8 Wrestling Gimmicks That Wouldn't Work In 2016
If they ever actually did anyway...
We live in a professional wrestling world where the full-on gimmick is a dying species. When this writer first started watching the sport, gimmicks were every bit as vital to wrestling as the wrestling itself. We saw law enforcement officers, clowns, living embodiments of natural disasters, kings, superheroes, and more battle it out inside the squared circle. It was wonderful.
Fast forward to 2016, and times are different to say the least. Full-blown character gimmicks have fallen more or less by the wayside in favour of individuals who are just real people that fight, tough guys with human emotions and human motivations. There is a lot that is commendable about this, but I'd be lying if I said I didn't yearn for the old days of wrestling hockey players from time to time.
There are a whole host of famous (or infamous?) gimmicks that brought different levels of success in the past that simply wouldn't work today. Of course, a lot of this is speculation, as you would have got long odds on a dead zombie mortician lasting 20+ years; at the end of the day it is all down to the talent that plays the character.
Even so, it would take some supreme talent to make certain gimmicks work in this day and age. Here are eight that would prove particularly troublesome.
8. The Boy Band
Before one even begins to talk about professional wrestling, it is clear that boy bands no longer work in music in 2016. The 1990s were a time of what seemed like a conveyor belt of boy bands, on both sides of the pond. Whether it was Take That, 5ive, East 17, or any of the others, the music charts were full to bursting point with scantily clad young chaps singing about girls that gipped them.
This is scarcely acceptable in music now, so it certainly won't work in professional wrestling. You could argue that the gimmick never worked at all. 3 Count are the example that jumps to the minds of most (for better or worse), and despite the best efforts of Shane Helms, Shannon Moore and Evan Karagias, the trio were nothing more than a joke way back in 2000.
7. The Man's Man
Another gimmick that didn't exactly set the world alight when it was first attempted, the stereotypical man is a completely outdated persona in 2016. A frequent claim is that no matter how wretched the gimmick a talented worker can make it work, but the 'Man's Man' gimmick seems to claim otherwise. William Regal is as talented as they come, but not even a man of his ability could make this work (although he was dealing with some personal issues at the time).
In fact, the only way this could work in 2016 would be if it was taken back 100 years or so, similar to the Vaudevillains. If a character was introduced as being an Old Timey Hard B*stard, you could get behind it. A moustachioed man who drinks whiskey for breakfast could have an ironic charm.
But a man in a hard hat with an axe? No.
6. The King
This is more based on recent history than pure speculation, but WWE needs to stop teasing pushing individuals as 'The King' in 2016. Even the most cursory glance at the last few attempts to do so makes for miserable reading; King Barrett was released last week, 2010 winner Sheamus' career hit a wall with the gimmick, 2008 winner William Regal was suspended shortly after.
WWE doesn't seem to care for its kings outside of making them wear ridiculous attire and transforming them into a laughing stock. The King of the Ring tournament could still be a vital cog in the WWE year, but it is telling that the most successful and memorable winners of that tournament (Bret Hart and Steve Austin) were only kings in a metaphorical sense, rather than actually living out the gimmick.
The king is dead, long live the king.
5. The Law Enforcement Officer
If a king, the highest authority in the land, isn't going to get much respect in 2016 then there is little hope for the lowly law enforcement officer. The Big Boss Man and to a lesser extent The Mountie experienced success in the World Wrestling Federation whilst working their authority jobs on the side, but in 2016 this just isn't plausible.
In 2016, authority comes from shady corporate entities. Once more, professional wrestling mirrors society here, in that young people are less and less afraid of the police themselves and more worried about the sinister elements that seem to defend and support the law enforcement officers.
In terms of wrestling gimmicks, you could probably throw all of the occupational gimmicks into this bag. That means no repo men, no bin men, no plumbers and certainly no evil dentists.
4. The Animal Carrier
Okay, it probably would work. If you had a guy called Archie 'The Lobster' Cateridge or Marcus 'The Marmoset' Matthews, and they brought their beast to the ring, people would be behind them to a degree. The only problem is that lurking behind the audience would be all sorts of legal issues, not to mention the travel problems of having to constantly lug a lobster through customs in airports.
We've had Jake with his snake, we had Davey with his bulldog, and we even had Ricky with his dragon, but these days are done. Any animal reference in professional wrestling characters today comes only in metaphorical and analogical form, such as Marty 'The Moth' Martinez in Lucha Underground.
I mean, imagine if Marty came to the ring with a moth. That wouldn't be so threatening. Animal gimmicks only work if they are enthusiastically played, or if it is Lucha Underground and the performer is literally the animal.
3. The Dancing Fat Man
What is it with Vince McMahon, World Wrestling Entertainment, and dancing fat guys? Even using that phrase seems a little disrespectful, as the guys that have been saddled with such a gimmick are only 'fat' in the most critical sense of the term, and only when compared to the 98% fat-free physiques around them. Brodus Clay isn't fat - Jimmy Five Bellies is.
And why is there such fascination with these performers dancing? It only works in short bursts, and even then it leads to comedy as opposed to credibility. The aforementioned Clay is a great example of this. If he was repackaged as the Funkasaurus and still retained elements of his prior violence, the gimmick could have been a success. As it was, he was more interested in dancing than wrestling and sucked because of it.
A dancing gimmick isn't an issue so much, it is more the fact that dancing becomes number one. Why would these individuals even bother wrestling if they were more interested in dancing? If we never see another dancing fat guy, it'll still be too soon.
2. The All-American Super Hero
For sure, there are some arguments for this gimmick today, but I stand by my original assertion The good old American Super Hero gimmick doesn't work in the way that the company wants it to in 2016, and recent attempts to force feed Roman Reigns down the throats of the audience show this. Sure, he isn't being pushed as an All-American, but the point stands.
Hulk Hogan gained a whole host of traction and became the biggest wrestling star on the planet with this gimmick in the 1980s, but that is because it was the 1980s. Thirty years ago. In many ways, the idea of a super hero in that sense is no longer relevant, as darkness must push its way into the psyches of our heroes in 2016; the audience demands it.
A professional wrestler that makes superhuman comebacks from every possible situation will only lead to a backlash from fans and rejection of them as a hero. We know this from John Cena and Roman Reigns. Vulnerability is key to a babyface getting face support, and being invulnerable is a death-knell for a good guy.
1. The Face Of All Faces
2016 is a strange place when it comes to good guys in fiction and media. Ever since the late 1990s, the anti-hero has taken the place of the hero as the one we want to root for, the one that crowds will get behind. We no longer want our heroes to be good, peace-loving, law-abiding, do right by all types. We want them to be flawed, full of self-hate, and most likely dealing with some deep-seated personal issues.
As such, the vanilla babyface is dead in the water in professional wrestling. WWE has known this for a while, and it may play a part in its overbalanced attempts to make the good guys 'edgy'. A guy like Tito Santana would fall flat today, purely because a cynical audience refuses to believe that a 100% good person can exist.
This cynicism is accurate. Even the greatest of individuals has a dark side, and as we hurtle deeper into the rabbit hole of fiction our desire to mimic real life as much as possible in our characters has overrun our desire for story. The pure babyface, more so than any other, is a wrestling gimmick that doesn't work in 2016.