8 Pieces Of Overwhelming Evidence That Vince McMahon Is Not A Visionary

1. He€™s Not A Creative Genius

When discussing WWE business ventures, I should point out that, despite a rocky start, WWE Studios (as it€™s known today) does make a profit, mostly due to a clever system of filmmaking and distribution in which the majority of their productions can make their small budgets back before release. It€™s also one of the only aspects of WWE€™s businesses that doesn€™t €˜benefit€™ from Vince McMahon€™s notorious micromanaging, since he knows nothing about the cinema industry. In other words, he can€™t take credit for their success: it€™s happening without him. However, I€™ve now gone through several of the badly conceived, appallingly executed business strategies and campaigns outside of professional wrestling that have cost the WWF/E and the McMahons umpteen million dollars over the years: decisions that give the lie to his reputation as a savvy businessman and entrepreneur. The art of the underhanded €˜homage€™ is a professional wrestling trope so entrenched in the industry that it€™s practically a gimmick in and of itself. I€™ve been through how Hulkamania wasn€™t a McMahon concept, and that the first Wrestlemania only differed from Starrcade in how many mainstream non-wrestling celebrities the WWF brought in€ well, the Attitude Era wasn€™t exactly an original notion either, given that much of the vibe and the content was both directly and indirectly taken from Paul Heyman€™s Extreme Championship Wrestling, with whom the WWF had business dealings at the time. Meanwhile, years earlier Eric Bischoff created the television format that WWE eventually co-opted, and still use for Monday Night RAW to this day. In the days before Nitro debuted, RAW was a one-hour taped show, and not a creatively impressive one. Bischoff introduced the idea of pacing a two-hour live television show like a supercard, showing main event calibre matches people wanted to see: it took McMahon a good year after Nitro€™s expansion to two hours to agree to extend RAW likewise, but it would remain taped one week in every two for well over a year after that, before going live every week when Smackdown began in 1999. Oh, and Smackdown? Debuted on Thursday nights as a direct answer to WCW€™s Thunder B-show. There€™s a case to be made that the only great ideas Vince McMahon ever had started in other people€™s heads. When he has had an idea all his own, it€™s almost invariably been a disaster, creatively and financially. His reputation as an innovator, an entrepreneur and a businessman are careful rewrites of history, stories told so often that they€™ve developed the ring of truth. But that€™s Vince McMahon€™s single great strength: he€™s a masterful, ruthless self-promoter: and like most self-promoters, he€™s worked the world into believing his hype.
Contributor
Contributor

Professional writer, punk werewolf and nesting place for starfish. Obsessed with squid, spirals and story. I publish short weird fiction online at desincarne.com, and tweet nonsense under the name Jack The Bodiless. You can follow me all you like, just don't touch my stuff.