8 Things We Learned From Pat McAfee On Stephanie McMahon's WWE Show

Pat McAfee isn't for everybody, but the WWE commentator is absolutely cool with that.

Pat McAfee Michael Cole
WWE.com

Pat McAfee isn't for everyone, and he knows it.

The WWE commentator even referred to himself as "a doofus" during a sit down interview for Stephanie McMahon's show on ESPN. McMahon wanted to know how Pat became such an energetic and integral part of the company's modern programming. McAfee's reply? He's "a doofus", and a "lucky" one - he knows he gets to clown around and just have fun.

There's some heartfelt passion behind all of the bravado and Duracell bunny hype. Pat revealed a lot about his personal life and ambitions during this snapshot chat with Steph, and it's well worth checking out even if you happen to roll your eyes at his soundbite-heavy commentary style during Raw and WWE PLEs.

You won't believe how McAfee used to make some extra pocket money in school. That 'hustle first, ask questions later' mentality was born from watching pro wrestling during the vivid 'Attitude Era'. There's something undeniably cool about the fact Pat knew from a young age he'd make his way into WWE eventually. The dude just wouldn't give up on that dream even when chasing others in the NFL or via real world sports analysis as a broadcaster or podcaster.

McMahon's natural ability to put her guests at ease, like she did during episodes with Rhea Ripley and Cody Rhodes, brought the best out in McAfee. He told fascinating tales about sharing the ring with Steve Austin, having heart to heart conversations with Triple H behind the curtain, who broke him into the business to begin with (that one was totally unexpected!) and more.

Also, did you know that Pat actually made his first appearance on WWE TV way back in 2009? Here's the full rundown on that and everything else.

8. His Career Day Aspiration At School Was To Be “Rich”

Stephanie McMahon Places Pat McAfee
ESPN/WWE

What did you jot down during career day at school? Police? Medic? WWE World Heavyweight Champion? They say all answers are valid, but then teachers go into tut tut mode when children start daydreaming or reach for the stars. Pat McAfee found that out firsthand when his school asked everyone to tell all on what they wanted to be when they were older.

Some in the class said firefighters or even teachers (the little suck-ups!), but McAfee hilariously wrote "rich" on his piece of paper. Honestly, the balls on this kid. His teach said that was pretty shallow, and they likely encouraged him to pick something else, but Pat wouldn't budge or change it. He had a good reason for coveting financial security though.

McAfee told Stephanie that he didn't want to walk into stores and struggle to pay for things like his mother. From a really young age, Pat had one goal in mind: "I wanted to change the trajectory of my family tree”. There's actually something pretty sweet about that - McAfee only wanted a better life for his family, and he knew earning some serious cash could make everybody more comfortable long-term.

McMahon was a little taken aback by Pat's outlook as a kid. Being fair, she had a completely different upbringing. Growing up, Steph wanted for pretty much nothing once her mother and father began reaping the rewards of their WWF/WWE empire with blockbuster events like WrestleMania. Meanwhile, in the more humble surroundings of Plum, Pennsylvania, the McAfee family had to count their pennies.

Pat was determined to change that as quickly as he could.


7. He Sold Cigarettes In Fifth Grade

Stephanie McMahon Places Pat McAfee
ESPN/WWE

Some of his schemes got him into serious trouble.

Pat revealed he was just 10 or 11 years old in fifth grade when he began selling cigarettes at school to make some cash. That business venture (ahem) all started when he wanted some grape juice for lunch. The juice was 50 cents extra, and he didn’t want to ask for that at home. So, McAfee took the butt of a cigarette from a teacher’s ashtray and sold it to some kid down the street for 50 cents. “Wait a minute - we got something here”, he said.

That one moment planted a business seed in Pat's brain, so he started building things up to the point he had a carton of cigarettes in his school bag. He got caught eventually, of course, and the school nearly expelled him for it. That's when McAfee's mother stepped in and fought for her son. She made sure Pat didn’t get kicked out. He’s grateful for that, because his life could’ve gone off in a totally different direction in a heartbeat.

Mrs. McAfee stunned members of the school board by pointing to the positives in her boy's story. He was showing entrepreneurial spirit, cigarettes or not. She figured that was worth overlooking if he promised to behave and channel his natural cleverness into something less unhealthy. Her argument worked, so Pat's mother must've cut one hell of a promo that day.

The Rock, Paul Heyman, CM Punk and other WWE promo experts would've been proud. Pat certainly was, and he was relieved he could stay put in school.


6. McAfee Almost Played Soccer

Stephanie McMahon Places Pat McAfee
ESPN/WWE

Cue endless back and forth debates about what the "real" football is. Is it American football or what's known in the UK as 'football football'? Pat McAfee had no time for that. He was just keen on making a good living for himself and his family, but he did blossom into a talented soccer player. Incredibly, Pat had "15 times" the number of schools trying to enlist him for a soccer scholarship compared to those interested in turning him into an NFL prospect.

In the end, he decided to go with American football.

Stephanie hit the nail on the head when McAfee asked why she thought he'd make such a decision. Pat and his family realised that he'd have to move to Europe if he ever wanted to make serious money as a footballer. "I'm an American baby", he added. So, the McAfees decided it'd be best if Pat took up one of the American football offers and pursued a career in that sport instead.

McAfee would become a punter for the NFL's Indianapolis Colts years later, but he had to put some serious hours in on the practice field to improve his skills. What's more, this crucial, life-altering decision happened during his senior year at high school, so the pressure was on. What if Pat made the wrong call and could've cut it in soccer instead? 

Stephanie's Places dropped a neat photo of McAfee shielding the ball on the soccer pitch. Things could've turned out rather differently for him had he been keen to move away from home. He might never have lived his WWE dreams.


5. Pat’s First WWE Appearance Was In 2009

Stephanie McMahon Places Pat McAfee
ESPN/WWE

The above screenshot is from the 12 October 2009 episode of WWE flagship show Raw. Check the contrast in facial expressions too; the dude on the right looks like he'd rather be anywhere else. Meanwhile, Pat in the middle is clearly having the time of his life and loving the fact that pro wrestling cameras are trained on him. McAfee wanted more of that. Way more.

He was a member of the Colts roster, so it made sense that WWE's cams focused on the group when running a show from Indianapolis, Indiana. Some of his teammates couldn't have cared less about the whole wrestling thing, but Pat was buzzing. He admits that some of his over the top reactions from behind the commentary desk were born during his cameos as a member of the Colts in '09.

McAfee appeared on camera for WWE TV shows several times over the next few years, and he was always energetic. When travelling to the arenas, Pat also told his teammates that he was “supposed to be a professional wrestler”. Some of them probs laughed at that, but he didn't care. The guy was manifesting hard. However, nobody would've suspected that the tanned jock with the wacky facial expressions in the front row was ever going to become a celebrated WWE colour commentator.

Pat didn't see that coming himself. He told McMahon that doing commentary was never his dream. If he was going to make it in WWE, it'd be as a full-time wrestler. It's funny how things shake out, eh? McAfee has had a few matches, but he's best known for using his voice rather than his fists.


4. His Pat McAfee Show Is “A 3 Hour Promo”

Pat McAfee
WWE

At one stage in this Stephanie's Places episode, Pat said he gets “to live the luckiest and dumbest life of all time”. He's paid oodles of cash to talk about pro wrestling and pro football, and he hosts a popular daily show on ESPN. What's more, network execs and even WWE bosses give McAfee a lot of freedom to do his own thing and say whatever's on his mind - he isn't over-produced.

This looser formatting lets Pat show off his charisma and personality every single time he grabs a microphone. To him, it's akin to cutting lengthy WWE-style promos, which he also appreciates isn't for everyone. In fact, when he's talking NFL or college football, McAfee is aware that the "sports media world doesn't know what a promo is".

They'd likely be horrified if he told them he was mimicking Steve Austin, The Rock or members of the current WWE roster.

Nobody can deny that Pat is really good at talking. It's interesting that he approaches his sports coverage like this. Some people just view him as a “loudmouth” (both in and out of the wrestling bubble), but he enjoys telling stories and aims to do that whether he's on Raw, WWE PLE or ESPN. Having that show of faith from show producers and Triple H is important to him.

The daily ESPN show is "a 3 hour promo", basically. Pat's infectious energy appeals to viewers tuning in; it's morning show radio host on caffeine content, and it's making McAfee a lot of money. He'll take that, especially because he's able to enjoy the best of both worlds: WWE and other sports.


3. A Chance Meeting Broke Him Into Wrestling

Stephanie McMahon Places Pat McAfee Scott Armstrong
ESPN/WWE

If you like Pat McAfee, thank Scott Armstrong. If you don't like Pat McAfee, blame Scott Armstrong. The former WWE referee is responsible for motivating Pat and turning him into a WWE success story. McAfee told Steph that he was flying between Charlotte, North Carolina and Indianapolis with the Colts when he spotted Armstrong on a flight one day.

Scott was wearing a WWE jacket, so Pat sat next to him and started asking questions about how he could break into the business. Being as honest as he could be, Armstrong told him that Vince McMahon didn’t typically hire people older than 30 at the time. McAfee was 29, so he decided then and there to take a stab at it. It was a 'now or never' moment for his childhood dream.

He “got boozed up one night” and bought a wrestling ring. Yes, an actual full sized squared circle he could put in his barn and use. Then, Pat “trained a little bit” (there's some clips of him hitting arm drags, taking bumps and that sort of thing) and generally tried to learn the ropes so he could make strides towards a WWE contract.

People must've started talking backstage, because Michael Cole text Pat and asked if he'd like to be on an NXT panel. One thing led to another from there. Most know that Cole chewed McAfee out for wearing shorts at WrestleMania 35, which almost caused Pat to quit the company entirely. Today, he and Michael are great friends.

Scott Armstrong might not even know he's responsible for Pat gritting his teeth and hunting down a WWE dream.


2. He Told Triple H He’d “Hit The Indys”

Pat McAfee Adam Cole NXT TakeOver XXX
WWE.com

After the drama over tuxedo shorts with Michael Cole at 'Mania 35, Pat got into a groove of appearing on more NXT panels and talking about WWE during his other media commitments. At home, Triple H told Stephanie that he’d like to use McAfee in a much bigger role on NXT programming. Interested, Pat had a chat with Hunter and said he planned to hit the independent circuit so he could find out if he had what it took to be a pro wrestler.

Trips told him not to do that, but to learn inside WWE rings instead.

'The Game' outright told the bubbly personality not to wrestle for anybody else, even small local promotions, to gain experience. That came as a slight surprise to Pat, because he figured he'd defo have to do some legwork elsewhere if he ever fancied wrestling on WWE TV. Hunter said he would have to show he belonged, but not by working the indy scene. That eventually led to McAfee's match at NXT TakeOver XXX vs. Adam Cole.

Stephanie’s Places didn’t mention Cole by name, presumably because he’s over in AEW. This kind of stuff kinda comes across as childish, being honest. There's a chance McAfee did talk about him but ESPN/WWE cut it out. It's their show, so they can do what they want, but it's hardly like talking about a match Adam Cole had on NXT in 2020 will suddenly swing the ratings in Tony Khan's favour.

Pat was stunned that WWE didn't want him to go out into the wider wrestling world and get some seasoning first.


1. Why WrestleMania 38 Meant Everything To Him

WWE WrestleMania 38 Steve Austin Pat McAfee
WWE.com

Steve Austin’s 'Stone Cold' character was the one Pat gravitated towards when he first saw wrestling. He turned on the TV and caught some Raw during the ‘Attitude Era’ in the late-1990s by chance. As a rowdy teenager, McAfee resonated with ’Stone Cold’ because he was anti-authority and seemed to stand up for those who had a rebellious spirit. Countless wrestling fans will have this same story, but it’s fun to hear Pat describe how the real world around him melted away when he watched pro wrestling.

He was able to live vicariously through the loud, brash characters he was watching on-screen. Unlike millions of others though, McAfee got to share the ring with his hero on the grandest stage. He downed some beers with Austin and took a stunner from him after beating Austin Theory then staring at the lights for a creaking Vince McMahon at WrestleMania 38.

This was a dream come true, and Pat says he was “honoured” to take a stunner. ESPN ran some nifty WWE footage of Steve complimenting Pat’s “composure out there” shortly afterwards behind the curtain at Gorilla. There were also some clips of the match vs. Theory, but there was nothing about his follow up impromptu battle vs. McMahon at all. 

The former boss has become borderline persona non grata in 2025.

'Mania 38 meant a hell of a lot to McAfee, and he was in dreamland when 'Stone Cold' gave him some compliments then said he'd enjoyed working with Pat too. McAfee probably thought things couldn't get any better after that night.

What else did you learn from Pat McAfee on Stephanie McMahon's ESPN show? For more WWE and wrestling, check out 10 Things We Learned From Dark Side Of The Ring: Billy Jack Haynes and WWE Backlash 2025: 7 Things That Must Happen! 


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.