10 Iconic Comic Book Moments (That Are Secretly Terrible)

The Killing Joke is one of Batman's most revered stories, but it commits a terrible comics cliche.

The Killing Joke Barbara Gordon
DC Comics / Brian Bolland

There are some comic book storylines that are so memorable, they are chiseled in our minds forever. Readers will never forget when Jean Grey turned into the Dark Phoenix. Witnessing Barry Allen give up his life to save reality was heart-wrenching. Seeing Spider-Man merge with the Venom symbiote was a huge moment, not just for the wall-crawler, but for the reader as well.

These scenes may stand out because they were the turning point in the story, permanently changed the character's dynamic, or because they led to the death of a major hero or villain.

These moments have become so embedded into the world of comic books, it feels blasphemous to criticise them. However, nothing is beyond scrutiny. Just because a story is iconic, well-drawn, or had a lasting impact doesn't mean it's perfect. Some tales seemed fantastic at first but when you look at it again with a fresh set of eyes, you may notice some flaws you didn't see the first time.

To criticise these stories isn't to suggest they aren't great. But it is possible that that some of these moments received far more praise than they deserved.

10. Jean-Paul Valley Becoming Batman - Knightfall

Azrael Batman
DC Comics

Bane has proven time and time again to be one of Batman's smartest and most intimidating adversaries. When he snapped Bats' spine in the Knightfall storyline, Bane became the stuff of legend in the supervillain community.

Bruce Wayne's injury was so severe, he took a sabbatical for several months to recover. Because Gotham needed a Batman, many readers assumed Bruce Wayne's protege, Dick Grayson, would step up and finally don the cowl.

Instead, Bruce passed the mantle to Azrael AKA Jean-Paul Valley. Even though Azrael was an ally to the Bat Family at this point, he was a brainwashed assassin for most of his life. Considering the Dark Knight had only known him for several months and Azrael tried to kill him upon their first encounter, this decision sounded ridiculous.

Why didn't he choose Dick Grayson? Heck, Alfred would've been a better choice! Bruce tried to justify his actions, saying he needed to give Azrael purpose to stop him from reverting to his murderous tendencies.

And what did Azrael do? Kill people as Batman!

While no one can deny Az-Bats is an iconic part of the character's history, Knigthfall probably should've been the vehicle for the former Robin to succeed his mentor.


9. The Death Of The Heroes - The Infinity Gauntlet

Infinity Gauntlet
Marvel Comics

The Infinity Gauntlet is the most famous Marvel crossover ever, more so after its story was incorporated into Avengers: Infinity War. In this six-parter, Thanos has achieved near-godhood after obtaining the six Infinity Gems. After wiping out half of all life in the universe, Adam Warlock leads the heroes of Earth to undo the Mad Titan's actions.

At the time, readers had never seen iconic superheroes being defeated so easily. Hulk and Drax were taken out with a single slap. Wolverine's unbreakable skeleton was turned to rubber. Captain America's "indestructible" shield was destroyed. Thor, Vision, Cyclops, Iron Man, and many others were effortlessly killed.

Witnessing the heroes die should be emotional but it loses its impact when every evil action Thanos committed is reversed at the end of the story. In hindsight, the heroes suffered little consequences or sacrifices, which is anticlimactic considering they faced the biggest threat the universe has ever witnessed.

Obviously, the deaths were reversed in the MCU adaptation but several superheroes did bite the dust for good. Although the deaths in The Infinity Gauntlet were always going to be undone, it would have been more effective if one or two stayed buried longer than two issues.


8. X-Men #1 Becomes The Best Selling Comic Of All Time - X-Men

X Men 1 Jim Lee
Marvel Comics

In 1991, Marvel launched a separate X-Men series alongside Uncanny X-Men called X-Men Vol. 2. The plot of the first issue revolved around Magneto building a base in Earth's orbit to serve as a haven for mutantkind.

Despite having a pretty standard story, X-Men Vol. 2 #1 is the most successful comic issue ever, selling 8.1 million copies. The main reason people were buying it wasn't just to read the latest X-Men story but purely because it was the first issue of a renowned property. At the time, it was common knowledge that the first issue of classic comics were being sold for a fortune. Consumers snatched up X-Men Vol. 2 #1, believing it would be worth millions.

When publishers saw the success of this relaunch, every company launched new comics and slapped a big fat #1 on the cover, knowing it would drive up sales. However, many consumers were buying these comics, having no intention of reading any follow-up issues. As a result, sales dried up in most series from #2 onwards, causing countless comics to be cancelled.

X-Men Vol. 2 #1 may not be a bad story in its own right but it nearly single-handedly led to the speculator boom and bust of the 1990s, and Marvel's own demise.


7. Doomsday Kills Superman - The Death Of Superman

Death of Superman
DC Comics

Let's be honest. The Death of Superman was a gimmicky idea since it was only written to boost flagging sales. Nevertheless, it was still pretty powerful to watch the world's most famous superhero meet his maker.

But if DC Comics made the bold decision to snuff out Supes (at least for a while), why not have him killed off by one of his more iconic villains like Zod or Brainiac? How about writing a story where the Man of Steel's rogue gallery team up to to defeat him once and for all? Wouldn't it have made more sense if it was Superman's arch-nemesis, Lex Luthor, to be the one who did the deed?

Instead, the spit-curled superhero was murdered by a mindless monster whose dialogue boiled down to "ARRGGHHH!"

Now, that's not suggesting Doomsday is a bad character. We discovered years later that this muscle-bound brute is Kryptonian himself and so, is instinctively drawn to Superman. That's a fantastic origin... but it's never mentioned in this story. At the time, we knew nothing about Doomsday. It would've left a much bigger impact to watch a villain with a history and relationship with the Man of Steel take him down - never mind the fact the character would return shortly after.


6. The Decimation - House Of M

M-Day No More Mutants Decimation X-Men
Marvel Comics

In House of M, Scarlet Witch uses her reality-warping powers to create a world where mutants live in relative peace. Although things start off fine, Scarlet Witch's mental instability causes the reality she created to gradually crumble.

Realising that she had been playing god, she utters the infamous words, "No more mutants", reverting the world back to normal. However, there is one major difference; 99.99% of all mutants have lost their powers. Not only that, the X-gene that triggers human mutation no longer exists. This means that new mutants can't be born, seemingly condemning them to extinction.

This is a great idea since we get to watch X-Men like Beast, Kitty Pryde, and Wolverine try to find a way to reignite their kind without the aid of their abilities.

At least... that's what you'd think would happen. This premise loses its effectt since nearly every mainstream mutant kept their powers. Wolverine, Mystique, X-23, Cable, Colossus, and dozens more weren't affected by Scarlet Witch's spell.

Even though The Decimation is meant to be the most devastating thing to happen to mutantkind, there are a lot of X-Men stories during this era where the reader wouldn't notice mutant numbers have dwindled to near-extinction.


5. Wonder Woman Kills Maxwell Lord - Infinite Crisis

Wonder Woman Kills Max Lord
DC Comics

When Superman suddenly started attacking his teammates, the heroes of Earth learned he was being controlled by psychic and former Justice League manager, Maxwell Lord. Realising that Lord could destroy Superman's reputation with his abilities, Wonder Woman tracked him down and snapped his neck. When the footage of Wonder Woman murdering Lord leaked, the world turned on Diana and superheroes in general.

Even though this story arc was created to build as much tension as possible for the upcoming event, Infinite Crisis, it doesn't make any sense. First off, Wonder Woman doesn't try to absolve herself. She doesn't bother to appear on the news for two minutes to explain that Max Lord was controlling Superman for his own agenda.

Also, Wonder Woman's actions seem highly out of character since she doesn't kill humans. Worse still, she doesn't act guilty and insists her actions were justified.

Furthermore, WHY is Maxwell Lord a villain all of a sudden? He may have been depicted as an amoral businessman for years but he was far from an outright baddie. Turning a smarmy entrepreneur into a genocidal murderer seemed downright absurd and insulting to long-time fans of the character.


4. Norman Osborn Is The Green Goblin - Amazing Spider-Man #39

Norman Osborn Green Goblin Reveal
Marvel Comics

When the Green Goblin first graced the pages of Marvel in Amazing Spider-Man #14 in 1964, readers were immediately intrigued by the masked madman's true identity. After two years of speculation, Spider-Man's arch-nemesis finally pulled off his hooded mask to reveal he was none other than Norman Osborn.

In hindsight, you probably assume it was a huge revelation that this supervillain was actually the father of Peter Parker's best friend, Harry Osborn. In reality, most readers said, "Wait, who?"

This big reveal wasn't the big twist you would expect. In fact, it was quite anti-climatic. Do you know why? Because Norman wasn't seen or named until TWO issues before the Goblin was unmasked! So when the pumpkin-hurling supervillain debuted, readers didn't know Norman existed!

This reveal is also considered a big moment because Norman was the first supervillain to learn of Spider-Man's secret identity. But because he conveniently suffered amnesia in the following issue, he immeditely forgot Peter's masked persona as well as his own. Even though Norman has taken centre stage in some of the most influential Spidey stories, his introduction was mishandled.


3. Iron Man Goes Evil - Civil War

Civil War Comic
Marvel Comics/Steve McNiven

It's fascinating to watch superheroes being forced to make a decision that is less than noble. The film, Captain America: Civil War, captured this idea perfectly. Even though Cap and Iron Man were at odds with one another, they both had compelling arguments why they were in the right.

But that's not the case with the comic that inspired the movie. After vigilantism is criminalised in the opening act of the story, many superheroes refuse to cooperate with the world's governments. Iron Man responds by arresting his comrades and transporting them to an interdimensional prison without trial. He admits to Peter Parker that they'll never be released unless they agree to play ball.

Not only that, he allows supervillains to work for him, which results in the death of the superhero, Goliath. After watching the founding Avenger turning on his friends, it wasn't long before readers compared Shellhead to a dictator.

This character arc was so reviled, the Marvel writers attempted to absolve Iron Man of his actions by writing a story where he lost his memory and couldn't remember anything that occurred during the Civil War.


2. The Fans Vote To Kill Jason Todd - A Death In The Family

Batman Jason Todd Robin Death in the Family
DC Comics

The original Robin, Dick Grayson, is one of the most beloved superheroes of all time. Sadly, readers weren't too keen on his successor, Jason Todd, since he came across as brash, immature, and cocky.

Realising that keeping this Robin in the series could lead to losing sales, the bigwigs at DC Comics decided to put Jason's fate to a vote. The company held a telephone poll to determine whether the Boy Wonder would live or die in an upcoming story. After receiving just enough votes in favour of Jason's demise, DC Comics had the character murdered by the Joker in 1988's A Death in the Family.

Here's the problem; why did DC have to kill him off? When a character isn't popular, they simply stop appearing in comics. Jason was a child! Why does he have to die? Not only that, why did he have to be slaughtered in such a brutal manner? Did readers have to watch the Joker smash a boy's skull in over and over with a crowbar before blowing him up?

Also, the fact that the Joker escapes justice due to diplomatic immunity after becoming the Iranian ambassador is so silly, it undercuts Jason's tragic passing.


1. Barbara Gordon Gets Paralysed - The Killing Joke

The Killing Joke Barbara Gordon
DC Comics / Brian Bolland

Even though Batman: The Killing Joke delves into the Joker's origins, the defining scene is when the grinning menace shoots Barbara Gordon through the spine, paralysing her. The Joker has committed far worse act over the years but this moment stands out since Babs was left confined to a wheelchair, forcing her to retire as Batgirl for 20 years.

Because Babs was a fan-favourite, readers were vexed this incident ended her career as a superheroine. However, it did allow Babs to reinvent herself as the world-class hacker and master informant, Oracle.

For years, she helped the Batman Family by building intel and formed her own team, the Birds of Prey. This drastic decision redefined the character since she became one of the first mainstream disabled heroes in DC Comics.

But that doesn't mean The Killing Joke is off the hook. After Babs is shot, the Joker undresses her and takes photos of her semi-dressed body. Even though Batman's nemesis is pretty screwed up, sexual humiliation doesn't feel like his MO. The moment seems to add nothing to the scene and came off as tacky and mean-spirited. Even the author, Alan Moore, admitted inserting this moment was a mistake.


Watch Next


You'll Never Be Able To Name All Of These Batman Villains!

hugo strange
DC Comics

1. Who Is This?

Contributor

James Egan has been with Whatculture for five years and prominently works on Horror, Film, and Video Games. He's written over 80 books including 1000 Facts about Horror Movies Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about The Greatest Films Ever Made Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about Video Games Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts About James Bond 1000 Facts About TV Shows