10 Amazing Video Games That Are TERRIBLE To Play

Can we all admit that Bioshock's gameplay is actually pretty bad?

Bioshock big daddy
2K

There’s a delicate balance between the different aspects of a video game, all adding up to one final product.

Sure, some could argue that gameplay is king and should be prioritised at all costs, but in the current landscape of experimental, artistic and stylistic video games, that isn’t always the case. Other aspects, such as a great story, captivating writing, interesting characters, an engaging world or even the atmosphere, can play just as big a part of any video game as the gameplay itself.

Don’t believe me?

Well, this list will look at great video games that were let down by their gameplay. Do bear in mind two things, though:

Firstly, we're not necessarily talking about masterpieces. The gameplay in these titles stopped them being something more than great; something perfect.

Secondly, each game on our list has the potential to be enjoyed by almost everyone, though, there is one glaring exception we’ll come to later on.

Ultimately, it’s a balancing act between the active and passive content the game offers, and sometimes, when shooting countless baddies can get tiresome, the plot points and twist at the end can reel you back in.

Others though... it just stays tiresome.

10. Alan Wake

Alan Wake
Remedy

Alan Wake, developed by Remedy Entertainment, who also released last year’s Control, is based around a writer struggling with insomnia, paranoia and demons.

The game hinges on its eerie atmosphere, narrated by Alan himself who ends up in all sorts of weird, frightening scenarios due to his sleep deprivation. However, what lets the game down is the repetitive gameplay of shining a light to pacify enemies, as only then can you shoot them.

You’ll go from wielding a pocket torch to a security flashlight, to some giant a** handheld spotlight, switching between single-action weapons. Yet, most of the time, you'll find yourself trying to avoid as many enemies as possible in order to quickly get to a new checkpoint.

This becomes even more tedious when searching for collectibles or going for achievements, as the way forward is often locked off until all enemies are dead.

Beyond repetitive, flashlight-shining gameplay, Alan Wake boasts some interesting characters and genuinely funny dialogue to help blanket the issues. As well as really cool set-pieces and environments that ramp up as the paranoia deepens.


9. BioShock

Bioshock 1 big daddy
2K

Generally accepted as one of the greatest games of all time, there isn’t a lot that BioShock doesn’t have going for it. We could also easily use BioShock Infinite as a parallel. example. Both games’ stories are fantastic, with two premises that had never been seen before, relating to that of slavery and choice, time-travel and alternate universes, respectively.

They also have incredible environmental design. The original being set in Rapture, an underwater city made for the highest of society to thrive, away from the riff raff above. Infinite went to the other extreme, taking to a city above the clouds, Columbia, controlled by a prophet and dictator.

What let it down, then?

Well, most agree that, although not the worst thing you’ll ever experience, the gameplay was very simplistic. We’ll continue our examples in light of the original. You go to a new area, meet a key character, boom, your road ahead becomes blocked.

You now have to do something for this key character in order to continue and of course, it requires killing countless enemies and… taking photographs of them to gain bonuses?

A unique idea at the time, but one that has not been missed in the modern era.


8. Final Fantasy XV

Final Fantasy XV doing a fish
Square-Enix

There’s nothing inherently wrong with Final Fantasy XV’s gameplay, in all honesty. Though, it was somewhat of a departure from the other hundred games’ mechanics.

The biggest issue with the gameplay was the pacing. At one point you’d be in an all-out battle with a group of soldiers, where you now have to flick through menus and plan your attacks or, of course, just button mash. Then, you’d be slowly driving through the countryside, always driving.

In fairness to Final Fantasy XV, it does a lot of things right and if you have the time, patience and understanding,, it’s a damn fine experience. Countless unique characters, regardless of how short they’re on screen. A variety of things to do. Even fishing, for goodness sake.

You’ve also got an epic, if not convoluted story. Yet, many people didn’t get to enjoy any of it because the game can is incredibly drawn out. In conclusion, sometimes the answer is not to add more things for variety.

Instead, it is to focus on what you already have, refining it and making the core gameplay loop as fun as possible.


7. Mafia 3

mafia 3
2K

Mafia 3 had the exact opposite problem to Final Fantasy XV. Some games spread themselves too thin and others become so boring it’s a surprise anyone made it past the prologue.

If you did make it past Mafia 3’s prologue, though, you’d be hit with one of the coolest openings to any game in the last decade. It kicks off the narrative and shows the motivations for a lot of characters in the story.

This story, as well as cut-scenes, though, are about as good as it gets.

That’s not to say you’re going to be playing a broken, bad game, but you will be playing the same level structure, copied and pasted over, and over, and over.

It’s no exaggeration, and this repetition becomes so overbearing, I could fully understand someone dropping this game entirely. I distinctly remember thinking to myself, “This game would have been so much better as a TV show.”

Mafia 3 is broken up into little episodes, districts, chunks dedicated to different characters and arcs, yet there you are, doing the same kill animation, against the same enemies, in near-identical buildings.

Your only solace is a decent bit of acting afterwards.


6. The Last Guardian

the last guardian
Sony

The long awaited spiritual successor to Shadow of the Colossus, The Last Guardian, disappointed fans with its janky and outright non-responsive gameplay elements. The biggest mechanic is, of course, based around your relationship with a giant dog, rabbit, kangaroo thing, that is present to look after a young boy and help him through his journeys.

That’s the selling point, this unique relationship between the two entities. What’s most unfortunate about this, is that the contact between them, motivated by the player, is often so busted that it takes you right out of the experience. If you don’t believe me, there are countless videos of how bad it can be. It won’t happen to everyone, I’m sure and maybe it’s the vocal minority, but it seems to be the sticking point of The Last Guardian.

A beautiful atmosphere, speechless narrative based around this unlikely duo that’s complemented wonderfully by pretty environments and decent level design. But what good is that when you’re trying to jump across said level and the damn dog won’t catch you. Instead, he’ll just stare, watching you plummet to your death.

There are several of these movement based instances between the two characters that can often end the same way, with you falling or flinging to your death due to an indecisive, oversized rodent.


5. Outlast

Outlast  Ubisoft
Red Barrels Studio

Horror games are difficult to pull off, we know that much. A game like Amnesia had the fortune of being one of the earlier big horror games.

As a result, The Dark Descent didn’t really have to worry about competition. It didn’t have to offer players a menagerie of gameplay elements to keep them occupied, as it was still a new-ish concept.

Outlast, however, came somewhat later and had to compete with titles such as Alien: Isolation, which blew other horror games out of the water due to its scope and source material.

Outlast had one gameplay loop: explore, find danger, run from danger, hide, repeat. With this, it also gave players the responsibility of managing a camera that had to be stocked with batteries. That’s it in regard to Outlast’s gameplay.

On the flip side, it had quite a lot going for it in light of villainous, evil characters and an underlying sinister story. A spooky doctor, naked knife-wielding lunatics, a hulking brute and even ghosts.

It did its best to be a fresh take on the horror genre, being set in a mental hospital with a twist but all in, it was held up by the antagonists and a refreshingly short length that made sure Outlast didn’t overstay its welcome.


4. Spec Ops: The Line

spec ops the line
Yager

Spec Ops flew under almost everyone’s radar. Another military third-person cover shooter, oh and there’s Nolan North again, how unique.

Well, guess what, it actually was unique. It deals with the harsh, mind-bending circumstances of war that are suffered by your standard soldiers. It showcases this through gruesome scenarios and player made choices.

The motivation and effects of said choices are often muddied beforehand to better blur the lines of war. A great example of this is when white phosphorous comes into the mix, as well as the potential for civilians.

The story is awesome. It’s inspired by Joseph Conrad’s Heart of Darkness, which although well-known, is a refreshing portrayal when placed in a video game. The game takes a dive when the reality sets in that you’ll be slogging through deserts and the same sand-ridden city for around ten hours.

Enemy AI is cowardly, at best, meaning that harder difficulties require you to act the same if you want to stay alive.

Duck behind cover, peek, shoot, run, repeat. It’s not the most engaging gameplay loop but luckily, it’s supplemented by a great story and an interesting camaraderie between you and your allies.


3. Heavy Rain

Heavy Rain
Quantic Dream

Heavy Rain is the exception of our list. If there is one game here that cannot be enjoyed by everyone, it’s Heavy Rain. It’s a monstrosity, but it’s the type that you marvel at, wondering, how did this possibly get made?

The answer: too many people said yes to David Cage. In a game with arguably no gameplay, what is there to discuss?

The performances from nearly every character are flat and lifeless, with the story being even more depressing, in all the wrong ways. And yes, there are the right kinds of depressing, as you’ll find out in the next entry. It’s a point-and-click adventure on a controller which strongly, aggressively insists that you use motion controls.

You walk around, interacting and detecting, wandering through the dreary world of murder and mystery. I feel Heavy Rain is given the mark of passable simply because of the time it was released.

There was nothing like it, honestly. It had a deep, interwoven story that felt as if you were playing through episodes in a TV show. It follows a detective-y plot, with drama and a good amount of intrigue.

Ultimately, as aforementioned, whether you enjoy Heavy Rain is a coin toss. Some adore the game and others find the entire execution laughable.


2. Life Is Strange

Life Is Strange
Dontnod Entertainment

Depressing, episodes, minimal gameplay, all words that lead directly into our next entry which could also be described as point-and-click.

This time, however, you have got one absolute banger of a story behind it that is going to make you feel some kind of way. I have never felt more uncomfortable from a video game, and only a few games have had me lying in bed the next week, still thinking, what the fu** just happened in Episode 3?

The story is paced incredibly well, introducing and affirming characters you can genuinely sympathise and relate to, that even change as the game goes on and you make different choices. There are twists, turns and moments that you’ll never forget.

The downside, however, is that there really isn’t a game behind Life Is Strange. You could watch a playthrough online and gain just as much. You play as Max, who wanders around her campus, interacting with people, entities and her environments. In brutal honesty, the gameplay is not engaging.

Somehow, though, it’s still great, if not amazing at what it sets out to do, which is tell a gut wrenching story of choice about a god damn time-travelling college student.


1. Fallout 4

Maze death house saw fallout 4
Bethesda

Fallout 4 was a good game, it just wasn’t a good Fallout game.

From Morrowind all the way to Fallout 4, you can see a blatant, intentional decrease in role-playing elements and a simplification of gameplay mechanics from Bethesda. Why? Because as their releases became more mainstream, the games needed to be streamlined for the now huge audiences.

Fallout 4 is not a bad game, by any stretch. However, beyond a large open world, varied companions, detailed side quests and some okay expansions, the game has two glaring issues with gameplay. Firstly, the dungeon system that was copied from Skyrim.

Almost all hostile structures, be it an abandoned mine, store or factory, are the same; an area full of enemies, where you can rush to the end, face some kind of boss, grab your chest and dip. Second to this is overpowered builds.

The game makes it trivial to get your hands on legendary or unique items, paired with skills and abilities which will have you sprinting at and smashing enemies heads in with your bare fists.

Combining this with the neutered, if not damn near non-existent RPG mechanics and you have a great yet bland game, developed by a company ten years past their prime.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Bioshock
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

A writer of any and all kinds. Lover of video games, films, writing and achievement hunting, as well as streaming.