12 Cursed Comparisons That DOOMED Promising Wrestlers
Too much pressure, too much hype, too many comparisons made far too soon.
The curse of comparison is an interesting mind-bender.
At first, comparing one wrestler to another who earned fanfare from audiences years before isn't the worst thing. In fact, it can be rather complimentary and often a sure sign that people (including those backstage making key decisions for massive companies like WWE) see a bright future for someone.
All too often, there's a bitter dose of realism lurking just beneath such observations though; and it's waiting like Edge/Adam Copeland in the corner to deliver a spear. In reality, referring to a promising wrestler as 'the next coming of...' can actually prove to be a creative noose that stifles their development rather than aiding it.
Can those afflicted with this curse come out on the other end with a smile? Of course they can, but not without spreading their wings and seeking ways to break free from pesky comparisons following them around like an unwanted shadow. Rather ironically, it's them who need to get out of someone else's shadow!
Various hopefuls on this list have been likened to heroes of yesteryear like The Undertaker, Goldberg, John Cena, Brock Lesnar, Eddie Guerrero and even The Ultimate Warrior. Unfortunately, despite the best of intentions from those gushing with praise, that didn't do the stars-to-be any long term favours.
Suddenly, and without warning, those they reminded fans/critics/management of became a cruel measuring stick nobody involved even asked for. 'Aw, it turns out they're not as good as this iconic wrestler I decided they're like after all'.
12. Shaniqua (Chyna)
Kicking off with an unexpected case study here.
Linda Miles was co-winner of the second Tough Enough season alongside Jackie Gayda. Looking back, neither woman was really ready for top tier WWE TV, but things were doubly unfair on Linda because she was immediately compared to Chyna because of her super strong physique.
Company announcers even mentioned that on-air from time to time. Linda's ascent and reimagining as dominatrix Shaniqua also fell just a few short years after Joanie Laurer left WWE, so management wanted to position her as an improvement. She wasn't just 'the next Chyna', Shaniqua was better than.
Except she wasn't - it wasn't even close. Nobody's gonna claim that Chyna was Chad Gable between the ropes, but she had more to offer than WWE fancied pretending she did in 2003-2004. Being brutally honest, the pressure of living up to her body proved to be too much for Miles.
The 'too much, too soon' bug walloped Linda as well. Reportedly, her ego got far too big and rubbed a few folks the wrong way backstage. Those in charge had quickly created a monster by acting like this genuine rookie was better than an iconic 'Attitude Era' favourite.
Shaniqua wasn't long for the biz. She wrestled her last match on the independent scene after leaving WWE behind in '04, then went on to give wrestling the middle finger. Looking back, higher-ups definitely got ahead of themselves by claiming she was Chyna 2.0.
She wasn't even Chyna 0.5, and that's the harsh reality.
11. The Renegade (The Ultimate Warrior)
WCW fans (rightly so) had been expecting The Ultimate Warrior in 1995, not some new character who was blatantly a knock off. After all, Hulk Hogan had been hyping up an "Ultimate Surprise" partner to help he and Randy Savage battle the Dungeon Of Doom heading into Uncensored.
As Jimmy Hart infamously yelped, 'It's The Renegade, baby!'.
This clanger sucked energy from an audience teased with another one of the WWF's biggest stars. Journeyman Rick Wilson, the dude behind this less-than-ultimate rip off, tried his best to make things work but was fighting a losing battle. He wasn't what the audience wanted and that was very much that.
Incredibly, as revealed on VICE's 'Dark Side Of The Ring' episode about Renegade, Warrior himself had given Wilson the rub on an independent show. Not even that was enough to convince people that he was in the same league, which is somewhat ironic given the general feeling on Warrior's skills as the real deal.
Not even his harshest critics could dismiss how much charisma and aura 'The Ultimate One' had though. By comparison, The Renegade was one of those dirt cheap wrestling figures you'd see at a car boot sale/yard sale as a kid.
Y'know the ones: The paint comes off easily, and they're always called things like 'The Phenom' or 'Hulking Superstar'. You get them home and they look awful next to your officially licensed Hasbro WWF toys.
Renegade's tale would prove to be a tragic and depressing one, but he wasn't really given a shot at glory because he was clearly pretending to be Warrior-lite.
10. Ryback (Goldberg)
It was a long year on the sidelines for Skip Sheffield as he pondered his next move. When the former Nexus rookie returned in April 2012, he was recast as Ryback. On wrestling forums at the time, some even typed that out as "RyBack"; they should've gone all the way and punched in "RyBaCk" for a laugh.
WWE put the big muscle mountain on a lengthy winning streak that drew immediate comparisons to ex-WCW fave Goldberg. On taped shows, booming "Gooooooooldberg" chants were deleted so producers could pretend that wasn't the case, but no-one was fooled.
The parallels were obvious to anyone with working eyes.
Ryback rode his Goldberg-esque undefeated streak all the way to Hell In A Cell and a loss to CM Punk. He was arguably never the same after that, but Vince McMahon still had high hopes he could turn Mr. "Feed Me More" into a main event sensation and booked him against John Cena in 2013.
Keep in mind that Goldberg hadn't experienced his renaissance back then (and wouldn't do until 2016), so the comparisons to him weren't considered favourable. WWE fans were pretty much telling those in charge that they didn't want to see workers like Billy big biceps on shows.
There seemed to be limited scope for a Goldberg repeat in 2012, put it that way. Hell, McMahon hadn't even been able to book the genuine article properly between 2003-2004, so how could anyone reasonably expect Ryback to succeed?
He did...OK until surprisingly winding down his WWE run and leaving in 2016, but the Goldberg comparisons certainly hampered his early run.
9. Mordecai (The Undertaker)
'He's a white version of The Undertaker'. When saying that, wrestling fans weren't referring to skin colour. Instead, they meant that WWE's new Mordecai character wore bright white shades and basked in cascading lights whilst 'Taker wore black and was shrouded in darkness.
Also, 'The Deadman' has just reverted to that gimmick after nearly 4 years as a biker, so it was a given that any supernatural guise popping up on programming was going to create discussion about the similarities. In some respects, Mordecai was like an inverted version of Undertaker's satanic 'Ministry Of Darkness' persona from 1998-1999.
Everyone could see it, but that caused problems for him straight away.
A debut win over Scotty 2 Hotty at Judgment Day '04 fell flat as a pancake. It wasn't quite the comprehensive squash win it should've been despite only lasting 3 short minutes, and that set the tone for all of the issues 'Big Mordy' would suffer through over the coming months.
By July, he was demoted back down to developmental for further seasoning. That was totally mortifying for Mordecai. WWE might as well have looked him in the eye and said, 'You tanked as a wannabe 'Taker, my boy'.
The gimmick was never seen again. Dreams Kevin Fertig (the guy behind the character) had of tangling with Undertaker vanished into thin air, and he was released before springing back up as a vampire on the old ECW brand years later.
Kane had been likened to 'Taker when he debuted in 1997, but that felt different. Mordecai never earned those comparisons or lived up to the billing.
8. Mason Ryan (Batista)
Welsh hopeful Mason Ryan was drawing double takes from people long before he inked a WWE developmental deal in 2009. He resembled Batista during his formative years as a wrestler on the UK independent circuit. Sadly, Ryan would never quite reach the heady heights of 'The Animal' when he signed on with the big time.
A stint in FCW proved fruitful, at least. There, Mason won the development league's top belt and seemed primed for bigger things to come on Raw or SmackDown. By late-2010, he was working SmackDown house show loops in Europe and was surely raring go to on mainline television.
Ryan joined CM Punk's new Nexus incarnation in early-2011, and that appeared to be the best possible spot for someone who had bodyguard vibes but still needed experience. Working with guys like Punk and John Cena regularly would only help him improve, wouldn't it?
If only things were that simple.
Injuries and a start/stop booking style for the Nexus generally scuffed his promise, and people just couldn't shake the 'he looks like Batista on a WWE tribute show' vibes. It turns out that physically resembling a dreamscape mirror image of someone in the main event mix doesn't always do one any favours.
Watch this space if anyone who looks like Roman Reigns shows up in years to come. Physically blessed? Sure, but emerging from the shadow of obvious comparison can prove to be too difficult for some.
Big Mason was put back to developmental in 2012 then released in 2014 without really achieving much at a tippy top level.
7. Sin Cara (Rey Mysterio)
Almost unbelievably, there's been talk about WWE bringing back the Sin Cara gimmick with a fresh wrestler in late-2026. File that under 'stories nobody thought they'd be hearing/reading' pronto! Mistico's time as Cara between 2011-2014 and Hunico's stint under the mask until 2019 proved largely uneventful.
The hype was unreal for Mistico's reinvention as Sin Cara in 2011 though. WWE told anyone who'd listen that he was going to be their biggest masked star yet - an odd statement considering one Rey Mysterio was still on the books and had been so successful.
Forget Rey Rey (as if anyone could) for now: Sin Cara is here, and he's going to rock your world with high-flying matches and dazzling moves nobody has ever seen before. Not quite, eh? Cara was a disaster from the off, and never quite fit into WWE's way of doing things.
Hunico, owning mainly to his tag-team run alongside Kalisto as The Lucha Dragons, fared slightly better, but few tears were shed when he departed and the character was put into storage.
The original teamed with John Cena, had Mysterio attempt to pass the torch his way, and was supposed to light up WWE cards with his moveset, but...it wasn't to be. Fans weren't as impressed by Cara as they had been by Rey during his debut months on SmackDown back in 2002.
It was maybe unfair to brag about someone who hadn't settled in yet, but WWE refused to slow down on the hyperbole. That made Cara's unflattering matches and entrance flubs even more of a disappointment.
6. Roman Reigns (John Cena)
Today, Roman Reigns is regarded as a majestic, swaggering, aura-heavy superstar of the highest order. He's a made man in WWE. Arguably, Roman always was, which is presumably why Vince McMahon chose to be so patient with him even in the face of scathing criticism from an increasingly-weary fanbase.
Those same folks had witnessed McMahon bash his head against a brick wall with John Cena for years. It feels like a sick joke that WWE resisted turning Cena heel until his retirement year, then they fudged the booking for that to completely waste a generation alignment switch.
D'oh!
Back to Reigns. In 2014, right after The Shield split, plans were put in place to turn him into the next coming of JC. When a 2015 Royal Rumble win was roundly booed, McMahon doubled down by ignoring the noise to super-push Roman to the moon as his new top face.
That led to countless painful moments for wrestler and fanbase alike. "Suffering succotash", the WrestleMania 32 win, some agonising moments against legends like The Undertaker. Oh yes, Reigns ran the full gauntlet of latter day Vince insanity and ignorance.
It wasn't until 2020 and his gimmick change to the 'Tribal Chief'/head of The Bloodline that Roman really started connecting with the core audience. They resonated far more with this version of Reigns because he wasn't tripping over himself to please them.
'Poster boy babyface' Roman worked some solid matches, but his promos sucked and his characterisation was flimsy. He was doomed to fail as that mediocre version of himself sans Shield cool points.
5. Lex Luger (Hulk Hogan)
Right, so it might be a bit of a stretch to claim that Lex Luger was "a promising wrestler" by 1993, but let's roll with it. He'd shown promise on the WCW side for years, so it wasn't far-fetched to imagine that Vince McMahon could mould Lex into something better under the WWF's star-making umbrella.
Originally, Luger had actually been signed to front up the WBF muscle sideshow, but he was tasked with hitting the rings as a heel once that inevitably failed. McMahon's next pitch when 'Narcissist' sagged? Turn Lex into the second coming of Hulk Hogan by making him the new hero America could rally behind.
The fed went even more overt with the patriotism by literally calling Lex an 'American Hero'. They even gave him a bus so he could tour around the country shaking hands, kissing babies and sucking up to anyone who'd previously worn a Hulkamania t-shirt. It was all destined to flop though.
Being compared to Hogan didn't do Luger any favours whatsoever. It only spotlighted how little charisma he had by comparison, and Lex couldn't match Hulk's watertight babyface performances during matches either. The connection with people who'd fawned over 'The Immortal' Hulkster just wasn't there.
No amount of on camera pretence was going to mask that. It was glaring.
Here's the truth: Lex Luger could've been a fine addition to the WWF roster post-WBF with the right idea. 'Narcissist' and 'American Hero' (particularly the latter) didn't cut it, and he was simply not going to fill Hulk's shoes.
4. Dominik Mysterio (Eddie Guerrero)
ARGH! This is a painful one, because Dominik Mysterio is still figuring things out and is hardly terrible. If anything, he's pretty good and blossomed into one of WWE's hottest onscreen characters for a spell. However, once the Judgment Day bubble faded, it became evident that he'd need more than Eddie Guerrero comparisons.
Those haven't aided him over the piece, they really haven't.
Guerrero was one of those talents who could do practically everything asked of him - he was a titan in the ring, he could cut fiery promos, Eddie could do comedy and he forged that all important connection with the audience organically through sheer hard graft as well as passionate performances.
'Dirty Dom' isn't quite there, and yet here he is being compared to 'Latino Heat' like someone poured water into water and asked you to spot the difference. That's completely unfair. How could someone 6 years into his career be expected to match the best of Eddie freakin Guerrero?!
WWE has leaned on the Guerrero goodness for years though, and so has Dom himself. He grew out a mullet, fashioned an Eddie-style moustache, and he even mimicked EG's merchandise and moveset. There have been real high points for Mysterio, but he's been struggling for direction lately.
Triple H doesn't appear to know what to do with Dominik going forwards. A seemingly inevitable babyface turn was abandoned in favour of more JD content, and now he's fairly rudderless on a stacked roster. Maybe the Guerrero parallels were drawn too soon then?
3. Ronda Rousey (Roddy Piper)
Oh, to have WrestleMania 34's mixed tag-team match back again. That captured lightning in a bottle. Ex-UFC mauler Ronda Rousey looked like the second coming of Kurt Angle when she teamed with the Olympian vs. Triple H and Stephanie McMahon whilst making this pro wrestling malarkey look like a breeze.
People got proper excited about Ronda's potential after that, and a singles run followed. Throughout it all, Rousey wore a kilt in honour of Roddy Piper, and even assumed his 'Rowdy' nickname. On comms, announcers told how Piper had passed his gimmick down to the MMA star.
So much for that once the honeymoon period of Rousey in WWE wore off.
WWE's audience never got in step with the idea that Ronda was Piper's echo in the company. After all, they weren't really anything alike; Roddy had been a silver-tongued devil on the microphone, and he was pure chaos inside the ring. Conversely, Rousey was nervy, stumbled over her words and was controlled during matches.
Ultimately, Ronda never had the right attitude for wrestling. She didn't appreciate it when fans booed her (another point at odds with the Piper comparison when he'd embraced any reaction and ran with it), and that caused major rifts.
Nothing about Rousey's presentation screamed Roddy either. It never did even when she was wearing the kilt, 'Rowdy' t-shirt and leather jacket. This was somebody who needed no-frills presentation cosplaying as a great for cheap brownie points.
It was so see through whether they were actually good friends before the legend's passing or not. That lore hadn't been told on WWE TV, so it meant little to viewers.
2. Gable Steveson (Kurt Angle)
Olympic gold winner Gable Steveson worked 17 matches for WWE, but only one of them was televised for a reason. That effort vs. Baron Corbin at NXT: Great American Bash 2023 proved to be one of the worst bouts in living memory. The bloom was off management's rose after that.
They realised that hey, Gable might not be Kurt Angle.
Those who follow WWE life closely rolled their eyes and shouted about Chad Gable during all of this. If the company wanted someone who could emulate Kurt's finest, then they had him. They'd just decided to call the poor guy "Shorty G" for a while when he richly deserved the kind of fanfare Steveson was getting.
Steveson's in-person appearance at SummerSlam 2021 was designed to introduce him to the fans as Angle's spiritual successor. Sadly for WWE, few emotionally invested in that idea until they saw what Gable could do between the ropes where it counted.
That proved to be smart. Nearly 2 years later, his first match vs. Corbin was an outright disaster and a cutting example of how difficult the pro game can be. Not just anyone, gold medal winning athlete or not, can pull on a singlet and do what WWE stars can do weekly.
Steveson proved that, and the Kurt Angle comparisons weighed heavy on him. He was taken out of the firing line then not-so-quietly released from his contract in May 2024. Gable Steveson would go down in history as one of the biggest busts in promotional history.
Yikes.
1. Parker Boudreaux (Brock Lesnar)
Poor Parker Boudreaux barely even got the chance to be considered a bust, such was his fleeting time in the limelight.
The celebrated college football player was signed in 2021 and began training at the Performance Center. Then, he debuted on NXT as Harland, and the internet took notice of his striking resemblance to a young Brock Lesnar. In truth, that's where the comparisons should've ended.
People went daft with 'Next Big Thing' chatter anyway, and did so without checking what the rough-around-the-edges rookie had to offer. They'd never seen him work a match, didn't know if he could even cut a promo, and yet here some were talking about how many World Titles Parker would win.
The number? 0. He left WWE and joined AEW, but more mediocrity ensued. It wouldn't matter if Boudreaux was halfway decent inside the ring - he'd annoyed folks by never coming through on their ridiculous aggrandisement. That wasn't on Parker.
It's just something that had occurred without any involvement from the man himself. In fact, during select interviews, Boudreaux addressed the way he looked and called it both a blessing and a curse. He knew that he'd be judged harshly if he didn't match the billing others had imposed on him.
That's what happened in the end, both in WWE and AEW. Now, it'd be a seismic shock if Parker even got another chance to prove himself.
What other comparisons doomed wrestlers to fail? For more WWE, check out 40 Greatest Stories Wrestling Ever Told and WWE's Biggest Booking DISASTER Every Year (1986-2026)!