7 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (20 Feb - Results & Review)
Slow burn heel teases and bags of good matches spotlight this week's WWE SmackDown.
WWE powered towards next week's Elimination Chamber PLE with an action-packed 3 hour episode of SmackDown that provided plenty of in-ring highlights. The sheer depth on this roster is wild, and it means Triple H can put pretty much any combo out there safe in the knowledge that they'll rarely drop below solid.
There were negative takeaways from Friday's show though. The main event might be an olive branch to Aleister Black at best, the ongoing drama (if you can call it that) involving The Wyatt Sicks and MFTs is flat out dull, and Jade Cargill just reignited one of 2025's worst mini feuds for no reason at all. Seriously, who knows what WWE's creative team are thinking here?
Back on the positive side, there was top work in both Triple Threats offering Elimination Chamber qualification. A pair of fresh faces got the star rub in those, which is great to see. This really was a night dedicated to pushing the future of SmackDown and WWE as a whole, and you've got to respect it - that's especially true during WrestleMania season, because the company once ignored newbies around this time of year.
Something interesting is brewing between Cody Rhodes and Sami Zayn too. Both are keen to vent frustrations, but either man could turn heel either before or after 'Mania. If it's Cody, then it'll likely come after, but at least there's an air of mystery about what his characters motivations are nowadays.
Here's all the yay and nay from a busy broadcast that had definite dips but was never less than watchable.
Downs...
4. Main Event Situation Feels A Bit Messy
There's a reason why this one falls so early in the 'Downs' section.
Aleister Black can point to a win over Randy Orton, and that is an improvement for him considering recent events, but Drew McIntyre blasting Randy with the title when he already has Cody Rhodes and Jacob Fatu chasing him dilutes things a little. No, this wasn't a bad match by any means, but it felt like it was just really getting going when McIntyre sprinted in out of nowhere.
The finish kinda smacks of WWE not really knowing what they want to do at WrestleMania, so they’re just gonna chuck everyone in there as a challenger to Drew. That's...fine, but they'll need to be careful with it. There'd be less excitement for McIntyre vs. Cody vs. Fatu vs. Randy than some may imagine, especially on a weekender as grand as 'Mania. A match like that would lay bare the truth: That Triple H didn't really know which direction to go with.
It remains to be seen whether or not this will even pay dividends for Black too. He's been here before, then the writers totally forget about or give up on him. If they follow through on this victory, then fair enough, but pardon yours truly if he has his doubts. Aleister doesn't tend to stay hot for very long despite his obvious talent, and that's a shame.
This almost crept into 'Ups' territory, but the scatty nature of Drew's interference and the unconvincing way WWE has booked Black since his return held it back ever so slightly.
3. Do We Really Need To Do This?
Uncle Howdy challenged Solo Sikoa to meet him one on one next week so he can “expose his insecurities”. Can he not just “move the hell on instead”? Y'know, do us all a favour here, because this feud has felt interminable and it's like pulling teeth at this point. There's almost zero interest in seeing this MFT vs. Wyatt Sicks thing continue, but continue it seemingly must.
It really says everything that Matt Cardona and Apollo Crews coming for the MFTs is more interesting than Howdy rambling away in pre-taped promos. How many of those can he and the Sicks cut, man?! They say largely the same things, then WWE books the tiniest bit of storyline progression/regression before hitting the repeat button. It's painful, and it needs to stop.
The Wyatts have strangled SmackDown's tag-team division for far too long.
Sure, Howdy vs. Solo is what this plot has been building up to, but it's still ice cold. Few actually care whether or not Unc wins back his prized lantern from Sikoa, and they're a hair away from sticking that thing on a pole here. Yes, your writer has cracked that joke before, but it's difficult not to when he's seeing the same stuff from these folks every bloody week.
Seeking positives from this feud has been akin to searching for needles in a haystack. Even if you want to like either group, WWE's booking makes it harder. Just get this singles match over with, give Howdy back his lantern, then move the hell on. Pretty please?
2. Jade Cargill’s Nothing Promo
Let's get this straight: WWE sent Jade Cargill out on SmackDown to say she’d be on Monday’s Raw to find out who Liv Morgan wants to challenge at WrestleMania 42. Thrilling. Hmm, this wasn’t very good. That isn't really Jade’s fault, to be honest. The writing team didn’t give her a prayer here. 'Go out and say you're going to be on the next TV show' is hardly electric material.
Perhaps the only interesting tidbit was that she mentioned Charlotte Flair when running down those involved in the women’s Chamber bout, but Flair wasn't the one who qualified in the end. That was a subtly lovely bit of foreshadowing from Jade - she assumed that Charlotte would get the job done vs. Kiana James and Nia Jax because she typically does, so at least Cargill has been paying attention.
That's the kindest thing one could say about her speech. It didn't do much for her bullying character, didn't capitalise on her first title defence vs. Jordynne Grace, and it pandered to Liv's choice after winning the Royal Rumble. That isn't something Cargill should be doing, especially for another heel. Besides, everyone knows Morgan won't pick Jade, so this is all pointless posturing to kill time.
So, it turns out that Jade's title reign means nothing without Bianca Belair and Naomi. Who knew? Triple H needs a shake considering Cargill is one of his pet projects and he pushed her to the strap late last year. Doing do without any sort of map for what came next? Pretty annoying.
1. Then They Continued The Michin & B-FAB Stuff?!
They're trolling us now.
Nah, nah, nah. What? Michin and B-FAB approached Jade Cargill when the Women’s Champ was doing a photoshoot. Sorry, but why would WWE think anybody is gonna care about this?! It didn't work as a mini-feud for Jade once she bagged the belt in late 2025, and it won't work heading into Elimination Chamber either. If they dare to put Cargill out there vs. Michin or FAB, then forget it.
Hit fast forward on that segment before it happens. It'll be a real 'nothing to see here' scenario. Man, they’re really fumbling Cargill’s title reign if this is all creative has in mind for her. Neither Michin nor B-FAB should even be in the conversation for a Women's Title shot at this time of the year, not least when they've already been benched by Jade's bully girl mentality. This just shouldn't be happening again.
You could almost hear audible groans coming from the live crowd in the house for SmackDown when the babyface duo showed up on the tron to get in Cargill's face. No amount of sassy lines or kendo stick waving can convince the fanbase that FAB or Michin could realistically derail Jade's march on the road to WrestleMania 42. Is Triple H out of his mind?
If you ran this skit and told someone it was from November 2025, they'd believe you. The problem with acts like Michin and FAB is that they don't evolve - they just do the same things over and over expecting different results. It's rubbish, uninspired creative.
Ups...
7. Twin Women’s Division Winners
Onto the 'Ups', and there are a lot of them.
This fan actually liked how hard fought a win it was for Tiffany Stratton over Alba Fyre, and it was nice to see Alba get more ring time than usual. Meanwhile, Chelsea Green was a riot at ringside as she sat in a wheelchair and somehow still commanded attention from the crowd. What a credit to the women's division she is.
Elsewhere, Rhea Ripley beat Giulia by DQ when Lash Legend and Nia Jax ran in, but Giulia was showing her best before that moment. She'll be heartened by that after watching her pal Kiana James burst through the so-called glass ceiling earlier in the night. Things haven't exactly been going swimmingly for Giulia on the main roster, but she looked well-matched to 'Mami' here, and Ripley bent over backwards to pull her peer up.
Both of these matches were fairly similar in terms of quality, which is why they’re lumped together. You honestly can’t argue with what WWE put on with either. They were functional bouts within the context of SmackDown overall, but both were well worked and played before polite responses from Fort Lauderdale. In that sense, Stratton vs. Fyre and Ripley vs. Giulia scratched an itch.
The quartet bridged a few gaps before major segments/matches on the show without killing the crowd, and they deserve plaudits for that. It's a promising sign for Giulia that her heat sections vs. Rhea had fans begging to see the babyface roar back. Plus, Tiffy's triumph kept her busy until Chamber.
6. Amazing What Being Squashed Can Do
Kit Wilson didn’t want another kicking from Oba Femi, so he read out a lovey dovey poem he’d prepared for Oba. Then, in a funny twist, Femi wanted another one, so Kit had to read some old material that wasn’t so flattering. That led to the inevitable squash. It's incredible how this side quest has worked out for both guys, it really is.
Battering Kit has been a nice way to introduce Oba to the main roster crowds, and Wilson has gleaned something out of it too by getting more screentime for his new character. People are onboard with chanting, "TOXIC" at the top of their lungs, and the way he referred to both himself and Femi as "feminists" raised a laugh. This is very on the nose, but WWE still need to be careful not to attract the wrong kind of PR with it.
Meh, Kit seems smart enough to sidestep that whilst cutely highlighting what's happening on social media.
Later, Oba smiled and licked his chops as The Miz accidentally talked his way into a singles showdown with the powerhouse next week. By the time Miz realised that he wouldn't be teaming with Femi but facing him, it was too late. Running straight through someone better established than Wilson will stand Oba in good stead, and these are worthwhile time killing exercises until his post-WrestleMania 42 push kicks in properly.
Kit can use this feud as a means to moan at GM Nick Aldis and perhaps politic his way into a United States Title shot vs. Carmelo Hayes. Why not? He should be rewarded for his work in recent weeks.
5. Tama Tonga Continues To Shine Solo
Solo, not Solo. So to speak.
Sikoa's MFTs did help Tama beat Ilja Dragunov, but Tonga looked really good out there on his own. He has a promising singles push in the works here, by the looks of things, and there's something in Shinsuke Nakamura drawing his attention away from Solo's mission vs. The Wyatt Sicks too. Honestly, if Shin saves Tama from that nightmare then they should build a statue of him!
The match itself was typically stiff Dragunov fare. He really does leave it all in the ring every single time he’s out there, and it's clear to anyone with eyes that Ilja is a fantastically intense worker who deserves all of the flowers. A leaping clothesline spot off the ring steps from Tama looked amazing, and so did Ilja’s German Suplex later on.
On a side note, is anyone else beginning to think it must be contractually obliged for Dragunov to bust his nose/lip/eyebrow during matches? The dude never seems to escape unscathed. It was his nose that took a pounding on this occasion, but Ilja wiped away the blood and soldiered on so he could make Tonga look like something special. Good on him for that.
Tama packed on some muscle a few months back and has looked better for it. Crucially, that extra beef hasn't stopped him from moving around the ring freely, so he can match up well against pretty much anyone and bump around when necessary. He could come in pretty handy on the midcard/upper midcard once this MFTs stuff is in the rearview mirror.
4. Jacob Fatu’s Air Of Danger
Cody Rhodes wouldn’t have had much new to say with his opening promo anyway, so it’s a good thing he was interrupted by Jacob Fatu. All fired up, a ticked off Fatu then called out Drew McIntyre, who was in a private suite watching the show. Nick Aldis begged Jacob not to go up there and tear the WWE Champion limb from limb, then teased potentially setting up McIntyre vs. Fatu for Elimination Chamber.
This felt a little more urgent than some WWE promo train segments. The reactions Drew is getting as a heel will need to be discussed though, because he’s receiving bigger pops than most of the babyfaces. The opening segment was solid stuff and there’s always an air of danger when Fatu’s around though. He ups the intensity in a hurry, and doesn't waste time mincing his words with empty platitudes as a character.
That's appreciated when Cody is all, 'What do you wanna talk about?' and Drew is in the mood to troll everyone within earshot. Having Fatu's intense approach at hand will help this situation if the company wants to go Triple Threat or Fatal-4-Way with it heading into WrestleMania. They've apparently still to make their minds up on that one.
Rhodes deciding against getting physical with Jacob put over how much of a threat everyone views Fatu as too. Cody knows he has Elimination Chamber coming up, so it'd be foolish to throw hands with the 'Samoan Werewolf'. The ex-WWE Champ took out some of his frustrations on a perceived soft target later in the night anyway.
3. Trips Backs Trick
Trick Williams beat Damian Priest and Carmelo Hayes to qualify for Elimination Chamber in the men's Triple Threat. It was lovely to see old NXT pals-turned-enemies Hayes and Trick out there doing their thing on SmackDown, and the live crowd picked up on that by chanting for the third brand. Somewhere, one Shawn Michaels cracked a smile under his cowboy hat.
Going with Williams as winner was the right call. Carmelo has his United States Title deal going on, and Priest has been pretty boring for a while now. Trick was definitely the best option of the trio, and this victory shows how much faith Triple H is willing to put in the main roster newcomer. He's quickly pushing his way to the top of the SmackDown tree rather than spinning wheels round about the roots, and that's a good thing.
Priest almost acted like a protective big brother to Melo early on, but that was never going to last. The best thing about that bit of booking is that Damian can't stomach how arrogant Trick is, so he wanted to tear him down more than help Hayes. They were still opponents, and there was still a Chamber spot up for grabs after all.
Williams managed to overcome that 'cause he can back up his big mouth with big actions inside the ring. His win was greeted favourably by the fans as well, so WWE could have their work cut out for them to keep Trick and his "lemon pepper steppers" full blown heel for too long.
Cracking match.
2. Kiana James Gets The Nod
What a refreshing surprise this was.
Kiana James has been super impressive alongside Giulia lately, and has actually started outshining her charge. So, it's great to see WWE give someone deserving a push into such an important match. James beating out Charlotte Flair and Nia Jax made her look big time, but it also shouldn’t be lost in the mix that Charlotte is struggling to win out on her own without Alexa Bliss around. That’s something to keep an eye on.
The announcers put a lot of shine on James hitting Jax with a Samoan Drop, which was visually impressive. That was a John Cena-esque show of power from Kiana. The only flub in this bout was James being late to kick out of a Spanish Fly from the corner; the ref stopped his count when he clearly could’ve reached the 3, but not many in the crowd seemed to really mind so it’s all good.
All 3 women got it together again in time for the creative finish: James interrupted a Figure Eight with a pinning combo for the win. That looked so slick. There you have it - a well-worked Triple Threat that saw a rising star beat out 2 established ones. It'd be hard to pick any faults in that strategy from the writers. You can’t be mad at it.
All going well, Kiana will get to eliminate somebody (maybe Alexa Bliss?) in the women's Chamber match on next weekend's PLE. Screw it, have her eliminate Asuka too just to put more spotlight on a rising star in the women's division. Another one.
1. Someone’s Slow Burn Continues
Note the italics there. They suggest that WWE could turn either Cody Rhodes or Sami Zayn soon. The babyface (for now) pair had an excellent backstage confrontation on this week's SmackDown. Cody tried giving Sami a pep talk about being unlucky in the Chamber qualifier last week, but Zayn was having none of it. He pointed out that he’d helped Cody by fighting off Drew McIntyre, then Rhodes stuck him with a finisher to take the glory.
Sami’s lines about Cody not knowing what it’s like to struggle, then Rhodes harking back to Germany and his ‘3 Stages Of Hell’ loss to Drew when he did effectively the same thing as Zayn by fighting off Jacob Fatu? Good lord, that ruled. It's always a good thing when workers have real conversations that flow naturally and don't just feel like pre-rehearsed lines, and hearing Rhodes remember when trying to do the right thing blew up in his face shows great continuity for his character.
Sami is clearly heading into heel territory, or is it Cody? The fact there’s a question mark over that is awesome. Tempers flared, then both guys apologised to one another once they'd calmed down. Zayn might be a little baffled that Rhodes slapped him on the shoulder rather than hugging it out though. Don't be too shocked if that comes up down the line.
Both men came out looking like real human beings who are desperate to make their respective marks on WrestleMania season. Go watch this skit if you only read reports and don't watch full TV episodes. You'll be glad you did.
What did you think about this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out The WORST Moment From Every WWE WrestleMania and 5 Things You Didn't Know Were BANNED In TNA!