Every WWE Champion From The '90s Ranked Worst To Best
Jinder Mahal may not be the best champion, but at least he's not Vince.
There’s been a lot of debate lately about the state of the WWE Championship, particularly Jinder Mahal’s reign with it. While many have gotten a kick out of the modern-day Maharajah’s ascension, others decry it as devaluing the championship, making it fall behind the US title in terms of prestige.
Whether or not that’s true, it’s clear Jinder’s months-long title reign wouldn’t have happened in the old days. In the '70s and '80s, WWE had only a select few carry the top title in the company. Save for transitional champions who only held the belt for a few days, the top babyfaces from Sammartino to Backlund would carry the strap for several years at a time. The last of this group was Hulk Hogan, who from 1984 to 1988, held the WWF Championship for an uninterrupted 1474 days.
In the '90s, WWE decided to play faster and looser with who was champion. Be it through longer transitional reigns, more experimentation with the top babyface, or straight-up nonsense, a total of 19 men held the WWE Championship during the decade. They weren't all made equally.
19. Vince McMahon
Number of Reigns: 1
Total Length: 6 Days
In the fall of 1999, Vince Russo and Ed Ferrara left the WWF under the cover of darkness and emerged as the head of creative at WCW. However, before they departed Big Vince’s Box of Human Rocks, they decided to give fans the most illogical storyline in existence (which is saying a lot when you consider their WCW run).
Weeks after Triple H defeated Mankind for the WWF Championship, Vince returned to television, despite a First Blood match in July between Steve Austin and The Undertaker that stipulated if ‘Taker lost, Vince could never appear on TV again. So naturally, he was back a month-and-a-half later with a bone to pick with Triple H. Invoking his championship match clause which he earned from winning the Royal Rumble, Vince defeated Hunter via shenanigans on SmackDown, and then promptly vacated the title on RAW, with Helmsley winning it back at Unforgiven.
So yes, in the same year, Vince McMahon won the Royal Rumble and promptly rendered that victory pointless, then won the WWF Championship and promptly rendered that victory pointless. It was signature Vince Russo, and a taste for fans of what he was going to do to the WCW Championship.
18. Bob Backlund
Number of Reigns: 1
Total Length: 3 Days
From early-1978 to late-1983, Bob Backlund was the WWF Champion. He was a clean-cut wrestling machine, and the last of Vince McMahon Sr.’s top guys. When he lost the title to The Iron Sheik, Backlund disappeared from the company, missing out the entirety of Hulkamania. He returned to the company in late-1992 as more-or-less the same character, and fans didn’t really take to him. In 1994, Backlund underwent a massive character shift, and became a raving, unstable megalomaniac. While the new Backlund was incredibly entertaining, most fans didn’t expect him to once-again reach main event status.
However, at Survivor Series 1994, he shocked the world when, thanks to Owen Hart, he defeated Bret in a throw-in-a-towel submission match. Backlund had won back the title in the same manner he lost it over a decade prior. However, Backlund was a transitional champion, as he dropped the title three days later to Diesel at a house show in Madison Square Garden.
While many would have probably gotten a kick out of a lengthy Backlund reign with the personality he had, at least he could say he got to be world champion one more time.
17. Kane
Number of Reigns: 1
Total Length: 1 Day
Kane has been one of the most reliable big men in the business for 20 years, and his lengthy service speaks volumes of his dedication. It’s a shame it wasn’t until 2010 he was given his due as a champion, when he won the big gold belt. Before then, his only claim to world title gold was in 1998, when he held the championship for one night after King of the Ring.
In his First Blood match with Steve Austin, Kane was rendered unconscious as The Undertaker got involved. After an errant chairshot from ‘Taker, Austin bled, forcing the match to end with Kane as the victor. The PPV ended not with new champion Kane celebrating, but with him flat on his back as Vince grinned evilly. The next night, Austin invoked his rematch clause and won it back in the main event, rounding out a tidy 24-hour reign for Kane.
While it was a genuine shock for fans, and popped a huge rating for RAW, Kane’s reign was ultimately hotshotting for hotshotting’s sake. It was a disservice to Kane, and it’s a shame it took WWE 12 years to properly thank him with a real world title run.
16. Big Show
Number of Reigns: 1
Total Length: 47 Days (Not Including 3 days in 2000)
Yes, the Big Show was the final WWF Champion of the millennium. Fair f*cks to that.
Coming in as a last-minute replacement for an injured Steve Austin, Big Show defeated The Rock and Triple H at Survivor Series 1999 to win his first world title in WWE. That’s quite impressive given how, in his first year with the company, WWE treated him like a complete joke. However, Show was vindicated, celebrating with the WWF Championship with tears in his eyes.
Unfortunately, his title run did not improve his standing. Playing the role of midcard champion while the Triple H/Vince McMahon feud dominated television, Show continued his feud with the Big Boss Man, culminating in a three-minute match at Armageddon: Show’s only PPV title defense. Three days into the 21st century, Triple H defeated Show on RAW to win back his title, and Show shuffled back down the card. While not the worst title reign, it’s one where, thinking on it, you can only shrug and say “Well, that happened,” and move on.
15. Sgt. Slaughter
Number of Reigns: 1
Total Length: 64 Days
Sarge was a star for the WWF and AWA in the '80s, known popularly as one of the cast of the GI Joe animated series. He reemerged in 1990, but now, with Vince hoping to capitalize on the Gulf conflict, Slaughter was repackaged as an Iraqi sympathizer. So sure it would be able to sell out the LA Memorial Coliseum for WrestleMania, Vince booked Slaughter to beat the Ultimate Warrior at the Royal Rumble to win the championship and face off against Hulk Hogan.
Unfortunately, the angle did not do the business Vince had hoped for. In addition to the tastelessness, Slaughter was older, fatter, and slower than when he was in his prime. He just wasn’t captivating as a champion, and his program with Hogan wasn’t drawing anyone to the Coliseum, forcing WWE to change the location of WrestleMania to the LA Sports Arena. Perhaps if they had gone with the original plan of a Hogan-Warrior rematch, they could have had a better shot at filling the 90,000 seat stadium. As is, Slaughter’s title reign goes on the pile of weird, failed Vince McMahon experiments. But hey, at least Sarge got a WrestleMania main event out of it.
14. Diesel
Number of Reigns: 1
Total Length: 358 Days
It’s difficult to determine where Kevin Nash should go on this list. Certainly, he belongs on the lower end, as during his year-long run as WWF Champion, WWE did their worst business ever, with Nash being the lowest-drawing champion to that point. However, it’s debatable how much of that was directly Diesel’s fault, as wrestling all-around was doing poor business. Plus, from a creative standpoint, the WWF in 1995 was complete dreck, pushing characters nobody wanted to see such as Mabel and Savio Vega. Looking at the roster and television, Diesel being champion was the least of their problems.
Still, facts are facts. Kevin Nash’s lack of wrestling chops and a discomfort with the white-meat babyface persona Vince saddled him with made for a poor reign as champion, featuring anti-classics against Mabel, Sid, and The British Bulldog.
Ultimately, while Diesel was booked incredibly strong as the leader of the New Generation, his title reign shows why he was unfit for such a position.
13. Triple H
Number of Reigns: 2
Total Length: 71 Days
Triple H absolutely dominated the 2000s, racking up multiple world title runs, WrestleMania main events, and countless opening monologues on RAW. However, it was in 1999 when Helmsley began his main event run, winning the WWF title twice. In all honesty, however, these weren’t the most memorable title reigns.
Caught in the midst of hotshotting fever, Hunter’s first world title reign ended three weeks later on an episode of SmackDown, when Vince McMahon defeated him. He would win it back at Unforgiven, but then he dropped it seven weeks later at Survivor Series to Big Show.
When he reclaimed the title in 2000, Hunter would go on a non-stop run at the top of the card for years. Still, it was clear by 1999 that WWE saw Triple H as a top guy, and he was able to rack up high profile victories against Mankind and Steve Austin, with his win over Austin at No Mercy being Stone Cold’s final PPV match for a year. Triple H accomplished so much more from 2000 onward, but he has 1999 to thank for giving him his start.
12. The Ultimate Warrior
Number of Reigns: 1
Total Length: 293 Days
The Ultimate Warrior achieved a rare clean victory over Hulk Hogan at WrestleMania VI to win the WWF Championship. This was supposed to be the coronation of WWE’s hero of the '90s, but as the subsequent Bret Hart, Diesel, and Shawn Michaels experiments show, that did not pan out for Jim Hellwig. Ultimately (ha), Warrior wasn’t the draw Vince was hoping for, and less than a year later, he pulled the plug to once more resume the Hulk Hogan Show.
Part of the problem was that Warrior didn’t have a great list of opponents. His only successful PPV title defense was against Rick Rude at SummerSlam, but fans had already seen Warrior beat him handily for the Intercontinental Championship a year prior.
In addition, while Hogan technically passed the torch to Warrior, he didn’t step aside gracefully to allow Warrior the spotlight. So while fans liked Warrior, Hogan was still in their hearts and minds, creating a Hulkster-shaped shadow too big for Warrior to escape. In the end, while Warrior won his title in one of the best WrestleMania matches of all time, he didn’t have the momentum needed to lead WWE in the '90s.
11. Randy Savage
Number of Reigns: 1
Total Length: 149 Days
Randy Savage’s first run was champion in WWE came in 1988, when he held the title for a year. Unfortunately, like Warrior, he had to do it in Hulk Hogan’s shadow, as the two operated as the Mega Powers. After their explosion, the two clashed for the title at WrestleMania V, when Hogan won the title. With the Hulkster departing for Hollywood in 1992, someone needed to claim the mantle of top babyface, so the Macho Man defeated Ric Flair at WrestleMania VIII to win his second world title.
While not as much a draw as he was in 1989, Savage was still widely beloved by fans, and his second title run saw him feud with the likes of Flair and the Ultimate Warrior, the latter of whom eventually teamed up with Savage to form the Ultimate Maniacs - who had the greatest gear in the history of ever.
Unfortunately, the fact that his drawing power had diminished doomed his title reign, and he dropped it back to Flair in September. Still, it was nice for fans to finally see Macho not have to share the spotlight with Hulk Hogan.
10. Sid
Number of Reigns: 2
Total Length: 97 Days
Sid had the strangest career in WWE. After two failed runs as a main-eventer, he returned in 1996, and was, for whatever reason, unbelievably over with the fans. Sid fed off this energy, and had what is probably his best run, spouting insane promos and dominating as a monster, eventually winning the championship from Shawn Michaels to a huge ovation at Madison Square Garden.
While he dropped it months later back to Shawn at the Royal Rumble, it was soon vacated, and Sid won it from Bret on RAW, carrying it all the way to WrestleMania 13, where he was defeated by The Undertaker.
Could Sid wrestle? No. Did that really matter? Not particularly. While Sid’s runs as world champion weren’t the longest, it was neat to see Vince’s fascination with big sweaty men actually yield an entertaining result for once. For a brief period in 1996, Sid was the man, and he deserved to be champ.
9. Ric Flair
Number of Reigns: 2
Total Length: 118 Days
For years, Flair had been the face of the NWA, but in 1991, he was in Vince’s Carnival of Carnivores. Soon after, Flair lasted an hour in the Royal Rumble to win the vacant WWF Championship. While Naitch's title win is iconic, the same cannot be said about his subsequent runs. Initially slated to work a program with Hulk Hogan, a series of underperforming house shows dampened Vince’s enthusiasm, so Hogan was shuffled off to work with Sid at WrestleMania, whereas Flair and Savage fought for the title in the midcard, with Macho winning.
Whether it was because Flair wasn’t a typical WWE wrestler and thus too much of an outsider, he simply wasn’t as big a draw as he was down south. Flair would win the title again in September, but it was a strictly transitional reign, as he dropped it weeks later to Bret Hart in Saskatoon, and he would leave the company in January of 1993, returning to WCW. Naitch accomplished a great deal in every promotion he worked for, and while he wasn’t the greatest WWF Champion, the fact that he, the face of WCW, won it when he did is quite the feat.
8. Hulk Hogan
Number of Reigns: 4
Total Length: 409 Days
Hulk Hogan wasn’t just the WWF’s biggest star in the '80s, he was the WWF in the '80s. He began the '90s as the champion, still in the midst of his second title reign. Although dropping it to Warrior, never doubt Vince’s dependence on the Hulkster. Hogan won it the following year against Sgt. Slaughter, and held the title for 248 days. At Survivor Series, he lost the title to The Undertaker in a screwy fashion, and won it back six days later... and was stripped of it due to winning in a screwy fashion.
Hogan’s final championship run came in 1993, when he barged in on WrestleMania IX's main event and defeated Yokozuna in 22 seconds after Yoko had beaten Bret Hart. Hogan proceeded to appear sporadically on TV in the months that followed, talked his way out of putting over Bret at SummerSlam, and then dropped the belt back to Yokozuna before leaving the company for nine years. What a guy.
A crappy final reign aside, Hogan’s golden era had its final hurrah at the start of the '90s, and while people began to cool to him during this time, it’s still vintage Hulkamania worth checking out.
7. Mankind
Number of Reigns: 3
Total Length: 44 Days
Mick Foley is the epitome of someone who never should have been WWE Champion, but was able to ascend thanks to his skill and connection to the fans. Mankind first won the WWF Championship on RAW in 1999, and it was one of the most iconic and beloved moments in the show’s history. From there, he would continue his feud with The Rock over the title which saw him lose it, gain it back, and ultimately lose it for good. However, he received one more world title in August when he defeated Austin and Triple H in a triple threat at SummerSlam.
Unfortunately, that reign would only last a day, as Helmsley defeated him on RAW. Mankind’s title reigns were never meant to be lengthy, being instead tokens of appreciation to Foley. However, the symbolic value of those victories make his time as champion all the more special. Mick Foley as WWE Champion signified that anyone could become world champion if they were in the right place, the right time, and they had a connection with the crowd. The likes of CM Punk, Daniel Bryan, and Jeff Hardy had Mrs. Foley’s baby boy to thank for starting the trend.
6. The Undertaker
Number of Reigns: 3
Total Length: 175 Days
What’s interesting about The Undertaker’s reigns as WWE Champion in the '90s is that each of his wins came in a different eras. First, he defeated Hulk Hogan during the tail-end of Hulkamania. Six years later, he dethroned Sid at WrestleMania 13 just as the New Generation era was transitioning into the Attitude Era, and finally, in 1999, he defeated Steve Austin during the height of Attitude. Those different eras also mean the Undertaker won with three different eras as his character. In 1991, he was still the spooky giant zombie, in 1997, he was the more humanized Lord of Darkness, and in 1999, he was full-on Buffy-esque Ministry of Darkness leader.
The problem with the Undertaker’s reigns is that despite being one of the most pushed and protected characters in history, he was never groomed to be the company-carrying world champion. So all of his world title reigns felt transitional in nature, and he never had compelling feuds when he held the belt for an extended period. Still, given its the Undertaker, winning the championship three times in three different eras is nothing to snuff at.
5. Yokozuna
Number of Reigns: 2
Total Length: 280 Days
In the early '90s, the government was investigating the WWF for steroid distribution. Vince McMahon was in a conundrum, as he was faced with the prospect of losing his beloved big, sweaty men. Thankfully, the large Samoan Yokozuna, who while big and sweaty was clearly not on any steroids, was there to satiate Vince's appetite. While not the best wrestler, Yokozuna should get credit for being one of the longest-reigning heel champions in WWE history.
Usually, Vince’s philosophy was to get the belt off of heels as quickly as possible and allow his top babyface to have a long, uninterrupted title reign. For Yokozuna to sit atop the WWF from June of 1993 all the way to WrestleMania is quite the feat, and it set a precedent for other future long-term heel champions such as Triple H and Edge, giving them long reigns that would result in a more satisfying victory for the babyfaces who would eventually defeat them.
Yoko wouldn’t have the most illustrious career after eventually losing to Bret Hart at WrestleMania X, but at least for a brief period, he was the ultimate dragon to slay in WWE.
4. Shawn Michaels
Number of Reigns: 3
Total Length: 396 Days
In 1996, Shawn Michaels achieved his boyhood dream, and defeated Bret Hart at WrestleMania to become champion. From there until Survivor Series, he performed consistently great defenses, bringing out the best in his opponents from Diesel to Mankind to Bulldog. He would lose the title to Sid at Survivor Series, but he gained it back at the Royal Rumble. Unfortunately, Shawn, not wanting to lose to Bret at WrestleMania, exaggerated a knee injury, “lost his smile,” and vacated the title. He then won at Survivor Series 1997 via the Montreal Screwjob, and would hold the title until WrestleMania XIV, which saw Steve Austin take the spot of top guy.
The problem with Shawn Michaels’ championship reigns are the legacies they left behind. His first reign is marked by WCW’s domination of WWE thanks to the nWo angle. His second reign is known for the “lost my smile” promo. And his third reign, aside from the shadow of Montreal, was marred by Atttidue-era nonsense booking full of screwy finishes and interference. Really, it was a transitional reign before Stone Cold’s inevitable ascension to face of the company.
Still, in-ring-wise, it’s hard to fault HBK’s initial run with the title, as every performance he turned in justified Vince’s faith in him as the new leader of the New Generation. It may not have ended ideally for Shawn, but in heat of the '90s, it was hard to deny he was a great champion.
3. The Rock
Number of Reigns: 3
Total Length: 87 Days
Dwayne Johnson was the greatest individual beneficiary of the Attitude Era’s success, currently enjoying life as the biggest movie star in the world. It was in the late '90s when he began his ascent to superstardom, winning the WWF championship three times. First, at Survivor Series 1998, he turned heel and joined The Corporation, and began his famous feud with Mankind, where the two would swap the belt with Rocky coming out as a three-time champion. From there, he lost his title to Steve Austin at WrestleMania XV in the main event. He would not become champion again until spring of 2000, but by then, he was already the biggest star in the business.
Rock may not have had the most memorable world title runs, but it was when he was the Corporate Champion going into WrestleMania that WWE was at its all-time zenith. The fact that he earned a WrestleMania main event less than three years into his main event run shows what a natural fit he was for the championship slot. The Rock was the people’s champion, and he was an exemplary world champion.
2. Bret Hart
Number of Reigns: 5
Total Length: 654 Days
Throughout the 90s, even when it felt like everything else was falling apart, WWE could always count on Bret Hart to steady the ship. This is reflected by his five different reigns throughout the decade, First winning it in 1992 from Ric Flair, the Hitman exemplified the WWF’s new, non-big and sweaty direction, showing off his workmanship and dedication by becoming the fightingest champion in such a short period. After that, whenever WWE needed someone as a reliable workman after one of their pet projects, Bret was there. Consistently, he put on excellent matches as champion, and while the mid-'90s wasn’t a great period business-wise or creatively for the WWF, they could always count on Bret Hart to make it a product worth watching.
Really, the business woes of most of the decade are the only factor that stymie Bret as a champion, but when his contributions are considered, they greatly outclass whatever struggles WWE were going through at the time. Simply put: there’s a reason Bret calls himself the best there is, was, and ever will be.
1. Steve Austin
Number of Reigns: 4
Total Length: 292 Days
There’s really no argument against calling Stone Cold the greatest WWE Champion of the 1990s. After all, it was him and his rise in popularity that saved the company and put wrestling on the map as an important and relevant cultural entity. Without Steve Austin, there would be no Attitude Era, and thus, no widespread mainstream success of WWE.
While marred by nonsense booking and hotshotting that was commonplace in its era, it was ultimately Stone Cold’s presence as World Wrestling Federation champion that lured the crowds and gave the people a hero they could get behind. Through Vince’s experimentation throughout the decade with all-American Adonises, giants, and dancing pretty boys, it was this no-nonsense, beer-swilling Texan who truly connected with the fans and gave them a hero of the '90s. So while it was only through the tail-end that he got to enjoy his success, it’s hard not to admit Steve Austin was very much WWE for the '90s.