What If WWE WrestleMania Was Always 2 Nights?
25. WrestleMania 11
WrestleMania XI is another one of the more obvious answers, as the true main event isn't the WWF Championship match, but Lawrence Taylor against Bam Bam Bigelow.
Diesel accompanied by Pamela Anderson and Shawn Michaels with Sid and Jenny McCarthy for the World title already should have been the main event in a lot of fans' eyes, and with a two-night setup, it not only would have definitely been at least one of those headlining matches, but it might have actually upgraded.
In a world where Vince McMahon has a WrestleMania Saturday to worry about, and had been doing that for ten years already with the previous year's double World title match setup, he might have been tempted to instead move Taylor and Bigelow to Saturday night to preserve the prestige of the World title as the official closing match.
Even if that weren't the case, if he stuck to his original idea of the celebrity match as the biggest draw, Diesel and Royal Rumble winner Michaels would default to night one's top spot, even on a card that only really has one dud on it with The Allied Powers against The Blu Brothers. The others feel important, but not enough to overtake the World title.
24. WrestleMania 12
Part of the reason Shawn Michaels and Bret Hart have a 60-minute Iron Man match at WrestleMania XII is to help fill in some time when the company didn't have a ton of big stars and probably couldn't fill a traditional WrestleMania the normal way. How would they have stretched this show into two nights?!
As much of an impossibility as that seems, given matches like The Huckster vs. Nacho Man being absolutely worthless and the Hollywood Backlot Brawl with Roddy Piper and Goldust causing too much of an editing headache to make into a main event, at least there's The Undertaker against Diesel to fall back on.
It's the biggest match on the card outside of the main event, featuring the two tallest guys who had been World champions at a point where The Undertaker hadn't fully established the concept of The Streak, but it had become customary that he would be a semi-main event just on name value alone, and ending the first night with The Phenom vanquishing his foe would have been a nice end cap.
23. WrestleMania 13
WrestleMania 13 is another one of the easiest years to pick, as the No Disqualification Submission Match between Stone Cold Steve Austin and Bret Hart steals the show to the point that it is better remembered than the actual main event of The Undertaker beating Sycho Sid for the WWF Championship in their own No Disqualification match.
Hart and Austin checks nearly all the boxes. They're two of the biggest stars on the roster at the time in the most passionate and interesting feud that had already proven itself to be worthy of a prominent focal point. They also have a special guest referee in Ken Shamrock to add that bonus flair to the match. If this were for a title—and you can argue it should have been, especially since Austin had won the Royal Rumble by cheating out The Hitman, who actually did win the WWF title right after and dropped it to Sid just to make this happen—then this might actually be another "what if" with a bigger change.
The Undertaker vs. Sycho Sid very well could have been a non-title No DQ grudge match to headline the first night, and Hart might have kept the title and defended it against Austin on Sunday night.
22. WrestleMania 14
WrestleMania 14 is another no-brainer, despite it being a rather small card. With only eight matches, it's rather efficiently-built with some admittedly lower-card bouts like the tag team battle royal and the Light Heavyweight Championship matches as well as the mixed tag team bout between Marc Mero and Sable against The Artist Formerly Known as Goldust and Luna Vachon.
Then, there are the midcard feuds for the European, Intercontinental, and tag team championships all featuring prominent talent, but not in enough of a top spot position.
That is because second to Stone Cold Steve Austin vs. Shawn Michaels for the WWF title is obviously The Undertaker vs. Kane.
Most posters for this event have either just Austin, Michaels, and Mike Tyson on it, or they include The Undertaker and Kane as the next most advertised talent.
The feud between those two behemoths had been built up for months as one of the most iconic storylines in wrestling history, resulting in the most interesting specialty feature match for The Phenom that had ever happened at WrestleMania by that point, and possibly never topped since.
21. WrestleMania 15
The Undertaker can't keep his main event streak up at WrestleMania XV, though, as his penultimate Hell in a Cell match with Big Boss Man sounds like a big deal on paper, but that gimmick speaks to how their match needed something to spice it up. Plus, it wouldn't be a great ending for night one of WrestleMania to finish with someone being hanged.
Unfortunately, WrestleMania XV is among the weaker cards where there are lots of big names, but they're mostly thrown together in matches that sound more appropriate for SummerSlam than the biggest show of the year, so there isn't a standout pick to immediately focus on.
For example, the Four Corners Elimination Match for the Intercontinental Championship with Road Dogg, Goldust, Ken Shamrock and Val Venis is more quantity than quality. The Brawl for All fight is a squash, Kane vs. Triple H is for nothing, the European title match between Shane McMahon and X-Pac doesn't scream main event...so what does?
Splitting this into two nights opens up an opportunity for Mankind vs. Big Show to headline the first night to establish who would be the special guest referee of the second night's main event, as Austin vs. The Rock is the only match that really sold this show.
20. WrestleMania 16
Would WrestleMania 2000 have had a Fatal 4-Way Elimination Match for the WWF Championship if the show were split in half?
That still might have been the case, and working with that in mind, rather than trying to split this up into some fantasy scenario of The Rock, Mick Foley, and Big Show fighting for the No. 1 contender's spot or something means something else has to step up.
That's certainly not going to be the cat fight between Terri Runnels and The Kat, the inter-gender tag team match, the hardcore battle royal or any of the other undercard fights, nor the oddball Kane and Rikishi vs. X-Pac and Road Dogg tag team match.
It really comes down to either the first TLC match that was still just called a "triangle ladder match" between Edge & Christian, The Dudley Boyz, and The Hardy Boyz, or the Two-Fall Triple Threat match for the Intercontinental and European titles.
Given how the TLC concept gained more notoriety because of this, rather than before, and tag team titles never mean as much in WWE compared to B-tier and C-tier singles championships, Chris Benoit, Chris Jericho, and Kurt Angle take the first night's main event with ease.
19. WrestleMania 17
A much better argument can be made for the Tables, Ladders, and Chairs match at the next year's WrestleMania in 2001 headlining the first night, as WWE knew the match would deliver. Sadly, there's still a disparity between that and Steve Austin vs. The Rock in a No DQ WWF Championship match, so something else probably would have taken the main event of Saturday night instead. TLC might have opened one of those shows to start things off with a bang.
The Undertaker vs. Triple H was the lead-in to the main event, so that might have been in contention—at least more so than the Gimmick Battle Royal and even the other title matches, which do feel like they're on a distinctly lower-than-main-event level, despite featuring future legends and Hall of Famers. Remember, at this time, Eddie Guerrero vs. Test for the European Championship isn't the same Eddie that is world champion three years later.
The real answer here is that The McMahon Family squabble would have headlined the first night of WrestleMania X-Seven, with Shane McMahon vs. Vince McMahon in a street fight having Linda, Stephanie, and Mick Foley all involved, especially given how the main event turns out.
18. WrestleMania 18
WrestleMania X8 is back to another obvious answer, as it's been debated over the years that Triple H vs. Chris Jericho for the Undisputed WWF Championship shouldn't have even headlined the one-night version of this show.
As much as you might enjoy Rob Van Dam vs. William Regal for the Intercontinental Championship, The Undertaker vs. Ric Flair, or anything else on the card, the definitive answer to this is The Rock vs. Hollywood Hulk Hogan in their "Icon vs. Icon" match.
To most people, if you were to ask them to name a match from this show, not only would they go straight to Hogan and The Rock, but they would instantly picture the face-off stare down moment in their heads—so much so that those two are essentially all you can see on the promotional material, not Jericho and Triple H. Even the big return of The Game winning the Royal Rumble to fight for the two world titles doesn't take priority over the star power of The Rock and Hulk Hogan.
17. WrestleMania 19
WrestleMania XIX is particularly tough, as there are three serious contenders that could all be seen as a rival for Brock Lesnar beating Kurt Angle for the WWF Championship, even while ignoring the best match in Shawn Michaels vs. Chris Jericho.
One would be to just put the other world title on Saturday night's main event, meaning Triple H defending against Booker T. Maybe on this timeline, the right decision would have been made and the World Heavyweight Championship would have changed hands - and it wouldn't have been one of the worst wrestling moments ever.
There's also the Street Fight between Hulk Hogan and Mr. McMahon, which sells itself by putting those faces on the poster and also had Hogan's retirement on the line. Given how those two shaped the whole industry, there's more than enough there to justify it as a secondary main event.
But don't forget about The Rock vs. Steve Austin in what was also effectively Stone Cold's retirement match up until his one-off return against Kevin Owens nearly 20 years later. If anyone would give Hogan and McMahon a run for their money in terms of popularity and importance to the company, it would be these two.
It's nearly impossible to tell which one of those would have been chosen, but with the option of Triple H vs. Booker T opening one of the nights, it would probably come down to Hogan vs. McMahon or The Rock vs. Austin.
16. WrestleMania 20
On paper, without context, WrestleMania XX looks like Goldberg vs. Brock Lesnar with Stone Cold Steve Austin as the special guest referee is the biggest match of the show. However, with both of them leaving the company, the quality of the match we saw, and the reception from the crowd at Madison Square Garden, that definitely wouldn't have been the case.
Chris Benoit beats Triple H and Shawn Michaels in a Triple Threat main event to end the show as-is, but the real finale is having Benoit celebrate in the ring with his friend, Eddie Guerrero, both holding up the two World titles.
That means Guerrero defending the WWE Championship against Kurt Angle would have been the first night's main event, with a traditional setup of the two top prizes in the company headlining each night, babyfaces going over, and the fans beaming with joy. After all, putting smiles on faces was always supposed to be one of WWE's missions, and that's what the eternally fascinating WrestleMania should be about more than anything else.