5 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (27 Feb - Results & Review)
Jey Uso gets replaced before Elimination Chamber; masked man revealed; WWE crowns new champs.
This week's SmackDown had multiple mission statements to tackle as soon as the show went live on the air. Firstly, get Jey Uso (who was already a replacement for the injured Bronson Reed) out of the men's Elimination Chamber match. Second, crown brand new Women's Tag-Team Champions. Thirdly, continue Oba Femi's impressive introduction as a main roster wrecking ball.
If they were adding in a fourth goal, then it probably wouldn't have been: 'Bore everyone senseless by sprinkling in a couple of crappy matches and R-Truth teaching his fellow superstars how to watch WWE PLEs via ESPN'. Sadly, as usual, there were some negatives to report coming out of the show.
The 'go home' edition was a fun ride for the most part, but it did expose the issues with tacking on a third hour to SmackDown. This was a 2-hour broadcast with heavy padding so it'd fit the 3-hour runtime. That's just the way it is, people. WWE will have a lot more of these once WrestleMania season comes and goes.
Reported major panic behind the scenes about the state of 'Mania 42 creatively and in terms of hype/ticket sales shouldn't detract from the good this company has to offer. The roster is insanely talented, they're working hard to build fresh stars (Oba, Lash Legend, Trick Williams etc) on the blue brand, and Drew McIntyre is still running around the place trying to book his own title reign like he's playing GM Mode in the upcoming WWE 2K26.
Here are all the plus points and downers from Friday's final push pre-Chamber.
Downs...
4. WWE's Open Challenge Concept Creaks
It won't be breaking news to anybody who watches SmackDown routinely that Carmelo Hayes has been sparkling in most of these United States Title ‘Open Challenges’ to date, but it feels like he should’ve moved on from them by now. Also, it doesn't make sense that Ilja Dragunov is knocking back the chance to challenge for the gold when he’s so competitive. That competitive spirit is literally his entire deal.
This week, Matt Cardona’s bid for US success just came out looking flat. The one time Zack Ryder was brought back to be a bit part player, sure, but Cardona has lost all steam already and Melo is just sort of drifting. There better be something meaningful at the end of this between Hayes and Dragunov. There just better be. A heel turn for Ilja might be the tonic needed.
Then, WWE can drop the 'Open Challenge' gimmick and concentrate on a fully fleshed feud that includes PLE matches for these dudes. Melo and Dragunov richly deserve that, because they've been holding down the fort in the midcard on Fridays for a long, long time now. However, as good as the impromptu match thing has been for both, it has definitely run its course.
SmackDown's match between Hayes and Cardona proved that.
It wasn't rotten from a technical standpoint, but the concept is creaking and the match came across as stodgy and unnecessary. Neither man gained anything from it, put it that way, and there was zero movement on the Dragunov front. A missed opportunity? Maybe that sums things up.
3. The Problem With Segments Like This
Did...did we just go back in time to 2019? No, that's not meant as a compliment.
All of the SmackDown stragglers were standing around checking out the big mystery box/crate that's being dragged between Raw and SmackDown when R-Truth walked in and told them how to watch Elimination Chamber via ESPN. So, the WWE roster need to pay to watch PLEs now? Got it. Yeah, this skit was like something from the dark days under Vince McMahon's gaze.
There's a fundamental flaw in segments like this one. Sure, WWE are entitled to hype their major shows and make it crystal clear to fans how they can tune in, but why does Rey Fenix need to know that? Or the Motor City Machine Guns. Or Fraxiom. Or anyone else who isn't booked on the card. Can't they just rock up to the building if they fancy watching?!
Here, the script unintentionally fed into claims that TKO are mega-greedy corporate types who will squeeze every last dollar they can out of everything. Not gonna lie, it is kinda funny to think that Nathan Frazer has to buy the PLE on ESPN if he even wants to watch it. What are we doing here, man?
Truth should be knighted for trying his best to make this guff entertaining. Build that man a statue right now. If somebody had told you he'd be producing puff pieces like this when he returned as badass Ron Killings during Money In The Bank last year, then you'd have (rightly) laughed right in their face; and yet, here we are.
2. Singles “Blowoff” Fails To Satisfy
Rather predictably, the Solo Sikoa vs. Uncle Howdy singles match failed to deliver. There was a serious lack of intensity here from the moment the bell sounded. Nah, the match wasn’t brutal in terms of sheer work between both guys, but it wasn’t great either, and it really needed to be great after the dull, endless feud the MFT and Wyatt Sicks crews have been working for months now.
Howdy going after the lantern Solo stole from him was never a compelling story. Not even close.
Plus, Unc got the win here, but it seems this rivalry will drone on and on because the MFTs grabbed the lantern and ran off. How thrilling. In other words, this...isn't thrilling. It's anything but. Nobody has paused to explain the power that Sikoa's team gains from holding onto the lantern. Is it akin to The Undertaker's urn? Did they forget to pay the electricity bill at MFT Towers and thus have to rely on it to light the room?
Later, GM Nick Aldis said that he wants the MFTs to defend their tag titles more often. So, next week, there will be a number one contenders situation to thrash out their next challengers. If it's members of The Sicks, then count this fan out. These stables are sucking the life out of SmackDown, and they have been for too long. Yours truly has tried to look on the bright side, but it's interminable rubbish that Triple H seems content to keep pushing onto TV.
Someone stop the pain train, we want to get off.
1. A Women’s Division Dud
Jordynne Grace running through Candice LeRae in around 4 minutes was as entertaining as it sounds. Honestly, this is a bloody nightmare outcome for Grace. She's ice cold after failing to beat Jade Cargill, and now she's a backdrop for the 'depressed Johnny Gargano' storyline that's going precisely nowhere in a hurry. What a slide down the ranks for Jordynne this is.
The match wasn't quite a full squash like Oba destroying Miz was, but it just didn’t work. The live crowd went totally silent for the bout as soon as it started, and understandably so. Why should they care? Again, Grace is struggling after failing to beat Jade, and whatever LeRae and Johnny have going on isn’t interesting in the slightest. WWE can’t afford too many matches this lifeless during WrestleMania season.
Sadly, there are probably more of them coming. It's becoming clearer and clearer that Hunter isn't the God tier booker some believed him to be when he first took charge of creative. It's either that or his focus is split between too many things and he needs to delegate. Or, and this is another possibility, maybe 'The Game' is delegating and the folks he's delegating to just don't have any good ideas for TV.
Whatever the case, there's no excuse for running with this half-baked fare so close to 'Mania. Grace vs. LeRae should've been on Main Event, not SmackDown. It had absolutely no business being hyped up by Joe Tessitore and Wade Barrett as something fans needed to pay attention to.
Next.
Ups...
5. Neat Twist On The Opening Promo Train
SmackDown opened with Jey Uso being wheeled into an ambulance after being taken out. Then, it quickly panned from the backstage hubbub to Drew McIntyre walking through the crowd claiming he had nothing to do with it. Cody Rhodes cut him off spoiling for a fight, then Randy Orton, Trick Williams, Je’Von Evans and LA Knight had their say on what’ll happen at Elimination Chamber too.
Sure, it was actually a pretty standard opening promo train deal, but the Jey angle got things moving quickly, and nobody droned on taking ages getting to their point. This was perfectly fine for what it was, and turned out to be way better than WWE's usual 'go home' revolving door promos are. Everyone involved deserves some credit for that.
The Uso bit helped a lot, because it upped the show's urgency immediately.
Trick and Knight brawled to the back, then Orton hit an RKO on Evans for talking smack about becoming the youngest ever WWE Champion if he wins at Chamber then beats McIntyre. Everything clicked into place here, and there was even time for a frosty staredown between old Legacy buddies Randy and Rhodes. Remove the "and" from that sentence and you've got Ozzy Osbourne's old guitarist (sort of; his surname was spelled Rhoads), which is fitting, because it's all aboard the crazy train heading into 'Mania.
WWE need some more of this energy, to be brutally honest. There's time yet to salvage a proper WrestleMania card out of this roster, but they'll need to move fast. For now, you've got to call each segment/match as you see it, and this was solid.
4. Oba Femi Crushes The Miz
The Miz is at his best when he's a delusional "locker room leader" who flits between offering his services and threatening to beat the snot out of everyone before realising that probs isn't going to happen. The fun part of this casting is that Miz is literally a locker room leader these days, and a fine one. He deserves endless respect for everything he's achieved in WWE, and for overcoming senseless bullying during his formative years.
This week, Miz wanted to form a tag-team with Oba Femi that'd dominate the landscape for years to come. Seriously, that'd be better than anything The Wyatt Sicks have been inflicting on the SmackDown tag division since last year. No joke. Make it happen. 'The Awesome Rulers' for tag champs in 2026. Mark your calendars.
Yeah, Oba said no.
These squashes against heels who range between begging off and showing delusional arrogance? Yep, they’re working for Femi. Miz offering to become his “Undertaker” was good clean fun, and so was Oba calling him “a Deadman” before squashing him. The line: “Mike, you’re dying tonight” was simple, vicious and to the point. The whole promo-into-match was exactly what it needed to be from the moment Miz walked through the curtain.
Few know their role better than he does these days. Chelsea Green is up there on the women's side, but she doesn't have the longevity Miz does. On Friday, the veteran and future WWE Hall Of Famer sold his butt off for Oba, and Femi matched him on the mic. Total winner of a quarter hour here.
3. Asuka’s Logic, Tiffany’s Win & Chelsea Green
Little known fact: Asuka wrestles when she wants to, and she won't be pressured into working unnecessary bouts before crunch PLE matches like Elimination Chamber. So, the vet bowed out of a scrap that was set up vs. Tiffany Stratton, and Kairi Sane wrestled in her place. It turned out to be a nice tune up match for Stratton.
Also, the aforementioned Chelsea Green joined commentary, and she was fantastic as always. One of the best things about Chelsea on this occasion was that she didn't try to shout down or over Joe Tess and Wade Barrett. Instead, she waited on them to feed her lines or leave noticeable gaps, and she filled them with banter-heavy statements which shone a spotlight on herself, Alba Fyre and what was happening inside the ring. The way she refers to Tiffany as "Tacky Time" is a hoot.
Does somebody have a future in colour commentary? Hey, don't rule it out.
Back to the match. Sane understood her assignment, and Asuka looked smart for deciding not to wrestle before Chamber. Meanwhile, Stratton just wants to boot some heads in because she's been frustrated since the second half of 2025 ended with a title loss to Jade Cargill. This writer still isn't convinced that she should stay babyface, but there are worse ideas on the table than pushing Tiffy as a competitive baby with a chip on her shoulder.
She's trying to build momentum after returning at the Royal Rumble over in Saudi. Matches with this preamble and execution will always do fine. It only amplified how useless the Grace vs. LeRae bout was, but that isn't Tiffany or Kairi's fault.
2. Fixing The Jey Uso Problem
Before SmackDown, it did feel like there was a disproportionate number of babyfaces compared to heels in the men’s Chamber match, so it made sense to put Logan Paul in there as a sub for Jey (who was a sub for Bronson Reed). Basically, creative swapped one Vision member for another, which was necessary. Now, Logan can become a villainous punching bag at some point in Saturday's brawl.
It is fair to say that Jacob Fatu will need a few big wins soon or he’s cooked as a main eventer in the short term, but this TV headliner worked a treat and felt legitimately fresh. That was a top near fall on Logan’s frog splash too - fans around ringside 100% thought Jacob was staying down for the 3 count, and there was a cracking pop when he juuuuuust lifted his shoulder before the end.
One of the bigger plot points coming out of this is the masked man reveal, of course. The dude under the hood was one of Seth Rollins' old students, apparently, but he didn’t take too much away from the match and the announcers didn't over-egg his involvement. They did, however, point fingers at Drew McIntyre for costing Jacob just because he can.
That was logical as well.
Hopefully, this isn't the last time WWE put LP and Fatu in a ring together. It's obvious they could do even better than this if given more time to work with, but they had a mission on Friday and worked it to perfection. The match is worth seeing even if you know the final result.
1. A Surprise Women’s Tag Title Change
Ditto for this scorcher.
Lash Legend and Nia Jax, who are collectively known as The Irresistible Forces, beat Rhea Ripley and IYO SKY to become brand new Women’s Tag-Team Champs. WWE gave all 4 women a good stretch of time, then Legend pinned Rhea to win the belts. Teaming with Jax is working for Lash, because it’s giving her time to develop as a worker and giving Nia something to do. Plus, she just pinned a top name.
Personally, this guy is slightly surprised that RHIYO dropped the belts before WrestleMania 42, but the decision will make sense if Ripley goes on to win at Elimination Chamber. Being realistic, that’s probably a lock on after this result, to be honest. Why else would creative take the straps from Rhea and IYO if she isn’t winning in Chicago, y'know?
Ripley and SKY's title reign only lasted less than 2 months, but it was an absolute joy to witness. They can look back on fine matches against the likes of The Kabuki Warriors (the 5 January Raw), Judgment Day duo Liv Morgan and Roxanne Perez (Saturday Night's Main Event on 24 Jan), Giulia and Kiana James (the 6 February SmackDown) and the Lash and Nia combo both here and beforehand on the 13 Feb SmackDown.
It's been a whistle stop tour of excellence from the team, and this surely won't be the last time they hold those belts. For now though, Legend and Jax look set to roll into 'Mania with purpose, and that's a big time positive for both.
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out WWE Elimination Chamber 2026: 7 Nightmares That Could Come True and 6 HUGE WWE Elimination Chamber 2026 Predictions You Need To Know!