10 Comics You Should Re-Read As An Adult
Comics you loved as a kid, but are in urgent need of a fresh perspective.
There are few experiences as transforming to a young mind than reading their first comic book. Whether you started with the big two, Archie, IDW, Dark Horse etc. Everyone remembers their first one. Or at least they remember the first one that made them start really getting into the medium and taking it seriously.
Conversely, there's nothing quite as guaranteed to make you reevaluate your entire personal identity than going back to something you love and finding the spark that it lit in you before is gone. You're older now, more experienced - what wowed you before just doesn't do it for you anymore.
Being a medium primarily made for children, comics are one of the most common examples of going back to something as an adult and not being able to love it quite as much anymore. But they're also the biggest source for going back to something you disregarded or even adored as a child and finding something magical you never knew was there before. Now the thing you loved before means even more to you.
There are tons of ways going back to re-read a comic as an adult can go for you. Not all of them good, but it's always worth doing...
10. The Infinity Gauntlet
Sometimes you need to re-read a comic as an adult in order to reevaluate the quality thereof (and trust me, we'll be getting to those), and sometimes you should go back to it because there's a lot of underlying stuff that you missed beforehand because you were a child and probably assumed "symbolism" was a weird marching band based religion and kept getting weird looks when you went to join.
Oh, that was just me? Alright then.
A prime example of the latter is Infinity Gauntlet, the inspiration behind Avengers Infinity War. Having the movie to compare it to now would be reason enough to go back and re-read it to study the differences and the implications thereof. But there's a ton more to this story that most kids reading it the first time just didn't see.
The story is obviously an exploration of power and its effects on those who wield it, both how it can corrupt us but also how it can give us some much needed perspective. But watching Thanos interact with Lady Death reveals another thematic layer: entitlement, toxic masculinity and the self destructive nature of both.
The story is just as grand and epic as it was when you read it as a kid, but maybe reading it again will provide a deeper understanding and appreciation for this classic event comic.
9. Daredevil Born Again
Another really good story that only gets better when you re-read it as an adult (a rarity among Frank Miller's library, it must be said).
Daredevil Born Again is rightly considered to be the definitive Daredevil story, encapsulating everything that makes the character compelling. Unless you read it in your mid teens - and can quote catholic scripture at a moment's notice - a lot of the subtext likely went over your head.
If you're not looking for the hidden meanings, then Born Again still holds up as a solid superhero/noir storyline about a man having his life torn apart by forces he can't control. But like all great stories, the closer you look, the better the story gets, as the Christian imagery very purposefully placed throughout the book reveals a story of forgiveness, martyrdom, and perseverance in the face of the overwhelming.
Frankly, you should go back and re-read Born Again purely to enjoy it a second time, but what's underneath the action and superhero drama is something that will stick with you for a long time.
8. Final Crisis
One of the most conflicting emotions to have about a comic is confusion. On one hand it's not entertaining you, but in some cases (such as this) you're left wondering how much of that is on you for not having the mental library for understanding the content in front of you.
The majority of people who read Final Crisis the first time had no god damn idea what was going on, completely losing the what's, where's and why's in its journey up its own ass. And we only retain the who's because everyone is wearing primary colors.
However, it IS a Grant Morrison comic, so there is undoubtedly something more going on underneath. Don't ask me what it is, because I don't know. But then, maybe you will. I cannot promise that you'll like or hate it anymore than you already do, but the content of this comic is so fascinatingly obtuse and weirdly written that it demands a re-read.
Maybe one day we'll figure out what Morrison was trying to actually say here. But that day probably ain't anytime soon.
7. Amethyst: Princess Of Gemworld
The younger comic fans among us probably best know princess Amethyst from the currently running Young Justice comics. But slightly older fans know princess Amethyst from when she had her own solo series. While more recent incarnations have pushed for more high fantasy drama, the original was a charmingly fun fantasy series for girls.
Sure it definitely had its moments where the stakes jumped up significantly, but hey, it's a comic book you can get away with slightly more than a kids show so might as well take advantage. Most comic readers at the time (i.e young boys) probably skipped over this one for obvious reasons. But also because DC, like its buddy Marvel, didn't advertise it great because it didn't have Batman.
A good light fantasy series is something that everyone could use in their lives. So while most readers skipped over the original runs of Amethyst, going back to it could prove a treat. Because honestly, them trying to force Amethyst and her world to be all badass is more than a little forced, even if the current version of Amethyst in YJ is great.
6. Spawn
So far we've seen comics that were either good and got better with age, or ones that you probably ignored and should give another try.
Yeah the gravy train stops here.
Not all the comics being covered from here on out are bad, but the way you interpreted them when you were a kid probably was, and a re-read will only do you good. To wit, we have Spawn, the golden boy of the 90's indie scene, the flagship franchise of the original Image lineup, and kinda disappointing when you actually read it today.
Sure guest writers like Neil Gaiman did their best to keep the ship afloat, but at the end of the day, it would come down to Todd McFarland, who was a FAR better business man than writer. Sure the best stories are still classics, but the bad ones form a big canyon between them because most of the issues are bad.
It cannot be taken away from Spawn just what his creation did for the industry. But it's safe to say that the industry has outgrown him.
5. Kick-Ass
Lindsay Ellis could not have been more right when she labeled comic writer Mark Millar as "the patron saint of 13 year old boys". His entire style, from his writing to his tone to the themes he tackles and the way in which he does so, just screams of an immature edgelord. He wants so badly to be Alan Moore, but really, REALLY isn't.
Case in point, look at Kick-Ass. A decently popular indie comic that was quickly overshadowed by a much more successful movie that cut out all of the horrible offensive stuff from the source material, and thus reached a wider audience, leading to exorbitant royalties for Mr. Millar. Because if you're gonna grift anyone, it may as well be Hollywood.
Going back to read Kick-Ass will make you want to throw your teenage self in the shame bin for the rest of time. It's violent, bleak, gleefully offensive to anyone with even a shred of empathy, and all for its own sake rather than trying to prove any kind of point.
4. Civil War
Now that we have the much, MUCH superior movie to compare it to, is there really any argument remaining about the quality of the original Civil War? Sure, arguments can be made for certain tie-ins (like how the Ms. Marvel tie in was the ONLY good part of Civil War 2), and the fact that the superhero accords, which were introduced in this story, DID stick around like they promised for a long ass time is a good feather in its cap.
But apart from that, go back and read this comic again and you find it's just more of Mark Millar's nonsense. The melodrama and obscene violence - now that it's mostly separated from Millar's more offensive proclivities - would be funny, if the tone wasn't so damn dour all the time.
The themes and ideas it introduces are fascinating - they wouldn't have adapted it to the MCU in the first place otherwise - but the comic just doesn't do anything with it that works when you think about it.
The MCU isn't perfect by any means, but going back to re-read this comic for this article made it abundantly clear that the movie removes any need to go back and read this again.
3. The Killing Joke
With the final three, we move on from comics that are better than you remember and comics that are worse, to comics that ARE great, but lots of readers should probably reevaluate what they get out of it. I could put the entire Alan Moore library into one entry, but to keep it streamlined it was kept to this and the last one (you know damn well what #1 is, don't lie).
The Killing Joke is not Alan Moore's best work, by the man's own admission, but it wouldn't have endured for so long if it didn't have its merits. Unfortunately, those merits tend to get overblown by people who read it when they were younger and it blew their damn minds.
The dialogue is superb, the art masterful, and the story iconic, but it doesn't really have much to say beyond "wow, look at these two wack-jobs!" Despite this, though, The Killing Joke is a really great comic. But maybe readers should reevaluate it and ask if this is what they want ALL Batman stories to look and act like.
Much like the next entry...
2. The Dark Knight Returns
If there's a more misunderstood Batman story than The Dark Knight Returns, I haven't heard of it. This has been seen by most Batman fans - not to mention the higher ups at Warner Bros. for the longest time now - as the definitive Batman story and the best work of Frank Miller.
Both of which are untrue as the correct answer to both is obviously Batman Year One, but that's for another time.
The Dark Knight Returns is not meant to be the definitive Batman. Much like Kingdom Come - but to a more severe extent - this is meant to be a cautionary tale of the DC Universe. Batman basically being a fascist, him and Superman being at each other's throats, the general state of the DC Universe in this alternate future - this future could not possibly be anymore dystopian, and yet that angle sometimes gets lost in the spectacle of the comic's grander moments.
A lot of this misunderstanding likely comes from Frank Miller kinda drinking his own kool-aid as the years went on, but a lot of it also comes from the misguided impression fans have made of Batman since. If you read this comic as a kid and loved it, try reading it again. While you'll probably still love it, you'll likely come to a different conclusion about this story than you did the first time.
1. Watchmen
The prime example of a comic book completely misunderstood by the audience that praised it, Watchmen - despite being one of the most universally acclaimed comic books of all time - is often the one most in need of reevaluation by the very people who give it such acclaim. Especially its original audience, who likely read it in their mid-teens.
It's old hat at this point to advise someone to distrust anyone who says Rorschach is their favorite comic book character, but that's because it's true. There is absolutely nothing about Rorschach as a character that should be admired, idealized, or mirrored. Paranoid, arrogant, bigoted even by the casually bigoted standards of the 1980s, Rorschach is a bastard, plain and simple.
Watchmen - as fantastic a comic as it truly is - is not a standard by which other comics should meet. As you can see by casually glancing at the content being put out by DC and Marvel when they were following this mindset in the mid-2000's, such practice leads nowhere pleasant.
Watchmen is as good as everyone says it is, but not in the way many claim it to be. If you read Watchmen when you were younger, you definitely need to give it another go as an adult. Chances are good that there's a lot to this comic you either misunderstood, or missed entirely.
DC Comics Quiz: How Well Do You Know The DC Universe?