10 Most Inappropriate Supergirl Storylines
The Last Daughter of Krypton hasn't always had the best run in comics over the years...
Throughout her 60-plus years in comics, Kara Zor-El has a storied history that has set her apart from her well-known cousin. This has enabled her to be a captivating character in her own right and not be overshadowed by Superman in the process. That said, any sizable comics tenure is bound to have less than stellar moments in it, and the Maid of Might is not immune to this.
Just like Superman, Supergirl’s adventures on Earth and beyond have taken her to weird places (literally and figuratively), and these experiences, for better or worse, have come to define her across different continuities. Therefore, there are moments that either fell flat or made readers cringe and wonder what DC has against the Last Daughter of Krypton.
While a good chunk of questionable tales featuring Kara come from the Silver Age, there are some early and recent Modern Age stories that were done in poor taste regardless of intention (it’s unlikely that some of these goals were noble in any way).
From brief but unsettling romances with super-powered animals, to cousins getting too close for comfort, and neglected orphans, it is a wonder that Kara Zor-El has been able to endure across six decades.
10. The Socialite Of Steel
Admittedly, this entry is nowhere as atrocious as some of the others on this list but it is still a laughably bad period in the Girl of Steel's lengthy career. It is doubly baffling when you consider that Wonder Woman of all people accompanied Kara on her desire to be rich and famous.
In the aptly(?)-titled "Revenge of The Super-Chicks", Kara saves a popular actress from certain doom and is instantly enamoured with the attention the public figure received. This convinces her that the life of a superhero is not what she wants, and Kara proceeds to quit being a superhero and become a debutante in Paris.
After failing to bring his cousin back to her senses, Superman enlists Wonder Woman's help but the Amazon is just as awestruck by the glamour of fame and fortune. This eventually stops when the superpowered duo realize that their responsibilities cannot be eschewed in favour of being socialities.
The story was published in 1965 and it shows in its absurd sensibilities. Kara and Diana come across as being too easily swayed by frivolous affairs and Superman does not fare any better, with the Man of Steel being smug in a way that you would only find in DC's Silver Age of comics.
9. Meet Kara Zor-El, Member Of The Red Lantern Corps
The New 52 can be best summed up as DC's creative and editorial teams trying their best to modernize the company's sprawling cast and stories. This endeavour was a very mixed bag, and one of the many reasons why this was the case was the time Kara became a member of the villainous Red Lantern Corps.
Before becoming a member of the rage-fuelled ring bearers, this version of Kara felt increasingly alienated from her adopted homeworld and, after an encounter with Lobo which drove this point home, the Kryptonian exploded in a fit of ferocious anger.
This attracted a Red Power Ring to her and she eventually joined the Red Lantern Corps (which was under Guy Gardner's leadership at the time).
Gardner had hoped to exploit Kara's power in his fight against Atrocitus (the Corps' former leader) but the Maid of Might was not too keen on being part of an intra-community conflict filled with anger-driven criminals. She eventually left the Corps after an encounter with the Worldkiller, a Kryptonian biological weapon.
While this story helped flesh out Kara's internal struggles, it is a shame it took her joining the Red Lantern Corps of all groups to do so.
8. Supergirl Was Once Married To Jimmy Olsen... Because Reasons
The Silver Age is best described as DC's awkward teen years that were filled with unusual creative choices and an unashamed embrace of ridiculous comic tropes. This is best exemplified in Superman's Pal, Jimmy Olsen. The wacky comic run endured for a staggering 20 years and this tenure saw everyone's favourite Daily Planet photographer get up to a multitude of shenanigans with his Superfriend.
One such misadventure saw Jimmy get married to Kara (who was suffering from Red Kryptonite-induced amnesia), or rather got married to her alter-ego, Linda Danvers. Despite having the power to stop this matrimonial sham, Superman opts to stand aside because he believed that the pair were happy together.
This would be fine and dandy if it were not for the fact that Jimmy had accidentally exposed his bride to the Red-K in the first place. It did not help matters that the couple were teenagers who barely knew each other at the time.
Eventually, Kara regains her memories and tells Jimmy the truth about her origins. Fortunately, most of these stories were standalone in nature and this spared readers at the time from seeing a teenaged marriage play out in their comics.
7. The Peculiar Romance Between Matrix Supergirl And Lex Luthor
Superhero/villain romances are not that common in the medium, but they do happen from time to time. From Batman and Catwoman, to Spider-Man and Black Cat, some crimefighters are able to have compelling and healthy relationships with their foes.
Unfortunately for comics readers in the '90s, that was decidedly not the case with the Matrix version of Supergirl and longtime Superman foe, Lex Luthor. After leaving her home universe following its destruction, Matrix settled on Earth and immediately got the attention of Lex Luthor Jr. (who was just the usual Lex inhabiting a younger, much hairier clone's body).
It was only a matter of time before the shapeshifting being and villainous billionaire fell for each other, much to Superman's ire. The Metropolis Marvel tried to convince Matrix that her newfound romance was an awful idea, but his pleas fell on deaf ears.
Naturally, Kal's concerns proved to be right once it was revealed that Lex was harvesting Matrix's genetic material for his own nefarious goals. This expectedly angered the super-being and she left Luthor before their unusual romance could continue.
6. Clark Kent Is An Awful Cousin
As mentioned before, the Silver Age saw different characters behave in the most peculiar manner possible and everyone's favourite Kryptonian was not exempt from this. Silver Age Superman was far from the paragon of justice we know him as, and in most instances came off as unlikable and judgemental.
This can be seen in his treatment of Kara shortly after she landed on Earth. One would expect the older, more adjusted to Earth Superman to guide his newly arrived cousin and help her get accustomed to her new planet's customs.
Unfortunately for Kara, the Silver Age version of her cousin was more interested in dumping her in Midvale Orphanage shortly after her arrival. He did this so that she would have a place to lay low until she could fully master her powers.
It does not take a sociologist to notice that this is extremely selfish (and ironic) thinking on Clark's part, as well as reckless due to the fact that he left Kara essentially unsupervised in a particularly sensitive time in her life. The fact that the duo remained close till Crisis on Infinite Earths is confusing to say the least.
5. Kara's Questionable Taste In Romantic Partners
Sticking to the absolute fever dream that was comics in the mid 20th century, Supergirl (just like her cousin) found herself in a plethora of weird situations, some more harmless than others. Unfortunately, her time with Comet the Super-horse was far from eccentric but ultimately palatable fun.
Most people often have tight, unshakeable bonds with their pets but Kara and her superpowered equine friend took things to the next, cringe-inducing level. It turns out that Comet was no ordinary horse but was once a centaur named Biron who was granted the ability to turn into a human once a comet passes through the solar system.
Convoluted origins aside, while in human form he took on the identity of Bill Starr, a rodeo trick-rider, and during this time, he and Supergirl had a brief romance where she was completely unaware of her partner's true identity.
DC would later repeat this awful decision (down to hiding Comet's true nature) when they decided to romantically link up the super-powered horse and Lois Lane in her own (just as weird) comic run.
4. Andy Jones's Disheartening Life
The Linda Danvers version of Supergirl was not quite as strange as her predecessor but that does not mean that she did not find herself in unsavoury situations. Some of these predicaments stemmed from the fact that the heroine's double life meant that some of her connections took a turn for the worse.
The latter issue was the case for Danvers's friendship with Andrea Martinez in the Supergirl's Peter David run. Martinez was a lesbian explorer who merged with the angelic Comet/Andrew Jones (it is a long story) and used her new form to find success and eventually get close to Linda. Unfortunately the latter did not reciprocate Martinez's feelings and they drifted apart.
While the deception is iffy, the comic run was lauded for its attempt at LGBTQ representation, even winning a GLAAD award for the landmark moment. This is nice and all, but it also ignores how Martinez/Jones was captured by the angel Blithe (who she ended up becoming romantically linked with) and tortured for multiple issues in order to get at Supergirl.
This was following another run where Jones endured torture at the hands of an unknown assailant who made her relive her worst life experiences. Representation in media is important but the way Andy as a character was handled was dismal to say the least.
3. The Time When Supergirl Was A Figment Of Jimmy Olsen's Imagination
As mentioned before, Jimmy Olsen's (mis)adventures with the Last Son of Krypton in the Silver Age essentially served as psychedelic trips, and one of these odd excursions to led Supergirl's first appearance in comics.
Now, this was not the Kara Zor-El that readers would later meet, but was rather a Kryptonian borne out of a wish Olsen spoke into existence through the power of a magical totem. His intent was to give his super-powered pal a partner on his level, but this was far from the case. 'Super-girl', as she came to be known, was a hindrance to Superman while he was engaged in his heroic efforts, and the powerhouse pair did not get along.
The walking wish got a chance to shine when she saved Superman from a particularly nasty case of Kryptonite poisoning. This sadly proved to be her undoing as she was just as vulnerable to the extraterrestrial mineral as her counterpart was, but lacked his ability to recover from it. Ultimately, Super-girl begged for Jimmy to end her pain and he did so by wishing her out of existence.
At the end of the day, this story was a litmus test by DC to see how readers would react to Superman getting a female counterpart. That however, does not explain why she was reduced to a faux romantic interest and nuisance rather than a compelling character worthy of her self-contained stories.
2. The Super-Cousins Got A Bit Too Close For Comfort Sometimes
Being a civilization located countless lightyears away, Krypton was bound to have customs that humans would have found completely alien to them as far as appropriateness and practicality were concerned.
Fortunately, incest is something Earth and the dead alien planet both considered taboo, but this has not stopped DC's writers to bring together their most famous cousin pairing over the years. One Silver Age story saw Kara trying to hook up Clark with various women since his relationship with Lois was going nowhere.
After those efforts failed, Kal told his younger cousin that he would have wanted to be with her if it were not for "Kryptonian incest laws". This meant that Superman was essentially pining for his underage relative and was only stopped by a dead planet's rules rather than his own moral standards.
To add to the ick factor of this one-off tale, Superman settles for a woman who is, for all intents and purposes, an older version of Kara.
1. Ariella Kent's Offputting Parentage
While it was bad enough that DC tried to ship their most famous cousins together, it is downright despicable that they would try it again, and give the Kryptonian family members a daughter no less.
The super-couple in question each hailed from different universes (Superman of Earth-1 and Linda Danvers/Matrix Supergirl of New Earth) and were not technically related, this still does not absolve their relationship and family of its revolting nature, especially when one considers who Superman and Supergirl are to each other.
After the Kara of Earth-1 met her untimely demise, Matrix took on her place and fought alongside the Kal-El of this timeline for a number of years before he revealed that he always knew that she was not a native of his universe. Furthermore, he expressed his love for her and she reciprocated in kind, eventually marrying and having a child called Ariella.
Not long after, the Spectre emerged in the alternate world and took Linda back to her reality and Ariella was left to wander the universe, all the while posing a threat to it due to her incredible powers.
As mentioned before, Kal-El and Linda are not blood relatives but it is a bit disconcerting to see DC try and find loopholes that would create stories where Superman and Supergirl are an item.