Ranking Every WWE NXT Commentator From Worst To Best

How will Nigel McGuinness fare against NXT's other booth occupants?

Corey Graves Nigel McGuinness NXT TakeOver
WWE.com

Every bit as important as the tremendously talented roster of wrestlers who have made NXT what it is today are the commentators who call the action, and in the five years the promotion has served as WWE's developmental system based out of Full Sail University, NXT has had a variety of voices behind the booth.

Two weeks ago marked the official NXT TV debut of Nigel McGuinness, who replaced NXT original Corey Graves as the black-and-yellow brand's lead color commentator. Of course, he will have rather large shoes to fill in the absence of Graves, who has truly come into his own as an announcer over the past two years. But based off his work in Ring of Honor and in the United Kingdom Championship Tournament, it's safe to assume he will fare better than a number of those who came before him.

NXT has gone through the best of times as well as the worst of times in terms of its commentary teams, and in honor of McGuinness' arrival on Wednesday nights, let's look at every announcer to have had a stint down in developmental.

12. Brad Maddox

Brad Maddox
WWE.com

Brad Maddox wore many hats in WWE. From when he debuted on the main roster in late 2012 to when he was released in late 2015, he worked as a referee, a wrestler, and as an on-air authority figure. But what some might not remember was that he also had a stint as an NXT commentator from November 2012 to July 2013.

As the general manager of Raw, he showed some personality and his promos were typically hit or miss. However, even the greatest talkers don't make the best commentators, and that was evident with Maddox. He wasn't an amazing promo to begin with, but you get my point.

Not only was he worthless, he also took away from the in-ring action just so he could get himself over. Although that's par for the course with some heel commentators, Maddox was simply flat out annoying. Perhaps the most shocking aspect of his NXT tenure was that he lasted as long as he did behind the booth. He was later booted in favor of Alex Riley in August 2013 after becoming Raw GM.


11. Percy Watson

Percy Watson Commentary
WWE

Granted, the jury is still out on Percy Watson considering he only debuted on NXT commentary a few short months ago. So far, however, he has added absolutely nothing to the product as an announcer.

Originally, Watson appeared on NXT as an in-ring competitor from 2010 to 2013, debuting on the second season of the show when it still carried a competition format. Early on in his NXT stint, he exuded incredible charisma that separated him from the rest of the pack, though his goofy appearance prevented people from taking him seriously.

To boot, he was skilled between the ropes, but he sadly never amounted to anything before being cut from his contract in 2013. Thus, it was that much more of a mystery when he randomly resurfaced in late 2016 as color commentator for NXT. The black-and-yellow brand has had three-man booths before and has made it work, but truth be told, Watson serves virtually no purpose and his presence behind the booth isn't necessary whatsoever.

Again, there is time for him to improve and evolve into a competent commentator, but he has quickly proven these last three months that he may not be long for the job.


10. Alex Riley

Alex Riley NXT Commentator
WWE

It was apparent from the moment he was partnered up with The Miz on the second season of NXT that officials had big plans for him in the future. He was barely above average in the ring, but in possessing the gift of gab, he and Miz were the perfect pairing.

They were equally entertaining rivals when they ultimately went their separate ways in mid-2011, and despite showing signs of potential as a singles star, Riley's push eventually fizzled out and he was taken off television all together.

By the spring of 2013, WWE decided to utilize Riley in another capacity by putting him on commentary. He actually did a decent job at first alongside Josh Mathews on WWE Superstars, as well as on NXT, but there came a point where he was almost unbearable to listen to.

Some announcers, such as Corey Graves, can pull off the heel announcer shtick wonderfully. Although Riley was a great heel earlier on in his career, that didn't translate to his commentary skills. He long overstayed his welcome behind the booth before being transitioned back into a wrestling role in 2015.


9. Tony Dawson

If the name Tony Dawson doesn't ring any bells, it really shouldn't. And no, he was not related to NXT's Scott Dawson in any way. Rather, he was just a forgettable commentator. He wasn't nearly as obnoxious as some of the aforementioned announcers, but in being generic as he was, he didn't do anything to stand out in the minds of fans.

Dawson had an extensive background in broadcasting before coming to WWE in covering the NBA, MLB, and NHL, among other sports. Although he was natural on the microphone and called the moves as he saw them, what he lacked was passion, and that was evident throughout his tenure in NXT from late 2012 to September 2013.

Dawson's voice can most famously be heard calling Sami Zayn's NXT debut as well as his classic contest against Cesaro from that same summer. Other than that, you would be hard-pressed to find a memorable match Dawson called that he actually contributed to in any significant way.


8. Renee Young

Renee Young Commentary
WWE.com

In her four years with WWE, Renee Young has fulfilled a number of roles, including backstage interviewer, host, and analyst. But the one role fans tend to forget she had for a time was commentating, specifically on NXT and WWE Superstars.

When she joined NXT's announce team in 2013, WWE touted her as their first full-time female commentator in over a decade. Simply because she thrived at interviewing didn't necessarily mean she would make for a serviceable commentator, but she actually did quite well and exceeded expectations of fans by injecting her own bubbly personality behind the booth on the black-and-yellow brand.

Granted, it took time for her to grow comfortable in the role, but once she found her footing, she was a welcomed addition to the announce team and didn't distract from the matches too much at all.

When she was pulled from commentary in early 2015, it wasn't a sign that she wasn't performing well. Rather, WWE had other uses in mind for her, and she has since moved on to become the lead interviewer on SmackDown Live and hosting Talking Smack, among other things.


7. Byron Saxton

Byron Saxton
WWE.com

It seems as if all fans love to hate on Byron Saxton these days, and sometimes, rightfully so. Whilst he isn't an awful announcer by any stretch, when you already have Michael Cole and Corey Graves calling the action on Raw, Saxton's presence behind the booth on Monday nights simply isn't needed.

What got him noticed by management, however, was his solid stint as NXT's lead color commentator from 2013 to 2015. Saxton previously wrestled in the original incarnation of NXT, but it was obvious he had a much brighter future as an announcer given how his mic skills surpassed his in-ring ability.

He wasn't any better of a commentator back then than he is now, but he was at least competent, built a rapport with fans, and earned the respect of the audience over time. He especially shined when it was only him and Tom Phillips, so reverting back to a two-man booth would do him wonders.


6. Jason Albert

Lord Tensai
WWE.com

It never made much sense for WWE to bring back Matt Bloom as an in-ring competitor in 2012, because by that point, it was evident he wasn't going to get above a certain level.

Once his push as Lord Tensai was cut short, he was largely utilized as an undercard act before becoming a full-time commentator on NXT in early 2014. It was unknown how he would fare in the role, but as Jason Albert, he did exceptionally well.

He was never known to be a tremendous talker during his time in the ring, but then again, he was never given the chance. As a seasoned veteran in the business, he was able to bring his experience to the announcer's table and find good chemistry alongside the likes of Rich Brennan and Corey Graves. They were a fun, incredibly underrated trio during their time together.

Albert eventually stepped away from NXT to replace Bill DeMott as the head trainer down in developmental. As a result, morale has apparently been higher than ever before. There are those who do miss his commentary work, though.


5. Rich Brennan

Rich Brennan
WWE.com

It would have been relatively easy for Rich Brennan to follow in the footsteps of Tony Dawson by being just another announcer on NXT before being let go shortly thereafter. He was an unknown when he arrived on the scene in late 2014, but what separated him from Dawson was that he had experience as a wrestling play-by-play commentator, previously calling the action for Booker T's Reality of Wrestling promotion.

Thus, he was a step ahead of his predecessors when he debuted in NXT and settled into his new role quite nicely. Sure, he wasn't the most charismatic commentator of all-time, but he had a clear knowledge of and passion for the pro wrestling business. If he didn't, he wouldn't have lasted roughly two years down in developmental.

He was a suitable replacement for Tom Phillips when he got called up to SmackDown, calling his fair share of TakeOver events and gelling well with Corey Graves throughout 2015 and 2016. Brennan could have been a valuable asset on Raw or SmackDown had he not been released from the company last spring.


4. Tom Phillips

Tom Phillips
WWE.com

Tom Phillips may not have been a part of NXT's original commentary team (that honor is held by Jim Ross and William Regal), yet he is more synonymous with NXT's announce team than anyone else in the promotion's five year history.

As previously noted, Brad Maddox was a pretty poor commentator in the time he served behind the booth from late 2012 to mid-2013, so Phillips' NXT stint was already off to a less-than-stellar start working with him. Thankfully, he came into his own as an announcer rather quickly and established an identity for himself as NXT's most trusted voice.

Phillips is far from flashy on the headset, but he doesn't need to be. He is genuinely likeable guy who pays attention to the action, doesn't stumble over his words, and has good chemistry with basically everyone he has worked with. He and Corey Graves were perhaps the best pairing NXT's commentary team has ever had, and the synergy between those two was untouchable.

In recent years, Phillips has gone back and forth between calling the action on NXT and SmackDown Live, and was most recently named the "host" of the blue brand. It's a rather worthless title, admittedly, but NXT's commentary team would be in deep trouble without him at the moment.


3. Jim Ross

Jim Ross NXT
wrestlingnewspost.com

Needless to say, Jim Ross is widely considered by many to be the greatest wrestling commentator of all-time, so to put him anywhere but the top of the list would be asinine. At the same time, however, he didn't have an extended stay in NXT, so it's difficult to call him the promotion's best announcer ever over the next two selections.

Nevertheless, JR's four months on the black-and-yellow brand were an absolute treat for viewers. In that time, he called Seth Rollins' historic NXT Championship victory as well as the first matches of Paige, Bray Wyatt, and others.

He and William Regal were virtually the perfect pairing and played off each other incredibly well. It was also a wise way for WWE to utilize the WWE Hall of Famer if he wasn't going to be appearing on Raw each week, while at same time lending credibility to the talent of tomorrow.

JR's involvement in the product early on drew fans in to give it a try, and who knows where NXT would be today had he not agreed to come in to call the action for the brand's beginning stages?


2. William Regal

William Regal NXT
WWE

These days, William Regal is best known for his work as NXT general manager as well as all the recruiting he helps do behind the scenes for the black-and-yellow brand. But alongside Jim Ross, he started out as one-half of the program's first-ever commentary team.

By the summer of 2012, Regal was far from an amateur at announcing. He had spent the previous 15 months calling the action on the original incarnation of NXT and quietly became one of the best commentators in the company. Obviously, he is unbelievably knowledgeable about the business, but he was also pretty hysterical with the anecdotes he would tell behind the booth.

Regal had always been a rather underrated talker, but being placed on commentary allowed his terrific talents to shine through. No matter whether it was JR, Tom Phillips, or Tony Dawson, Regal brought the best out of everyone he worked with.

It was bittersweet to see him ditch his announcing duties to take over the role of NXT GM in August 2014, but would it be too much to ask for him to put the headset back on just one more time in the not-so-distant future?


1. Corey Graves

Corey Graves Commentary
wwe.com

There is no denying that Corey Graves being forced to retire from active competition in 2014 as a result of the many concussions he suffered was extremely unfortunate. But every cloud has a silver lining, and what came from him hanging up the boots was an amazing opportunity to become the best commentator NXT has ever had.

Graves had such unlimited potential as a wrestler, mostly because he looked like a star and his mic skills were well above average. Thankfully, those talents translated quite well behind the booth when he joined NXT's commentary team at TakeOver: R Evolution in December 2014.

Unlike Alex Riley and Brad Maddox, he wasn't (and isn't) overly obnoxious as a heel commentator. In fact, he's actually hilarious, exuding enthusiasm and charisma every time he puts on a headset. His unwavering love for Eva Marie on NXT was also amazing, as well as his hatred for 'The Drifter' Elias Sampson.

WWE immediately took notice of how well Graves had progressed as an announcer in such as short span of time. Before long, he was serving as an analyst on the Raw pre-show before becoming a full-time commentator on Monday nights in addition to 205 Live. He sadly had to step away from NXT earlier this year, but he leaves behind a legacy that might never be topped.


Contributor
Contributor

Since 2008, Graham has been a diehard pro wrestling fan and, in 2010, he combined his passions for WWE and writing when he joined Bleacher Report. Equipped with a master's in journalism, Graham has contributed to WhatCulture, FanSided's Daily DDT, Sports Betting Dime, and GateHouse Media. Along the way, he has conducted interviews with wrestling superstars like Chris Jericho, Edge, Goldberg, Christian, Diamond Dallas Page, Jim Ross, Adam Cole, Tessa Blanchard, Ryback, and Nick Aldis among others.