10 Comic Book Supervillains Who Should Actually Be Heroes

Are these villains really that bad? ... yeah, kinda.

Poison Ivy DC Comics
DC Comics

We've all heard the adage that every villain is the hero of their own story. But what does this mean?

Well, everyone thinks that they're on the right side of history. And, sometimes, assurance of our own righteousness can lead us down a dark path. That's definitely what happens for most comic book villains.

Sure, sometimes comic villains can be a bit mustache-twirly. The Joker's only real motivation is to sew chaos and create destruction in the world. But, other baddies are a little more complicated than Joker. They have legitimate reasons for the horrible acts they commit.

While many of these wrongdoers may act out in violent and extreme ways, we might agree with their reasons. Some bad guys only want to bring peace to the world. Others only want to save their people from the hate of society.

These are some supervillains who actually might be heroes, if not for a few (or maybe a lot of) bad decisions.

10. Amanda Waller

Amanda Waller
DC Comics

We all know Amanda Waller as a heartless bureaucrat with a dark and paranoid worldview. She's willing to send people to their death without a second thought because she sees her soldiers as expendable. She's even teamed up with the likes of Lex Luthor in pursuit of her own political power.

But, take a look at Waller's backstory, and you'll discover a powerful motivation behind all her actions. Waller was raised by her grandmother but was kicked out at the age of fourteen. She was later married and had two children. However, she resided in a dangerous Chicago Project, and Waller saw her entire family die at criminals' hands.

Waller later, or perhaps in a different timeline, joined the Army. On a special ops mission, her entire team was killed. This is where she began developing the idea for the Suicide Squad. Waller wanted a special ops squadron of entirely expendable people. Who better to send on dangerous missions than a bunch of hardened supercriminals?

Sometime after the death of her children, Waller pursued a degree in political science. She pulled herself out of a life of abject poverty and personal trauma to become a smart and powerful force in Washington, DC. Waller then used her power to end the cycle of violence that plagued her youth.

So, she's basically the female version of Batman when you really stop to think about it. Except she didn't have the benefit of billions of dollars at her disposal.

So... better than Batman??


9. The Leader

Leader Marvel
Marvel Comics

In a former life, the Leader went by the name Samuel Sterns. In this life, Sterns was an unremarkable individual. He dropped out of high school and seemed fated to live the life of an unskilled laborer. Sterns's only dream was to be more like his brother, Phillip, a well-regarded scientist.

When Sterns took a job at a chemical research facility in the Nevada desert, his life turned around. Like Bruce Banner, Sterns was accidentally exposed to a lethal dose of gamma radiation.

Why was he exposed to gamma radiation at a chemical plant, you ask? Who the hell knows? But, this is the Marvel Universe. Naturally, he was imbued with superpowers rather than withering away like a popsicle left in the sun.

Unlike Banner, it was Sterns's mind, not his body, that was supercharged. He became hyper-intelligent and began calling himself Leader. Now, sure once he became Leader he got up to some pretty nefarious business. This includes creating an army of plastic humanoids to take overthrow the US government and capturing Bruce Banner and experimenting on him.

At one point, Leader did, however, operate on The Hulk to save the latter's life. But, for the most part, Leader has remained unredeemable. If maybe, he ever recalled his humble beginnings, the Leader could use his intelligence for good rather than evil.


8. Cheetah 

Cheetah Wonder Woman
DC Comics

Unlike Samuel Sterns, Barbara Anne Minerva did not come from humble beginnings. Quite the opposite, Minerva was a wealthy heiress hailing from somewhere called Nottinghamshire, which just sounds fancy. She was also an archeologist who earned fame as someone who would go to any lengths to recover an artifact.

If this sounds familiar, Minerva has a lot in common with everyone's favorite fictional archeologist, Indiana Jones. For a while, Minerva even seemed like a standup person. While on an expedition, Minerva encountered a tribe amid an ancient ritual.

With the ceremony, the tribe hoped to restore the health of an aging priestess. This priestess was the avatar of the tribe's god, Cheetah. During the ritual, things go wrong, and the village is attacked by outsiders. Minerva actually saves the tribes priestess, Chuma.

The two are locked away in a cave, and this is where Minerva's heroics end. She forces Chuma to perform the ritual on her. This transforms Minerva into Cheetah. When the outsiders return, Cheetah kills them all, which, you have to admit, they kind of had coming. Unfortunately, Cheetah also sacrifices one of her colleagues to perform the ritual, setting up her path of villainy.

But for a few murders, Cheetah had the chance to be a hero on her nemesis Wonder Woman's level.


7. Magog

Kingdom Come Magog Superman
DC Comics/Alex Ross

Magog debuted in the wildly popular Kingdom Come graphic novel. In the story, Magog represented a new generation of metahuman superheroes. These heroes were much harsher with how they dispensed justice. Magog filled in the absences of Superman with the Man of Steel retired from public view.

One of Magog's first acts to gain him notoriety was to publicly execute The Joker. Though he surrenders himself to authorities, he was later acquitted by a jury. As it turns out, the public didn't have much love for the Joker after the Clown Prince murdered the Daily Planet staff.

Magog went on to inspire a generation of violent superheroes. He led an attack on a criminal named Parasite, which sparked a battle in the middle of Kansas. During the campaign, Captain Atom reached critical mass, creating a nuclear explosion. Magog was instantly blamed and vilified for this event.

Traumatized by the incident, Magog gave up his life as a superhero and spent the rest of his days healing the injured on Themyscira.


6. Giganta

Giganta DC
DC Comics

Giganta, or Doria Zuel, is just one of those fun, old-school comic book villains. Whereas newer characters have complicated powers and abilities, Giganta is pretty simple. She can get really, really big.

Zuel can grow to several hundred feet, becoming invulnerable and incredibly strong. In her standard form, Zuel is a brilliant scientist, but her intellect proportionately diminishes when she grows. The bigger she gets, the dumber she gets. Luckily, after DC Rebirth, writers have done away with this silly aspect of her character.

Another aspect of Giganta was refreshed with the New 52 comics. Zuel's backstory was changed to make her a more sympathetic character. In the New 52, Zuel is stricken with a fatal blood disease from childhood. Zuel becomes a doctor owing to her desire to help people. In a desperate attempt to cure her affliction, Zuel injects herself with an untested vaccine.

The unintended aftermath is Zuel's newfound ability to increase in size, but her superpowers also cause her intellect to diminish and fills her with rage.

Before the effects of her vaccine, Giganta was a good and decent person. A doctor! Which makes it all the more confusing that she would turn to a life of crime.


5. Lobo

Lobo DC
DC Comics

Lobo is one of Superman's more colorful rogues. Like Supes, Lobo is the last of his kind, a species called the Czarnians. Known as one of the most feared bounty hunters in the galaxy, Lobo has come to blows with both Superman and the Justice League.

As a bounty hunter, there isn't a bounty that Lobo is above going after if the money is right. In his first encounter with Superman, the two discovered they were evenly matched. A few more tidbits about Lobo can survive in the vacuum of space, is basically immortal, and he's been banned from both heaven and hell.

Because he's a bounty hunter and only motivated by money, Lobo isn't always bad. In fact, he's now mostly presented as an antihero. Recent incarnations of the character saw him as a member of the Suicide Squad, working closely with Amanda Waller.


4. Ras Al Ghul

Ras Al Ghul
DC Comics

Ras Al Ghul's name literally means, "The Demon's Head," so it's going to be hard to make a case for this guy, but here we go. In the current timeline, Ras is around 700 years old and was born to a nomad group in the Arabian desert. The secret to Ras's longevity is his use of the Lazarus Pit.

Early in his life, Ras decides to use his gift of the Lazarus Pit to help rid the world of crime. He amasses enormous amounts of wealth and establishes a group called "The Demon." From that organization arose the League of Assassins. Ras eventually becomes a terrorist determined to rid the world of evil. He studies martial arts, fencing, and becomes adept in science in medicine.

With his righteous cause, immortality, and superhuman ability, Ras seems like a tailor-made hero. Unfortunately, Ras believes that the only way to rid the world of evil was to wipe out all of humanity and start over fresh.

Not precisely heroic means.


3. Deadshot

Deadshot Coat
DC Comics

Deadshot, or Floyd Lawton, is another villain with a tragic backstory. As a child, he had one idol- his older brother, but their mother convinced his brother to murder their abusive father. Lawton's brother agreed but locked Lawton out of the house in a bid to shield him.

Lawton wanted to save his brother from committing murder. He stole a rifle, climbed a tree, and prepared to shoot the gun out of his brother's hand. Fate intervened when the branch he perched on broke. Lawton shot his brother in the head, killing him.

In truth, Deadshot is a bit of a nihilist. He doesn't really care what side of the law he's on. When he first debuted, he tried to replace the Dark Knight as Gotham's premier crimefighter. When that plan failed, he decided to become the king of the Gotham underworld.

Later, he joined the Suicide Squad willingly, stating a desire to die, but not wanting to commit suicide. This was especially true after Lawton's son was killed by a pedophile. Yeah, this guy can't catch a break.

In later years, Deadshot's willingness to die waned a bit when he learned that he had a daughter, Zoe, in Star City. Deadshot is a character who has no real reason to be evil, and for the most part, he's not. But, he's not a hero, he's a hitman for goodness sake. He once tried to kill a senator! He just doesn't care where on the spectrum he falls, but he could certainly use his talents for good.


2. Magneto

Magneto Marvel
Marvel Comics

Magneto was born Max Eisenhardt at the height of Adolf Hitler's persecution of the Jewish people in Europe. After his family fled to Poland, Magneto spent his youth in a Warsaw Ghetto. Eventually, Magneto's entire family was executed, leaving him as their sole survivor. He was sent to the infamous Auschwitz concentration camp. There, he was forced to remove the victim's bodies from the German gas chambers. As far as backstories go, this is about as brutal as you can get.

Magneto's turn to evil isn't that unexpected, and while we may not agree with it, it's easily understood. As a child, Magneto witnessed society as they demonized, and murdered, millions of innocent people. As an adult, he once again saw society demonize mutants. He knew where these politics of demagoguery and division led.

Still, Magneto had the perfect opportunity to turn it all around and bridge the gap between mutantkind and humans. When he ran into and befriended, a young Charles Xavier in a hospital in Isreal, Magneto could have joined Xavier in his crusade for peace. But, that was probably impossible for such a deeply traumatized individual like Max Eisenhardt.


1. Poison Ivy

Poison Ivy DC Comics
DC Comics

The real tragedy of Pamela Lillian Isley is that she has no control over her own villainy. As the daughter of wealthy parents, the Seattle native left for college to study advanced botanical biochemistry. Isley was a brilliant student but was seduced by her professor Dr. Jason Woodrue. For totally inexplicable reasons, Woodrue decided to inject Isley with a plant-based poison. This poison not only had terrible physiological effects on Isley; it also had a damaging impact on her mind.

Still, Isley tried to soldier on and continue college. Yet, as her mind deteriorated, she became the Poison Ivy, we know and love today. Poison Ivy is, first and foremost, an eco-terrorist. As she came to believe that she was the physical embodiment of mother nature, she was increasingly concerned about mankind's terrible influence on the environment.

And with climate change in full swing, you really have to ask yourself? Is Poison Ivy that wrong about us?


Watch Next


DC Quiz: How Well Do You Remember Batman's Villains?

Batman Year One Selina Kyle
Warner Bros.

1. In Frank Miller's Batman Year One We Are Introduced To Selina Kyle Whilst She Is Working As A...

In this post: 
DC Comics
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

John is a teacher and writer living in Texas. He spends far too much time watching Star Trek. Check out more if his work at artofnarrative.com