The Good, The Bad & The Ugly Of Hulk Hogan's Wrestling Career

The Hulkster's legacy is not as simple as it might seem. Should he be celebrated, shunned, or both?

Hulk Hogan WWF WWE Shirt Rip
WWE.com

The legacy of the late Hulk Hogan is… complicated.

Undeniably, professional wrestling wouldn’t be what it is today without Hulkamania runnin’ wild throughout the 80s and 90s, until the Hulkster changed the game again and went “Hollywood.”

Ask any wrestler or fan of a certain age and they almost universally will tell you that they dropped a leg on their favorite stuffed animal, cupped a hand to their ear, or said their prayers and took their vitamins because of Hogan.

But just as Hulk left an indelible positive mark on professional wrestling, he also left various scars and stains on the industry, and pop culture at large. Toward the last decade of his life, Hogan had all but become a wrestling pariah, excommunicated from WWE for a period, only to return and face diminishing reactions from a fanbase that had moved on or were judging him holistically, and not just based on his contributions to the industry.

It’s not typically a classy move to speak ill of the deceased, but it also is unfair to whitewash a person’s existence simply because they aren’t around to rebut the negatives. Ignoring the detrimental parts is unfair – to those harmed, to a sense of morality, and to history.

We’ll attempt here to present those different facets straightforwardly and without too much editorializing, simply painting a more complete picture of Hulk Hogan.

Let’s get to it…


The Good

5. An Iconic Showdown

The Rock Hulk Hogan
WWE

While the vast majority of Hulk Hogan’s great moments came during the last century, he delivered one of his biggest career moves in 2002 at WrestleMania 18, when Hollywood Hogan squared off against The Rock.

Forget all the dismal WWF-nWo dreck that polluted our televisions that winter and spring, including the attempted vehicular manslaughter. All anyone really cares about from that era was Hogan and Rock facing off in the Skydome in Toronto that night.

Hogan came into the match as the clear villain, an invader recruited by Vince McMahon to kill his creation – the WWF – alongside his nWo compadres. Rock was the hero, defending the company against the man who tried for a decade to kill it while in WCW.

Instead, fans turned this into an unforgettable moment, cheering Hulk and making Rock the bad guy in the story. Hogan and Rocky had to change roles on the fly, as Hulk became a babyface in the moment. He would lose that night, but the Hulkster would ride that newfound popularity to one final WWF (Undisputed) World Championship reign.

This was truly a magical night for wrestling fans, regardless of how you felt about Hogan.


4. Thunderlips

Thunderlips Hulk Hogan
MGM/UA

These days, it’s pretty common to see wrestlers parlaying their presence on weekly episodic television into acting roles on popular TV shows or movies.

This month alone, Becky Lynch and MJF will appear in Happy Gilmore 2. John Cena, Batista and The Rock have launched successful Hollywood careers that brought their full-time wrestling appearances to a close. Others, such as Andre the Giant, Jesse “The Body” Ventura, Steve Austin and Kevin Nash have appeared in popular movies through the years.

All of them have Hulk Hogan to thank for that in large part.

Hogan appeared in Rocky III in 1982, standing opposite Sylvester Stallone’s Rocky Balboa and playing Thunderlips. Hulk’s decision to appear in the movie led Vince J. McMahon (Vince K’s father) to release him from his contract. The movie blew up, and when Hogan returned to the WWF a couple years later, he was the center of the wrestling universe.

Since then, dozens of wrestlers (Hogan included) have chased the dragon, trying to capture the popularity and notoriety that Hulk’s turn in Rocky III brought him.


3. Banking It All On WrestleMania

WWE WWF WrestleMania I Hulk Hogan Mr T Roddy Piper

Today, WrestleMania is the pinnacle of WWE and professional wrestling events. While other companies have boasted wildly successful mega-shows, WrestleMania remains the standard against which all others are measured.

But while WWE’s signature show these days is measured by record gates and attendances, it all stemmed from one show 40 years ago. The McMahons have told the story several times: how they mortgaged their lives to finance the original WrestleMania, and had it flopped, that might have been the end of the WWF’s plans for national expansion.

At the center of the star-studded extravaganza was Hulk Hogan, teaming with one of the biggest stars on television at the time, Mr. T. The two not only headlined Mania, but they went everywhere promoting the show. Hogan’s charisma and presence helped put WWF on the national map, and his star power generated enough wattage for WrestleMania to succeed.

While you can’t give Hulk all the credit, he was the world champion and easily the most identifiable wrestler in the company – and likely the country – at that point, so he deserves the lion’s share.

Just two years later, Hogan would again take center stage at WrestleMania III, this time opposite Andre the Giant for the WWF Championship in the biggest show in the company’s history. Even taking the more accurate 78,000 attendance, that number would not be eclipsed until SummerSlam 1992. Hogan slamming Andre remains one of the biggest moments in wrestling history.

And three years after that, Hogan would pass the torch (somewhat) to the Ultimate Warrior in a title-versus-title match that saw Warrior walk out of WrestleMania VI with the World Heavyweight and Intercontinental Championships, an iconic showdown between the two biggest stars in the company at the time.


2. The Third Man

Hulk Hogan Bash
WWE.com

By 1996, Hulk Hogan’s star was fading. The red-and-yellow had run out of steam, as fans were tiring of the perennial good guy. Jumping to WCW buoyed him for a bit, but Hogan wasn’t going to remain a top “over” act for much longer.

Then came the New World Order.

Kevin Nash and Scott Hall wreaked havoc on WCW throughout the summer of 1996, culminating in the infamous six-man tag at Bash at the Beach, with the invaders promising to reveal their “third man” that night.

If you don’t know what happened, you really should just Google it and watch the video. It’s kind of required viewing for any wrestling fan to be taken seriously. Bottom line: Hulk dropped the leg, told the fans to stick it, and Hollywood Hogan was off to the race with the nWo.

Hogan’s run in the black-and-white vaulted him back to the top of the company for another three years and another five world title reigns.

While the nWo undoubtedly was beneficial for Hogan’s career, his presence and impact on the success of the New World Order itself can’t be understated: the ultimate babyface turning heel and joining a stable of invaders trying to take over WCW became the biggest angle in wrestling, propelling the company past WWF and nearly putting their competitor out of business.

It’s highly doubtful that the nWo would have succeeded to this level had, say, Sting been the third man. Hogan was needed to launch this industry-changing angle into the stratosphere.


1. ‘Hulkamania Is Here’

Hulk Hogan Iron Sheik
WWE.com

You can’t talk about Hulk Hogan’s positive moments without mentioning the one that launched his entire voyage.

Hogan defeating The Iron Sheik in January 1984 was effectively the christening of a new ship, launching it with a smashed bottle to the side. Hulk had returned to the WWF the previous month, saving former world champion Bob Backlund from a beatdown by the Wild Samoans. Backlund put Hogan over as a babyface, and he was off to the races a few weeks later.

At this stage, Hulk was already becoming a huge star, but he had yet to win a world championship. Once he captured the title – a title he would hold for more than four years – Hogan would become the talk of the professional wrestling world and a bona fide pop culture icon. Think of all the Wrestling Buddies, toys and other paraphernalia kids snapped up in the 80s.

It’s really not surprising this happened. As WWF World Heavyweight Champion, Hogan was front-and-center for the Rock ‘n’ Wrestling Era as Vince McMahon pushed the company toward a national expansion, with Hulk becoming the face of the WWF. Even today, people over the age of 40 who don’t know the first thing about professional wrestling know exactly who Hulk Hogan is.

And it all launched with one leg drop on 23 January, 1984.


The Bad

5. Hogan’s TNA Run

Hulk Hogan TNA Genesis 2010
IMPACT Wrestling

As monumental as Hulk Hogan’s contributions to professional wrestling were, he also had some truly questionable, negative and even downright damaging actions through the years.

In 2009, Hogan joined TNA, then WWE’s sole competition, though they were a distant second in the wrestling landscape. Almost immediately, he made his mark on the company, albeit in a dubious manner. He first appeared on an episode of Impact! that competed with WWE Raw in January 2010, effectively restarting the Monday Night wars. That would bomb and TNA would retreat.

Hogan (along with Eric Bischoff) pushed through other unpopular decisions, such as getting rid of the six-sided ring, giving his daughter a prominent role, and signing a few of Hulk’s buddies who were well past their prime. His run lasted a little more than three years before he quit (in kayfabe) and left while TNA owner Dixie Carter groveled at his feet.

Before Hogan came to TNA, it had been gaining momentum and was carving out a niche for itself. By the time he left, no one was going to mistake TNA as a company that could compete with WWE.


4. Refusing To Lose, Holding Others Back

Hulk Hogan Shawn Michaels
WWE

There has been a lot of discussion among their wrestling illiterate about “creative control,” alleging that several wrestlers, such as AEW’s Mercedes Mone’, have that provision written into their contracts.

In reality, very few wrestlers have influence over their character quite like Hulk Hogan. There’s a reason “That doesn’t work for me, brother,” is a popular phrase among wrestling fans.

Throughout Hogan’s career, stories have followed him about refusing to lose matches or work with certain wrestlers, resulting in changes to storylines. We’ll get into probably the biggest one later, but there are others to mention here.

Hulk tried to suggest that Undertaker injured him during their 1991 feud over the WWF Championship. It might sound crazy to say today, but Taker was far from the vaunted veteran he is today. A complaint from the biggest star in the company could have derailed Undertaker before he really took off.

Bret Hart should have been put over in 1993 before Hogan left the WWF – especially given how WrestleMania IX ended, but he never got that rub. In WCW, Jeff Jarrett and Billy Kidman both fell victim to Hulk’s control over his character.

But the most memorable of this bunch has to be Shawn Michaels in 2005 WWE. Originally, Hogan and HBK were set for a three-match program, but Hulk tried to pull a fast one, refusing to lose. In response, Michaels (who turned heel specifically for this program) bumped around like a cartoonish madman at SummerSlam, adding an extra somersault for every bump and flailing about. Whenever that video shows up in someone’s social media feeds, they should remember that HBK did that because Hogan backed out of their original plan for the program.


3. The Fast Count That Wasn’t

WCW Starrcade 1997 Hulk Hogan Sting
WWE

During the heyday of the New World Order storyline, the WCW opposition was helmed by a man who never wrestled a match, never spoke.

Sting would descend from the rafters to plague the nWo for months until he finally earned a WCW World Heavyweight Championship match at Starrcade 1997, the company’s signature show. In theory, this was an easy decision: Sting wrestles his first match in more than a year and finally vanquishes Hulk Hogan and the nWo after the group had run roughshod over WCW for 18 months.

But, as Eric Bischoff has noted, Hogan wasn’t feeling it and called an audible, leading to a mad scramble to book a satisfactory conclusion to WCW’s biggest show of the year. For context, could you imagine Roman Reigns sitting in the locker room in Philadelphia while night 2 of WrestleMania 40 is unfolding and saying that he doesn’t feel like losing to Cody Rhodes, even if it upends a year of booking?

Hogan finally relented, but the “fast count” by referee Nick Patrick never materialized, thus rendering the entire false finish pointless and neutering Sting’s eventual victory.

It can’t be stressed enough how insane this is, that Hogan pulled a powerplay like this before WCW’s biggest show and threatened to detail the booking and the show itself because it “doesn’t work for me, brother.”


2. The Lies

Hogan Elvis
wwe / wiki

Hulk Hogan is a serial liar.

This isn’t hyperbole or some unpopular opinion. Anyone who has watched multiple interviews with Hogan knows that he is either a pathological liar or is incapable of retaining information and fills in the blanks like a human Mad Lib.

Throughout his career, Hogan has claimed a lot of whoppers, too many to fully document. For example though: Hulk claimed Andre the Giant weighed 600 pounds at the time of their WrestleMania III match (it was 500 pounds); that he was the first to slam Andre (not true); that he tore every muscle in his back; and that Andre died shortly after that 1987 match (he died in 1993).

Hogan also claimed to have wrestled 400 days in one year due to the time zone changes from flying back and forth between the United States and Japan. He said he was in the mix to play bass for Metallica. He claimed Elvis Presley was a fan of his, despite Hogan debuting just week before Presley’s death in 1977. He said he was the first person to wrestle Brock Lesnar after Brock left UFC.

There’s telling tall tales, and then there’s just lying because it’s all you know how to do. For the most part, if you watch a Hogan interview, you have to assume that three out of every four “facts” are actually fiction.


1. Later Appearances

Hulk Hogan Jimmy Hart WWE Raw Netflix
WWE.com

The personal controversies that plagued Hulk Hogan’s later life clearly took a toll on his reputation.

In 2015, Hogan was removed from WWE programming and their Hall of Fame for racist comments he had made. He would remain in exile for three years. When he returned, Hulk saw diminished reactions from fans. When he co-hosted WrestleMania 37 alongside Titus O’Neill, fans let Hogan know they didn’t care too much for him.

Hulk turned up on the Raw is XXX show in January 2023, but his mic malfunctioned on him, leading to fans growing restless. It didn’t help that he said nothing of note during his three-minute appearance.

But Hogan’s last appearance in WWE was possibly the worst. Earlier this year, Hulk turned up on the Raw on Netflix debut and was vociferously booed as he stumbled along and tried to plug his Real American Beer. It was a really sad moment, with Hogan blaming it on his political beliefs.

In reality, Hogan’s image never really recovered from the controversies, and younger fans who never saw him wrestle in his heyday didn’t have that connection to the Hulkster. All they saw was a cartoonish musclehead blustering through a meaningless promo that ultimately said nothing. And then his last involvement in WWE was being booed out of the building before one of Raw’s largest television audiences due to the streaming debut on Netflix.


The Ugly

3. Hogan’s Sex Tape

Hulk Hogan Bubba The Love Sponge
Gawker

Hulk Hogan had faced some difficulties in his life after his in-ring career wound down, but things really took a turn in 2012 when a sex tape involving Hogan and his best friend’s wife popped up on the internet.

The incident took place in 2006, while Hogan was still married to his first wife, though she would file for divorce the following year. Hulk would claim he was taped without his knowledge or consent, but with Bubba the Love Sponge’s permission to sleep with his wife.

The publishing of the video online was bad enough, but Hogan would then sue Gawker for leaking the video, which put the entire issue on the front burner of news shows. Two trials later, Hogan would win a $31 million settlement, but his reputation would take quite the hit.


2. A Different Kind Of Vitamins

Dark Side Of The Ring Steroid Trials Hulk Hogan Vince McMahon
VICE

Looking at the physiques of wrestlers from 35 years ago, it’s impossible to think any of them achieved those bodies without some sort of chemical assistance.

But when Dr. George Zahorian was convicted of supplying steroids and it was revealed that he was supplying WWF wrestlers with the drugs, the federal government took an interest.

At the time, Hulk Hogan was still the biggest star and face of the company. And with his name mentioned as one of Zahorian’s clients, the media took a particular interest in Hogan.

That’s when Hulk decided to do his own damage control.

Remember how Hogan is a serial liar? One guess how an appearance on Arsenio Hall in 1991 went.

During his interview on the late-night talk show, Hogan went into a lengthy explanation where he said he only took steroids on three occasions at the direction of his physician to help recover from injuries. Of course, that was pure BS, and the backlash would envelope the Hulkster.

This was the first real negative press Hogan faced, and it was made worse by Hulk’s poor fabrication skills. Rather than turn the temperature down, Hogan’s visit to Arsenio ensured that his name remained tied to the steroid scandal until he became the prosecution’s star witness when the federal government took Vince McMahon to court. Hogan would refuse to turn on Vince, but his “train, say your prayers and take your vitamins” image pretty much was buried by this scandal.


1. A Racist Rant

Hulk Hogan WWF WWE Shirt Rip
WWE.com

Despite his various bad acts in wrestling and controversies, no issue had a more wide-ranging and damaging effect on the public perception of Hulk Hogan than the leaking of a racist rant.

In 2015, an eight-year-old recording of Hogan using the “N-word” slur and claiming to be “racist, to a point” exploded on the internet. In the clip, Hulk spoke about how he was disgusted about the idea of his daughter dating a Black man, punctuating the point by using the slur.

Hogan would apologize, but WWE wasted little time in taking action. At the time, Hogan was part of a relaunched Tough Enough television series. WWE would remove him from the program, terminate his contract and take down his merchandise from the online store. Hogan would be removed from the Hall of Fame as well. Toy stores also took down their Hogan merch.

It would get worse for Hulk. More reporting indicated Hogan also had used homophobic slurs on the recording, and he used similar racist language in a 2008 call to his then-imprisoned son, saying he hoped they wouldn’t be reincarnated as Black men.

Ultimately, Hogan would be welcomed back into the WWE fold after a three-year hiatus, just in time to appear on the company’s second PLE in Saudi Arabia.

Still, this controversy would follow Hogan around, with his appearances on WWE programming often sparking a retelling of the racist rant to educate another generation of wrestling fans.

As mentioned at the outset, Hogan’s legacy is complicated. His career involves the highest of highs and some of the lowest lows. It’s possible to both love him for his contributions and despise him for the negative elements he brought along for the ride.


In this post: 
Hulk Hogan
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.