4 Reasons Why Batman Must Be Considered An Anti-Hero
On September 16th, 2003 What Culture published my last feature 10 Human Comic Book Anti Heroes You Don't Want To F**k With ... Ever!. In this feature I examined 10 of the roughest, toughest 'good guys' in the history of comics - not including mutants, super humans etc. - that you would never wish to cross if you were a bad guy and in some cases even as a regular person with no crime affiliations. For the most part you all agreed with my choices with one or two of you suggesting alternate choices (Tank Girl, Dylan Dog, Spider Jerusalem) and others completely missing the point and insisting on Wolverine and Venom. One choice in particular upset a lot of you more than any other. That was my pick for the number one spot, DC's Dark Knight himself The Batman. As the comments (positive and negative) began to flood in I sat back in my chair and revelled at the debates that ensued. It was clear that daring to call Bruce Wayne's alter ego an anti hero was a crime against superfandom and I should be strung up by my ankles and pelted with batarangs and all manner of other implements wielded by angry fan boys the world over for even suggesting such a thing. Undeterred by the torrents of abuse I've (not really) received I stand by my statement and if anything I am even more convinced that my argument is correct. However, the arguments in the comments thread do deserve further investigation which is why I am now putting the subject out to all of you to debate amongst yourselves. To help you along I shall provide evidence to further nurture the idea and hopefully we will be able to settle once and for all whether Batman really is an anti hero. So let's begin. Click next to continue.
4. Batman Is A Vigilante
The idea of Batman as a vigilante was a key focus of Christopher Nolan's recent Dark Knight trilogy. If you haven't seen the films - shame on you - then you may not know that at one point Batman assumes responsibility for the many crimes of Harvey Dent to protect the reputation of the deceased ex-do gooder. As a result the Dark Knight becomes a wanted man and as you can see from the above image becomes hunted for his 'crimes' against Gotham City which included murder, kidnapping and assault. Despite his outlaw status Batman remains a heroic figure to some. With the exception of Jim Gordon the people of Gotham are unaware of Batman's innocence and yet still secretly hope for his return. A hero of the people but wanted by the police? If you ask me that makes him more of an anti hero than a superhero. The people who contest the idea of Batman as an anti hero seem less ready to argue over his status as a vigilante. Have you ever looked up the definition of the word vigilante? According to the dictionary a vigilante is any person who takes the law into his or her own hands, as by avenging a crime. Then if you go even further and look at the American legal system it becomes even clearer that Batman is not what you would call a straight up hero. The United States is a nation of laws and those laws state that no man is above the law and must never act according to their personal preferences or private agendas. Bruce Wayne's alter ego sees himself as a proponent of good - as do all of us - but it cannot be refuted that he operates outside of the law thus making him a vigilante and as such an anti hero. It is my firm belief that a vigilante in the real sense can be nothing other than an anti hero. What's that you say? What about Spider-Man? Well if you ask J. Jonah Jameson I'm pretty sure he'll be quick to tell you where the web slinger fits in to the argument. And before you start going on about Superman just remember he's not of this Earth so the same rules do not necessarily apply.
3. Batman Is A Menace To Society
2. Batman IS A Killer
When making a point about Batman being an anti hero one cannot ignore that despite his so-called 'code of honour' Bruce Wayne's Dark Knight persona has in fact killed people. Don't believe me? Then Google it. You'll find all manner of bizarre murders committed in the name of justice by DC's favourite hero. Way back in the olden days when Batman was just starting out in comics he committed his very first killing. He passed it off as a mercy killing at the time with blatant nonchalance but to hang a 'mental patient' from a helicopter until he was dead doesn't sound like something a nice guy would do. In Detective Comics issue 35 Batman conveniently kicks an assailant so hard he lands on a sword impaling him causing a slow, agonising death. He didn't die directly by the hands of the bat but it is still his fault. More recently there was the incident in Hush where Batman strangled The Joker and the only reason he didn't end his favourite adversary's life is because Jim Gordon convinced him not to. If all that isn't convincing enough then how about the recent revelation by comics writer Grant Morrison that in the 1986 genre classic The Killing Joke Batman does indeed kill his arch enemy. Talking to Kevin Smith on his podcast Morrison said: "No one's noticed -- however much, 30 years on, almost -- Batman kills the Joker. That's why it's called The Killing Joke. The Joker tells the 'Killing Joke' at the end, Batman reaches out and breaks his neck, and that's why the laughter stops and the light goes out, 'cause that was the last chance at crossing that bridge. And Alan Moore wrote the ultimate Batman/Joker story. He finished it ... but he did it in such a way that it's ambiguous, so people will never have to be sure, which means it doesn't have to be the last Batman/Joker story. It's brilliant!"If Batman was the hero we all thought he was he would have brought Joker to justice not ended his life. It's just that simple.
1. Because Frank Miller Said So
In 1986 DC released a four part mini series by Frank Miller called The Dark Knight Returns. At the time the character of Batman had become somewhat stale with very little of DC's output for their top cash cow challenging the readers who were turning to Marvel in their droves. Miller's work was like nothing that had come before it and completely changed the character forever. In the story Batman is long retired, out of shape and out of sorts with the people of Gotham City. His big return to the world of crime fighting comes at a time when violence has besieged the world and it will take a very different kind of Batman - a God damn Batman as it were - to restore order in this very different world. Batman's re emergence also brings back his arch enemy The Joker who has been in a catatonic state in Arkham ever since Bruce Wayne called it a day as a 'hero' further hammering home the idea that without a Batman there would be no criminals. Unlike previous incarnations of the masked marauder of Gotham this was a Batman with an edge unsurprising with the creator of Sin City at the helm and this edge more than anything else shaped the character into the ultimate anti hero that even Superman wants to put an end to. Of course you may argue that the work of Frank Miller is the exception and not the rule and instead the traditional Batman stories are canon and thus the only ones that should be considered when making this argument but tell me what writer since 1986 has legitimately not been inspired by Miller's characterisation. I think you will be very hard pressed to find one. SO now all that is left is for you all to debate amongst yourselves. Have I done enough to convince you or are you even less convinced? The beauty of our combined love of comics, Batman and the Geeky little asides like this is it brings out the true passion in us all and I look forward to reading all of your comments. The floodgates are open Bat fans. Let the debate begin.
