9 Wrestlers Who Had Their WORST Match EVER This Year
Stinking up the joint: featuring Cope, Sami Zayn, and more…
In November, WWE Chief Content Officer and Dana White cosplayer Triple H claimed, on the All-In podcast, that his promotion doesn’t “write the shows based on “that would be a great match””. And, while that would adequately explain the big Jey Uso push of 2025, he’s still not entirely correct. Triple H books matches for the explicit purpose of putting on a “banger” every week.
Every promoter in wrestling does the same thing, and as a result, the bad match isn’t nearly as prevalent as it used to be.
The outright stinker, the dud, no longer exists - at least in the way we used to know it. Wrestling is no longer teeming with the uncoordinated meatheads summoned from gyms in the 1980s, and the industry is nowhere near as funny as a result. The average roster is too skilled mechanically. The bad match needs to be redefined. Where once it was the glorious art of a dumbass getting completely lost, or a barely trained glorified bodybuilder having no clue how to execute their stuff, now, in this era of homogenised style, it’s about something else.
It’s about how the sheer desperation to have the best match results in soulless, cringeworthy irony.
It’s about the modern “cinema” trend, and how the abysmal, overt attempts at acting have replaced actual crowd psychology.
It’s about the mindless trope slop of smashed barricades and ref bumps.
Obviously, this list can’t be entirely literal - but you can’t compare the match catalogue of a major league wrestler to what they were doing when they first started out. Not all of them are Kurt Angle, Jun Akiyama, or Ronda Rousey.
Some vets have no excuse.
9. COPE Vs. Jon Moxley (AEW Revolution)
Contrary to the intro, Adam ‘Cope’ Copeland stunk the joint out the old-fashioned way at Revolution: by wrestling an incredibly long and dull match that played out to utter indifference.
Cope and Mox did the right things in the right order and all of that, but much of the action was janky - and when it wasn’t, it was just tedious. Ahead of it, Cope said he wanted to have a “gritty, old school NWA World Heavyweight title match”. Why, then, was it paced and worked like a Triple H main event in 2004?
Laboured and methodical, the match was cursed by the weird image Cope has conjured up about himself following his return. In his head, he’s a violent, vengeful, authentic badass. In reality, he’s off-putting and impossible to take seriously. His snarling facials are comical. There’s an almost profound disconnect between what he thinks he’s doing and what he’s actually doing. Edge got over by being an entertaining rapscallion. How come he thinks he’s Steve Blackman now?
And was this really Cope’s worst match ever?
This is a guy who unwittingly referenced Chris Benoit’s death in a three-hour walk-and-brawl against Randy Orton at WrestleMania 36, after all. That can be disqualified. It was the pandemic. The very purpose of pro wrestling as an interactive performance art was broken; the few great empty arena matches of the time were miraculous.
Cope Vs. Mox was a match featuring two performers intent on proving that they were intense and tough that it forgot to be, you know, entertaining. And it wasn’t even stiff or bloody or actually intense.
Almost everything Mox did after it was awesome, too, which was quite the indictment of the former Edge.
8. JACOB FATU Vs. Solo Sikoa (WWE SummerSlam)
Has WWE ruined Jacob Fatu?
There’s obviously time left, and the fans haven’t stopped caring about the guy, but his characterisation throughout 2025 was really poor. He was framed as a sympathetic babyface opposite the useless Solo Sikoa, who tormented Fatu by saying he was “all gas, no brains”. When Jacob turned on Solo at Money In The Bank, by loudly shouting “I hate you, Solo!”, it was meant to be an uplifting moment. It was in fact just awful acting, but these days, everybody’s gotta do it.
Their Steel Cage match at SummerSlam was horrendous in ideation and execution.
In a bogstandard exchange, a decent enough dynamic was established. Solo was no match for Fatu, whose no-selling and fire-up spots generated a decent reaction. But the match fell apart, quickly and badly.
Fatu hit Sikoa with a senton. Solo then scrambled towards the corner as quickly as possible to voluntarily take Fatu’s hip attack into the turnbuckle. This was pathetic, brainless pro wrestling, a thoughtless rush to get to the next spot.
Amid the obligatory activity on the outside, Talla Tonga handcuffed Jacob Fatu to the girder atop the cage wall. For a company obsessed with their beloved stories, they got it badly wrong here. This moment wasn’t milked at all. Solo should have smugly gloated right in Fatu’s face, particularly since that is one of the few attributes he has going for him. He should have laughed as Fatu struggled to break free - before the crowd could enjoy his look of pure fear when it actually happened. Instead, Fatu freed himself within seconds, undermining any sense of drama or peril.
The big climactic spot was good, in a guilty pleasure sense, since Tonga Loa ate Fatu’s tree trunk of a thigh at full-force from about 15 feet - but on the whole, this was too idiotic in the bad way.
7. SAMI ZAYN Vs. Karrion Kross (WWE SummerSlam)
Karrion Kross dominated the wrestling conversation for much of 2025.
The debate ping-ponged in several directions. Why wouldn’t WWE push him? Why would WWE push someone who couldn’t wrestle particularly well? Could Karrion Kross even take a back bump?
Kross suffers from a particularly cruel curse, in that he has great attributes as a manager, but he’s caged within the body of a hulking powerhouse wrestler, somebody who gets managed, and he can barely move that body around. He has a very good presence, and an even better handle on the darkly funny putdown. It was hilarious when he threatened to break the Miz’s legs. The threat of him breaking anybody’s legs in the ring doesn’t work, though, since he wrestles like he’s a submersible.
His match against Sami Zayn at SummerSlam was a miracle, in that it should have been impossible for Sami to have a match that bad. And it’s not as if the matchmaking was bad, either; if anything, a smaller guy who is almost peerless at selling was the ideal opponent for Karrion Kross. And it still sucked.
The story saw Kross try to lure Sami over to the dark side. He tried berating him, he tried stomping him out. Neither worked. Sami, as mentioned, is great at selling - but even he was unable to convince fans that Karrion’s stuff was even remotely impactful.
At the finish, Sami appealed to the crowd. He was a good guy! He was going to win the right way!
Nobody bought it, and nobody cared about Sami’s soul - for the very first time during an incredible mainstream career high under Triple H’s regime.
6. CODY RHODES Vs. John Cena (WWE WrestleMania 41)
A lot of fans wanted to see a John Cena heel turn under Vince McMahon in 2012. You effectively saw what that would have looked like under Triple H in 2025.
Cena blamed the fans - the same fans who had universally loved him for about half a decade - for hurting him in a “toxic relationship”. This “each and every one of you” stuff was diabolical. It was a cliche, which was bad enough, but it didn’t even make any sense. This lack of imagination extended to the ring, where Cena, ultimate WWE guy, did the only thing he could think to do.
He went methodical.
This match was such a nothing. Cena had no clue whatsoever as to how to approach playing heel. He didn’t even seem to relish it. His personality vanished as he opted to play a dour, unconvincing villain, booting and stomping away for minutes on end. His bump-and-feed was so arthritic that people thought he was completely finished physically - but he was mobile at Elimination Chamber before and at SummerSlam afterwards. Turns out, as a heel, he was simply incompetent. It took him several months to fall down whenever Cody struck him.
The action was worse than basic; the atmosphere nightmarish. It was loud, but since nobody wanted to really boo Cena, the resentment was mostly targeted at Cody. The situation drew heat, not the match. The fans made noise for the obligatory exchange of signatures and finishers, but the sequence wasn’t amazing or anything. That is the absolute bare minimum for a PLE match, let alone the main event of WrestleMania.
The finish was infamously bad. Travis Scott emerged, but the Rock didn’t. Scott took even longer to get to the ring than Cena did to bump.
The ref bump spot happened. Cody eventually ejected Scott before dithering over whether or not to hit his hero with the belt. Cena - cheered heel after years of playing the jeered babyface - hit a low blow and belt shot to wrap it up.
A boom-busting disasterclass.
5. MICKIE JAMES Vs. Maki Itoh (WrestleCon Mark Hitchcock Memorial SuperShow)
The hell was this?
The action in Mickie James Vs. Maki Itoh was wretched. The mat wrestling was frigate-slow and horrendously loose at a level that you could scarcely believe. Itoh is a comedy act, but she’s not the worst technical wrestler alive. James isn’t a world-beater, but has played a key role in some genuinely very good efforts over the years. They weren’t trying to have a great match, as would be revealed, but they might have taken the punchline much too far. Apropos of nothing, Mickie James interrupted the match by leading the crowd in chants of “Meltzer sucks!”
It was as if she was giving herself an alibi to excuse a shockingly bad match, subpar even by the standards of a phoned-in WrestleMania Weekend fart-around, using Meltzer’s reputation to shield herself from criticism. The match must have been good, if that mark hated it!
This desperate attempt to hide under the veil of irony and entertainment was pathetic.
Sucking wind, James then promised those fans that they were going to see some of the best wrestling ever, did Dude Love’s knee dance…horribly, and initiated a sing-off. Itoh’s song was bad. Mickie’s was excruciating. Radiating intensely unlikeable energy, James crowbarred far too many syllables into a rendition of ‘Hardcore Country’ designed to mock her opponent. She got badly lost at one point, and could only laugh nervously. This was an unintentional, roaring success of a cringe comedy. James, without realising it, created a skit about a narcissist dying onstage.
The rest of the match was almost as poor. James completely whiffed on a superkick, and Itoh seemed to forget how to take a DDT twice.
This was one of the most astonishing spectacles in modern wrestling history. Mickie James did the whole “I’m not owned!” bit before anybody even owned her.
4. BECKY LYNCH Vs. Nikki Bella (WWE Clash In Paris)
This was mostly depressing. It was still quite funny, but it was mostly depressing.
Nikki Bella is past her prime, but she can still smash people in cool TV matches that have little right to be as cool as they are. Becky Lynch meanwhile is great in her stated mission of elevating talent; Becky in effect does everything that male veteran wrestlers pretend to do. While this wasn’t necessarily inexplicable - few expected a Match of the Year contender - it was still well below the expected level. Perhaps the cruel reaction afforded to Nikki threw her off. Everybody on that show was over other than her.
Mostly, this was your garden variety bed-sh*tter. The layout was not ambitious, but the execution was laughable. In the second most infamous moment, Nikki attempted a springboard roundhouse kick. This was all kinds of botched; Nikki was in the wrong position to begin with, rushed through a spot she might have blown even if she was in the right place, and slipped on the ropes. Becky, the target, was nowhere near Nikki - but muscle memory kicked in. She was, and this is no exaggeration, several feet away from Nikki, and she still lifted her hand towards her jaw to convey the pain of impact.
In the most infamous moment, Nikki dragged Becky around the outside and attempted to drive her face into the announce tables. Becky was inexcusably bad here; she yeeted the table with her hands in a totally bizarre motion, like she was hovering on the edge of a pool, scared of learning how to dive.
3. TIFFANY STRATTON Vs. Nia Jax Vs. Jade Cargill (WWE SmackDown, September 26)
This was a terrible night for Tiffany Stratton, who got over in NXT through effective use of juxtaposition: she seemed like she didn’t have it in her to fight, but when the spotlight was on, her stuff looked gruesome. She’d break a nail and your skull alike. But what can you do against Nia Jax and Jade Cargill in the same match?
The scope for botches was vast. The nicest way of putting it is that Tiffany Stratton Vs. Nia Jax Vs. Jade Cargill realised its potential.
In a multifarious disaster, Jade split her head open when Nia Jax did her sadly customary spot, in which she acts as if she's angrily slamming a car door shut when guiding her opponent’s head towards the steel steps. That was the worst of it, outside the omni-botched finish, but virtually every second was undermined by some immersion-breaking moment or outright botch.
Early in the match, Nia and Jade exchanged (bad) forearm shots on the outside. Nia and Jade visibly talked themselves through the sequence. They barely looked at each other; preoccupied by the next story beat, they kept glancing towards the ring, waiting for Tiffany to hit her suicide dive. Nia Jax knowingly walked into the landing zone. Tiffany hit the suicide dive. Nia failed to catch the suicide dive. How did Nia not see this coming?
She’d been waiting for it to the point of distraction for several agonising seconds.
At the finish, Jade hit Nia with a Black Hole Slam. Nia kicked out, even though the planned finish was the finish to every WWE Triple Threat match ever: Tiffany was meant to kick Jade and steal the win. The ref failed to follow protocol; even though it made no sense for Nia to stay down, having already kicked out of the move that preceded the pin, Daphanie LaShaunn halted her count, despite Jax failing to lift up her shoulder.
2. CM PUNK Vs. Jey Uso (WWE Saturday Night’s Main Event #41)
Infamous for the worst and funniest botch of the year, Jey Uso slowly landed on his forehead when CM Punk attempted to hit him with a neckbreaker. That was something Simon Gotch would accuse Enzo Amore of doing, but Enzo Amore never headlined a major WWE card in a match held to determine the new WWE World Heavyweight champion.
The match did get…well, “good” isn’t the word. The match did turn into something broadly competent and heated by the second half. Boasting precisely one good idea - Jey applying the sleeper was both a creative way of fooling Punk, and a suspenseful reminder that he’d won a World title with this strategy - elsewhere, this was slop. Pure slop.
It was an irritating and lazy match even if you don’t factor in Jey’s abysmal individual performance. The WWE main event formula is practically an insult to your intelligence. Finisher kick-out, finisher kick-out, opponent’s finisher kick-out, opponent’s finisher kick-out, finish. They expect to blow your mind with this every time.
Because they think you’re a goldfish.
Sometimes wrestlers just do things to do it - just to grab a pop wherever they can. Why of all pairings did Jey Uso and CM Punk need to indulge in finisher theft? Theirs wasn’t an epic rivalry forged on begrudging respect.
CM Punk should be thankful that Jey stole headlines with his even worse than usual effort; Punk’s spear was almost as bad as his Buckshot lariat. He doesn’t like the word “moveset”, but he should probably familiarise himself with it. When he gets mistaken, and thinks he’s Jey Uso or Randy Savage, the results are invariably embarrassing.
Punk used to be such a clever pro wrestler. He’s happy being institutionalised these days.
1. CLAUDIO CASTAGNOLI Vs. Jeff Jarrett (AEW Dynamite, January 29)
You can deduce what Tony Khan was thinking here.
He wanted to establish battle-worn Jeff Jarrett as a sentimental fan favourite, using the pathos of his struggle-afflicted life to heat up MJF. The idea of MJF breaking Jarrett’s promise to win the big one wasn’t bad. MJF needed something big to get him back to where he was. The issue is that AEW fans seemed to prefer Jarrett as a gleefully unfair midcard clown. Quietly brilliant as a babyface in 2024, he still wasn’t received as a Dustin Rhodes type.
His match with Claudio Castagnoli followed his inexplicably misogynistic retorts to MJF in their fateful, rotten face-to-face. He was doomed after that.
The dissonance between Jarrett’s heart-on-sleeve babyface spots and the apathy of the crowd was torturous. The fans didn’t care about Jeff at all, and he was performing like they were living and dying with him. Jarrett’s hand vibrated when he asked for their help when trapped in a sleeper. The director must have a cruel sense of humour; they cut to a wide shot of the crowd, and, no exaggeration, about five people in the front row gently slapped the barricade. Everybody else wondered why Jeff Jarrett had promised to become AEW champion.
Jarrett’s punches still looked the business, but under these hostile conditions, his classic style scanned as parody. This was a brutal misjudgement. Mox had to interfere - to help Claudio Castagnoli beat Jeff Jarrett - and Claudio looked scared after hitting the Neutraliser. That won’t be enough to put this guy and his undying spirit away. He had to hit it a second time.
A match that portrayed Jeff Jarrett like he was Bruno Sammartino in MSG, when he was received like Eric Escobar, this was all kinds of bleak.