10 Horror Films That Actually Won Oscars
Who says the Academy doesn't like a jump-scare?
Since the first Academy Awards in 1929, horror and the Oscars have made for strange bedfellows, which perhaps accounts for the number of smaller ceremonies that recognize talent within the genre.
It’s there of course, but you wouldn’t know it from a casual perusal of the list of Oscar winners over the decades. The awards given out to scare pictures mostly honour technical achievements and even then only in “safe” studio movies. In nearly ninety years, only one horror movie has won Best Picture (more on that later).
The Academy’s judgment has sometimes come back to haunted its members, such as when Emil Jannings won Best Actor in 1929. The only German to have won the accolade, Janning’s heavy accent meant that the coming of sound effectively destroyed his career in Hollywood and sent him back to his native land, where he earned a crust by appearing in Nazi propaganda films.
As Hollywood gears up for its 89th Academy Awards, nominations for horror filmmakers are as sparse as ever, with not even Train To Busan being honored in the Foreign Film category. Here, then, are ten reminders of when horror did matter to the Academy, and while it’s good to see the films honored for their contribution, note how few of them proved to be controversial choices.
10. An American Werewolf In London
Won: Best Makeup
One of the first films to prove that a horror movie could have a sharp sense of humour and deliver a few shocks, John Landis' An American Werewolf In London works on so many levels that several contemporary critics were wondering if the film had a split personality.
The Chicago Reader called it “a lot of dissociated segments left hanging in midair” while Roger Ebert complained that “Landis never seems sure whether he’s making a comedy or a horror film….the laughs and the blood coexist very uneasily.”
Neither credited Rick Baker with creating some of the best transformation sequences ever put on celluloid, nor did they credit him with making werewolves scary again after all those old Hammer and Universal movies. If the movie has a hero then Baker is it, and his Oscar was richly deserved.
9. Misery
Won: Best Actress
Scripted by William Goldman, Misery is in the first rank of Stephen King adaptations, fully realized on the screen by Rob Reiner, whose previous films included When Harry Met Sally, The Princess Bride and This Is Spinal Tap.
Reiner might seem an odd choice for a claustrophobic movie about a writer held captive by his “number one fan” but he’d also made Stand By Me, another good King adaptation, and his production company is named after King’s fictional town of Castle Rock.
Reiner’s not the movie’s beating heart, though – the honor falls to Kathy Bates as Annie Wilkes, who’s so much more than a standard-issue movie villain. Likely to swing from one extreme to the other in a microsecond, Annie presents any actress with the opportunity to overact in true Joan Crawford fashion, but Bates delivers a minimalist performance that’s much more powerful and unpredictable.
8. Aliens
Won: Best Visual Effects, Best Sound Effects Editing
Also Nominated For: Best Actress, Best Art Direction, Best Sound, Best Film Editing, Best Original Score
One of the most influential movies of the 1980s (and cruelly overlooked for a Best Picture nod in its day), Aliens has been parodied and/or ripped off in everything from Jason X to Doom, and every subsequent bug hunt movie feels obliged to pay homage.
That’s a remarkable feat in itself, but for a sequel to someone else’s movie, it’s practically unheard of. Kudos to writer/director James Cameron who made a follow-up that builds on the original but also works well enough as a stand-alone movie. Nobody could’ve predicted he’d one day make Titanic.
All of Cameron’s trademarks are present and correct: a female warrior with a love of hardware, a corporate bad guy and a succession of large-scale action sequences where stuff blows up real good. For sheer entertainment, it’s probably his best film.
7. Jaws
Won: Best Sound, Best Film Editing, Best Original Score
Also Nominated For: Best Picture
Dated only by its lack of show off digital effects, Jaws shows how a stripped-down narrative with good actors trumps an overextended blockbuster that depends upon OTT effects sequences for its thrills. Spielberg’s rubber shark with its pneumatic movements might look unconvincing, but the attack sequences stand up better than any of its digital equivalents will four decades from now.
Sure, you can dismiss Jaws as bubble-gum if you want, but don’t forget the effect it had on an unsuspecting public. William Goldman saw the film when it was first shown in New York and knew from the moment he heard John Williams’ score that the audience was hooked. For the next two hours, nobody spoke, they just screamed at key moments.
“When the lights came up,” he wrote, “we all knew something remarkable was about to go out into the world.”
6. Rosemary's Baby
Won: Best Actress
Also Nominated For: Best Adapted Screenplay
Before The Omen and The Exorcist there was Rosemary’s Baby, and who could make a better film about Satanism in modern day New York than Roman Polanski?
At that point in his career, Polanski had won critical (if not commercial) success for Repulsion and Knife In The Water and he brings the same eerie stylings to this astonishingly faithful adaptation of Ira Levin’s bestseller. When producer William Castle (who as the director of The Tingler knew a thing or two about cheap horror movies) said that when he saw the finished film it was like ordering a Mini and receiving a Rolls Royce.
As good as Mia Farrow is in the lead, the acting honors go to Ruth Gordon as Minnie Castevet, the kindly old neighbor who turns out to be a member of a satanic coven. It’s a sign of how good Gordon’s performance is that she can go from motherly to sinister without overplaying, and her newfound fame later brought her roles in similar fare, including Whatever Happened To Aunt Alice and the TV Movie sequel, Look What’s Happened To Rosemary’s Baby.
5. Beetlejuice
Won: Best Makeup:
If you didn’t know Tim Burton from his short films or Pee Wee’s Big Adventure, then Beetlejuice was the film that put him on the map and pointed the way forward in terms of visual style and manic invention.
In his two-star review, Roger Ebert dismissed the film for being “about gimmicks, not characters”, but he missed the point: like several of Burton’s later films, it’s a snapshot of a weird place presented through the eyes of shining innocents. What’s weirder than a manual for the recently deceased, an afterlife staffed by three-fingered typists and a wild-haired character named Betelgeuse (Michael Keaton) who advertises “exorcisms of the living”?
Barely recognizable beneath heavy makeup, Keaton pulls out all the stops with a performance Bill Moseley claims was inspired by his turn as Chop Top in The Texas Chainsaw Massacre 2. His character fits in perfectly with production design that’s somewhere between Chuck Jones and Salvador Dali, all bright colours, manic energy and bizarre, surrealist images.
Burton might’ve had more money on his Batman movies, but they somehow feel smaller when contrasted with Beetlejuice’s scope, which takes in our present, the afterlife and a desert landscape populated by sandworms.
4. The Omen
Won: Best Score
Also Nominated For: Best Original Song
Scripted by David Seltzer, The Omen is strictly a tawdry Exorcist cash-in but in upping the number of violent incidents that befall members of the cast it also laid the groundwork for the Final Destination series.
The story couldn’t be simpler: when a US Ambassador realizes that his adopted son is evil incarnate, he sets out to stop the little tyke from fulfilling his destiny as the prophesized antichrist. Brought to life by an excellent supporting cast (which includes David Warner, Billie Whitelaw and Patrick Troughton), the movie gets a big shot from Richard Donner’s slick direction but if you remember the film for any one thing it’ll be Jerry Goldsmith’s score.
One of the few foreign language songs ever to be nominated for an Oscar, Ave Satani (“Hail Satan”) is a satanic version of a Gregorian chant with a master leading his choir in a sinister inversion of the Catholic rite of the consecration. Used whenever the going gets weird, the song is the perfect accompaniment to the mayhem occurring onscreen.
The song’s concept later inspired Oculus Infernum, a concept album recorded by Van Helsing’s Curse, a side-project band of Twisted Sister frontman Dee Snider.
3. The Exorcist
Won: Best Adapted Screenplay, Best Sound
Also Nominated For: Best Picture, Best Director, Best Actress, Best Supporting Actor, Best Supporting Actress, Best Cinematography, Best Art Direction, Best Film Editing
Between December 5 and 26 1973, five new movies appeared in American theaters and each one of them became a solid gold classic. They were: Serpico, Papillon, Sleeper, The Sting and The Exorcist.
More than 40 years since The Exorcist first thrilled audiences, you can say this much about William Friedkin’s movie: no subsequent religious-themed horror movie was as shocking, well mounted or suspenseful as his signature film.
Religious horror pictures are generally dire (see: Exorcist II: The Heretic), but not only does The Exorcist live up to the hype (“the most electrifying thing that will ever happen to you,” the ads read), it throws in some still-powerful images.
Watching Linda Blair perform unladylike acts with a crucifix is one thing, but how many films could show her throwing a doctor across the room without ending up as a laugh riot? When people say they don’t make ‘em like they used to, this is the film they have in mind.
2. The Fly
Won: Best Makeup
When Mel Brooks realized he had too much baggage as a director of comedies to make darker films, he produced them through his company Brooksfilms and brought in directors like David Cronenberg, the only filmmaker who could do this remake justice.
Having established himself as the go-to guy for “body horror” with Shivers, Rabid, Scanners et al, Cronenberg got the biggest budget of his career to date on The Fly, and it shows in Chris Walas' award-winning effects, which still hold up after more than thirty years (and yes, these practical effects are more convincing than CG).
Seth Brundle (Jeff Goldblum) is an expert in the field of matter transportation, able to send objects between a series of “telepods” he’s developed, and after impressing a female journalist with a demonstration, he decides to transport himself, little realizing there’s a fly inside the pod with him.
As he transforms into an insect-human hybrid he calls “Brundlefly”, his fingernails fall off, body parts mutate and he takes on the characteristics of a common housefly. In one scene, to the understandable surprise of his girlfriend, he’s shown crawling across the ceiling.
It all ends in an incredibly gooey climax so the squeamish should probably give this one a miss.
1. The Silence Of The Lambs
Won: Best Picture, Best Director, Best Actor, Best Actress, Best Screenplay
Also Nominated For: Best Sound, Best Film Editing
The first movie since One Flew Over The Cuckoo’s Nest to bag all the top Oscars, Silence is, like all trendsetting movies, both the best and worst thing that ever happened to the genre. While it raised the bar for what a horror could be (who’d have thought you could win an Oscar for biting a guy’s face off?), it also paved the way for Hannibal (2000), Red Dragon and Hannibal Rising. Which frankly is unforgivable.
Hard to believe now, but when Silence was was first unleashed on American audiences (it was released on Valentine’s Day 1991!), a movie where the FBI hunt a serial killer seemed like a novelty. On top of that, it was difficult not to be charmed by Anthony Hopkins portrayal of Hannibal Lecter as witty and urbane.
His grace and good humor will win you over in a heartbeat, but as Jodie Foster discovers in one of the most famous (and quoted) scenes, if you get too close he’ll consume your organs with fava beans and a nice Chianti. Hopkins may have been parodied more than any Oscar winner since Marlon Brando in The Godfather, but that just proves how persuasive he is in the role.