10 Reasons WWE Feels UNDERWHELMING in 2026

"There are times when I look at the WWE and I see nothing worth liking".

By Iain Taylor /

When pitching this article to the WhatCulture overlords, one of the entries was initially going to discuss the lack of likeable champions spearheading WWE (Cody Rhodes is basically a heel already, CM Punk is so far removed from his iconoclast roots he may as well be on the cover of WWE's PR manual, and Liv Morgan's gimmick of never defending her championship - while not her fault - made her look lazy rather than nefarious). So, when two of the three aforementioned champions were dethroned this past weekend, it sent this writer into a tizzy. 

Advertisement

A tizzy that lasted all of five seconds, as that's how long it took to zero in on another of the many, many problems that have plagued WWE in 2026. 

This year has seen WWE offer more sticks to bash it with than a masochistic piñata, as corporate greed and shoddy creative have combined to create a product that offers less and less value for your time. And of course, it's not only your time that WWE is demanding you thrust into its grubby, outstretched hands...

10. Tickets Cost How Much Now?

It's true that everything is more expensive now (have you seen how much a Mars Bar costs? And how small the damn things are?) but the fact is that WWE and TKO's blatant greed has been indefensible for anyone who isn't a shareholder in the company. Hell, even the company's talent has put the bean counters on blast, as seen when Randy Orton tactfully pointed out that $5,000 for a lower bowl seat at WrestleMania is "So much f***ing money".

Advertisement

Randy said those words in 2025, but that didn't stop WWE try to gouge its audience for more, more, more as WrestleMania 42 charged $14,149.20 for ringside seats -  an almost $4000 increase from last year (via Athlon Sports). Brilliantly, WWE noted that purchasing these tickets also allowed you to keep the ringside chair - presumably so you had something to shield yourself with when your enraged partner found out how much you'd spent.

Sadly, this isn't even the most blatant example of WWE's desperation to turn a buck in recent times...

9. My God, It's Full Of Ads.

The match between Kendal Grey and Kelani Jordan at this year's NXT Heatwave showed the best and worst of WWE. The best, in that both women put on an instant classic. The worst, in that the match was hindered by the wrestling equivalent of VAR - Picture in Picture ad breaks.

Advertisement

Like VAR in football, PiP was designed to solve a problem - in this case, showing commercials without cutting away from the action. Also like VAR, it didn't solve anything and in fact made things worse. Now, rather than commercials occurring between matches or pre-planned breaks in the action, adverts dominate the screen while the match is going in full gear. 

Unfortunately, this isn't even the biggest ad-related sin in the company. The modern WWE ring looks like someone stretched a NASCAR driver's outfit over the mat, as ugly, ostentatious logos cheapen the action on-screen even as they line the executives' pockets. Even Logan Paul - whose Prime energy drink provides the example in the above photo - has said the on-mat ads are problematic, as the paint used for them becomes dangerously slippery as the night wears on (via Fightful). 

Buy hey, surely the extra ad revenue is making its way into the pockets of the wrestlers risking their wellbeing on these greasy deathtraps? Yeah, about that...

8. Silly Workers, Money Is For Shareholders!

The former New Day sent shockwaves through the industry when they walked out of the WWE earlier this year, as the duo once rated by the company themselves as its greatest ever tag team chose to seek pastures new.  Once the pair's non-compete period was finished, Kofi and Austin Creed made a big splash in AEW before proceeding to make an even bigger splash in the headlines by revealing that WWE wanted them to take a pay cut of more than 50%.

Advertisement

This is an ongoing trend throughout the company - Sheamus left after being similarly lowballed, and even lesser lights like Karrion Kross aren't immune - and it's one that WWE's current owners are perversely proud of. Mark Shapiro recently assured investors that "...[TKO] did resize our fighter and superstar pay composition" (via PWMania), just in case any of them were worried about workers receiving adequate compensation.

As anyone who's read Bret Hart's excellent biography knows, WWE has a long history of mistreating its wrestlers. But the open glee with which its current owners brag about screwing over their talent is especially tasteless, particularly when a wrestler's perceived worth can be sent plummeting by lazy or malicious booking (if New Day's stock dropped, it's only because WWE completely screwed up their heel turn). 

OK, enough discussion of the financial reasons behind WWE's diminishing appeal. After all, there's so much to say about the creative side of the company... 

7. Nonsensical Babyface Booking

When this writer heard Stephanie Vaquer beat Liv Morgan for the RAW Women's Championship, he was thrilled. Vaquer is a generational talent, Liv's reign as champion was utterly lackluster thanks to WWE seldom letting her defend the belt, and having the title change occur in Vaquer's home country should have been a reminder that WWE can still book inspirational, uncomplicated tales of good vanquishing evil.

Advertisement

"Should have" being the operative words, because upon actually watching the bout it becomes clear that WWE's bookers are apparently worshipping at the altar of accused WCW murderer Vince Russo.

Russo became infamous for his love of convoluted plotting and distaste for the traditional heel/babyface dynamic, and that was in full effect on what should have been an unqualified triumph for Vaquer. Instead of having the local hero incontrovertibly defeat her hated hero, WWE's brain trust muddied the waters by having Liv Morgan screwed out of the title when guest referee Becky Lynch - also a heel, by the way - refused to count a match-winning fall when Morgan had the match won. Basically, the hero only won because one bad guy screwed over another bad guy.

Not to worry - Vaquer got to look strong on the following RAW by... being beaten up by Liv and her posse. 

*Sigh*

Wrestling is at its best when there are strong babyfaces to cheer, and watching WWE drag its heroes through the mud simply isn't entertaining televison.

6. NXT Has The Worst Men's Division In Wrestling

As a long time viewer and enjoyer of WWE's bronze medal show, it gives this writer no joy to lament the current state of the brand. But the fact is, as things stand, NXT would be better off jettisoning its completely useless men's division and focusing solely on its amazingly talented female roster. And to channel Becky Lynch, it's not just me saying that - it's Kevin Owens, as the Prize-fighter went on record to say "...the women of NXT are kind of whipping the dude’s asses right now as far as in‑ring work and performance.” (via Faces Magazine).

Advertisement

It's hard to argue against KO, with the recent Heatwave PLE offering the perfect example. Kendal Grey and Kelani Jordan's aforementioned bout was a Match of the Year contender, while the men scraped together a passable three-way bout that was the equivalent of staying in a two-star hotel - a perfunctory, adequate experience that you forgot about the second it was over. 

Granted, the writing hasn't exactly helped the men (why bring in a former IWGP Heavyweight Champion only to have him lose - twice - to a half-blind opponent?). But the fact remains that the current NXT men's division looks less the future of the business and more like a vestigial, evolutionary dead end that could be removed without any lasting damage - the appendix of the WWE, basically.

5. Too Much Inside Baseball

Kayfabe - the act of pretending wrestling is a legitimate sport - hasn't existed for decades, but WWE have been really hammering the point home the past couple of years. If Vince McMahon's 1989 testimony that wrestling is scripted told people how the sausage is made, then shows like WWE Unreal and Cody Rhodes' podcast are the equivalent of watching the butcher splay open the pig's guts and try to mold them into something palatable. No matter the end result, by the end, you're never going to look at at sausage the same way again. 

Advertisement

Putting some distance between your audience and your product is a vital part of keeping the latter's appeal, but WWE have been determined to close the gap to their own detriment. Reality shows like WWE Unreal offer little that hardcore fans didn't know already, and simply make casual fans raise their eyebrows at how screwed up the company is behind the scene (Bruce Pritchard being needlessy cruel to Chris Park being an especially galling example).

Add to that the proliferation of podcasts, which reveal golden gods like Cody to be total goofballs while menacing heels like Kevin Owens come across as positively avuncular, and WWE's mystique has been all but erased. Sometimes its good to keep the curtain shut, even if it's just so no-one can see the mess you're making in the kitchen.

4. Too Many History Lessons

The above image would have had wrestling fans salivating a few years ago. Kevin Owens and CM Punk, two of the most gifted talkers in modern wrestling, engaging in a war of words? How could this be anything other than feud of the year? 

Advertisement

Answer: Have both men's beef be about petty grievances from quasi-imagined slights that occurred in other company's locker-rooms over twenty years ago. 

Vince McMahon was infamously disdainful of discussing wrestling's history due to his fear of him or his company appearing old (a fear evident from one look of his over-botoxed face). But CM Punk and Kevin Owen's griping is symptomatic of the WWE going too far in the other direction, treating every scrap of wrestling history as something worthy of parading on television. 

CM Punk and Cody Rhodes' infamous go home promo on RAW before this year's WrestleMania was another example of this tendency, as the two company mascots engaged in a lengthy blab over their careers rather than focus on their upcoming matches. There's a difference between respecting history and being in thrall to it, and wrestlers focusing on events that occurred near the beginning of this century veers towards the latter.

3. Iyo Sky's Booking

One of the highlights from Triple H vehicle WWE Unreal was seeing that Iyo Sky is just as fantastic a person as she is a wrestler. Head Honcho HHH (HHHHH?) best summed up Iyo's brilliance when he said that, if he had to start over from scratch, he'd be fine as long as he had Iyo around. 

Advertisement

All of which leads you to wonder how the former Io Shirai has become symptomatic of WWE's recent booking woes.

Despite being someone you could allegedly build a company around, Iyo's 2026 has fallen short of the esteem in which she's held. Her Queen of the Ring win led to a big dollop of nothing, as Liv Morgan's one notable title defense came at Iyo's expense at SummerSlam. This has resulted in Iyo not just falling down the card, but seemingly off the face of the Earth. Heck, the above image is the most recent one of Iyo Sky in WhatCulture's media library, as WWE have done absolutely nothing with the uber-talented superstar since she was booked to crash her head once again on the company's glass ceiling.

Iyo's hardly the only superstar who WWE have booked poorly despite getting incredibly over, but she remains the starkest example of the difference between how a WWE superstar is perceived in the business, and how she's actually treated by the people in charge of the book.

2. Lack of Hot Crowds

Credit where it's due, the recent RAW in Mexico City was outstanding. Local hero Penta looked like a megastar even in defeat, Chad Gable and Dragon Lee had the best Intercontinental Championship match since Gunther's record-breaking reign ended in 2024, and the crowd were molten hot throughout the night. The latter point in particular felt like a revelation, because it drove home the fact that the average crowd on WWE TV these days are more reserved than tickets for a Taylor Swift concert.

Advertisement

Take 946's destruction of the Uso's car as a recent example. The big, show-closing angle played out to a subdued reaction from the crowd, whose interest only briefly ignited (ho ho) when Royce and chums set fire to the unfortunate vehicle. When a show's main set-piece elicits around the same level of reaction as a clunky, unsatisfying qualifying match, it's clear the crowd aren't buying what WWE is selling.

A hot crowd is vital to any wrestling act. The excruciating silence that greeted DIY and Motor City Machine Gun's Royal Rumble bout effectively acted as a death knell for both team's WWE careers, and it's hard not to worry about the acts that are currently coming out to crickets.

Mind you, you can't blame the fans for being wary of investing in new talents. Not when they've been burnt so many times before...

1. Hot Acts Fizzling Out

One of the worst traits HHH has carried over from his father-in-law's leading style is a refusal to push certain wrestlers no matter how popular they get.

Advertisement

The aforementioned IYO Sky is the most prominent example, but you don't need to look hard to find others. LA Knight's main-even level reactions from the crowd have led to nothing more solid than two unremarkable runs with a midcard belt. The man he lost the belt to second time round - Jacob Fatu - went from being cheered wildly as a crazed babyface to receiving notably cooler reactions as a member of WWE's increasingly lacklustre Bloodline. Joe Hendry went from being TNA Champion and internet sensation to total geek, Fatal Influence's reactions have cooled off from their molten hot debut, where they departed the arena to vociferous "YOU SUCK!" chants, the image adorning this entry sees NXT golden boy (back when it's men's division was worth watching) having the fan interest beaten out of him by Big Cass... 

It's hard for audiences to care about the wrestlers put in front of them when WWE seems hellbent on ensuring only a small fraction actually gain any forward momentum, and that apathy has bled into the entire product. Until WWE relearns how to spin more than the same handful of plates, the hot streak of 2024 will become an increasingly distant memory.

Advertisement