10 Times Comic Book Heroes Became Villains (In A Big Way)
When Marvel and DC decided that being a good guy wasn't nearly badass enough.
Do you remember the days when comic books were all about fairly one dimensional heroes fighting goofy bad guys?
Probably not, as most readers (and probably most of you reading this) probably picked up their first comic when characters would spring out of the pages with the prefix of 'super' being as clear to see as it was colourful.
Heroes could move mountains with their minds, beat up legions of enemies with ease and even eat a whole bunch of chillies without shedding a tear. Comic book characters were all essentially gods, instead of just do-gooders wearing spandex. This sense of the extreme was often pushed when it came to their morality too, which is why it’s interesting to see stories where the lines become blurred.
This includes times like the original Civil War seeing Iron Man resort to more and more villainous acts, such as being okay with super baddies hunting down old super buddies and locking captured foes in an other-dimensional prison.
With that in mind here are 10 times that comic book heroes became villains, in a pretty big way.
10. Superman: Injustice
Injustice was the result of DC and NetherRealm Studios getting round a table and asking two questions; one was “how can we get the taste of Mortal Kombat vs DC out of audience’s mouths?” and the other was “how can we justify Superman fighting Batman?” The answer to both questions was make Superman evil, which they did in a way that, on paper, sounds kind of stupid.
In this reality the roulette wheel spun and it was the Joker’s turn to mind control Superman, and that he did.
In his confusion the big blue boy scout thought that his pregnant wife Lois was Doomsday (an obvious mistake, obviously) and accidentally killed her. As if that wasn't tough enough, a nuke had been rigged to blow when her heart stopped, taking out Metropolis. The utter devastation to Superman’s life made him snap, punch through the Joker, and start him on a path of being Earth's judge, jury and executioner.
As you might imagine, a super powered dictator would get up to some pretty evil stuff, and he did, including using his laser eyes to burn a hole through Shazam’s head, who remember, is just a kid in normal form, just for saying “hey, maybe we’re not really good guys anymore”. Way to prove him wrong, Supes.
9. Scarlet Witch: House Of M
This may tow the line between being a villain and just being angry, but when you’re a being as powerful as the Scarlet Witch there isn’t much wiggle room for semantics.
After suffering a mental breakdown, Wanda Maximoff’s powers start to become so powerful that even Professor X and Doctor Strange can't restrain her. Terrified by what she could do, the Avengers and the X-Men debate whether or not to kill her, as that’s essentially the only way to stop her from going all nuclear on creation.
Having heard this her brother, Quiksilver, basically tells her to “make a reality where everyone’s happy”, which he believes would, you know, make everyone happy. Everything seems good at first; Peter Parker is married to his first love Gwen Stacey and good ol’ Cap’n America is enjoying life as a retired veteran. Then Wolverine ruins it all by actually remembering everything and goes on a crusade to set the world the way it was.
Eventually other heroes also remember this, engaging in a huge fight that pushes Scarlet Witch to utter the phrase “No more mutants”, which wipes out roughly 90% of Homo Superior’s superb powers from existence. Not only did she steal the powers of all those people on the planet; she did so across the multiverse. That means, in Marvel’s world, that there could have been a version of me with powers, like being able to produce spiced rum out of thin air, and she stole them. Not cool, Wanda, not cool.
8. Captain America: Secret Empire
If controversy could manifest in a physical form it would be, without a doubt, Secret Empire. For those not in the know, Secret Empire basically revolves around Oh Cap’n My Cap’n revealing himself to be a Hydra agent. This kicks off almost immediately, with the chitauri (you know, those space jerks in the first Avengers film) trying to invade Earth. It’s a bit much for everyone, especially as S.H.I.E.L.D’s planet-wide shield (ingeniously called ‘The Shield’) goes down and causes hell to break loose on Earth.
World leaders panic and Cap’n America is given total control of the American military. This is when he shows his ‘true’ colours, turning The Shield back on (trapping the strongest heroes out in space) and systematically taking over the planet in the name of Hydra. He transforms the world all Orwellian style and imprisons anyone with any form of powers whatsoever. He also has a shady cabinet of guys working with him, and they’re all just generally super-dicks.
Plus, the initial alien invasion thing was kicked off by him stealing a baby Chitauri queen, so that’s pretty nasty. We find out that the Red Skull changed Steve Roger’s memories via some sentient Cosmic Cube, but the ‘original’ Cap’n comes back to save the day. He locks Cap’n Hydra in a maximum security prison, and the day's all saved. The last shot shows you that even with his good intentions he’s a villain though. All because of one cliche evil smirk, so he's definitely a bad dude.
7. Wonder Woman: Injustice 2
DC and Injustice always provide plenty of ‘good guys gone bad’.
Although other members of the Justice League did spurn the dark side and ultimately wuss out and start repenting, like The Flash and Hal Jordan, there was one collaborator that turned evil ‘for the right reasons’ but then refused to come back to the winning team when the dust had settled: Wonder Woman.
Acting more or less as Superman’s super girlfriend during Injustice, her transformation into a villain had little motivation behind it in the grand scheme of things. Sure, Supes had the death of his wife and child to act as a catalyst, but Wonder Woman kind of just went along for the ride. When the Man of Steel got locked up at the end of the first Injustice, Wonder Woman kept crusading as the world’s most ferocious woman scorned.
It didn’t really make much sense, yet her new, evil nature continued into Injustice 2. She tried to make the newly arrived Supergirl a force for The Regime, saying that Batman was evil. Eventually Supergirl saw sense though and realised what the rest of the world knows to be true: Batman’s awesome.
6. Spider-Man: The Marvel Universe Vs The Punisher
Over the decades of being plastered over the pages of comics and appearing throughout TV shows and films, Spider-Man has amassed a wealth of weird iterations and appearances, some of which are even outside of Marvel (such as the Italian Spider-Man; everyone should see the Italian Spider-Man).
Many of these are morally dubious; none, however, come close to Spider-Man in the story of The Marvel Universe vs The Punisher.
Set in a reality where The Punisher accidentally released a virus that spread throughout the states, which turns people into cannibals (that’s cannibals, not zombies, just to make that point completely set in stone). It just so happened to infect Peter Parker seemingly as patient zero. Fast forward a while later and the world has, inevitably, gone to that old chestnut; nuclear war. Essentially humanity (uninfected humanity, that is) is almost extinct, but that doesn’t stop The Punisher going around and doing his thing: blowing people’s heads off with a load of guns.
This includes when he encounters a totally friggin’ beefed up Spider-Man again, who is in charge of a clan of cannibals. There’s a lot more to cover with this story, especially as it’s a Punisher story, but the point is Spider-Man started eating people and didn’t stop until he bit off more than he could chew with The Punisher.
5. The Hulk: Old Man Logan
In the original Old Man Logan story, the world has been decimated by the Red Skull. Basically he united super villains and pitted them against superheroes who aren’t prepared to take them on, which ended up with most of them dying.
For reasons that vary from ‘radiation poisoning’ to ‘just being himself’, the Hulk decided to be on the side of kicking ass and taking names (for the sake of putting them on headstones). The United States was split between a variety of super-villains, with a lot of it going to that green gamma infused goliath the Hulk.
The worst of all, however, this is the way that the Hulk expanded on his ‘gang’. He forced She-Hulk, his first cousin, to birth his offspring.
That’s right, he raped his cousin to make a load of inbred soldiers. Bad enough, right? End of argument, you’d say. But no, they also eventually killed Wolverine’s family just to get the old man to fight him. Thankfully he went down in style, as he ate Old Man Logan (oh, yeah, he ate everyone he beat up, so, there’s that) but Wolverine healed up in his stomach and tore his way out of the not-so-jolly Green Giant.
4. Green Lantern: Emerald Twilight
A classic case of “the fans don’t like him so we don’t like him”, Hal Jordan went on a murder spree when DC saw Green Lantern comic sales weren’t looking so hot.
Coast City was utterly destroyed by a villain called Mongul, and Hal Jordan went completely insane; killing everything left, right and centre. He killed the Green Lantern Corps, he killed the all-powerful-yet-apparently-not-that-powerful Guardians of the Universe and he killed any hope of being seen as a half decent guy.
Taking the power of the Central Power Battery all for himself, this lunatic proclaimed he was now Parralax and began making life for everyone in the DC Universe pretty unbearable. Now, this was retconned later to say that he was possessed by the actual Parralax, the embodiment of fear itself and the kind of god of the Yellow Lantern Corps/Sinestro Corps, but this was originally Hal Jordan just being straight up evil.
In Blackest Night, when Hal Jordan was ‘back from the dead’ and talking to fellow coffin dodger Barry Allen, the two discussed their escape from death with the Green Lantern saying how everyone loved The Flash in death, after he’d saved the multiverse from the Anti-Monitor, while everyone was happy that he had died since he went out as a villain.
3. Cyclops: Avengers Vs X-Men
A pretty phenomenal story, Avengers vs X-Men sees the two teams start to butt heads when both of them want to take care of Hope Summers. She's considered the 'mutant messiah' by some due to her grand amount of power blowing up the X-Men’s mutant detecting machine - Cerebro - as soon as she was born. So yeah, she was a pretty big deal.
Like two parents duking it out to settle who loves the kid more, the two teams went to war. During the pandemonium that pesky ol’ cosmic entity known as the Phoenix Force came about and decided it’d be hilarious to possess Cyclops, Emma Frost, Colossus, Magik and Namor. It turned them into what sounds like a Saturday morning cartoon - the Phoenix Five. One by one they’re depowered, with their Phoenix power going to the other hosts, until ol’ Scotty is the last one standing.
Of course, during their reign as what can only be called gods, the Phoenix Five did do some good. The problem is that they got out of touch with their humanity and started doing some pretty shady stuff. It’s Cyclops who took the cake; and then smashed it right into readers’ faces. He tore Professor X apart, when the guy was just trying to talk to him.
2. Batman: The Batman Who Laughs
What starts with a pretty gritty idea circles the drain of decency, with the Joker basically tormenting Batman by having his goons kidnap and showcase families consisting of two parents and one child. The Joker continuously recreates the Dark Knight’s origin time and time again in front of him as he’s all helpless and chained up. Batman does break free but he accidentally snaps the Clown Prince of Crime’s neck, which releases an extra strong dose of Joker Gas straight into Batman’s face.
When it becomes painfully clear that Batman is getting more and more messed up, he assembles the Bat Family (Nightwing, Robin, Red Robin, Batgirl and Red Hood) and puts them through some pretty arduous training. They quickly realise that their mentor is prepping them to defeat him when he finally snaps. It seems for a second like he’s ready to take their help and try to fight the Joker’s toxins inside him, but then... well, he turns around and guns them all down - all with a smile on his face.
From there on in he’s just completely lost, killing the Justice League, destroying the world’s governments and ending humanity on Earth. A terrifying turn for all concerned.
1. Mister Fantastic: Marvel Zombies
Marvel Zombies: Dead Days totally warps any preconceived perceptions of Mister Fantastic. That is to say it shows him as nothing but a villain, entirely thanks to this story.
So, in that sense Marvel Zombies shouldn’t be new to anyone, but if it’s new to you then here's the abridged version: Marvel’s heroes and villains get infected by a zombie virus, which not only makes them undead, it retains their superpowers and their intelligence. So yeah, it’s a pretty terrifying concept.
The difference with Mister Fantastic is that while he’s performing an autopsy on one of the defeated zombies he begins getting all amazed. He's marvelled by how they can survive without their brains, how they don’t need to eat (well, eat proper food that is) and that they can essentially be immortal. That’s what makes him so cold and callous - he admires them, even after one had just killed his children a few hours ago .
It’s to that length that he purposefully infects the rest of the Fantastic Four, allows himself to be infected ‘first hand’ and, after becoming a zombie himself, he attempts to devour the rest of the survivors on their base. Worst of all? He wants to spread the zombie plague to the rest of the multiverse. Makes him a man that should be hated across the entire multiverse, including the real universe we live in.
Know of any more heroes that fell from grace harder? Let us know in the comments!