Kevin Kline: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

Let's look back over the awesome and the cringeworthy points in his career and hope that his role in Last Vegas doesn't find a home among the latter.

Kevin Kline's three-decade career in film has been interesting in that he works with many of the same directors, writers, and actors over and over again. Having done six films with director Lawrence Kasdan, two apiece with directors Alan J. Pakula, Richard Attenborough, Irwin Winkler, and Ivan Reitman, as well as frequent collaborations with the likes of Kenneth Branagh, Sigourney Weaver, and John Cleese - it's safe to say that the man doesn't have any trust issues. This kind of career is interesting on one hand for the inevitable comparisons between all of these various collaborations, but it's also interesting to see when Kline takes on new roles with new people. His latest film, Last Vegas, which opens in the UK on Friday, is just such a role. Jon Turteltaub directs this romp through Sin City with Kline and three other spring chickens you may recognize - Robert De Niro, Michael Douglas, and Morgan Freeman, all of which have already gone through our regular Friday column dissection (Douglas, ironically, for when Last Vegas was released in the US at the end of last year... simply click on their names above to be re-directed to their respective entries). While Kline may not be the most famous of that bunch, he's certainly had his fair share of success in Hollywood. Let's look back over the awesome and the cringeworthy points in his career and hope that his role in Last Vegas doesn't find a home among the latter.

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Joey Boca - I Love You To Death (1990)

One of Kline's many efforts under director Lawrence Kasdan has him starring as the loudmouthed, unfaithful pizzeria owner Joey Boca. Finally coming to the realization of Joey's frequent infidelity, his wife Rosalie (Tracey Ullman) opts for the most drastic of measures - killing him. What follows is over-the-top roguery involving poisoned pasta, reggae, and William Hurt and Keanu Reeves as the two most incompetent hit men in the world. Kline is nothing if not lovable as the buffoon Joey. Sure, an actual Italian-American might have been less distracting, and Kline's caricature of the dough-spinning, mustachioed Joey almost approaches that level of stereotype. But this is not the kind of film you hold up as an example of something like that, and the actors are all well aware of this. This is farcical comedy, over-the-top in almost every sense of the phrase, and Kline is hilariously comedic throughout. Some actually find this to be one of Kline's worst roles, but when you consider how differently the film could have turned out you realize how much of the success can be attributed purely to him. Picture how annoyingly bad it could have been if it were made with one of today's "funny guys" - picture Adam Sandler hacking a thick Italian accent - and you'll appreciate Kline's ease with this kind of comedy.

4. Tulio - The Road To El Dorado (2000)

Tulio from The Road to El Dorado fits nicely with Joey Boca in the mischievous fast-talking hustler category. Alongside Kenneth Branagh's Miguel, Tulio escapes imprisonment for petty crimes and finds El Dorado, the golden land that time forgot, nestled in the South American rainforest. The pair are mistaken for gods and hatch various plans to extract gold from the city, and Kline's vocal performance is unparalleled. Much of the pacing of the movie can be attributed to the rapid-fire exchanges between Tulio and Miguel, and were it not for their quick banter the otherwise plot-light El Dorado would certainly drag. And Kline's vocal performances are often overlooked - he lent his voice to The Tale of Despereaux as well as Disney's two Hunchback of Notre-Dame movies. As Tulio, though, he's perfect. A mix of gusto and idiocy makes for a frustratingly likable quality found in so many of his live-action roles, and to bring that quality to a character using only your voice is surely no small feat. This is why Tulio numbers among his greatest roles - while Kline is an impressive physical actor, boasting an almost Jim Carrey-esque ability to make his face and body seem like rubber, his subtle delivery of dialogue may take a backseat to his visual antics. But when Kline stands behind the animated Tulio, his ease with dialogue and his grasp of language can be appreciated more fully. Ultimately, this makes for a memorable role and an enjoyable movie, which I believe is kind of the point.

3. Dave Kovic/Bill Mitchell - Dave (1993)

Throughout Kline's career he's had both success and failure playing both the buffoon and the aristocrat, but only in Ivan Reitman's comedy Dave does he have the opportunity to play both simultaneously. Unlike some other movies in Kline's filmography, Dave does not attempt to pass itself off as anything but a highly unrealistic comedy. The plot - President Bill Mitchell (sophisticated Kline) falls ill and is replaced by hapless lookalike Dave Kovic (slob Kline) - is both ridiculous and overdone in the world of cinema (see Kagemusha, The Prince and the Pauper, and The Prisoner of Zenda, among others). Dave has all the cliche elements of an early 1990s feel-good comedy, but when that montage kicks in - yes, montage - the fact is that you actually do feel pretty damn good. Dave is having a blast playing Prez, Kline is having a blast playing Dave, and despite the whole been-there-done-that premise, you might find yourself having a blast watching it all over again. This is the kind of role that would be easy to overact, perhaps making Dave into more of a slob or the President into more of a gentleman in order to highlight the differences between the two. But there is much more subtlety in Kline's performance(s), and his apparent effortlessness as an actor is what keeps the film from slipping into the abyss with all of those other feel-good '90s flicks. Instead, you get the sense that all of those cliches were actually riffing off Dave rather than the other way around, and if that's not high praise for an actor's ability to make the same old thing feel fresh again then I don't know what is.

2. Nathan Landau - Sophie's Choice (1982)

Kline was a big deal on the Broadway circuit before he ever appeared on the silver screen, garnering multiple Tony awards and even being dubbed "the American Olivier" after his numerous appearances at the New York Shakespeare Festival. When he finally took his first film role in Alan J. Pakula's adaptation of Sophie's Choice, he found himself starring opposite none other than Meryl Streep. Streep had already garnered one Academy Award and would win her second for the role of Sophie, but Kline's first screen performance deserves laudation as well. Nathan Landau, Sophie's short-fuse lover, is by turns tender and abusive toward her, swinging violently from one mood to the next as the film progresses. The explosive first scene, in which Nathan is convinced that Sophie has been unfaithful to him and proceeds to heap a brutal verbal attack on her, perhaps shows Kline still attached to his theatre roots; he is loud and animated, immediately projecting his character above the frail figure of Sophie, and one might think Kline had just ignored the rolling cameras. But his next scene, in which he literally apologizes for his prior outburst, sees Kline enter into the cinematic tradition. He is quiet, no doubt holding that capacity for rage at bay, and achieves no small amount of charm as he sits casually on a windowsill. Later in the film, Nathan is revealed to be a paranoid schizophrenic, and all of the turbulent emotion required by such a part would come to prove that Kline was a film actor here to stay.

1. Otto - A Fish Called Wanda (1988)

Putting in his only Oscar-winning performance to date, Kline has never been so sidesplittingly hilarious as in A Fish Called Wanda. It would seem the obvious choice for the #1 entry on the Most Awesome list, but the fact is that despite his demonstration over a thirty-year career of being able to handle almost any kind of role, Otto was the role he was born to play and likely the role he'll be remembered for. To paraphrase one of Roger Ebert's initial reviews on the movie, there's something that's quite simply refreshing about knowing in the first scenes of a movie that the entire thing is going to be packed with laughs. These laughs can first be attributed to the Monty Python-style writing and the great acting from John Cleese, Jamie Lee Curtis, and Michael Palin - but if you only remember one thing about A Fish Called Wanda, it's almost certainly the dim-witted intellectual Otto. There are too many hilarious lines to quote here. Again, the physical acting that Kline brings to the performance is as impressive as ever - the sex scene being the funniest - and while his Italian-American Joey Boca in I Love You to Death is charming enough, the use of the Italian language here is used to greater comic effect. Whenever I hear a fake Italian accent I think of Kline singing "Volare" or him standing, shirtless, with a pair of panties draped on his head, majestically intoning: "Benito Mussolini".

5 Performances That Sucked...

5. Luc Teyssier - French Kiss (1995)

We've seen already that Kline has had success playing the Italian-American and the American who can't speak Italian. The actor is an aficionado of French, too, and among other roles plays a convincing old recluse in 2009's Joueuse (or "Queen to Play", by the English title), a role in which almost all of his lines are in French. His turn as Frenchman Luc Teyssier in Lawrence Kasdan's 1995 film French Kiss is less convincing, but it numbers among Kline's worst performances for another reason: he's just plain unlikable. We meet him on a plane, seated next to Meg Ryan's character Kate, and soon discover the slightly-crass Parisian to be a petty crook. What follows is a fairly predictable if not altogether unenjoyable romantic comedy, as Luc's smuggling operation demands the unwitting cooperation of Kate. There is little to no chemistry between the two leads, and every now and then you get the sense that Kline may even be aware of this. In the opening scene on the plane he is cold and detached, and he hardly warms as the plane lands and the movie plods through Paris. While Kline's French accent is actually quite good, his outward appearance almost undoes everything his voice works to have us believe, as if we would nod amiably and note that he has not shaved, his jacket is made of leather, and his shirts are free-flowing around his neck, and so he must automatically be French. For an actor who is usually engrossing and not unbelievable for a moment, Kline really struggles to make Luc Teyssier into a sympathetic character.

4. Jeffrey Andersen/Dr. Rod Randall - Soapdish (1991)

Soapdish is apparently meant to be a satirical take on the world of daytime soap operas. Starring Sally Field as an aging soap queen, Whoopi Goldberg as her agent, and Robert Downey Jr. as the scheming show runner, this comedy from director Michael Hoffman takes a peek behind the scenes of these daily dramas. I understand that Soapdish is supposed to be a self-indulgent parody of the soap world, but it fails to do anything meaningful with that intention and isn't really funny enough to be propped up by humor alone. Did I forget to mention anyone named Kevin Kline in that summary? Perhaps that's because his character is instantly, utterly, truly forgettable. As washed-up actor Jeffrey Andersen, Kline hardly appears in the first half of the film outside a few brief glimpses, and by the time his connection to the rest of the action is revealed, the charm of the "real life is just like a soap opera!" gimmick has all but worn off (perhaps there's a reason actual soaps last no longer than a half-hour). When Andersen plays Willy Loman in a dinner-theatre production of Death of a Salesman, the geriatric audience probably pays about as much attention as the Soapdish audience. He's supposed to look out of place here€but not like this. It's a mystery to me why Kline would take a thankless role like this, especially coming off some strong comedic performances in the previous years. Soapdish is one you can skip.

3. Alvin - No Strings Attached (2011)

Speaking of out-of-place Kline, his role in the 2011 Ashton Kutcher/Natalie Portman vehicle No Strings Attached would seem an equally random choice as his role in Soapdish. Here he is mostly a minor character, playing the cheating (why is Kline always cheating?), devil-may-care father of Ashton Kutcher's character Adam. He lifts weights, he plays piano, he delivers a few lines, and then the movie ends - that's about the extent of the enjoyment to be had here, and Kline doesn't really seem to be having any much more fun than we are. You would think his involvement, however minor, would be touted so as to lend some credibility to the movie among filmgoers who aren't Kutcher fans. "Kevin Kline's in it," they'd think, "so it mustn't be a total loss." But his name is nowhere to be found on the posters and the poor guy doesn't even make the trailer. Ludacris makes the trailer, for goodness sake. Twice. No Strings Attached was directed by the once-promising Ivan Reitman - director of Stripes, Ghostbusters, and the 1993 Kline comedy Dave. Again, Kline has a penchant for working with collaborators multiple times, but there is very obviously no chance that No Strings Attached would have success attempting to replicate any magic Reitman and Kline found with Dave. But they could have at least tried.

2. The Pirate King - The Pirates Of Penzance (1983)

Again, Kline proved himself an admirable stage thespian long before he ventured into Hollywood, and won a Tony Award for Best Leading Actor in a Musical in a celebrated production of The Pirates of Penzance in 1981. That production would head to the screen two years later with almost all of the original casting intact. The film version would receive generally positive reviews despite a limited theatrical release, and Kline likewise received praise playing the same role for which he'd already won a Tony. And yet the new-to-film actor, in his portrayal of the tenderhearted Pirate King, is very clearly still stuck on the stage in spite of the rolling cameras. While it might not be considered "overacting" on a stage, and while that still may be a bit of harsh criticism here, one gets the sense that Kline doesn't really know when to just turn it down a notch. When not speaking, he looks frantically from one character to the next as if watching Murray vs. Nadal. When he does have a line, there seems to be little discrimination as to what the line is, as if he's still shouting what he's memorized at a theatre full of the deaf - at one point, in offering transport to young Frederic, he exclaims with as much gusto as he can possibly muster, "Don't swim€TAKE THE DINGHY!" There is definitely some impressive physical acting on display here, as is usually the case with Kline, effortlessly zipping back and forth and up and down the masts of the pirate ship. The problem is that he never has the opportunity for a quieter scene, something to counterbalance these more theatrical moments as he had in his previous film, Sophie's Choice. I'm certainly not comparing that film to The Pirates of Penzance, and the lack of material is perhaps not Kline's fault, but it doesn't do away with the disappointing realization that any stage thespian could have played the Pirate King with as much success, provided they have copious chest hair and the ability to stand for an hour and a half with feet shoulder-width apart.

1. Artemus Gordon - Wild Wild West (1999)

I tried really hard, for the sake of something unexpected and shocking, to not include this as the top entry on the Sucked Hardest list. You can't blame Kline for joining this movie based on the people involved, with the ever-respected Kenneth Branagh and the up-and-coming Will Smith as stars and the seemingly-capable Barry Sonnenfeld behind the camera. I'm not sure if there's some kind of record for respected actors and filmmakers collaborating on what turns out to be absolutely awful, but I am sure that Wild Wild West is absolutely awful. As U.S. Marshal Artemus Gordon, Kline runs the gamut from cross-dressing to being one-upped by Will Smith's swaggering Jim West at every turn. The pair play the only agents able to stop Kenneth Branagh's power-hungry Dr. Loveless from effectively dividing the United States into fractured territories using magnets and robot spiders. There are a few bad performances on this list earned by Kline through a seeming lack of interest, especially his detached, throwaway roles in French Kiss and Soapdish. The case with Wild Wild West is a much more painful one, because here he really tries. By god, does he try. It's excruciating to see the former Oscar and BAFTA winner caked in pale makeup and toddling around in a dress with a large bottom. It's even more painful how feeble is connection to the rest of the movie is, despite his clear effort. He meshes not at all with Will Smith, which was a doomed match from the start, and his ease with lines both dramatic and comedic seems to have evaporated. To properly describe Wild Wild West one need only list synonyms for "drivel", "vapid", and "exhausting". Kevin Kline is, in my opinion, a great actor, and because of that we've come to expect (and deserve) so much better.

Contributor

Matt is a writer and musician living in Boston. Read his film reviews at http://motionstatereview.wordpress.com.