What If WWE WrestleMania Was Always 2 Nights?

Which matches would have main-evented Saturday if all previous WrestleMania shows were two nights?

Daniel Bryan Kofi Kingston
WWE.com

Since WrestleMania 36, WWE has split the biggest event of the year into two nights. This has allowed twice as many people to have their "WrestleMania moment" by officially being in the "main event" of The Showcase of the Immortals, even if we all know the true main event of the weekend is whatever goes on last Sunday night.

Still, it is an honor that is reserved for just one more match, and it needs to be an important one for the card to draw in audiences Saturday night and make them feel like this is just as big (or as close to it as possible) to balance the scales.

But what if that was always the case? 

Similar to how it's interesting to ponder who might have become a World champion if there were always two titles to go around, which matches from previous WrestleManias would have been in contention for the Saturday night main event?

Let's look back on every single card from the first WrestleMania up to the final one-night extravaganza at WrestleMania 35 and determine the runner-up that would have been the other main event on The Grandest Stage of Them All!

35. WrestleMania 1

Wendi Richter Cyndi Lauper WrestleMania
WWE

An important note to set is that it isn't fair to fantasy book matches that aren't on the cards with the assumption WWE would have made a better lineup if they were scheduling things out for two nights. Going down that rabbit hole just creates problems of what these new matches conjured up out of thin air would have been, and anyone's thoughts could be different.

With that in mind, the first WrestleMania doesn't have a strong card worth of options to pick from by modern standards.

For example, the Intercontinental Championship match is just Junkyard Dog beating Greg Valentine by count-out. Andre the Giant puts his career on the line against Big John Studd in a $15,000 Body Slam Challenge, but that would be functionally odd for a main event.

Thankfully, Wendi Richter beating Leilani Kai for the WWF Women's Championship checks off a lot of boxes for the WrestleMania I pick.

While it's hard to imagine WWE would have been so kind to the women's division back then as to give it the first night's main event, it is still the match that went second-to-last, a big title change for the women's top title, and it featured Cyndi Lauper, whose celebrity involvement helped create this event in the first place.


34. WrestleMania 2

Roddy Piper Mr. T WrestleMania 2
WWE.com

Already, there's a conundrum with WrestleMania 2 technically having three main events, as the show was split between three different venues. However, this is actually quite easy to pick, as one of them just doesn't hold the same weight.

The British Bulldogs defeating The Dream Team for the WWF Tag Team Championship is all well and good, but it can be argued it not only is less interesting than the WWF vs. NFL Battle Royal that preceded it, but as the midway point, it is less important than the main event of the first venue, Mr. T vs. Roddy Piper in a boxing match.

The marquee would have been much easier to promote Mr. T and Roddy Piper over the tag teams, and the celebrity angle that piggybacked off the previous year's main event is overall far more valuable than a tag title change.

That tag team match instead could have opened Saturday or Sunday if this was a two-night event, and perhaps, the boxing match would have ended in a more definitive fashion if it were main-eventing.


33. WrestleMania 3

Savage Steamboat WrestleMania III
WWE

Whenever anyone mentions WrestleMania III, an image of Hulk Hogan slamming Andre the Giant is the first thing that comes to most people's minds. The other part of the card that gives it a run for its money is the actual best match of the night by a mile: Ricky "The Dragon" Steamboat vs. "Macho Man" Randy Savage for the Intercontinental Championship.

Without even looking at the rest of the card, this would be the obvious pick to main event WrestleMania III's first night. That is solidified even more when you do in fact look at the rest of the lineup, and nothing gives it a run for its money.

A Hair vs. Hair match? A Loser Must Bow match? The lead-in match for the main event was The Iron Sheik and Nikolai Volkoff against The Killer Bees, which couldn't possibly hold a candle to the classic Savage and Steamboat put on.

This being for the second-tier championship makes it even more of a clear winner that would have sent fans home happy the first evening.


32. WrestleMania 4

Hulk Hogan, Andre the Giant, WrestleMania IV
WWE.com

WrestleMania IV is an interesting case, as most of the event is comprised of a tournament to crown a new WWF champion.

Hercules against The Ultimate Warrior in a generic singles match wasn't strong enough to headline, nor Brutus Beefcake beating The Honky Tonk Man by disqualification for the Intercontinental Championship—though WWE could have possibly considered a title change there if that had been the case.

Demolition's tag title win from Strike Force and the opening battle royal also seem like strange main events, which means the tournament itself would have to be the focal point.

In all likelihood, WWE could have probably changed the layout of the tournament, but since that's too speculative, it's a safer bet to just say Hulk Hogan vs. Andre the Giant would have been the last quarter-final match of the night. Ending in a double-disqualification makes for an odd finish to night one, but since it leads directly into the next night, there's a way to book it where it acts more as a cliffhanger than a disappointing ending to that match.

Night two would have been the semi-finals and finals, as well as all the non-tournament matches, still ending with Savage beating Ted DiBiase.


31. WrestleMania 5

Wrestlemania 51
WWE.com

No one will make an argument that WrestleMania V's first main event should have been The Red Rooster against Bobby Heenan, which led into the main event, somehow.

Despite having a lot of talented wrestlers on the card, this is another less-than-impressive overall lineup. Most matches just seem to be thrown together for the sake of it, as WWE put nearly all its eggs in the basket of The Mega Powers storyline.

Thankfully, there's an Intercontinental Championship match to fall back on, with Ravishing Rick Rude beating The Ultimate Warrior for the title. Assuming the rest of the timeline works out the same, and this was still Warrior's first pinfall loss, that's a huge deal to end on.

That wouldn't have sent fans home happy the first night, but sometimes, the bad guys just win. The next night would make up for that with Hulkamania coming out on top of Macho Madness, though, so much like WrestleMania XL, heels winning to cap off the first night is made much more palatable when it all works out in the end.


30. WrestleMania 6

Ted DiBiase Jake Roberts
WWE.com

As the main event of WrestleMania VI features both the WWF Championship and Intercontinental Championship up for grabs, that rules out the second-tier title from headlining the first night, so we'd have to look elsewhere.

Funny enough, this card also features the Million Dollar Championship on the line, and with no slouches competing for it, either. Ted DiBiase and Jake "The Snake" Roberts are among the perennial go-to names to bring up when discussing wrestlers who arguably should have been a World champion, but never won the top title. This still wouldn't make up for that, but they could at least say they fought in a WrestleMania main event for a belt that was created as an alternative to the World title. That's something, right?!

Demolition beating The Colossal Connection for the tag titles is another possible option, but as mentioned before, two singles stars works for a better main event and marquee than a tag team match, and as popular as Demolition and Haku were, even with Andre the Giant in the mix, that quartet fighting over the Tag Team Championship isn't as appealing as DiBiase and Roberts battling for the flashy new title.


29. WrestleMania 7

Warrior Savage1
WWE.com

For anyone suggesting The Undertaker's match against Jimmy Snuka would take the WrestleMania VII slot, they're looking at it through retrospective goggles. His streak had not become a thing, and he wasn't anywhere close to the icon he would become. That was just one of many matches all filling up the undercard and midcard, along with Jake Roberts against Rick Martel, Earthquake beating Greg Valentine, and The Mountie beating Tito Santana.

Had Big Boss Man defeated Mr. Perfect by pinfall instead of disqualification to win the Intercontinental Championship, that could be more in the running. The same for Virgil against Ted DiBiase, if that had been when Virgil won the Million Dollar Championship, but that didn't come until SummerSlam.

The true No. 2 main event is clearly the retirement match between The Ultimate Warrior and Randy Savage, and it's not even a close race despite all those great names listed and many others on the card.

Warrior had just won the world title and beaten Hogan in the main event the prior year, Savage was a multi-time World champion who main-evented twice before, and the retirement aspect gives it an extra boost of importance.


28. WrestleMania 8

WWE WWF WrestleMania VIII 8 Ric Flair Randy Savage
WWE

It's a good thing Savage's retirement didn't actually stick, as he arguably should have been the headlining act of the next year with WrestleMania VIII, too!

A special shout out should go to Bret Hart vs. Roddy Piper for the Intercontinental Championship, which could have easily main-evented any show at any time, but this is a rare scenario where the WWF Championship match is not only not the finale, but it isn't even the second, third, or fourth to last match of the show!

Savage and Ric Flair fight for the top prize in the company in the sixth match of the show, because even the World title and the Royal Rumble winner apparently don't take priority over Hulk Hogan vs. Sid Justice—even when that match ends in a botched disqualification!

It's a travesty that in hindsight, never should have happened. Arguably, with Hogan's heel antics, the way the Royal Rumble match ends, and the star power involved, this should have even been Savage vs. Justice and Flair vs. Hogan, or Hogan and Sid should have been the first night's main event, at least, but that's too revisionist, so The Nature Boy and Macho Man get bumped to night one.


27. WrestleMania 9

Wrestlemania 9
WWE.com

WrestleMania IX presents both an opportunity and a challenge. Knowing how Yokozuna wins the Royal Rumble, beats Bret Hart, and then, immediately loses the title to Hulk Hogan in an impromptu bonus match, would WWE have booked Yokozuna vs. Hart as the main event of the first night, setting up the Hogan match for the second and spoiling that surprise?

As awful as that sounds, remember, this is the card that also features The Undertaker against Giant Gonzalez, a heel Doink the Clown against Crush in his blonde Hawaiian era, Tatanka beating Shawn Michaels for the Intercontinental Championship by count-out, and yet another Hulk Hogan match where he teams with Brutus Beefcake to lose to Money Inc. for the tag team titles.

If Lex Luger vs. Mr. Perfect were for a title, maybe that could have been upgraded to a main event as they were huge names, but even that feels like a stretch.

As the surprise Hogan match was too big to forecast ahead of time, and WrestleMania Sunday couldn't go on without a main event being advertised in advance, perhaps history would have changed and Tatanka would have kept his winning streak going with an actual intercontinental title win as the Saturday main event instead.


26. WrestleMania 10

yokozuna lex luger
WWE.com

When it comes to WrestleMania 10, the temptation is certainly there to jump straight to the ladder match for the Intercontinental Championship between Shawn Michaels and Razor Ramon. After all, it's not only the best match on the entire show, but the most iconic of the pay-per-view's history.

However, it's important to keep in mind that in this hypothetical, WWE doesn't have the ability to book in retrospect. They wouldn't know that that would be such an amazing match and steal the show. Deciding on a secondary main event has to be picked with their thought process at the time that these events were taking place, instead of with 20/20 hindsight.

That means it's far more likely WWE would have split this up between the two Royal Rumble winners, with Lex Luger facing Yokozuna in the main event of the first night and Bret Hart getting his match with Yokozuna on night two. Bret would have probably kicked off the first night with his match against Owen Hart, and the Intercontinental Championship ladder match would have been the opener of Sunday night.

Bonus addition to the card, if this were two nights, the 10-man tag team match that was cut for time would have actually made it onto one of those shows!


Contributor
Contributor

Founder of pro wrestling site Smark Out Moment (https://www.smarkoutmoment.com) and geek culture site Fanboys Anonymous (https://www.fanboysanonymous.com).