10 DC Comics Stories That Changed Everything

More of the same... but different.

Infinite Crisis
DC Comics

With the release of Action Comics #1, National Comics (now DC) inadvertently birthed the superhero genre of comic books, changing funny books forever.

These colorful modern gods would dominate the medium for the rest of the century and beyond. Superheroes are more popular now than they've ever been, with no end to their influence in sight but its been a bumpy ride to get the industry where it is today.

Superman was the first of his kind but he was far from the last. Noticing Big Blue’s success, DC started creating similar characters and even published stories where these new bombastic heroes would meet, essentially creating the DC universe that we’ve come to know and love (most of the time). Since the Man of Steel's introduction, DC Comics has been at the forefront of the comics scene and for better or worse, they are the status quo.

When a big change happens in DC, it alters comics as a whole.

As you can imagine, reading stories about the same characters for the better part of 100 years can get a little stale. When sales start to slump, DC has a tendency to throw new scenarios and characters at the wall to see what sticks, except in this case, us readers are the wall.

Some of these tweaks to continuity have been met with enthusiasm and fanfare while others, well… they didn’t stick so well. Regardless of how they were received, these events changed the status quo, for better or worse.

10. Action Comics #1 (1938)

Action Comics 1 Superman
DC Comics

Action Comics #1, published in 1938, is arguably the most important single issue of a comic book ever written. Regardless of its significance it holds the Guinness record for most valuable comic ever, having sold for $3.2 million at auction in 2014.

Even though Superman is on the cover, his feature shared the book with 10 others, one of them starring Zatanna's dad Zatara.

There's a reason the imagery of Superman lifting the car has been reused widely: it's almost the starting point of the whole Man Of Steel visual vocabulary, and it deserves its place at the foundation of the character's lore.


9. All-Star Comics #3 (1940)

all-star comics 3
DC Comics

All-Star Comics #3 contains the origin of the worlds first superhero team, the Justice Society of America. The formation of the JSA was pivotal not only for inspiring their more popular modern counterpart the Justice League, but for creating the concept of a shared comic book universe.

Before this title, most of the characters on the roster existed completely separate from each other. The seemingly obvious idea of putting a bunch of popular superheroes together in a single narrative had never been attempted before. Not only were these characters meeting for the first time, technically this was a cross company endeavor as All-American Comics and National comics hadn't yet merged to create DC.

The original roster consisted of Doctor Fate, Hourman, the Spectre, the Sandman, the Atom, the Flash, Green Lantern, and Hawkman with Wonder Woman being introduced in the original arcs 6th issue.

The way the arc was structured, each hero would star in their own feature but they were all working toward a common goal, usually coming together in the end. Superman and Batman were also members but enjoyed a "reserve" status. The was due to an interesting editorial policy mandating that any hero currently starring in their own book couldn't be active members.

This policy began the trend of teams having an ever-changing roster with heroes being removed and added. This was also the reason for Wonder Woman's seemingly sexist role as team secretary... doesn't make it feel any less wrong though.


8. Showcase #4 (1956)

showcase 4
DC Comics

There was a steep decline in the popularity of superheroes who weren't Batman and Superman following WWII, leaving most people to view them as a passing fad. Not only that but the industry itself was struggling after the Senate Subcommittee on Juvenile Delinquency held congressional hearings focusing on comics as a cause of deviancy.

During the hearings, expert witness and by all accounts super fun guy Dr. Fredric Wertham said Batman and Robin was “a wish dream of two homosexuals living together" and called Superman a fascist... It was a different time.

The industry was forced to regulate itself by establishing the Comics Code Authority which severely limited writers freedom by restricting the use of adult themes and stories. The tone of comics were forced to change, becoming more lighthearted and family friendly and all of DC's horror and mystery books were cancelled.

In an attempt to revitalize the superhero genre, DC editor Julius Schwartz ordered a story featuring a re-imagined Flash with a new identity and costume be penned. This Flash was Barry Allen, the one most people identify with the persona. He actually adopts the persona of the Flash after reading about his exploits in comics. Flash was meta before meta was a thing.

The Flash story was a surprise hit and its success paved the way for reboots of some of DC's other formerly popular characters. Soon following were stories introducing the modern Green Lantern, Atom, and Hawkman. Barry Allen's origin is traditionally designated as the dawn of the Silver Age of Comics.


7. Flash #123 (1961)

the flash 123 Flash of Two Worlds
DC Comics/Carmine Infantino

In "Flash of Two Worlds" an otherwise innocuous meeting between the new Silver-Age Flash, Barry Allen and his Golden-Age counterpart Jay Garrick, would change the structure of the DCU forever.

Since Barry's introduction, the DCU had been functionally rebooted, with no mention of the Justice Society or any of its founding members. Fans of the original Flash and his fellow WWII era heroes were left to wonder what became of them. Right until this story gave a definitive explanation to their curious absence.

The story itself is rather unremarkable. Barry Allen vibrates his body at such a frequency that he phases through realities to Keystone City, the home of Jay Garrick. Three of Garrick's enemies are committing robberies around the city and the two flashes have to team up to stop them.

The significance of this story isn't in the events themselves but the implications. We learn that the Golden-Age DCU still exists and all of their adventures did happen, just in a universe separate and parallel from the one that was currently being written. In subsequent books the two timelines would be designated Earth-1 (Silver-Age continuity) and Earth-2 (Golden-Age) but they would be far from the only ones.

The book was a hit and heroes found themselves dimension-hopping on a regular basis, meeting alternate versions of themselves and discovering new realities.

While this device gave writers more freedom to play with their characters and environments, canon became more muddled and hard to follow over the next 25 years. Right up till DC devised a brilliant plan that would "fix" it forever.


6. Dark Knight Returns/Watchmen (1986)

Watchmen team
DC Comics

The Modern Age of comics started in 1986 and two stories published by DC are most often cited as the cause. Frank Miller's The Dark Knight Returns and Alan Moore's Watchmen were quite unlike anything that came before, with an adult tone, subject matter and deep subtext. They helped the medium be seen as more than just funny books for kids.

Dark Knight Returns did just that, returned the dark and brooding Golden Age Batman back to the forefront, having never quite lived down the campy nature of the '66 TV series. The story focuses on an older and more battle-worn Bruce being forced to come out of retirement and being a generally grumpy old man.

Released later that year, Watchmen was a refreshing take on superhero books, exploring the genre and introducing deep and flawed characters with mature relationships and ethics. Both of these stories were a breath of fresh air for the industry. Garnering wide critical acclaim, they assisted in legitimizing the graphic novel as an art form.

While their impact is seen as mostly positive and was a shot in the arm for the floundering medium, they've also been pointed to as being responsible for comics' increasingly dark and gritty tone. That may have been unavoidable however, as the comics audience had grown up and clamored for stories that reflected their own maturity.


5. Crisis On Infinite Earths (1985-1986)

Superman Crisis On Infinite Earths
DC Comics

Crisis on Infinite Earths was the first story of its kind. COIE was a massive crossover event promising readers "Worlds will live, worlds will die and nothing will ever be the same". They kept that promise, probably to a greater extent than was ever expected.

Prior to COIE, many of DC's most iconic characters had conflicting origins and backstories, making creating any kind of cohesive greater narrative difficult. A number of alternate universes were created by writers following the inception of Earth-1 and Earth-2 and were considered too convoluted. This was DC's first attempt to "simplify" their continuity and may be the only time they actually succeeded in that aspect.

In COIE, we're introduced to the Anti-Monitor, a cosmic being that wants to effectively erase the earths of the multiverse and replace them with his own. Our heroes (literally all of them) succeed in stopping him but not before Supergirl and Barry Allen give their lives for the cause.

Most of the surviving characters find themselves on a new Earth while Earth-Two Superman, Earth-Two Lois Lane, Earth-Prime Superboy, and Alex Luthor Jr., being the only ones who remember the multiverse as it was, inhabit a pocket "paradise" dimension.

This was the first time the numerous Earths of DC were canonically referred to as the "multiverse" and theoretically would have been the last. The main function of the story was to combine the timelines into one that would become the entire scope of the DCU.

And so it was... for a while.


4. Death And Return Of Superman (1992-1993)

The Death of Superman
DC Comics

The Death of Superman is arguably the most important story arc of the last 25 years. It's left an impact not only on DC, but comic books in general that is felt to this day. When DC announced that they would be killing off the most recognizable superhero ever, and an American icon, it garnered a vast amount of media attention. This wasn't only a big event in the world of comics, it was a big event in the world.

DC editorial created the mindless killing machine Doomsday for the sole purpose of murdering Superman to boost readership. Superman and the grey spiky Hulk clone go toe-to-toe, eventually beating each other to death. After a short mourning period, four substitute supermen were introduced to take his place: Superboy, Cyborg Superman, Eradicator, and Steel.

The Pokemon Go levels of hype quickly dropped though, as many people who purchased the book weren't actually interested in the story. Speculators bought up multiple copies believing it to be a "collectors item" that would eventually skyrocket in price. This would never come to pass, as the market was flooded with copies. You can still find them in nearly any back issue bin.

Many fans who actually were invested in the story felt deceived when Superman was slated to return less than a year later, seeing the Man of Steels as nothing more than a marketing ploy. Due to the backlash, readership fell across the entire industry.

Superman's quick resurrection left death feeling inconsequential in comics. Literally hundreds of characters have died and returned since, removing any permanent impact dying or self-sacrifice once had.


3. Infinite Crisis/Final Crisis (2005-2009)

Shazam Infinite Crisis
DC Comics

Infinite Crisis and Final Crisis are sequels to "Crisis on Infinite Earths" and were conceived for the same reason, to simplify DC's seemingly out of control continuity. The event didn't quite achieve its goal though when compared to Crisis on Infinite Earths. While the effects of COIE lasted for twenty years, the DCU has been in a seemingly continual state of flux since Infinite Crisis.

Infinite Crisis' main antagonist and catalyst is a furious Superboy-Prime, angered by the trend of DC Comics getting progressively darker since his sacrifice in COIE. The story starts proper when, in an infamous splashpage, Superboy-Prime punches reality so hard he breaks it and escapes into main continuity, setting out to destroy the entire multiverse. Seriously.

Final Crisis follows our heroes (again, all of them) as they attempt to defend against Darkseid's invasion of Earth, as he enslaves humanity with the Anti-Life equation. Meanwhile, Flash is messing with the timeline again.

Batman ends up sacrificing himself to defeat Darkseid, only to be brought back to life a year later. Welcome to post-"Death and Return of Superman" comic books, where the stakes are artificially raised and death doesn't matter.

Its ironic that in the act of trying to buck the gritty comics trend, they accidentally started a new one: constant company wide events. Countdown to Infinite Crisis began in 2005, followed directly by Infinite Crisis, 52, Countdown to Final Crisis, and finally Final Crisis ending in 2009. That's four straight years of events with nearly no time in between.


2. Flashpoint/New 52 (2011-2016)

Justice League Flashpoint
DC Comics

In 2011, just two years after Final Crisis, DC editorial was concerned the greater DCU was becoming too bogged down in continuity, again. Using the Flash family's time-hopping hijinks as a catalyst, DC decided to retcon everything to give new readers a jumping-on point, free from all that pesky, intimidating continuity. Again.

With the intention of making characters and their relationships easier to understand, all of DC's heroes' histories were altered. Canon was modified so that it'd only been five years since the beginning of the main DC continuity. Due to this, a lot of pivotal moments and characters were left on the cutting room floor. Except for Batman.

Batman's most defining post-Crisis activities were still considered canon. Except they all took place in the five years that Bruce (and every other character) has been active. That means Bruce has gone through three Robins and a Batgirl, been "broken" by Bane, "died," was replaced by Dick Grayson, and came back to life, all in half a decade. Needless to say, this was a little harder to follow than was intended.

Fans weren't too pleased that the characters they'd invested themselves in for years had all been functionally reset, rendering all their past successes and tragedies inconsequential. It combined or did away with DC's myriad realities into just 52 self-contained timelines, hence The New 52.

DC did their best to try to win readers over with this new direction but unsurprisingly, fanboys weren't very receptive, prompting a compromise and yet another retcon with DC Rebirth.


1. Rebirth (2016-Present)

DC Rebirth
DC Comics

DC's most current soft reset to their canon is Rebirth. It's so current, in fact, that at the time of this article's composition, it's still going on.

The overall fan reception of DC's editorial direction following Flashpoint and into the New-52 was lukewarm at best. Due to this, DC's golden boy Geoff Johns was faced with the daunting task of returning the DCU to its pre-Flashpoint state, while keeping the parts of the New-52 that fans did enjoy.

Rebirth didn't just modify characters and canon, but DC's publication schedule as well. DC's most popular titles (Action Comics, Detective Comics) became bi-weekly, most of their poorer performing books (Secret Six, Omega Men) were cancelled and a few new titles emerged (Super Sons, Superwoman).

Being a universe-wide event that's lasted more than a year at this point, there are just too many reworked plots and histories to cover here. What we do know is that someone is "stealing time" from our heroes in order to weaken them. All of the revamped continuity since Flashpoint seems to be influenced by Dr. Manhattan, of Watchmen fame.

Until recently, Watchmen has been considered a self-contained story existing in its own universe. That doesn't seem to the case anymore though, as the iconic smiley face button stained with The Comedian's blood found its way into the Batcave to be discovered by Bruce and Flash.

All signs point to the near omnipotent Dr. Manhattan playing a large part in the DCU's most recent upset.


In this post: 
DC Comics
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Wes is a video game and comic book enthusiast. You can just call him a nerd.