AJ Styles' World Title Wins Ranked - From Worst To Best
6. IWGP Heavyweight Championship - NJPW Wrestling Dontaku 2014
Don't get me wrong, winning the IWGP Heavyweight Championship (especially in the modern age) in your first New Japan Pro Wrestling match isn't an achievement that should be sniffed at. When he defeated Kazuchika Okada for the belt at Wrestling Dontaku in May 2014 AJ became only the sixth gaijin to be crowned champion, and the first since Brock Lesnar way back in 2005.
The problem with it is that it came completely out of nowhere and incensed the crowd in the worst way. Styles defeated the beloved Okada thanks to the turn and interference of Yujiro Takahashi, a decidedly-American style finish that will always draw groans from audiences in the Far East.
Styles' run as champion didn't set the world alight either, and it wasn't until a MOTY contender (and probable winner) with Minoru Suzuki in the G1 Climax that Japanese crowds began to take to Styles. It was too little too late for this run however, as Hiroshi Tanahashi defeated him for the strap not long after.