The Damning Legacy Of Braun Strowman

Braun Strowman was the best chance WWE had of being WWE again.

Braun Strowman
WWE.com

Braun Strowman will be back.

Most do return eventually, and what's especially cruel about his shocking release is that it's calculated. Should Strowman return within 18 months, he still won't be 40, and he will have shedded the stigma as a big, fading guy who is simply there. But for now, he is no longer in WWE, having been released on June 2.

At the turn of the 2010s, WWE had changed - or at least, the fandom projected change onto WWE.

Super John Cena had descended into goofy, overpowered parody. Headliners Shawn Michaels, Batista and Edge were all gone as active competitors by the spring of 2011. Triple H and the Undertaker transitioned into part-time roles. In parallel, the dysfunctional, myopic developmental system proved so fruitless that Triple H, in 2011, drafted up blueprints to shred and transform the bizarre territory emulation model. In short, Vince McMahon was desperate for star power, and, gauging by the demented and cruel exercise that was the original incarnation of NXT, he wasn't particularly well-equipped even 11 years ago to build the next generation.

The NXT game show was a bizarre and counterproductive exercise in sink or swim. It was so mean-spirited and damaging that honestly, who the f*ck knows what the point of it was. There is no other way to interpret the show than through a cynical lens, and the only reasonable explanation is that Vince, irritated by the failure of so many developmental prospects, psychologically projected his own management failures outwards. McMahon is famously impatient. This was McMahon at his most impatient. These men were not getting over as stars. It was all taking too long, damn it. Have Eli Cottonwood cut a promo on a moustache, and if he is stigmatised as an unsalvageable embarrassment in 30 seconds, then good. He wasn't cut out for it.

CONT'D...(1 of 6)


Triple H Daniel Bryan
WWE.com

In the wake of the departing 'Ruthless Aggression' main event set, certain acts did get over in spite of the stilted polish inherent to the company's presentation. CM Punk was a unique, captivating presence with a state-of-the-art in-ring game and the confidence to excoriate everything around him. That so much of the bullsh*t needed to be excoriated bonded him to the audience. As pushed as Punk was, his "co-main event" role always scanned as appeasement more than reward. By 2014, he saw through it and left as a disenchanted husk of the man who was once so driven to realise the promise of change. He knew it was pointless.

Daniel Bryan got all the way over as an incandescent in-ring virtuoso who nailed the broader rhythms of the WWE style. His humble, self-effacing persona was the perfect antidote to Cena's domineering cockiness. His push happened and it didn't; even before WrestleMania XXX's 'Miracle on Bourbon Street', Vince took him aside and told him that he wasn't going to be the man for long. Roman Reigns was the long-term play. Unlike Punk and Bryan, he had the look.

Despite the air of "For f*ck's sake, fine, have him" that surrounded Bryan's main event push, the hardcore fandom was mobilised - or conned - into believing that change was feasible through the revamped NXT. The wonderful peak of the third brand did not inform any fundamental change, as evidenced by virtually every single bungled main roster promotion.

This change did not materialise. WWE no-sold the clamour.

CONT'D...(2 of 6)


Braun Strowman Roman Reigns
WWE.com

WWE was never going to be the WWE that a lot of super-invested fans wanted it to be. It was naive to think otherwise, given what is so clearly true of its internal culture. In Braun Strowman, however, WWE had an opportunity to once more become the WWE that WWE wanted WWE to be: an outsized anti-wrasslin' spectacle built around an airport test valedictorian.

And what's more, fans were into it. It is no exaggeration to state that Braun Strowman was the solution to a labyrinthine puzzle in 2017. John Cena was a star, but he was loathed by half of a divided fanbase. The super-indie darlings were over, but were promoted with a seething reluctance. WWE was a wrestling promotion - promotion being the key word - that operated in almost complete reverse.

Strowman reconciled the gulf between the office and the audience. He was the first "Vince McMahon guy" that fans had actually connected with in years and years and years. His popularity was all the more impressive given that a performer of his proportions and style was so unfashionable.

Strowman's breakthrough arrived at Fastlane 2017. He was no longer the immobile goose sh*t-green hoss that shadowed the fading Wyatt Family. A powerhouse so spectacular that he elicited the old feelings every wrestling fan grew up on, his match against Roman Reigns was strictest-definition awesome. A propulsive bomb exchange that built its legit Holy Sh*t moments within a masterful layout, it was the night on which Strowman became a star.

CONT'D...(3 of 6)


braun strowman backstage
WWE.com

Strowman got over huge in the wake of the first transformative Kazuchika Okada Vs. Kenny Omega match.

His excellent performance built on his entertaining character work - the man embodied big dumb fun with a genuine intimidation factor - and illustrated that WWE could be WWE again. He was Coliseum Video in the Network age, evidence that WWE still retained the old, quintessentially WWE magic.

The company that couldn't book also booked Strowman effectively across the challenging TV model. The Fastlane performance was impressive, but even then, great in-ring wasn't enough. The standard was being elevated across the board. Strowman's ability to credibly "execute" worked stunts on Monday Night RAW got him over all the more. His gilded strongman background brought back the elusive angle to WWE's dire, exposition-heavy scripted TV. His freakish strength and massive frame allowed creative to disrupt the squash, squash, ????, profit pattern typical of the hoss monster.

So much of his early run wasn't just creative; it was practically loving. It's shocking to conceive of now, looking at the absolute state of the rematch content churn on Monday nights, but WWE actively seemed to enjoy telling stories on behalf of the Braun Strowman character. Enthused fans reciprocated. It seemed Strowman, who could even get bullsh*t prop comedy over at one point, was made.

Until he wasn't.

CONT'D...(4 of 6)


Braun Strowman Elf
WWE.com

Strowman was effectively killed dead when Brock Lesnar gave up on working him, much less making him look halfway respectable in defeat, at No Mercy. At one crucial point, at which the match fell apart, Strowman cut a lamentable presence. He became a gurning mascot subsequent to that night, and even before that, it had become clear that Roman was a blockade. Strowman met an even more abject fate at Crown Jewel 2018, at which there was no pretence of competition. He was resoundingly squashed by Lesnar in Riyadh.

In a continuation of the bullsh*t Vince thing that Vince always does, McMahon became delighted at the possibilities of juxtaposition. You see, Strowman was very large. So large in fact that it was funny to see Strowman stood next to Nicholas and Alexa Bliss. You see, they are each very short!

Strowman's aura was all but gone after this pseudo-comedy arc. He had decent timing, too. A non-canon goof-off in which he parodied Will Ferrell's Elf wasn't ideal, but he still pulled it off. He probably shouldn't have.

Vince's awful value system further undermined Strowman deep into 2018, for a large portion of which he was programmed with Kevin Owens. He played the babyface on paper, but he was a bully figure who needlessly applied the exclamation mark on an opponent who had already been handily defeated.

Strowman was not built to last. He peaked as a performer early into his career. His thrilling, improbable explosiveness had dulled by 2018, likely because WWE was dumb enough to make him run around the ring in every match, and the limitations of his style were exposed time and time again when he ate the ring post in every last match. The Monster Among Men had become the Magnet Among Men, as all the while, his once super-over catchphrases only faintly echoed across arenas.

CONT'D...(5 of 6)


Braun Strowman Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

Various reports surfaced of Braun's poor attitude. An unintentional big-leaguing of Karen Jarrett was instantly enshrined in wrestling folklore. The reputable Mike Johnson of PWInsider reported in November 2018 that "4 different people" spoke of Strowman's dire punctuality and poor grasp of etiquette. But then, if anything, Vince often gravitates towards the alpha. He hates meek, entitled millennials too, proving that virtually everybody is f*cked either way. Strowman emerged from this period having appeared to have matured, a callous burial of the beleaguered indie wrestler entering uncertainty ahead of the pandemic notwithstanding. Even if he was still a d*ckhead, and nobody caught it, it's not as if WWE is quick to punish them.

He was in great, shredded shape as WWE entered the rancid pandemic era in which Strowman was effectively buried for good. His ac-ting was understandably atrocious, given the material and how unsuited he was to deliver it. After his WrestleCrap year, Strowman was something approaching Strowman again in the first quarter of 2021, if you forget about the punishingly sh*te storytelling ahead of WrestleMania.

He entered a great performance at WrestleMania Backlash. It was almost too committed, in that he almost took a diving bump right on his head, but he got himself up for a Michinoku Driver in a ridiculous spot. It didn't matter, in the end. Fun as it was, nobody thought he was winning the WWE Title. Those days were well beyond him.

The failure of Braun Strowman symbolised the very failure of WWE in this catastrophically dog sh*t modern era. He was an oxymoron among men - a near 7" dynamo - and Vince still couldn't make all the money from him.

That Vince McMahon could not and would not maximise the manifestation of his very impulses as a promoter acted as proof - not even evidence - that he was utterly cooked as a promoter.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!