10 Film Remakes That Actually Worked

True Grit Following on from my pessimistic article discussing 10 Upcoming Film Reboots And Remakes That Nobody Is Asking For, I thought I'd write an article a tad more positive and explore 10 of my favourite film remakes. The dreaded word 'remake' inclines audiences and film buffs to take to the internet and contribute to the collective moans and groans, claiming that Hollywood filmmakers and producers are out of fresh ideas. However, it is important to remember that not all remakes are bad ideas. If a new spin is put on a classic, or enough time has passed, justifying its translation to a new time-zone and cultural differences, then remakes can work. If there is room for improvement, or simply room for change, along with the possibility of attracting younger viewers who were previously unacquainted with the story, then a remake, or a reboot, or whatever producers and studios want to market said film as these days, then why not update a promising classic story to a contemporary setting, or a fantastical setting that can be improved upon with superior visual effects? So click 'NEXT' below and read on and agree or disagree with my choices, and criticise for the impressive remakes that I've possibly missed out. These are the remakes that buck the trend and stand on their own success as fantastic examples of film.

10. King Kong

king kong Nobody would have been blamed for their sharp intake of breath upon hearing the news that the 1933 classic King Kong was to be remade, even with the biggest director in the world at the helm, perhaps expecting a repeat of Emmerich's take on Godzilla. However, like Godzilla, it was a classic film that made sense to be remade. With 72 years between the original and the remake, times have changed and so have the movies - better visuals, a different style of acting and music, different editing and camera techniques, etc. It may be a clear-cut repeat of the original when it comes to the narrative, but as film has evolved, sometimes it is a sensible creative and marketing choice to evolve classic stories with it. Of course, that should never mean that the newer version is a replacement of the old, and you never get the feeling that Peter Jackson is trying to do that. It plays more like a homage, everything is very similar apart from the look of it, updating it for multiple newer generations. It still has a classic feel to it; a big, bold epic with beautifully epic music and slightly over the top acting that wouldn't have been out of place in movies 80 years ago. Accompanied by the wonderful set and costume design of New York, Jackson was correct not to make the film a contemporary one, instead keeping it fixed in a classic setting. It may have split audiences down the middle, but critics were generally favourable to Jackson's efforts, and rightly so. King Kong is huge, loud and fun, and the ape doesn't look too bad, either. Also, it doesn't slack when it comes to the quieter moments, and the surprising, but talented cast, all give in terrific performances, and even Jack Black proves that he's not a one-trick comedy pony. Peter Jackson's King Kong exists as the greatest film about a giant ape since 1933. Yes, even better than Mighty Joe Young.

9. Dawn Of The Dead

dawn of the dead

George A. Romero, the king of the zombies, made the critically and hugely financially successful Dawn of the Dead back in 1978. It is often considered the film that kickstarted the cultural obsession of zombies, and went on to spawn many references and spoofs in popular culture, perhaps most memorable of all being Shaun of the Dead. Its iconic scenes of gory violence, and the ultimate location during a zombie apocalypse, a shopping centre (or mall to US readers), which is both incredibly handy but also openly dangerous. So why remake it? Ever since Romero kicked off the craze, there has been a constant healthy stream of zombie films being released. Many people would suggest that zombie films have been done to death by now (not myself, I can't get enough) due to the fact that there's only so many different scenarios that you can create with dawdling, stumbling meat bags that have a craving for your brain. Why not try and create a narrative involving zombie's that has absolutely never been done before instead of remaking the quintessential classic? The biggest difference, and certainly not to Romero's liking, was changing the slow-paced zombies into quick-paced zombies that would outrun the majority of us (maybe if we didn't sit around watching so many movies...) that were more akin to the creatures from Danny Boyle's 28 Days Later. Zombie purists, like Romero, may lament this choice, but at the end of the day it is the biggest difference from the original, which only gives it more credibility to be remade. If anyone should remake (or re-imagine) a film, then you could go worse than Zack Snyder. He has his own directorial style, and although this debut for him didn't feature the vibrant bright colours and slow-motion being heavily used in every other scene that we have all come to expect from Snyder, it was still apparent that this remake was made by a man who would go onto become one of the most popular and successful filmmakers in Hollywood. If you flick onto a film that he directed and you don't know what the film is, chances are you will still know that it is a Zack Snyder film.

8. Man On Fire

man on fire

The late, great Tony Scott's Denzel starring revenge thriller is the second adaptation of A. J. Quinnell's 1980 novel of the same name. The first adaptation came from the largely unknown ‰lie Chouraqui in 1987. And despite boasting an impressive cast featuring the likes of Scott Glenn, Joe Pesci and Jonathan Pryce, it underwhelmed both critics and audiences on release. Nowadays, even though Scott's adaptation was unfairly lamented by many critics, the 2004 adaptation is the film seen by most and often highly praised by many audiences, as the original has faded into obscurity. It features a brilliant cast with the likes of Denzel's former CIA officer going on a rampage to find the abducted "Pita", played by a young and impressive Dakota Fanning. The cast also includes Christopher Walken and Mickey Rourke for your viewing pleasure. Man on Fire is a well-paced and fantastically directed revenge-thriller - a sub-genre that often captures people's imaginations on screen so that we don't have to in real life. And despite the fact that revenge-thrillers often get people's overly political correct knickers in a twist, Man on Fire poses debate of moral ambiguity and asks how far will people go to do the right thing, and when does that right thing become wrong? One thing that can be said about Man on Fire is that the violence isn't glorified; Creasy kills when he has to, and it is evident that he gets no satisfaction from doing it. But we will receive satisfaction from watching a film from one of the greats.

7. The Mummy

The Mummy

Stephen Sommers' 1999 fantasy action film revolving around a rampaging, infamous mummy named Imhotep is a loose remake of the 1932 Boris Karloff starring original. Whereas the 1932 version focussed mainly on elements of horror, the 1999 version (and its fun sequel and abhorrent sequel to that one) starred Brendan Fraser, so its obvious that its going to be more interested in light-hearted fantastical action that will annoy some and charm many. Sommers' The Mummy is one of those films that you will watch to the very end if you stumble across it on the television on one rainy afternoon. It's a guilty pleasure to many, and whereas some cinephiles will constantly argue that it devalues the original, nobody can deny the popularity and the success of this take on the franchise. It goes in a completely new direction than the original, and surely that's when a remake has the right and the clarity to exist. The Mummy is set to be remade for a third time, but details are currently slim. We are yet to know whether it will involve any of the cast that featured in this trilogy (if so, I'm on board). It's also unknown whether it's going to be an action/comedy/fantasy hybrid, or more horror oriented like the original, or perhaps even something completely different. The Mummy: The Musical, anyone?

6. Sweeney Todd

sweeney-todd-the-demon-barber-of-fleet-street-original

Films, television series', stage productions, radio plays, even a musical - there have been many adaptations of the infamous story of Victorian based serial killer Sweeney Todd, and his accomplice who who turned the bodies of the victims into meat pies, ever since the character's first outing in a Penny Dreadful serial titled The String of Pearls, way back in the 1840s. There have been many claims that the stories are based on a real person, but despite denials from historians and researchers, Sweeney Todd has existed in the public imaginations of many for quite some time now. Considering the brutal and gloriously dark subject matter, it only seems natural that iconic filmmaker Tim Burton would tackle an adaptation himself. Many consider it Burton's last truly great film, as for a while it seems that his gothic themes and wacky style is getting a bit old. Perfect then, for a musical set in Victorian London that even has a musical number featuring Sacha Baron Cohen and Johnny Depp singing about piss. Ah yes, did I forget to mention that this was a musical? Many viewers were put off this fact on release, instead expecting a straight-up horror due to its surprising 18 certification in the UK. But as Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street is specifically an adaptation of the 1979 Tony Award winning sequel of the same name, a fantastically gory musical is what it is. In between all of the gloriously over the top crimson drenched throat slicing, a stellar cast including Depp, Helena Bonham Carter, Alan Rickman and Sacha Baron Cohen all put in wonderful performances and aren't bad singers to boot. Notes are sometimes missed, but the emotion, power and anger is always felt. Plus, considering the characters are all Victorian era Brits with bad teeth and poor hygiene, it seems all the more credible that these characters are not perfect singers with angelic voices. This is by far the most successful screen adaptation of Sweeney Todd to date, and often the most celebrated.

5. Casino Royale

Casino Royale

Some may argue the opinion that Martin Campbell's brilliant Casino Royale isn't a remake, but this is technically the third adaptation of Ian Fleming's novel of the same name. The first adaptation of the source material came in 1954 on television and isn't seen by many. The second adaptation of the novel came in 1967, and was, to put politely, an absolute mess of a film, directed by a host of different filmmakers and featuring an ensemble cast with the likes of Peter Sellers, David Niven, Ursula Andress, Orson Welles, and Woody Allen. With those names in mind, it's clear to assume that it wasn't a faithful adaptation to the source material, instead it was an unfunny loosely remade Bond spoof (the best Bond spoof to date is Austin Powers). So, considering the two efforts that preceded the big-screen 2006 version, Campbell would have had to be high on bath salts to make a worse Casino Royale film. However, with regards to the outcry over the casting of Daniel Craig as the iconic spy (eating your words now, aren't you?), not many would have guessed that Campbell was going to direct arguably the best James Bond film to date. It's a bold statement, especially when speaking to James Bond purists who still yearn for gadgets, lots of fast cars, and casual sexism and racism, as Martin Campbell and Daniel Craig both took one of the most famous story characters in history in a completely new direction. Gone was the man that couldn't be harmed and who's every other line was a quip (still done, but not as frequently), and people said hello to a more realistic, gritty take. Bond could finally take a punch, and he could finally take his life-threatening situations seriously. He still shags anything with legs, but this James Bond is the most different that we've ever seen, who refreshed a franchise that was slowing down, and has perhaps gone onto overtake Sean 'can't pronounce his S'' Connery to the accolade of the best ever Bond.

4. True Grit

true-grit-2010-rooster-cogburn-jeff-bridges-billboard-600x300 Watch an old western these days on daytime television and you'll probably switch it off half way through if you're not a racist old man who still yearns for the past. The majority of westerns have aged horribly - the acting, visual style, pace, and ideologies. It's a genre of film that isn't often seen in cinemas these days. Most westerns this century have been poor spectacles that have relied on merging with other genres, and have still failed: Cowboys and Aliens, Jonah Hex, The Lone Ranger, etc. (Although, I do enjoy Shanghai Noon!) When you think of a western, you often think of John Wayne. Even his name screams cowboy and he was the poster-boy for the genre, and whether you love him or hate him, he remains one of the most iconic Hollywood movie stars that has ever lived. 1969's True Grit is the only time he won an Academy Award for best actor, and has since gone onto become a celebrated film about Wayne's fictional hero "Rooster" Cogburn who is hired by a fourteen-year-old girl to hunt down her father's killer. It's often ill-advised to closely remake a successful film, what's the point if you can't improve on the first one? Well, it would have took a brave gambler to bet against (and ultimately lose) to the Coen brothers, for ultimately, they did make a better film. Some may argue that it's not necessarily a better film, that it simply highlights how cinema has evolved, making it easier for younger viewers that have probably never seen a conventional western before. They may be right... if they weren't wrong. The Coen's made a simply outstanding western with a world-class cast including Jeff Bridges (a more likeable, yet no less ruthless Cogburn), Hailee Steinfield (who was thirteen-years-old when cast, and went on to be nominated for an Academy Award for best supporting actress), the ever-reliable Matt Damon, and Josh Brolin, who's mug and voice is perfect for the genre. Everything about the film was fantastic - the cinematography, the editing, the score. It may not have inspired a new wave of groundbreaking westerns, but it did, however, prove that westerns can still be successful and attract a healthy audience.

3. The Departed

People will probably argue between which is better out of Martin Scorsese's The Departed or Andrew Lau's and Alan Mak's 2002 Hong Kong original Infernal Affairs until the end of days. More will probably veer towards Infernal Affairs for original's sake, claiming that people who only watch The Departed are too lazy to read subtitles. They may be right, but nobody can deny that both films are true spectacles of cinema. Following Leonardo DiCaprio's police officer going undercover to uncover Jack Nicholson's organised crime ring, The Departed translates brilliantly to US culture. And even though when the words 'organised crime' are used you tend to think of 1930s gangsters, it works perfectly in the modern day and even gives you an interesting insight into how the business has (or hasn't) changed. Both films feature glorious performances from equally glorious casts, twists and turns in an inescapably layered and magnificent plot combine with fantastic action and thrills that will keep you on the edge of your seat throughout its running time. It's a waste of time arguing which is better, they're both perfect and both received universal recognition from critics and audiences alike. Why not simply enjoy both?


2. Scarface

Scarface Although the original 1932 Scarface has gone down in film history, the 1983 version directed by the enigmatic Brian De Palma works because of the reason so many of the other films in this list does - time. Al Pacino's take on the iconic gangster, Tony Montana, is loud, brash, bloody and over the top - all of the things that the original wouldn't have been allowed to be even if it wanted to. And although it received much attention for its controversial graphic violence and use of language at the time, we all love it. Scarface has gone onto inspire video games, spoofs, countless references in different films and television shows (perhaps most recently Breaking Bad) and is quoted every day. We never seem to get tired of hearing "Say hello to my little friend!" Tony Montana is one of the most celebrated film villains in the history of cinema and rightly so, for Al Pacino made the role his own. When the villain is the main character in the film instead of the hero, the makers have to make sure that the audience wants them to prevail, despite all of the atrocities they commit and their lack of morals. And when a film can make you root for a crack head with a bloodlust, you know it's doing something right.

1. The Thing

The Thing It's like looking in a mirror, isn't it? John W. Campbell, Jr's 1938 novella Who Goes There? was first adapted in 1951 by Christian Nyby and Howard Hawks under the title The Thing from Another World. The film has gone down in movie history and its legacy lives on, but as you'd imagine from a horror film of the 1950s that doesn't come from Alfred Hitchcock or Hammer Studios, it's a pretty soft horror film that children of the time were allowed to see, skipping blood, gore and gruesome death. In 1982 one of the true masters of horror, John Carpenter, adapted the novella and called it simply, The Thing. It certainly didn't skip blood, gore and gruesome death, and has since remained as one of the most frightening films of all time, that plays on paranoia and the human fears of the unknown. As well as incorporating out-of-this-world, mainly practical special effects (that still look brilliant today), making seeing the alien in its true form an unforgettable experience, the film was also blessed with great performances and a perfect directorial style, pacing the film to be a suspense-filled nightmare that will make sure that you feel the cold. The iconic climax and its final shot in the film will live on in your memory, further highlighting the ambiguity that the film offers throughout its entire duration. It's one of the greatest horror films ever made and never fails to terrify, and in my opinion, the best remake ever made. Disagree with any films included? Or feeling that I'm missing some key ones? Add your thoughts to the comment box below.

Contributor
Contributor

Aspiring screenwriter. Film & TV Production BA (Hons) graduate. Currently studying MA Screenwriting at LJMU. Addicted to Breaking Bad and Chinese food.