9 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Collision (July 8)

A MOTY candidate, a magical main event, and plenty more on AEW Collision.

AEW Collision CM Punk Samoa Joe
AEW

It's been very much a case of so far, so good for AEW Collision during the show's previous three outings, and All Elite Wrestling's Saturday offering once again delivered the goods in its fourth week.

Emanating from Regina, Saskatchewan's Brandt Centre, the clear and obvious main attraction of this week's Collision was the renewed rivalry between CM Punk and Samoa Joe. With their extensive history - and the small fact that Punk has never bested the Samoan Submission Machine - anticipation was high that these wily veterans would put on something special when they clashed in the semi-finals of the Owen Hart Cup Tournament.

In other Owen action, former Team Taz cohorts Ricky Starks and Powerhouse Hobbs squared off to see who would face Punk or Joe in the men's final of this tourney. Elsewhere on the card, FTR faced Bullet Club Gold's Jay White and Juice Robinson in an eliminator affair, House of Black's Julia Hart took on Bambi Hall, and we had the long-awaited return to action of Scorpio Sky, as the two-time TNT Champion tangled with the promising Action Andretti.

As has become a regular pattern in its short lifespan, AEW Collision again proved to be a highlight of the pro wrestling week here. With that in mind, let's see how where this latest episode shone, and where it maybe fell a little short.

Saturday night's alright for fighting, indeed...


Downs...

3. The Biggest Match Of CM Punk's Career?

AEW Collision CM Punk
AEW

C'mon, Phil...

While CM Punk opened AEW Collision with some words to hype his upcoming match against Samoa Joe and to, let's face it, pander to the Regina crowd, one line in particular felt 'off' from the Second City Saint.

Yes, CM Punk had never beaten Samoa Joe. Yes, CM Punk vs. Samoa Joe in the Owen was a huge deal. Yes, Samoa Joe is the proverbial white while for CM Punk. But to call this Collision contest the biggest match of CM Punk's career? Steady on, there.

Punk has obviously competed in major matches on major events and has challenged - and won - World Titles on numerous occasions. To call this Collision match the biggest of the Straight-Edge Superstar's career felt like a massive stretch and came across as disingenuous.

A minor misstep in an otherwise solid promo from Punker. Tell me when I'm telling lies, right?


2. More Blah WWE-Lite Content

AEW Collision Malakai Black
AEW

Andrade El Idolo vs. Buddy Matthews was phenomenal on AEW Collision's debut episode. Andrade El Idolo vs. Brody King on the following week's Collision was phenomenal. The inevitable Andrade El Idolo vs. Malakai Black and/or La Faccion Ingobernable vs. House of Black matches should be phenomenal.

Unfortunately, everything outside of in-ring in this burgeoning rivalry continues to feel utterly naff. Worst of all, these segments continue to feel like something pulled from WWE Raw. And no, that's not meant to be a compliment.

Yes, masks are obviously an important part of lucha libre, but this feud feels so daft at this point. Sadly, 'daft' is a suitable word to sum up so much of what House of Black does away from the ring. It's a fine line to walk between 'atmospherically spooky' and 'cheesy bulls**t', and AEW has often veered more towards the latter when it comes to House of Black's escapades outside the squared circle.

The Julia Hart vs. Bambi Hall match did what it needed to do - with Julia continuing to show in-ring improvement, and Bambi showing some nice personality - but the other House of Black content on Collision was too hokey.


1. Eliminators Are Forever Stupid

AEW Collision FTR Bullet Club Gold
AEW

As a match, FTR vs. Jay White and Juice Robinson was a captivating example of why tag team wrestling can be so special. As a concept, AEW's eliminator matches will continue to be stupid.

WWE will often label such matches as something along the line of 'championship opportunities', but regardless, the same complaints are in place for these bouts - whether they take place in WWE or AEW.

By doing these eliminators, you end up in a lose-lose scenario. If the champion(s) lose, you've beaten your champion(s); something which should be an extreme rarity. Similarly, if a challenger comes up short, they're just another loser who has to head to the back of the line.

Simply put, there are far more suitable ways to crown a #1 contender for any title than by having a champion lose. A major part of the intrigue of any title match should be the possibility that the champion may somehow get beat. By using eliminator matches to get to a title shot, you've already shown your audience so much more than you needed to.

Yes, FTR vs. Bullet Club Gold in a two-out-of-three-falls bout should be magnificent. But did we have to have Dax and Cash lose to get this point? Asolutely not.


Ups...

9. Pre-Titles Promos

AEW Collision Ricky Starks
AEW

As mentioned in last week's AEW Collision review, this show will forever get an Up whenever it utilises pre-titles promos.

Once again, AEW made use of this extremely simple but hugely effective concept. This time, we got to hear from Powerhouse Hobbs, Ricky Starks, Samoa Joe, and CM Punk before Collision fired up its title sequence. All four delivered short, snappy diatribes hyping their impending matches in the semi-finals of the Owen Hart Cup Tournament.

Continuing to feature such pre-titles promos makes AEW Collision stand out from other pro wrestling programming, while also serving to dish up a nice slice of nostalgia for those of us who were around to see such promos play a part in the likes of Saturday Night's Main Event back in the day.


8. A Solid Opener

AEW Collision Ricky Starks Powerhouse Hobbs
AEW

Powerhouse Hobbs vs. Ricky Starks was a solid, if not spectacular opening match on this latest episode of AEW Collision.

Clearly, these two former partners have great chemistry together, and this bout did what it needed to do in terms of advancing Starks to the final of the Owen Hart Cup Tournament. A tornado DDT from Ricky may have gone array, but the match quickly recovered from that, largely due to the babyface fire shown from Absolute.

As expected, the story of this match was the stronger, bigger Hobbs using his size to dominate his opponent, whereas Starks was the scrappy hero fighting from underneath. Likewise, the commentary team of Kevin Kelly and Nigel McGuinness did a nice job of putting over the damage done to the Stroke Daddy's left knee in last week's Owen bout against Juice Robinson.

The finishing sequence of Hobbs vs. Starks did seem to go on a smidge too long - QT Marshall distracting referee Aubrey Edwards - but the main thing here was that Ricky got the W, and that Powerhouse Hobbs seems to thankfully be discontinuing his relationship with QT and his QTV faction.

Also, the Owen Hart-inspired attire for Hobbs was a fantastic touch.


7. A Step In The Right Direction

AEW Collision QT Marshall Powerhouse Hobbs
AEW

One of your writer's major complaints about last week's AEW Collision, was how the Powerhouse Hobbs and QTV relationship simply wasn't working. Thankfully, it looks like we've seen the end - or at least the start of the end - of this relationship.

Hobbs is an extremely talented fella with a huge upside and plentiful potential to become a genuine top tier player for AEW. Rather than adding to the overall act and presentation of Powerhouse, his alignment with QT Marshall had the complete opposite effect.

By associating with QT and his goons, all that did was make Hobbs feel lesser than what he was previously. Marshall was dragging Big Will down and making him feel like just another no-name member of what is essentially AEW's iteration of the J.O.B. Squad.

Hobbs shoving QT to the mat post-match and then hitting a spinebuster on Aaron Solo, that felt like a huge step in a more positive direction for Powerhouse. Seemingly turning babyface as a result of this, Hobbs will likely have to spend the next little while tangling with QTV, but long-term this has hopefully helped get the 32-year-old back on track as a singles act with so much promise.


6. Owen Taking Centre-Stage

AEW Collision CM Punk Owen Hart
AEW

From those who got to share the ring with him, Owen Hart is one of the most beloved, mischievous figures in the history of professional wrestling. That he sadly passed away on 23 May 1999 and just 34 years of age is one of the greatest tragedies the industry has ever seen.

While this is of course the second year that AEW has run the Owen Hart Cup Tournament, this week's AEW Collision really felt as if this tourney was all about Owen, his legacy, and his influence on the business.

That's not to say that last year's Owen didn't pay tribute to the King of Harts. It's just that this week in particular seemed to properly have Owen take centre-stage.

Whether it was the Regina crowd, whether it was the opening promo from CM Punk, whether it was the short hype videos for the tournament's semi-finals, or whether it was something else entirely, this week's Collision felt more about Owen Hart than previous shows that have featured this tournament. Likewise, the men's tournament in particular feels far bigger and more important than last year's.

For those who witnessed the career of Owen, it's impossible not to get emotional when the Regina audience burst out into a loud "Owen" chant midway through Collision's main event. Forever is he missed.


5. Allowing Athena To Showcase Her Personality

AEW Collision Athena Willow Nightingale
AEW

While the numbers watching Ring of Honor on a weekly basis are unfortunately minimal, one of the constant shining lights of ROH TV right now is Athena.

As the ROH Women's Champion, Athena has a pep in her step, a brilliant edge, and is fully in her stride in a way rarely seen before from the one-time Ember Moon. This is a performer who is fully comfortable in her skin and who is grasping the opportunities finally being afforded to her.

So, while it was disappointing to hear that this vicious, clinical Athena's bout with ever-loveable babyface Willow Nightingale had to be postponed to next week due to an injury to Willow, this week's Collision at least gave non-ROH viewers a sneak peak at what Athena is all about right now.

The backstage promo between Athena and Nightingale served as a nice tease to what should be an excellent match between the pair, and giving Athena a chance to showcase her current persona was a smart move.


4. A Stunning Tag Team Bout

AEW Collision Bullet Club Gold FTR
AEW

Excellent. Exceptional. Electric.

They're just three words to describe the magical tag team match put on between FTR and Bullet Club Gold.

Sure, your writer will forever moan about eliminator matches, but this match itself was a stunning showcase of tag team wrestling. FTR have long been the best tag team in the industry, and the pairing of Jay White and Juice Robinson is working extremely well since Collision launched and the Bullet Club Gold boys have been allowed more substantial TV time.

Here, we had a brilliant back-and-forth barn-burner with some amazing false finishes. In particular, FTR pulling out the old Power & Glory top rope suplex/big splash combo left many thinking the match was over. Likewise, a spike piledriver from Dax and Cash was another great near fall.

As for the finish, Harwood would end up being hit by the Juice is Loose after the FTR man lost track of who the legal man was on Bullet Club Gold's side.

A rematch between these two tandems has the potential to once again be special, and even more so with FTR defending their AEW Tag Team Titles in a two-out-of-three-falls offering against King Switch and Juice next week.


3. The In-Ring Return Of Scorpio Sky

AEW Collision Scorpio Sky Action Andretti
AEW

While some will claim that AEW Collision is a dumping ground for the company's naughty kids, the other way to look at Collision is as an opportunity to showcase lesser-featured talents. And in that regard, few have been less featured across the past year as Scorpio Sky.

To be precise, prior to this week's Collision, it had been one year and two days since Scorpio Sky's last match. Thankfully, a backstage promo last week was followed here by an actual in-ring outing for the former TNT Champion.

The match itself was fine for what it needed to be, with Sky getting the better of Action Andretti in a bout which went a smidge over seven minutes. Andretti served to be a a solid fit as Scorp's opponent, with the pair's sleek, smooth styles nicely complimenting one another. Also, a post-match show of sportsmanship from Sky let us know that this is a Scorpio Sky who is very much a babyface these days.

Elsewhere, Miro - another misfit toy left out in the cold for most of the past 12 months prior to Collision's launch - got a solid, steady promo where he again lambasted his god and talked about his double-jointed wife. Again, this was fine as AEW look to reintroduce the Redeemer, although he will need to start doing more than short promos and squash matches sooner rather than later.


2. The Main Event Felt Massive

AEW Collision CM Punk Samoa Joe
AEW

AEW absolutely could've done more on last week's Dynamite to hype Samoa Joe vs. CM Punk here, but the way this match was handled on Collision was masterfully done.

From the pre-titles promos, to Punk's show-opening verbiage, to the commentary team, to the video packages detailing their battles in Ring of Honor, Collision made Joe vs. Punk feel huge. If you were a fan from the classic ROH days, all of this fantastically whet your appetite for these two rivals locking horns once again. Should you have no knowledge of their ROH wars, Collision nicely set the table for what you should expect.

At times, many wrestling shows have a main event that's just, well, there; a main event solely because it's in the main event spot. With Samoa Joe vs. CM Punk, AEW made you realise that this was in the main event spot due to it being a massive deal, featuring two old gunslingers drawing their weapons one more time, in a tournament that carried a boatload of prestige and was vitally important to both men.

In terms of hyping up a match, this week's AEW Collision did a magnificent job.


1. Most Importantly, The Main Event Delivered

AEW Collision CM Punk Samoa Joe
AEW

It's one thing to build up a match, but it's key that such build is delivered on. And boy, did Samoa Joe and CM Punk deliver.

It was always going to be a tough proposition for anyone to follow the outstanding FTR vs. Bullet Club Gold bout, yet Joe and Punk managed to overcome that potential obstacle to close Collision out in thrilling fashion. With call-backs aplenty, these two veterans delivered pro wrestling gold for 15 minutes, as the Second City Saint rolled up the Samoan Submission Machine for the 1-2-3.

While the in-ring work was fantastic here, even more important was the body language of both men once Punk had scored the three-count. These two icons of ROH and beyond sold the magnitude of the result magnificently. For CM Punk, he was almost in disbelief at what he'd finally been able to do. Likewise, Samoa Joe was similarly stunned at what had just taken place.

Again calling back to Ring of Honor, a post-match handshake between these warriors was a respectful way to mark the occasion... only for Joe to turn that handshake into a Coquina Clutch.

From here, we've got the tantalising prospect of more to come from Punk and Joe, plus the intriguing final of the men's Owen pitting the Chicago native up against his pal Ricky Starks.


Senior Writer
Senior Writer

Once described as the Swiss Army Knife of WhatCulture, Andrew can usually be found writing, editing, or presenting on a wide range of topics. As a lifelong wrestling fan, horror obsessive, and comic book nerd, he's been covering those topics professionally as far back as 2010. In addition to his current WhatCulture role of Senior Content Producer and Presenter, Andrew previously spent nearly a decade as Online Editor and Lead Writer for the world's longest-running genre publication, Starburst Magazine, and his work has also been featured on BBC, TechRadar, Tom's Guide, WhatToWatch, Sportkskeeda, and various other outlets, in addition to being a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic. Between his main day job, his role as lead panel host of Wales Comic Con, and his gig as a pre-match host for Wrexham AFC games, Andrew has also carried out a hugely varied amount of interviews, from the likes of Robert Englund and Eli Roth to Kevin Smith and the Russo Brothers, to Kevin Conroy and Frank Miller, to Bret Hart and Sting, to Mickey Thomas, Joey Jones, Phil Parkinson, and Brian Flynn, to many, many more. Where his beloved Wrexham AFC is concerned, Andrew is a long-standing season ticket holder and an FSA Award-winner for his time co-hosting the Fearless in Devotion podcast.