10 Different Ways Superman Has Been Defeated

The Man of Steel isn't invincible.

Superman is powerful, but he isn€™t invincible. With Henry Cavill€™s Superman set to clash with Ben Affleck€™s Batman next year, people are chattering away about the omnipotent being€™s Achilles heel - Kryptonite - but there are more ways to defeat the Man of Steel than just throwing the glowing green rock in his direction. The powers of Superman are well known - heat vision, flight, superhuman strength, speed, ice cold breath, impenetrable skin and x-ray vision. Being endowed with such powers would make the character a god amongst men, so it is necessary for the publishers at DC to implant weakness and vulnerability into the character, otherwise the stories would be mundane and repetitive. If Superman was infallible then the hero would lose his popularity - nobody wants to read a comic where even the strongest nemesis cannot pose a danger to the titular hero. You want to see a challenge, so without some latent weakness Superman€™s veritable smorgasbord of spin-off material would have fizzled out years ago. This is perhaps best highlighted by The Death Of Superman storyline, which increased sales in the dwindling comic by thousands. Weakness sells, and DC are aware of this. The Kryptonian powerhouse has been beaten many different times by many different people €“ one storyline back in the Eighties saw him beaten by a teenager (check out The Sinbad Contract) while the aforementioned The Death Of Superman gave the comic unprecedented media attention. With this in mind, we count down ten different ways Superman has been defeated.

10. Brute Force And Trauma

Everyone knows this one - even casual comic book readers and non-fans are aware that the monstrosity known as Doomsday beat Superman to a pulp, practically killing him. The beast was born on Krypton, and possessed strength comparable to the Man of Steel. Their battle was an enthralling one, with the final issues of the Superman comic depicting a blow by blow account of how Superman was killed. The issue ended with Superman laying, bruised and bloodied in front of Lois Lane, finding out that he had stopped Doomsday, but amid a great cost - his life. Doomsday didn€™t need an advanced brain, technology or luck to destroy DC€™s flagship character. The monster was pure muscle, with bone-like spikes protruding from his body in order to inflict the maximum damage with every single strike. Superman€™s ultimate loss in this battle was because he was simply inferior to the single minded killing machine. It was all a sales ploy in the end, wasting time until the Lois & Clark TV series could stage a wedding which would occur at the same time as the duo got hitched in the comics. Despite these insincere motives, the storyline has become so iconic that the graphic novel is still one of DC€™s highest sellers, and people who don€™t even care about comics are aware of the plot.

9. Telekinesis

From brawn to brain, Superman has been beaten on both fronts. Doomsday showed that the seemingly impenetrable skin, hardened by Earth€™s yellow sun, could be broken with enough strength, but Manchester Black caused Superman much more damage with nothing more than his mind. Manchester Black had a growth on his brain which gave him telekinetic and telepathic abilities. In a showdown with the Man of Tomorrow, the English villain used these abilities to pinch the blood vessels in Superman€™s brain, causing Superman to exhibit stroke like symptoms. The Man of Steel uses his heat vision to target the part of Black's brain which gives him this power, but the hero was nearly killed by the brainpower of his opponent. Black has further constructed intricate illusions for the powerful Kryptonian, creating a vivid reality where everyone in Clark Kent€™s life, including Lois, had been killed by enemies on behalf of Black. Superman believed this but refused to kill Black, prompting the villain to commit suicide. Even though Superman eventually won the battle in this situation, he was fooled for a long time, contemplating taking Black€™s life as vengeance for the loss of Lois Lane. For a villain to bring Superman to this dark edge takes a lot, so Black€™s telepathic attack on Superman certainly warrants its inclusion here.

8. Kryptonite

It had to be on here, didn€™t it? The radioactive remnants of Superman€™s home planet ended up as his primary weakness, ensuring that even mere mortals could challenge the Kryptonian powerhouse in the right setting. The glowing green rock weakens Superman, while the red variant sees the hero lose his inhibitions. Black kryptonite splits him into a good and an evil version of himself, and the golden variety permanently removes the powers of Kryptonians. Lex Luthor, Batman and Green Arrow have all used this radioactive substance to cripple and defeat the Man of Steel, and it consistently works. It not only sickens the mighty hero, but it causes him to be vulnerable to attacks by humans. The term kryptonite has entered popular language, with the word essentially meaning someone€™s Achilles heel, and it is the most common thorn in Superman€™s side. Although it isn€™t quite the most spectacular way to cripple the Man of Steel.

7. Nuclear Weapons

In Frank Miller€™s seminal work The Dark Knight Returns, Superman is forced to divert a Russian nuclear warhead, transforming the typically muscled hero into a skeletal frame of his former self. In the aftermath of this devastation Superman somehow absorbs the trapped sunlight from a nearby plant, regenerating himself a teeny bit at a time, allowing him to return to Gotham strong enough to battle the Kryptonite-armoured might of Batman. The comic later saw a one armed Oliver Queen shoot Superman with a Kryptonite arrow, allowing Batman to make his mark, showing Superman to be a fallible hero - he was beaten by Batman, Green Arrow and a nuclear warhead. Next year€™s Batman V Superman is set to draw heavily from this spectacular piece of comic book history, so it will be interesting to see how much of this makes it onto screen. DC don€™t want their flagship character to look weak, but after the destruction seen in Man Of Steel they need to show that Earth has a response to its alien visitor.

6. Being Deprived Of Sunlight

Superman€™s powers are given to him by the yellow sun of Earth; his home planet of Krypton had a red sun, and there his people had human-like qualities. So, if Krypton€™s last son is deprived of sunlight, he loses his abilities. Like in the Flashpoint storyline, where the government kept the alien visitor isolated underground, making him a weak and feeble boy until he was given access to the sun. The fact that trapping Superman in a dark room for a long period of time will bring him to the same level as ordinary humans is a key weakness - sure, it is hard to keep Superman subdued in a subterranean cavern, but if this can be accomplished then the character is as good as dead. Superman€™s dependency on sunlight means that he is powerful on earth, but in other environments - alien worlds and deep space - his powers are unreliable and he is easily defeated. Although in the Flashpoint storyline the government had kept the Kryptonian underground since he arrived on Earth, the fact that Superman requires a yellow sun makes him more vulnerable than you can possible imagine. This doesn€™t mean that a dark room will defeat him, but it means that with enough thought and planning, villains and governments have managed to exploit this weakness.

5. Magic

One of the stranger inclusions on this list of Superman€™s weaknesses, this has seen Superman fattened up, misshapened and turned into a crime fighting gorilla throughout his long history. Despite his apparent invulnerabilities, Superman is helpless against magic - he is as vulnerable as the rest of us to its torment. One of Kal-El€™s most irritating and consistent foes is the magical Mr Mxyzptlk - a villain from the 5th dimension who can only be defeated by tricking him into saying his own name backwards. Although the character is usually a slightly amusing one, Alan Moore reinvented him into a twisted villain in the Whatever Happened To The Man Of Tomorrow storyline. He normally only troubles the Man of Steel with trivial issues, but in this story the magical being is responsible for nightmarish horrors that deeply impacts Superman. In one of Mxzyptlk€™s strange experiments he gives the Joker some of his magical powers, leading to a new reality. In this newly formed reality Superman is imprisoned in Arkham Asylum by Bizzaro, and only Batman was able to end the chaos. In both of these stories Superman was powerless to stop atrocities from happening, requiring outside help to help limit the damage being inflicted on the DC universe.

4. Psychological Distress

There€™s a reason Superman keeps his identity private €“ he doesn€™t want to risk those dearest to him. Some of the darkest hours for the Man of Steel have been caused by the loss of, or perceived death of, his loved ones. Under the influence of Manchester Black, the possibility of seeing his beloved Lois Lane dead nearly pushed him to break one of his key rules - he toyed with the possibility of killing Black in vengeance. In other cases Superman has been unable to deal with issues he cannot stop - he is not all powerful, and some events are beyond his control. The fact that Kal-El has been bestowed with such amazing gifts, yet Clark Kent€™s associates are fallible and mortal humans, means that Superman has to cope with the very real sense of loss. The death of Jonathon Kent is one of the best examples, where a young Clark Kent must come to terms with the knowledge that he cannot control everything. This humanises the character, but also shows how much his abilities trouble him - in the wake of the Doomsday War, Superman struggled to come to terms with such a loss of life, and there have been tonnes of times when the thought of losing Lois Lane nearly destroyed the hero.

3. Red Sun Radiation

As said earlier, Superman is given his powers from Earth€™s yellow sun, but under a red sun radiation Superman is reverted to mortal stature. In Superman: Red Son, a three issue storyline exploring what would have happened had the infant Kal-El landed in the Soviet Union, President Lex Luthor teams up with Batman to trap Supes in a radiation chamber designed to sap the hero€™s powers. Superman would have been beaten to a pulp had Wonder Woman not freed him from his confinement. The Nineties animated Superman series explored this vulnerability as well, with Brainiac using a red sun lamp to inhibit the Man of Tomorrow€™s powers and keep him trapped in his collection. Although the red sun doesn€™t neccasarily defeat Superman, it enables pretty much anyone to attack him as if he were a weak human being. This makes it one of the most innovative and interesting ways that Superman has been bested in comics and on TV.

2. High Pitched Frequencies

Man Of Steel showed how a young Clark Kent struggled to hone his newfound ability to hear nearly everything, and in the climactic battle with Zod the villain was caught off guard through this peculiar power. Superman€™s enhanced hearing enables him to always hear Lois Lane€™s constant screams, and help him to find incoming police sirens, but they are also one of the key weaknesses. Like any of us, loud noises can weaken the hero. In one instance, Wonder Woman hit Superman€™s ears with enough force to cripple the character, paving the way for her to beat him with her superhuman strength. Loud noises aren€™t the sole way to defeat Superman, but they provide a crucial stepping stone on the way to pummelling the Man of Steel. Seeing as Man Of Steel showed that Kryptonians are susceptible to this form of attack, this method could easily make appearance in Dawn Of Justice - maybe Batman can produce a sonar like device to incapacitate Henry Cavill€™s Superman so that the Dark Knight can have some semblance of a chance in the titular fight.

1. Wonder Woman€™s Sword

DC€™s Amazonian princess has crippled the Man of Steel by attacking his hearing, but she also possesses one of the few objects in the DC universe which can penetrate Superman€™s ultra hard skin - her sword. The weapon was forged by the god Hephaestus, and has been shown to be so razor sharp that it can cut electrons from atoms. Wielding this weapon makes Wonder Woman one of the biggest potential threats to the Man of Steel. It's a good thing that she typically aligns herself with him, although it has been rumoured that in the upcoming Dawn Of Justice Gal Gadot will be teaming up with Batman to fight the dangerous alien threat. Seeing as DC€™s movie iteration of Wonder Woman is set to follow the New 52 version, it is likely that this sword could be pivotal to the movie. Although the title is Batman V Superman, Wonder Woman is probably the biggest threat to the Man of Steel. What did you think? Did we miss anything out? How would you like to see the Man of Tomorrow beaten in Batman V Superman? Let us know in the comments section below!

In this post: 
Superman
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A 21 year old History graduate looking for someone to listen to his ramblings. Lover of comic books, movies and all other superhero related things. Published in The Independent, always looking for interesting things to write about...Follow me on Twitter at @samclements1993, and check out my blog: http://samuelclements.wordpress.com/