X-Men: 10 Worst Things The Mutants Have Done

'Cause even Professor X can stoop that low.

X Men Deadly Genesis
Marvel Comics

The X-Men started out as B-listers in the '60s before making it big in 1975 with a revamp that would change the team forever. Since then, the group blossomed into one of Marvel's leading titles while branching out to spin-off books such as The New Mutants and X-Force. They have been part of films, TV shows, video games, and their MCU debut is highly anticipated.

Within the Marvel Universe, however, the X-Men have been hated and feared by humankind because of their differences. This has caused schisms within the mutant community such as the subterranean Morlocks or Magneto's Brotherhood of Mutants coming into conflicts with the team.

And while our Merry Mutants have done their best throughout the years, they have also been guilty of terrible things that would make their rogues' gallery blush. These are acts that put a blemish on the X-Men's otherwise goody-goody image.

With that said, there will be spoilers inbound so fair warning for new readers of the comics who are eager to enter the world of the homo superior. At the same time, the individuals mentioned here will be the X-Men as well as the mutants directly associated with the team.

10. Magneto Removes Wolverine's Adamantium

Fatal Attractions
Marvel Comics

Magneto was the first villain the X-Men ever faced, and while he has joined them from time to time, he has also done terrible things for the sake of mutant rights.

In the 1993 crossover event 'Fatal Attractions,' the Master of Magnetism renounced his reformed ways and turned on our heroes. In the ensuing chaos, Wolverine tries to attack him so Magneto retaliates by removing Logan's Adamantium skeleton. The extraction kicks his healing factor into overtime and nearly kills him. It is then revealed that Wolverine's trademark claws were bone before being bonded by the metal.

In the aftermath, our hero regresses into a feral state, becoming more animal-like and violent. This is due to the Adamantium process helping him gain more agency and so without it, Wolverine becomes more savage than ever. This 'Feral' version would sport a wilder appearance while losing his nose.

While Logan would eventually gain his metal skeleton and his rugged good looks, this remained one of Magneto's most heinous acts. Despite fighting for the good of mutantkind, this was proof of how low he could go to achieve his goals and why he is the quintessential X-Men villain.


9. Cyclops And Emma Frost's Psychic Affair

Emma Frost Cyclops Jean Grey
Marvel Comics

Scott Summers is known for his by-the-book attitude, but throughout his career as Cyclops he has done morally questionable things such as leaving his wife Jean Grey and their child. But during a troubled time in their marriage, Slim would cheat on Jean in Grant Morrison's New X-Men.

This begins when a rift between the two is caused by Scott's recent encounter with Apocalypse while the Phoenix Force manifests through Jean once again. This leads to the couple confiding in other people, with Grey kissing Wolverine, while Summers vents out to Emma Frost in a series of psychic therapy sessions. Eventually, however, Scott and Emma's relationship becomes intimate and they have a psychic affair. The pair are soon caught by Jean and, in the aftermath, Cyclops leaves the team while Emma is believed to have been killed. The whole thing even gets messier when Jean dies but convinces a grieving Scott to move on - which he does by kissing Ms. Frost beside his wife's grave.

Though Cyclops would defend himself by saying that it was only thoughts and no physical contact was made, his infamous affair would remain a dent in his character.


8. Beast Brings The O5 Into The Present

Beast O5 X-Men
Marvel Comics

Dr. Hank McCoy is known as one of the X-Men's smartest members and has been indispensable to the team while even being part of other groups such as The Avengers. But despite his impressive list of credentials, Beast's decision to bring in the O5 X-Men would cause ripples throughout the Marvel Universe.

After Cyclops killed Professor X while under the influence of the Phoenix Force, he had become a revolutionary, which caused a rift within the mutant community. Beast then decided to bring the younger versions of himself, Cyclops, Marvel Girl, Angel, and Iceman to the present after seeing how far his former friend had fallen.

This causes trouble for years to come with the time-displaced team coming to terms with the terrible events that will transform them. The young Scott Summers is ostracized for the crimes of his future self, while Jean Grey is horrified by the deaths and hardships she'll experience with her encounters with the Phoenix.

McCoy's actions would even cause his allies to question his decisions, and though the O5 would eventually return to their time, Hank's decision would remain hated by the fanbase.


7. '60s Professor X Being Shady

Professor X
Marvel Comics

One of the most iconic things Kitty Pryde ever said was the line, "Professor Xavier is a jerk!" Though it was meant to reflect on her immaturity, Charles Xavier was, in fact, a jerk, especially during the early years of the X-Men.

In the 1960s, Professor X was portrayed as a manipulative man who didn't mind using his powers to achieve his goals, such as wiping the memories of villains like the Vanisher. He would even pretend to lose his powers and intelligence all in a ploy to teach his students how to become independent. And when he wasn't busy emotionally scarring teenagers, Charles would leave them alone from time to time and give leadership to a teenaged Scott Summers.

But if there's one thing fans won't forgive '60s Xavier for, it would be for his 'crush' on an underaged Jean Grey. In one of the comic's earlier issues, Charles' thoughts reveal that he is in love with his student but cannot do so as the leader of the X-Men and his disability, not the fact that he is way older than her. Not exactly the student-teacher relationship readers want to see.


6. Kitty Pryde's Mental Prison

Astonishing X-Men 17 Kitty Pryde Michael
Marvel Comics

Cassandra Nova is Charles Xavier's twin sister who would serve as a foe for the X-Men in the 2000s.

After her initial defeat, she would later manipulate Emma Frost to do her bidding and perform a psychic assault on each member of the super-team. This ranged from reducing Cyclops into a catatonic state, to turning Beast into a wild animal, but the one who got it the worst has to be Kitty Pryde.

First, Kitty is placed in a dream world where she has lived happily ever after with Piotr Rasputin, aka Colossus. She then gives birth to a child that she names Michael and raises him for the next three years. But one day, the X-Men arrive and take their son away from the couple as Professor X believes the infant to be a threat. Piotr even betrays his spouse and knocks her out to surrender Michael to their former allies. This pushes Kitty to find the boy at all costs, not knowing that she has been manipulated by Nova in an attempt to return her to power.

Though the events that transpire are mere hours, in Kitty's perspective, she had lived those three years which makes her loss even more painful.


5. The Death of Charles Xavier

Avengers Vs X-Men
Marvel Comics

In the 2012 crossover event Avengers vs. X-Men, Earth's Mightiest Heroes were up against the Phoenix Five. The quintet consisted of Cyclops, Emma Frost, Namor, Magik, and Colossus who reshaped the world according to their will until they themselves became a threat.

As each member of the five fell, the last ones standing were Scott and Emma, who were becoming more tyrannical by the minute. To stop this deadly pairing, Professor X was recruited by Magneto himself and joined the battle as a last resort.

But the cosmic entity had consumed Scott and even led to him betraying Emma Frost to gain more power. After a mental battle between him and Xavier, Scott used his power to kill the Professor and became the Dark Phoenix. He was eventually defeated by Hope Summers and the Scarlet Witch while wilfully accepting his arrest after realizing what he had done.

Charles Xavier's death would mark a turning point for the X-Men, with the irony that he was killed by his first student and surrogate son. And while Professor X, like most of the mutants, would come back to life, his death haunted Scott for several years.


4. Ultimate Wolverine And MJ

Ultimate Spider-Man 67 Wolverine Mary Jane
Marvel Comics

The Ultimate Universe tried to revamp classic characters by making them darker and edgier, with examples such as a mean-spirited Captain America and the Maximoff twins being too close for comfort. But the worst thing they did, was turn Wolverine into a full-blown creeper.

In the 616 Universe, Logan always had a thing for Jean Grey, but despite his feelings towards her, he never did anything serious out of respect for Cyclops. In Ultimate Marvel, however, he actively seduces Jean to provoke Summers and even tries to kill him out of jealousy.

The most infamous example of Wolvie's creepy behavior is when he sets his sights on another redhead, Mary Jane Watson, after switching bodies with Peter Parker. Posing as the Web-slinger, he makes advances toward the underaged girl without her ever knowing that Peter was actually Wolverine. He even breaks the fourth wall and gives a devilish grin to let readers know that what he's doing is wrong as he gets frisky with MJ.

Wolverine's decisions are inappropriate and straight-up gross with the issue of MJ's age and him taking advantage of her ignorance. Had the mainline Logan exhibited this creepy behavior, he would never reach the fan-favorite status he has among fans.


3. Deadly Genesis

X Men Deadly Genesis
Marvel Comics

Professor X has been the paragon of moral virtue as leader of the X-Men throughout the years. Despite starting out questionable, Charles soon grew into the kind-hearted person who served as the center of the group. But in the 2005 limited series, Deadly Genesis, readers found out the biggest skeleton in Xavier's closet.

In Giant-Size X-Men # 1, most of the original team plus Havok and Polaris were captured by Krakoa, the living island, with only Scott left to warn the Professor. This led to the formation of the second generation of X-Men, but Deadly Genesis reveals that there was another team.

Xavier, with the help of Moira MacTaggert, recruited Vulcan, Sway, Darwin, and Petra to rescue his students, but their career as X-Men ended in tragedy when they were killed by Krakoa. Professor X then went to Scott, the only one aware of the group, and wiped his memories to spare him from the pain and grief.

Unbeknownst to the Professor, Vulcan had survived and returned to exact revenge on him and the X-Men, starting with the murder of Banshee. Though the team eventually overpowered their foe, the revelation of Xavier's duplicity forced Scott to banish the Professor for good.


2. No More Mutants

House of M Wanda Scarlet Witch no more mutants
Marvel Comics

House of M had the Scarlet Witch change reality into a world where mutants were the dominant species of the planet and Magneto and his children ruled the Earth. This forced the Marvel heroes to band together in this alternate universe and restore the world they knew.

In the climax of the storyline, the Master of Magnetism kills Quicksilver after finding out he was responsible for the events that transpired. A grief-stricken Wanda, who realizes that Magneto has placed mutants above his own children, utters the words "No more mutants". Her actions restore the Marvel Universe back to normal, but with severe consequences. A lot of mutants lose their powers, while their numbers are reduced to a few hundred, effectively turning them into an endangered species.

Wanda's actions would cause ripples across the Marvel Universe with villains such as Onslaught and the Shadow King returning because of the new reality. At the same time, the reduction of the mutant community forces Cyclops to take desperate measures, which leads to his schism with the X-Men and his transformation into a mutant revolutionary.


1. Dark Phoenix Destroys A Planet

Dark Phoenix Saga
Marvel Comics

The Dark Phoenix Saga is one of the X-Men's most popular storylines and deservingly so. When Jean Grey is manipulated by the Hellfire Club, the barriers of her powers are destroyed, which corrupts her as she transforms into the Dark Phoenix.

When the entity is drained by recent events, the cosmic force devours the energy of a D'Bari star which causes the deaths of every inhabitant on a nearby planet. In just a few panels, Jean Grey, through the Dark Phoenix, has basically committed genocide.

This forces the Shi'ar Empire to take action and conclude that Grey has become a threat that rivals the likes of Galactus. They sentence her to death due to the risk she poses, but the X-Men challenge the alien empire to a fight on the moon; one that will free Jean should they win.

Though the X-Men lose the climactic duel, Jean realizes the threat she has become and kills herself to prevent the Dark Phoenix from harming anyone else. Ultimately, as the Watcher said, Jean Grey chose to die as a mortal than live as a god.


Watch Next


Can You 100% This Impossible X-Men Quiz?

Cyclops Optic Blast
Marvel Comics

1. Which Of These Characters Isn't Related To Cyclops/Scott Summers?

Contributor
Contributor

Loves film, games, and music. Collects Predator figures from time to time and a huge Sonic fan.