9 Wrestlers WWE Has BENCHED

WWE don't leave wrestlers benched with nothing to do...or do they?

Bo Dallas and Uncle Howdy - News June 25
wwe

Karrion Kross finds himself in an odd position in WWE at present.

As of writing, his t-shirt's one of the best sellers on WWE Shop, various promos he's cut have gone viral beyond even the wildest expectations, and support for him online is starting to stretch way beyond the "cult" tag it was given when he first assumed The Miz was dead in a hilarious hotel room chat with Scarlett at the tail-end of 2024. He's doing all the things wrestlers are told to do to get noticed on television too - maximising his minutes in backstage segments, stealing shows via vignettes that position him as the straw that stirs every WWE drink, and even getting people to tune into episodes of Main Event just to get to see him lock up.

It's almost if he's featured, but then not featured at all. Always playing, but always stuck on the bench.

But then the latter can't be true, because just recently Nick Khan said WWE don't do that. Forming part of a bizarre pre-WrestleMania promo junket from him and his ilk, Khan's comments seemed to be directed more at AEW's large roster rather than trying to get particularly introspective about the market leader's top crop, but then in the wake of the 'Show Of Shows' and a series of releases, there's just as much as chance he was trying to establish some received wisdom before a big round cuts brought it closer to the truth.

Even then, there are exceptions. BIG ones...

9. Omos

Omos WWE
WWE.com

Standing at a colossal 7'3", Omos is one of WWE’s most physically imposing Superstars, yet the giant has been curiously absent from meaningful storylines since 2023, and out of the ring entirely since WrestleMania weekend 2024. Once presented as a near-unstoppable force, especially during his time with AJ Styles and later feuds with Bobby Lashley and Brock Lesnar, Omos has since faded into the background, reduced to footnote status despite his stature offering the opposite.

At this point a name that inexplicably could be speculated on during release season, Omos was cast as a generic monster in the 2024 Royal Rumble and Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royal several months later, but unlike the latter's namesake, came nowhere close to victory in either. 

This benching feels especially baffling considering WWE’s renewed creative focus over the last few years, and the raves the seven-footer received for his early-2025 sojourn to NOAH as Jack Morris' tag partner. While not the most technically gifted, his sheer size and aura should make him a consistent attraction, particularly in an era where WWE thrives on viral moments and visual dominance of the marketplace. Instead, he's become a special attraction with no platform to be an attraction, his entire appeal going uncapitalised upon.  

The question remains: why isn't WWE doing more with him? Whether it's a creative impasse or uncertainty about how to book such a unique performer long-term, the results are the same - lost years and wasted potential. As WWE embraces the media-friendly Netflix era, it’s unclear if Omos fits into that vision, but even more unclear why. 


8. Brinley Reece

Brinley Reece
WWE

Brinley Reece made her NXT debut in late 2023, stepping in as a surprise participant in the Women’s Breakout Tournament. Though she showed heart in her first match - a loss to Arianna Grace - it became the first of many losses dressed as half-baked opportunities. Throughout 2024, Reece competed in several televised matches, including bouts against Kiana James, Sol Ruca, and Wendy Choo, but unfortunately found herself on the losing end more often than not. Then, despite being included in the qualifying rounds for the NXT Women’s North American Championship ladder match at Battleground, Reece predictably failed to secure a spot.

Frequent absences from weekly programming suggested a clear lack of momentum with those behind the scenes, and it's hard to discern why. Infectiously entertaining on a show where everybody is encouraged to go to daft levels to get over, Reece was a blast, but failed to blast off, 

Later losses to the Zaria and  Izzi Dame expedited her disappearing act, and an attempted resurgence through NXT’s crossover with TNA (she faced Ash By Elegance) resulted in yet another defeat, doing little to raise her stock.

A brief stint in a romantic subplot involving Karmen Petrovic, Nikkita Lyons and Ashante “Thee” Adonis seemed like it could provide a fresh start but her part the story fizzled out before it had a chance to take hold. As of 2025, Brinley Reece’s future in NXT remains unclear, and select shots with Evolve haven't even resulted in a permanent role there. Her athleticism and charisma are evident, but she’s become a clear example of how talent can be benched before getting a fair chance to show why they shouldn't be near it. 


7. Shinsuke Nakamura

Damian Priest Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

Shinsuke Nakamura’s 2025 has been a puzzling chapter in the career of the once-electric New Japan Pro Wrestling star.

After vanishing from WWE TV for much of 2024, Nakamura returned late in the year with a dramatic, samurai-inspired presentation and shockingly defeated LA Knight to capture the United States Championship at Survivor Series. It was an unexpected moment that hinted at a potential resurgence for the 'King of Strong Style'.

However, whatever momentum Nakamura generated quickly fizzled. His title reign felt more like an experiment than an acknowledgment of his experience or tenure, and with little character development beyond his reintroduction, the run felt like a creative afterthought. Disqualification defences and vague promo segments failed to give his reign the fire it needed and the reign came to an end in March when he dropped it right back to Knight ahead of the latter taking the gold to WrestleMania 41. The while thing like a rushed way to hit reset on both characters, and it ended any meaningful push for Nakamura.

Since then, Shinsuke's been AWOL again. A quick elimination in the André the Giant Memorial Battle Royal was his only major appearance, making his use in 2025 all the more baffling. Now 45 but feeling older in TV years just shy of a decade into his WWE run, Nakamura remains under a deal but creatively adrift - so much so that plenty have wondered aloud if his next contract year could be his last. 


6. Carlee Bright

Carlee Bright
WWE

When Carlee Bright made her televised WWE debut on NXT LVL UP in January 2024, there was genuine optimism surrounding the collegiate cheerleader-turned-wrestler. Bright' gility and bubbly charisma made her stand out in the Performance Center and almost immediately she seemed poised to become a fresh face in a women’s division increasingly being promoted as the best and most diverse in wrestling. 

Fast-forward to mid-2025 and her presence on WWE programming is practically nonexistent.

After more sporadic appearances on NXT's B-show and a brief tag team stint alongside Kendal Grey (more on her elsewhere) on Evolve, Bright’s trajectory stalled. She hasn’t been featured in any notable NXT storylines or live events since, and 43 matches in two years (as of this writing) aren't exactly the numbers that are likely to get the budding star where she potentially needs to be. While WWE has a history of slow-burn development for new talent, Bright’s vanishing act has been disappointing for NXT fans - and per CW chiefs, there are a satisfying number of them - who saw potential in her energetic style and underdog appeal.

Carlee Bright's disappearance exemplifies how WWE’s developmental system can sometimes swallow emerging stars. One moment, it's fanfare and big debuts. The next, somebody's off the radar entirely. Whether her absence is temporary or permanent remains to be seen, but for now, Bright is another example of an ostensibly promising talent left waiting in the wings.


5. Zoey Stark

Zoey Starks Nia Jax
WWE.com

Zoey Stark arrived on the main roster with the kind of momentum a current era-NXT call-up rarely receives.

A standout in developmental thanks to her athleticism, crisp in-ring work, and no-nonsense persona, Stark was poised to become a reliable force in WWE’s women’s division, and her debut alliance with Trish Stratus in 2023 gave her instant exposure, and a shot at the Women’s World Championship. 

From there, she was partnered up with Sonya Deville and Shayna Baszler as part of the Pure Fusion Collective, but in the wake of both stablemates getting released, she's all but vanished from television. WWE has struggled to carve out consistent midcard stories for its women's division despite the addition of secondary singles titles, and Stark has unfortunately become a casualty of that creative gap. It’s a puzzling move, especially considering her versatility; Stark could ostensibly thrive as a heel or babyface, elevate others in the ring, and cut solid promos when given time. She has the tools to be a workhorse akin to Natalya or a dark horse breakout like Rhea Ripley once was. Instead, she’s treading water in an increasingly crowded locker room, and left to try and fashion her own cult status with some middling X patter.

Stark may want to find what fits sooner rather than later - WWE hasn't shied away from cutting those they believe to be surplus, even if they haven't been given chance to show otherwise. 


4. Edris Enofé & Malik Blade

Edris Enofé & Malik Blade
WWE

Once considered one of NXT’s most promising and hilarious tag teams, Edris Enofé and Malik Blade have seen their momentum stall dramatically in 2025. 

After a string of engaging performances in 2023 and early 2024, the duo’s appearances dwindled after both were sidelined due to injuries. Enofé suffered a shoulder injury in August 2024, requiring surgery and a lengthy recovery period. He was medically cleared to return in February 2025 but the wait goes on for that to take please. Blade, meanwhile, has been out of action recovering from a torn ACL, which could keep him out longer leaving Enofé trapped between the bench and doing more jobs than is ideal. 

The timing couldn't have been worse - prior to their injuries, the pair were starting to get traction on NXT rather than LVL UP, but as of mid-2025, the future of the tag team remains uncertain. It’s unclear whether WWE has plans to reunite the duo or if they will pursue separate paths upon Blade’s return. Both men have shown flashes of potential separately, but it's together where they've shone the brightest - the timing of the knocks in combination for how much either man wants a singles run in their futures could determine if the unit even makes it back on screen in tact. 


3. Nikkita Lyons

Nikkita Lyons WWE
WWE.com

Once considered a breakout star in NXT thanks to her idiosyncratic blend of athleticism, charisma, and crowd appeal, Nikkita Lyons has struggled to maintain momentum due to a series of physical setbacks that kept her off television for long stretches.

After missing most of 2023 with a torn ACL and meniscus, her return was hampered again in early 2024 by another serious knee injury - this time to the opposite leg. While Lyons remained active in the Performance Center and vocal about her rehabilitation journey, her absence from the ring left her out of the conversation as NXT’s women’s division changed dramatically without her. When she finally returned in late 2024, Lyons managed to score a few victories on NXT television, implying that a renewed push was forthcoming. But rather than becoming a fixture on the brand, Lyons was quietly transitioned to Evolve in early 2025 amidst a slew of more experienced talent being signed to the show. Her debut victory in Evolve was a positive sign, but it also marked a clear demotion from her once-prominent NXT position. 

As of mid-2025, Lyons remains largely benched in the broader WWE landscape. Though still young and marketable, the frequent injuries and inconsistent booking have left her treading water. For now, Lyons is a prime example of a talent WWE hasn’t fully figured out how or when to use.


2. The Wyatt Sicks

The Wyatt Sicks WWE
WWE.com

Few stables in recent memory have generated as much buzz in WWE with less actual matches and appearances as The Wyatt Sicks. 

Teased for months throughout 2024 with cryptic vignettes, the group was positioned as a spiritual successor to Bray Wyatt’s haunting legacy - a mysterious faction ready to wreak havoc across WWE. Yet as of mid-2025, fans are still waiting...and waiting.

Despite the hype, the Wyatt Sicks have remained in limbo. Bo Dallas, Erick Rowan, Nikki Cross, Dexter Lumis and Joe Gacy were brought into the light then subsequently left in the shadows, victims of either cold feet or shifting creative priorities. This extended benching is baffling. WWE invested months in eerie build-up - easily among the most talked-about storytelling threads of the last year regardless of your opinions on the genre - only to stall following a 50/50 booked rivalry with The Final Testament. In an era of patient, long-term narratives and consistent character work, the Wyatt Sicks could've brought psychological horror and fresh creative energy to Raw or SmackDown. Instead, their absence is becoming more frustrating than mysterious.

Whether it’s a tribute project gone cold or simply poor timing, WWE might have squandered what could’ve been yet another Wyatt-adjacent money-maker. As of writing, it's unknown when they'll return to house shows, let alone television or Premium Live Events. 


1. Kendal Grey

Kendal Grey
WWE

Kendal Grey entered WWE with impressive amateur wrestling credentials, including a standout collegiate career. However, her transition to the NXT roster in 2024 and into 2025 has been defined by limited exposure and non-existent utilisation.

Grey made her in-ring debut on the March 29, 2024 episode of LVL UP, teaming with Carlee Bright in a losing effort, but she went from Developmental B to A within months when she participated in a six-woman gauntlet match on the August 20, 2024 episode of NXT, eliminating Brinley Reece before being eliminated herself. This followed a singles match at NXT's Great American Bash television special, where she faced Jaida Parker but suffered a loss after interference from Myles Borne.

In 2025, Grey's visibility diminished further. She was featured in the debut episode of WWE Evolve on March 5, teaming with Carlee Bright to defeat Kali Armstrong and Dani Palmer. While this victory marked a positive note, it also signalled a shift away from the main NXT programming.

Despite her athletic background and early promise, Grey has struggled to find a consistent role within WWE's developmental system. Her appearances have been largely confined to lower-tier programming and multi-woman matches, with little in the way of sustained storylines or character development. As of mid-2025, Grey still finds herself awaiting an opportunity to showcase her full potential on a larger stage.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.