10 Comics You Must Read Before The Gotham TV Show

Guys, you've got some homework to do before the new series debuts.

McKenzie Gotham Not long after being cast as young James Gordon in the upcoming Fox series Gotham, Ben McKenzie posted the above photo on his Twitter as a portion of his €œhomework€ for the role. There is obviously a large trove of material from which to draw upon when crafting a Batman prequel series, so McKenzie and the other actors and writers involved have their work cut out for them if they want to make Gotham a memorable and lasting show. While a lengthy synopsis was released a few weeks ago, there are still multiple directions the show could take. The first season will establish that direction, and for many comic fans it€™s important that the traditional Batman mythology be recognized early and often. Granted, the show will only last if it forges a new and original path €“ adhering too closely to the comics will only bookend the later seasons, trap the story and limit the ultimate potential. But there are elements of Gordon€™s character that shouldn€™t be ignored, and there are dozens of comic book arcs and graphic novels that Fox should look to during the first season. A brief breakdown of the trades in McKenzie€™s Twitter photo is followed by a few entries speculating on possible sources for Gotham. Again, there are many such sources €“ be sure to name those you hope to see as influences in the comments section below.

10. Year One (1987)

The most obvious source among McKenzie€™s lot is Frank Miller€™s seminal Batman origin tale Year One. Focused as much on James Gordon as on Bruce Wayne, Year One depicts the lengths both men will go to €“ and some they won€™t €“ in order to fight crime in Gotham. A greenhorn as far as €œthe way things work€ is concerned, young Gordon finds Gotham to be a horrible place to raise a family. The politicians are corrupt, the cops are corrupt, and just about everyone seems to want to impede Gordon from doing what he knows is right. There€™s plenty of police station drama here, and characters like Flass will hopefully crop up in the show. Year One features some of the most significant Gordon moments in the history of his character. While the common conception of him is of the grizzled, determined, trenchcoat-wearing commissioner who stands on top of GCPD headquarters flicking the Batsignal on and off, Gordon paid his dues as a detective in his own right. He deals swiftly €“ and awesomely €“ with police corruption in Year One, and it€™s that Gordon we€™re most likely to see in the Gotham series.

9. The Long Halloween/Dark Victory (1996/1999)

This list will actually include more than ten entries, as many of them can be grouped into two-for-one specials. The first such pairing is the Jeph Loeb/Tim Sale mystery The Long Halloween and its direct sequel Dark Victory; both books appear in McKenzie€™s pile of homework, and the influence of both, even at this early stage, is fairly apparent. Christopher Nolan colored his Gotham with a rich underground populated by the likes of Carmine Falcone and Sal Maroni, and Jeph Loeb and Tim Sale were rightfully credited by Nolan and David S. Goyer as the source of characters such as these. The Gotham underground has appeared elsewhere, of course, but perhaps never so vibrantly as in The Long Halloween; Dark Victory continued that trend, and is an excellent book, but The Long Halloween deserves most of the laudation here. The news that Jada Pinkett Smith will be portraying gangster Fish Mooney €“ a character never before seen in Batman comics €“ means that the Gotham series will be creating new characters. Sure, the likes of Maroni and Falcone may show up someday, as the villains of Gotham age and Bruce gets closer and closer to the mantle of the Bat. But even if they don€™t appear in the flesh, their characterizations in The Long Halloween and Dark Victory can provide strong frames for Fish Mooney and other new thugs.

8. Batman: Earth One (2012)

One of the most recent entries in a long, long line of Batman origin tales is the 2012 graphic novel Earth One, written by Geoff Johns and illustrated by Gary Frank. Following the 2010 success of Superman: Earth One, the alternate Batman beginning twists and subverts some of the most basic elements of the more famous origin tales like Miller's Year One. Still, despite many departures from the original canon, Earth One remains true to the Batman mythos at heart. Earth One is probably the most surprising inclusion on the required reading list, but the ways in which it will influence the show are already becoming obvious. The casting of Sean Pertwee as Alfred Pennyworth and the news that the usually stuffy butler will be portrayed as an ex-military soldier seem to have roots in the Geoff Johns story. Alfred is very much a part of Earth One, and the recently-confirmed second volume will likely feature him in a large role as well.

7. Gotham Central (2003-06)

The procedural series Gotham Central rounds out the collection of books in McKenzie's photo. Written by Greg Rucka and Ed Brubaker and illustrated by Michael Lark, the series follows members of the GCPD as they fight crime in the DC Universe's darkest city. Unfortunately, despite being nominated for several major Eisner Awards, the series was a brutal commercial failure. But Gotham Central is a success where it counts - on the artistic side of things - and the storylines are rich enough to provide plenty of material for the writers of Gotham. Well-known GCPD characters, cameo appearances by the likes of Maggie Sawyer, Slam Bradley and Jim Corrigan, and a whole host of fresh characters all crop up in the pages of Gotham Central. Most notably, Batman is largely absent from these storylines. Granted, he exists and is operating around these plots (as is Robin, as are the Teen Titans, etc.), but the GCPD never lose the limelight. They fight famous Batman rogues like Mr. Freeze and the Joker, but they attempt to do so within the confines of the law. This theme should be a major part of Gotham - the necessity of a vigilante who fights outside the law, the effectiveness of fighting from within it, and the gradient of good and evil across the entire Gotham police force.

6. The Black Mirror/Skeleton Cases (2011)

Writer Scott Snyder is currently dominating the New 52 Batman title. The stellar Zero Year is unfolding at a tantalizingly slow pace, and this month's Batman: Eternal looks promising. Before the New 52 initiative Snyder worked on Detective Comics, where he turned out some equally good material, and one of his final arcs put James Gordon at center stage. Collected in the must-have trade paperback The Black Mirror, the titular story is the one that least concerns the GCPD Commissioner - Skeleton Cases, Skeleton Key, and Lost Boys, all of which are beautifully illustrated by Francesco Francavilla, are all about the Gordons. Dick Grayson's Batman hardly makes an appearance until the end, but it's still one of the best stories under the Batman title in recent memory. The sudden, suspicious return of Gordon's son - James Jr. - is the occasion for the drama. While a story like this wouldn't be used as direct inspiration for the early seasons of Gotham, the depths to which the Gordon Family is plumbed are fascinating. Looking to later Batman arcs - even just hinting at a possibility, planting an inauspicious seed for later seasons - would show both a respect for long-term storytelling and a respect for the comics. Let's hope we're that lucky.

5. Gothic (1990)

The first of two entries from the original volume of the Legends of the Dark Knight title, Gothic is one of Grant Morrison's earlier (and better, and less convoluted) Batman storylines. James Gordon doesn't feature much, but Gothic is a good example of how Bruce Wayne can be involved in the Gotham series long before he becomes Batman. When a mysterious killer starts offing mob bosses across Gotham, the mob turns to Batman for help. Through a series of events and flashbacks that only Grant Morrison could manage to wrangle into one cohesive narrative, Bruce Wayne€™s schoolboy years play into the current case - and through that brilliantly complex structure, we get a rare glimpse into Bruce Wayne's innocent years. Plenty of books tell of the years between the death of Bruce's parents and the donning of the cape and cowl - 1989's Secret Origins: The Man Who Falls by Dennis O€™Neil collects and retells the most famous bits. But while Gotham will likely focus here, the casting of David Mazouz as the young Bruce Wayne is interesting on a few levels. It's apparent that the death of the Waynes will be depicted early in the series, but will Bruce disappear after that? If not, Gothic could provide a way to incorporate a pre-training Bruce in an inventive manner.

4. The Court Of Owls (2011-12)

As small compensation for what was probably an indefensible exclusion from the 50 Greatest Batman Comics, Scott Snyder manages to make this list twice with a second appearance for the New 52 arc The Court of Owls. Set well into Bruce Wayne's tenure as the Dark Knight, the plot concerns an ancient, hidden brotherhood operating for centuries behind the scenes of a dark Gotham City. Like The Black Mirror, The Court of Owls is likely too recent and too Batman-centric to serve as a direct inspiration for plot points in the early episodes of the Gotham TV show. Still, the Court arc presents a twofold argument for inclusion on this list. Firstly, the depiction of Gotham City is nothing short of awe-inspiring, and for a location that's been depicted again and again for nearly 75 years, Snyder and artist Greg Capullo do a hell of a job making it feel fresh again. Secondly, and more importantly, The Court of Owls did what every New 52 title should have done: it respected the past while simultaneously being unafraid to mess with it. The Gotham series - and any other live-action or animated adaptations - are essentially setting out to do what the New 52 did, creating fresh stories from existing material. It's certainly a fine line to walk, keeping new fans excited without neglecting old fans (and vice versa). Snyder has shown this to be his major strength, even in later arcs like Zero Year, where he subtly paid homage to Frank Miller time and again. The Court of Owls has flaws, certainly. But the Gotham series would do well do adopt a similar practice of toying with the comic book lore in a respectful way, lest they unleash the wrath of that other hidden brotherhood: The Court of Batman Nerds.

3. Vows (1992)

The second Annual issue of the original Legends of the Dark Knight - the first being the twisted, dreamlike tale Duel - features James Gordon, Sarah Essen, and a surprisingly small amount of actual Caped Crusader. The plot is as simple as they come: old thugs are seeking revenge against Gordon, and they use his family to put the pressure on. It's the relationships between Gordon and the women in his life that drive Vows. Erin Richards has been cast in Gotham as Barbara Kean, who will eventually become Barbara Gordon, but Sarah Essen will appear as well, played by Zabryna Guevara. Essen plays a big role in Miller's Year One, and her role in Vows is possibly her biggest appearance. She shows a strong knowledge of police work, a patient manner with the sometimes-temperamental Gordon, and no small degree of badassery throughout Vows, all of which should be brought to the first live-action portrayal of the character.

2. Gordon€™s Law (1996-97)

Gordon's Law is a four-issue miniseries featuring - you guessed it! - Gordon, who just so happens to lay down the law every now and then. Set firmly in a Gotham watched over by the Bat, Gordon nonetheless shuns the help of the Dark Knight in order to solve a particularly personal case. There are several comic arcs that choose to focus on Gordon instead of Batman, but Gordon's Law is one of the more concise, complete stories. Something like this would make a great multi-episode storyline, and not simply because the mystery makes for compelling drama. Gordon's Law is unoriginal in that it features a healthy dose of corrupt cops and politicians - it's well-known that such positions attract the corrupt in Gotham City. But Gordon's Law features allies, too, and it's one of a surprisingly small handful of Gotham-set stories that features good guys that's aren't costumed vigilantes. Based on the recent casting of the young Penguin and the young Riddler, Gordon's certainly going to need allies.

1. Gordon Of Gotham (1998)

A great, lesser-known source that the writers of Gotham - and you - should look to is the 1998 miniseries Gordon of Gotham. If the title doesn€™t immediately tell you that this comic arc is applicable to a show concerning James Gordon in Gotham City, read on. The story of young Detective Gordon coming to Gotham after political machinations all but force him out of Chicago is told by the older, grayer Gordon as he stands with Batman on the roof of the GCPD Headquarters. The Gotham TV show seems to be rewriting (or omitting) the Chicago stint of Gordon€™s backstory, even though his actions as a detective there are actually an intriguing element of his comic book persona. In any case, plot points and story developments concerning the characterization of young Gordon are the things that the TV show could benefit from. The case itself is relatively simple €“ Gordon learns important lessons about trust in his early policing days, facing a different kind of enemy than the ones he has faced before. Some of Denny O'Neil's writing is really stiff, but some of it absolutely sings. When we discover that the case has reopened like a poorly-treated wound €“ hence Gordon€™s retelling of it to Batman €“ the greatest sections of the four-issue miniseries occur. Gordon asks for Batman€™s help to finally close the case, and what does Batman do? Swoop heroically? Nope €“ he refuses. He recognizes this as another personal case for Gordon, one the Commissioner himself has to put to rest once and for all. Batman barely appears outside that scene, and this is totally Gordon€™s show. If Gotham doesn€™t decide to completely disregard the comics, Gordon of Gotham will likely have a great influence on the characterization of the young detective.

In this post: 
Gotham
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Matt is a writer and musician living in Boston. Read his film reviews at http://motionstatereview.wordpress.com.