15 Actors Who Were Almost Cast In Harry Potter

These guys just missed out on their Hogwarts' acceptance letter.

The Harry Potter movies may have deviated from the books in some pretty major ways, but they did get a lot right in capturing the essence of J.K. Rowling's novels. The increasing maturity of the stories and overall magic of the world is well captured, while the characters are perfectly observed. Across the board the casting choices were spot-on. The young actors all progressed through puberty at a rate that matched their on screen development, while the plethora of British thespians who filled out the adult roles were spot on; it feels like if you weren't in Harry Potter, you just weren't a prominent enough actor. Of course, when dealing franchise this big, with so many characters, some actors are going to miss out on being a part of it. Some managed to get a part the second time around - David Thewlis almost got the role of Professor Quirrell in The Philosopher's Stone, before getting the much meatier Remus Lupin - but most ended up having to view the franchise as a behemoth they weren't quite a part of. Today we bring you fifteen of those actors who narrowly missed out on being a part of the wizarding world. The squibs of acting, if you will.

Honourable Mention - J.K Rowling As Lily Potter

In what would have been one of the most over-the-top in-jokes of all time, J.K. Rowling was considered for the role of Lily Potter in The Philosopher's Stone. Although it would be quite cool to see the creator of Harry Potter as his literal mother, it could have easily ended up a little too much, pulling us out of the action. At least she has the same eye colour as Harry - the same can't be said of the actresses who ended up playing Lily.

15. Kate Winslet - Helena Ravenclaw

When Harry Potter kicked off the ghosts were central to the appeal. Given a massive amount of screen-time relative to their actual importance to the plot, they were everywhere, with John Cleese even getting fourth highest billing (behind the three leads) on The Philosopher's Stone. As the series went by they played a less prominent role, but there was still one ghostly character who would prove essential in the story's finale; Helena Ravenclaw. The daughter of Rowena Ravenclaw, Helena helps Harry find her mother's diadem, one of Voldemort's last remaining horcruxes in The Deathly Hallows. In the film she's played by Kelly Macdonald, but originally the part of the Grey Lady was offered to Kate Winslet. A massive star even by Potter standards, Winslet never got a say on whether she'd take the role or not, with her agent rejecting the offer out a rather snobbish view on Potter's prolificness.

14. Hugh Grant - Gilderoy Lockhart

Nobody could have done Gilderoy Lockhart any better than Kenneth Branagh. No doubt channelling other actors he's come into contact with in his time, the actor-director delivered an entertaining performance as the egotistical author-cum-teacher, despite toning down some of his more unlikable characteristics from the book. It was a shame a scene seeing him still unrecovered from his memory loss in Order Of The Phoenix was cut; he's one of our favourite characters from the whole series. Branagh, however, was not the first choice for the part, with Lockhart originally being offered to, and accepted by, Hugh Grant. Grant only left the project when scheduling conflicts got in the way. Quite what his Lockhart would have been like remains to be seen, although if his Daniel Cleaver from Bridget Jones' Diary is anything to go by he'd have been a little more out-and-out detestable.

13. Patrick McGoohan - Albus Dumbledore

The saga of casting Dumbledore is a long one with countless actors considered and dismissed at various points. It stretches through this list, but we'll start at the very beginning. Patrick McGoohan is best remembered for sixties TV show The Prisoner, which remains a touchstone in mystery television, but leaves the actor in relative obscurity. However, had things gone slightly differently, he could have been much more prolific. Not only was he in the running to play James Bond in Dr. No, but he also had the opportunity to play Dumbledore, headmaster of Hogwarts. Citing health reasons, McGoohan turned down the role, leaving the door open for Richard Harris, who would play the wizard in the first two films before his death in 2002.

12. Bob Hoskins - Horace Slughorn

To many Bob Hoskins is best remembered for the role of the gruff Eddie Valiant in Who Framed Roger Rabbit. Playing things rather straight next to his elastic cartoon co-stars, that's just the tip of his extensive career. Beyond his most well-remembered role, Hoskins was a top notch character actor, delivering a wide range of performances that suggested he'd have been a good fit for the eccentric Horace Slughorn. Hoskins was considered for the new potions master with an obsession with famous students, but lost out to Jim Broadbent. Given how enjoyable the latter was it's hard to get too worked up about. This wasn't Hoskins only run in with the franchise though. J.K. Rowling once said she'd write a character Hoskins could play on screen, with her subsequently stating the seventh book had an older wizard suitable for him, although nothing came from it.

11. Robson Green - Sirius Black

The Prisoner Of Azkaban brought with it a major shift in the series. With director Alfonso Cuarón replacing Christopher Columbus and the tone of the movies getting decidedly darker, it stands as the bridge between the original child adventures and the epic action that followed. Columbus was quite happy to leave the series, having barely come up for air during the production of the last two films, but before he did he had some involvement in Prisoner's pre-production. One piece of his input was suggesting casting Robson Green as Harry's godfather Sirius Black. Bringing in an actor whose work is exclusively in British television probably wouldn't have been the best choice for the ever growing series, which the rest of the film-makers obviously agreed with. Gary Oldman was eventually offered the part, although he only took it because he needed to money. Good, accidental choice Gary.

10. David Walliams - Barty Crouch Jr.

Here's one of the more ridiculous almost-castings for the series. In the early films Harry Potter provided a home for actors with a history in comedy - John Cleese, Zoë Wanamaker and Rik Mayall all acted in the first film (although the latter was cut) - but by the time the fourth movie rolled around things were getting more serious. Humour still played a role, although you'd think not to extent of any stunt casting. Well you'd think wrong. Goblet Of FIre director Mike Newell and co. offered David Walliams the part of the un-polyjuiced Barty Crouch Jr., a small but effective role in the fourth film. With his once-funny Little Britain entering its third series Walliams didn't have the time to spare, with another David, this time Tennant, coming on board. In the years since Walliams has become a prolific children's author himself, with his creations also getting their live-action versions (although none to the same success as Potter).

9. Tilda Swinton - Sybill Trelawney

Professor Trelawney is a character done rather badly by in the movies. Trotted out whenever the story demands a weird character or a bit foreshadowing, her biggest contribution, the prophecy fortelling Voldemort's destruction, is reduced to little more than a plot device propagating a generic chosen one plot. Still, Emma Thompson gives it her all, fully embracing the ridiculousness of the character and amping up the ambiguity of her real divination skills; she's memorable for her personality, if not her actions. Early on in pre-production Tilda Swinton was offered the part, but had to immediately turn it down due that recurrent issue, scheduling conflicts. Swinton subsequently said to the press that she'd never star in Harry Potter because she doesn't believe in it. No, she wasn't showing disbelief in magic; she's morally against boarding school.

8. Peter O€™Toole - Albus Dumbledore

When he fell into ill health after filming The Chamber Of Secrets, Richard Harris told the producers to not recast Dumbledore, confident he'd pull through. Sadly he didn't, with the producers having no choice but to find a replacement headmaster. The first actor considered was Peter O'Toole, the iconic British thespian best known for Lawrence Of Arabia. Harris' family were keen for O'Toole to take over Albus; not only was he obviously a great actor, but he had been a good friend of Richard. And we must say he'd have been a good shout for the role. However, Warner Bros. were a little worried; O'Toole was in his seventies, with health issues a very real issues. They didn't want to have to go through the whole recasting process again, so went with Michael Gambon, who was eight years younger.

7. Rosamund Pike - Rita Skeeter

The character of Rita Skeeter is rather prophetic. Intended as a dig at journalists who twist and fabricate stories with nary a thought for those involved, the reveal that much of her column inches come from spying on celebrities in the form of a beetle is somewhat predicting the phone-hacking scandal that rocked the British press around the time of the final film's release. Of course, that whole animagus subplot was cut from the films. And here's why. In Goblet Of Fire Skeeter's played by Miranda Richardson, but the role was first offered to a then-rising Rosamund Pike, fresh off Die Another Day. When she learned the part would have her contracted into the fifth film as well, despite rather minimal screen-time, Pike backed away. It appears that with that move the character's presence was also reduced, with Richardson's take little more than a cameo.

6. Billy Connolly - Xenophilius Lovegood

You don't have to travel far in the internet to find people who assert that Billy Connolly was in the Harry Potter movies. And obviously they're completely, totally, utterly wrong. Unless they're for some reason talking in a world of hypotheticals. Shortly after the final book was released, there were widespread reports the Billy Connolly was going to play Xenophilius Lovegood, father of Luna and one of the most ignored bastards of the series. Xenophilius (the character Rowling no doubt offered up there for Hoskins, as mentioned a few points ago) eventually went to Rhys Ifans, who was really overshadowed by the exemplar animated sequence slap-bang in the middle of his scene. Connolly will star in another big screen fantasy later this year; he'll play Dáin Ironfoot, Thorin's pig-riding cousin, in The Hobbit: The Battle Of The Five Armies.

5. Tim Roth - Severus Snape

Picture the scene: Severus Snape walks into the Potter's house in Godric's Hollow, discovers the evil work of the Dark Lord and cradles the dead Lily in his arms, uttering "I love you, Honey Bunny." That's a rather protracted way of saying that Tim Roth was almost cast as Severus Snape, the turncoat Death Eater who over seven books/eight films comes out as the franchise's best character. With Alan Rickman delivering a career-best performance as the potions master it's hard to comprehend anyone else donning the robes. Which makes it all the more surprising Roth was an initial favourite for the part. Frontrunner in the casting process, Roth dropped out so he could star in Tim Burton's The Planet Of The Apes. Probably one of the worst career decisions ever.

4. Robin Williams - Rubeus Hagrid

In the aftermath of his death, there was a lot reported about roles Robin Williams almost played - the Joker, Jack Torrance, Willy Wonka. Clearly had things gone a little differently the late actor could have been even more prominent. What would have probably put his face out there the most was the role of Rubeus Hagrid in Harry Potter, which the actor was reportedly very keen in playing. While Williams, who was Warner Bros.' favourite to play Hogwarts' groundskeeper was never but offered the part, he did have a big impact on the Harry Potter series. Resolutely against the choice, Rowling decreed that not only would Williams not play Hagrid, but that all actors in the film would have to be British. With her getting final refusal on all casting, the producers had no choice but to comply. Robbie Coltrane eventually got the part and did a better, less over-the-top version than Williams would have delivered. Oh, we shouldn't have said that.

3. Richard E. Grant - Lucius Malfoy

Lucius Malfoy initially seemed like such a simple character to pin down. The father of Harry's school rival Draco, he's clearly a bad'un from the off. But the reveal that he was and still is one of Voldemort's Death Eaters had a whiff of shock to it, while the subsequent disgrace of him and his family by the Dark Lord is definitely unexpected. This arc makes him one of the series more interesting villains (Bellatrix, for all her menace, is much more by the numbers). Jason Isaacs (Hello to...) did a bang up job portraying the character's fall and even added some significant elements to him; he suggested giving Lucius long hair. Before he was cast, however, Withnail himself, Richard E. Grant was considered for the role. Now that's an interesting what if; could he have matched Isaacs' menace? Bill Nighy was also rumoured for the part and eventually appeared in the series as Rufus Scrimgeour, the new Minister for Magic.

2. Ian McKellen - Dumbledore

After Richard Harris' death numerous actors were considered to take over Dumbledore, some more suitable than others. Hearing that Richard Attenborough lobbied for the role makes a lot of sense; he did, after all, do kindly old man greatly in Jurassic Park. But then the productions initial interest, Christopher Lee is more questionable; surely his horror history doesn't make him a great fit. One of the most interesting considerations was Ian McKellen, who had already found recent mainstream success with other big franchises, playing Magneto in X-Men and Gandalf in The Lord Of The Rings. Most people assume that McKellen turned down the role because of its similarities to Gandalf (who no doubt provided original inspiration for Rowling), although there's something a little more personal at work; Harris had called McKellen a dreadful actor, meaning him taking the role would have been woefully disrespectful.

1. Liam Aiken - Harry Potter

Of course, all of these different castings would have had a minor impact on the series compared to having a different Harry at its core. Daniel Radcliffe has stated he thinks he's "not very good" at acting, but as Harry Potter he was pretty damn great; like his co-stars Rupert Grint and Emma Watson he matured with the character and successfully pulled off some of the more complex, emotional scenes. Of course we don't know quite what effect a different lead actor would have had, although we doubt it would be any massive improvement. Before Radcliffe was cast, the role was offered to Liam Aiken, but then immediately retracted. Why? Had director Christopher Columbus, who had worked with Aiken on Stepmom, acted out of turn? Or had Aiken done something to unearn him the role? Nope; Aiken wasn't British. As we've already seen, Rowling forbade any non-Brits from starring in the series, so Aiken was clearly unsuitable. While we have no idea how his Harry would compare to Radcliffe's, having an American Potter would certainly have had a negative effect on the totally British series as a whole. Aiken hasn't been that prolific in the years since missing out on Potter, with his most recognised roles coming in The Road To Perdition and Lemony Snicket's A Series of Unfortunate Events over a decade ago. Which other actors were almost cast in Harry Potter? Would any have been better than who ended up in the films? Let us know in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Film Editor (2014-2016). Loves The Usual Suspects. Hates Transformers 2. Everything else lies somewhere in the middle. Once met the Chuckle Brothers.