black Reign killed all interest in Dustin Rhodes as a performer until the 2010s. Their penchant for murdering wrestlers when they disembark the TNA ship a la EastEnders is a hilariously dumb concept, but hilarious all the more when the murderer is never charged with a crime and the murdered later returns.
Then, there is the good stuff. Ultimate X is always well-received. A Television Title with weekly defences on television(!) was a deft, if brief, concept. Gut Check was a developmental showcase that should have been stolen by WWE already. Open Fight Night offered a change of pace from the week-to-week arc, allowing anyone from the World Champion to the backstage janitor to settle their beef in the ring.
It is hardly groundbreaking material, but in a medium so full of theft, it is refreshing to see TNA try out something new.
5. They Didn't Benefit From The AEW Partnership
You are ignorant to believe that TNA didn't emerge from its one-year AEW partnership all the more better for doing so, particularly as the falsehoods surrounding it are easily solved by reading an excerpt from an interview between Fightful's Sean Ross Sapp and Scott D'Amore, the former TNA President (h/t to Fightful):
“At the time, IMPACT was really struggling to [garner] traction. We were doing our damndest and putting out everything we could, but really struggling to find ourselves. Getting Kenny Omega as IMPACT World Champion and getting The Good Brothers featured on their [AEW's] show. From a business point of view, the two Kenny pay-per-views, were two of the three highest pay-per-views the company had at that point. Even the one with Christian when he came in was pretty high when it came to buys. There was a lift in business and viewership. A massive lift on social views and monetisation. Anything that was Kenny Omega monetized well. [...] Did it have its hindrance, as far as what some of the restraints were? Sure. That’s why it ultimately had to end. While we were doing it, there is no question from a financial point of view, it had its benefits. There is no question when it came to eyeballs, buzz and legitimacy, it certainly helped."
Inserting that quote isn't designed to eat into the word count; it's necessary information. April 2021's Rebellion, where Kenny Omega was hailed as the dual TNA and AEW World Champion, did nine times as many pay-per-views as the previous October's Bound For Glory, headlined by Rich Swann's triumph over Eric Young. TNA also achieved considerable boosts to its 18-49 demographic with Omega at the helm, a trait which continued well past his tyrannical reign over TNA.
The novelty of the partnership wore thin quickly for staunch TNA supporters, who tore into AEW and Tony Khan on social media for its lack of promoting the cross-promotional product, but who cares?
TNA was raking it in...
4. They Aren't Benefitting From The WWE Partnership
...and they still are.
At Slammiversary 2025, TNA broke its twelve-year North American attendance record when 7,623 punters filled Elmont, New York's UBS Arena, just shattering the previous record of 7,200 fans: that was set in March 2013 by Lockdown, which was located at San Antonio's Alamodome.
Why now?
The card was solid by TNA's standards, though nothing was outwardly must-see. AJ Styles' lauded comeback after a twelve-year absence performed exceptionally well analytics-wise for TNA's social media, but rumours regarding it only formalised in the days before.
Indeed, the involvement of WWE benefitted TNA to a degree which nothing else could have ever achieved, more specifically, WWE's marketing of the event. No wrestling fan is going to confess to purchasing a ticket because DarkState were announced - to fight Eddie Edwards, the former Fandango, and the latest reunited incarnation of The Edgeheads(!) no less - but the very principle behind the logistics of DarkState's involvement will draw staunch NXT supporters into an area of the medium which has been neglected for too long.
You are right to be critical of it as much as you were right to be optimistic by its existence, but you cannot statistically deny that TNA working with WWE is doing them wrong.
3. They Only Sign Former WWE Stars
Everybody does!
It is categorically impossible for a major wrestling outfit to not have a roster that is comprised largely of talents who had previously wrestled under the mangled banner of WWE. AEW had a four-year problem with hiring whichever WWE castoff was available that week, resulting in a lopsided roster that featured both the Bryan Danielsons and the Parker Boudreauxs of the pro wrestling spectrum. ROH, pre-AEW buyout, was a haven for lowly ex-WWE stars. Even New Japan(!) has fallen victim to the WWE plague.
But TNA, like their listed compatriots, is not strictly the home of WWE's unwanted treasures (and whatever you'd class AJ Francis as). Across 2024 and 2025, they have either signed or begun to regularly feature:
- Leon Slater, a 2023 Gut Check winner from Bradford, England, whose body of work at the tender age of 20 years old is criminally ludicrous.
- Mance Warner, a gifted, grizzled athlete whose contributions to the art of deathmatch wrestling in North America have helped convey the notion that not every over-the-top plunder brawl needs to follow the same arbitrary formula.
- KC Navarro, a buzzworthy cruiserweight standout who is as consistently eager to showcase his beligerent personality as he is to show out on major platforms.
- Maggie Lee - the now-M By Elegance - a towering figure whose standing within the Knockouts division has already been felt considerably.
Even when TNA does pluck from TNA's pool of "budget cuts", it is never done as a means of filling a spot on a show; TNA will always have a plan for its slew of signings that doesn't come at the expense of its existing crop.
2. Everybody Uses TNA As A Stepping Stone
WhatCulture's Michael Sidgwick, writing in the AEW iteration of this concept, addressed TNA's inability to maintain any stars they may create: specifically, Joe Hendry, Jordynne Grace, and Mike Santana, all three of whom became breakthrough talents in TNA, but who are expected to depart for WWE. Grace already has. Hendry won't be far behind her. Santana's contract is up before the year's end.
It is a fair and honest assessment of TNA's most prominently lacking trait - but it isn't all it's made out to be.
TNA will never be capable of creating and maintaining stars in the same manner as WWE and AEW have done, but they are no longer the layover they were throughout the company's infancy. TNA is now a seriously considered landing point for independent talents, evidenced by a large proportion of its currently active roster having maintained their position on the payroll for longer than twelve months. Eddie Edwards joined TNA in 2014. Moose did in 2016, as did Rosemary. Brian Myers and Chris Bey signed on in 2020, Steve Maclin in 2021, and Killer Kelly in 2022.
None are considered for the ballot when end-of-year awards season rolls around, but their commitment to TNA in an age in which they could easily land a more lucrative deal elsewhere is constantly rewarded.
1. They Were Always The Number Two Promotion In North America
"Our goal is to become the world's biggest professional wrestling company."
That was the line spewed by Dixie Carter, then-President of TNA Wrestling, upon the unveiling of Hulk Hogan as TNA's latest acquisition - and yet, TNA wasn't even the second biggest professional wrestling company.
By October 2009, the month in which Hogan was revealed to be crossing the line into TNA, Ring of Honor was fast emerging as a credible threat to TNA's throne. Its back-to-basics presentation of the art of pro wrestling was inviting to those turned off by WWE's poncy character-centric sports entertainment approach. This continued well into the 2010s, too, no matter how much TNA threatened to knock ROH. Internationally, Japan and Mexico were offering an entirely nuanced approach to the medium, with various promotions becoming more widely accessible. By 2019, when All Elite Wrestling was formalised, TNA was far removed from the conversation of being the second most-prominent wrestling group.
TNA's acquisition of Hogan - and Eric Bischoff, who helped orchestrate the deal - should have propelled TNA further in the race to tackle WWE, but it was screwed within one night of the Hogan and Bischoff-led stewardship.
Again: Hogan and Bischoff didn't hammer the final nail into TNA's coffin, but they certainly pulled the trigger.