The Disturbing Truth Behind WWE's Recent Controversial Decision

Limited.

Keith Lee Randy Orton
WWE.com

Your writer recently elected to take some annual leave dates to recharge from a brutally stressful lockdown, and spend some time with his family the way it was intended - i.e. not telling the son for four months straight that he can't stream anything because the internet is needed for work, so why don't you go outsi-oh for f*ck's sake f*ck everything.

The first day off fell on August 26: the day after Keith Lee's WWE RAW debut. The wrestling world was paused, more or less. There wasn't much time to keep up with it fully.

When your writer returned to work, on September 7, WWE had already conspired to normalise the man who went over the man established as WWE's top heel in just six shocking minutes. Christian, Edge, Big Show, Ric Flair, Shawn Michaels: all were punted and written out of storylines to push Orton as the most sadistic heel in the company, and its biggest full-time star, in the form of his on-paper illustrious career.

Went away. Heard whispers that WWE went all in on a top new babyface.

Returned after a fortnight.

Said babyface is taking an RKO, the implication 50/50 if not quite the result, in a rematch WWE couldn't be bothered to promote.

And scene.

CONT'D...(1 of 6)


Keith Lee Randy Orton
WWE.com

What's ironic, given the pearl-clutching over the excruciating discourse surrounding AEW, and the flips and the "lack of selling", is that selling in pro wrestling isn't just clutching a leg for an adequate amount of time.

These entities are called wrestling promotions. Selling the public on the match is significantly more important than delivering the match itself. When a promotion goes big on promoting a match, it conveys a monumental importance. You have to see it. A generation that grew up on Vince McMahon screaming himself hoarse at the mere mention of the name "Tito Santana!" when he ran down the Royal Rumble participants isn't going to feel like Keith Lee Vs. Randy Orton III means a sh*t when Michael Cole, in slick autopilot, casually mentions that it's happening later in the show on the show itself.

Theoretically, the brand new babyface star wrestling the top heel is a massive, massive deal. WWE, even if unconsciously, told you not to care about Keith Lee or his match via their customary broken last-minute chaos. By not hyping it well in advance as a big deal, it becomes just some wrestling that happens that might be good and might lead to something. This is how WWE normalises talent - in addition to the dire scripting that homogenises them - and this is how Keith Lee already feels like the furniture in the MVP Lounge. They all do. They all will.

Since the dreaded comparison has been made, it can be taken further.

CONT'D...(2 of 6)


FTR Young Bucks
AEW

FTR debuted in May and immediately teased a dream match with the Young Bucks a near half-decade in the making. It is now September, and the match hasn't happened.

Gauging by AEW's booking patterns, it's only likely to happen at November's Full Gear pay-per-view at the earliest. The plot thread has not been abandoned; all the while, AEW has gradually cultivated interest in the match by introducing a tense subplot based on mutual respect. This manifested in a tremendous match, the best of the no-fans era, in which FTR and the Bucks teamed to take on the Lucha Bros, the Butcher & the Blade. Then, when it became clearer that FTR had mounted a mind games campaign to cut Kenny Omega and Hangman Page in half, and they were very much the heels in this deft, dovetailing saga, the first meeting was glimpsed in a gauntlet match. It never happened; Hangman Page, successfully manipulated, cost the Bucks the chance to finally wrestle FTR. The Best Friends won that round, FTR defeated them, and FTR Vs. Page and Omega was set for All Out.

To arrive at the dream match, and create an immense sense of anticipation around it that in theory results in a strong buy rate, AEW withheld, prolonged, and teased it for over a half calendar year. They are making you desperate to finally, finally see it. They have conspired to fictionalise the aching longing of the fantasy booking. This is tremendous build. Tremendous promotion.

Keith Lee Vs. Randy Orton isn't the same thing. It isn't the same cross-promotional dream match finally made real. It's nowhere near as mythical nor as natural a conflict, but the principle should still be applied; between August 25 and September 7, Keith Lee and Randy Orton shared a ring four times.

CONT'D...(3 of 6)


Killian Dain Xavier Woods
WWE.com

The first match ended inconclusively as pretext to a rematch in the same punishingly familiar mode with which WWE has haemorrhaged viewers for years now. Lee won the second match emphatically, but didn't benefit from it (?). He was protected - that word has lost all meaning - because Orton pinned Seth Rollins to earn his rematch (Jesus Christ) against Drew McIntyre at Clash of Champions. Then, on this week's RAW, to no fanfare and for no discernible storyline reason, WWE ran the match back again.

14 days. This process usually takes three weeks, but this, one supposes, is what happens when Vince McMahon doesn't look at anything until the day of the show, is handed last week's script in error, and deems it acceptable.

It was likely doomed from day one; literally, the very first second we laid on eyes on the RAW version of the Keith Lee character. He emerged wearing a skin-tight t-shirt that sought to conceal his body - but only succeeded in exposing what Vince McMahon thought of him. Lee also wore a swimming cossie underneath.

Much like Killian Dain in 2018, he covered up his awesome, imposing and gnarly hoss body because Vince McMahon is a muscles guy and didn't think you'd want to see a dreaded fat guy on television, unless that person is comedic relief, like Otis.

Vince McMahon's general approach to the naturally larger gentlemen is thus:

1) Figure o' fun!

2) Replacement for juiced-up behemoths in the mid 1990s, before he simply allowed the drug culture to seep back into his locker room.

There is no 3) - Guy who looks like he could toss hapless pricks around like sacks of sh*t, and who gives a flying f*ck if he has a spare tyre.

CONT'D...(4 of 6)


Keith Lee
WWE.com

The fact that it happened to Dain, and is now happening with Lee, hardly inspires confidence that it won't definitely happen again. Jesus Christ, Brodie Lee somehow got the Dark Order over, and Vince McMahon lost all faith in him because, get this, his topknot came unloose in an AXXESS match with Dominik Dijakovic.

This is standard Vince practise so standard that it's foolish to think better of him, at this point, but altogether more inexplicable was the decision to change Lee's entrance theme. The first bit is a cosmic joke - loads and loads of people like the wrestler, but the person with the power thinks he's unsightly - but the theme tune, f*ck. It's generic butt rock recycled from the Ruthless Aggression days that conveys nothing of his cocksure character.

Lee's next appearance, somehow, was worse. Lee, not the coolest of pro wrestlers, wore something adjacent to a LARP outfit. Not that that is a bad thing in itself, but it's not something the wrestling fan wants to see on their new fave. Whether this was his way of responding to an outfit change edict or not, it did him no favours at all. The presentation was lame and confusing. It was as if Vince McMahon was tinkering with Lee, in real time, after Lee had spent two years in a system designed to do precisely that before he entered his clutches.

There is good and bad everything. Things that are designed to be good are often bad. Rocket-strapped pushes to the moon can, in fact, be bad. "He beat Randy Orton Clean cry-laugh emoji" isn't a well-supported comeback because Randy Orton, a big protected star yes, isn't remotely flattering as an opponent for Keith Lee's strengths. Big pushes can be bad. Look at Vladimir Kozlov.

CONT'D...(5 of 6)


Randy Orton Keith Lee
WWE.com

This is not Kozlov bad, nowhere near, but he works closer to Kozlov to the Keith Lee that at times literally exploded across the indies. The Keith Lee who got over was a preposterously awesome talent who had no physiological right to do the things that he did. He isn't out there smashing Randy Orton's ribs in with moonsaults or pouncing him into the grainy faces of the ThunderDome crowd. He's, yes, taking chinlocks and doing power moves connected by the same WWE transitions burdened on everyone.

There's no "burial," either, to be clear. He isn't a 2019 Paul Heyman Guy dead after three weeks. Clearly, Drew McIntyre's interferences are booked with Lee Vs. McIntyre in mind. An attempt is being made to map Lee's medium or long-term future.

But the disturbing truth here is that the best of intentions do not matter, if the execution is a total failure. The slick, super-ironic "perfect" WWE veneer suffocates everything. WWE can push any old talent they like. They can even push them hard. It might even turn out OK, like it did for Drew, but only after a series of missteps and mid feuds. But it's never so good so quickly that you can embrace it right away, and for every Drew McIntyre, there's a Ricochet, Aleister Black - virtually 86% of the WWE dot com roster page.

The process is broken - Keith Lee is the latest illustration of a take as cold as the ThunderDome atmosphere - and it warrants an editorial of its own in the not too distant future.

By which point Randy Orton might actually get that win back, f*ck it.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!