10 Amazing Video Games That Didn't Deserve To Flop

You can't trust people, Jeremy.

Midnight Suns
Marvel

Unfortunately, we live in a world where money is still king. In the world of video games especially, it doesn't even matter if a video game makes a lot of money, a blockbuster release has to receive a blockbuster payday in order to be viewed as a success and enjoy a sequel.

As a result, there have been so many great games which ultimately became viewed as flops. It didn't matter that they attracted a die-hard group of fans or even smashed it out the park critically by bringing home 10/10s and Game of the Year awards, they didn't make enough money to justify another game or extended support by the developers.

And that's a shame, because while nothing can be taken away from some of the following games and they still work as complete packages, they absolutely deserved to be huge hits as well. So, let's give them the appreciation they deserve today.

10. Marvel's Midnight Suns

marvels midnight suns
Firaxis

The first of two Marvel superhero games on this list, Midnight Suns is an incredible blend of tactical turn-based combat and RPG character building all set within one of the most compelling fictional universes around.

Building on what the developers already crafted in the genre-defining XCOM 2, Midnight Suns allows players to pick from a multitude of different heroes and embark on challenging missions during the day, before returning to base by night to spend time strengthening their relationships and indulging in the aforementioned RPG choices.

It's that second element that's surprisingly the game's biggest strength, as hanging out with the likes of Blade, Wolverine, Spider-Man and more is a comics fan dream come true.

Despite an excellent, lengthy campaign though, Midnight Suns didn't manage to succeed in finding an audience. The developers did everything right, but unfortunately multiple delays, backlash to the game's initial card-based gameplay and a late December release meant that, despite solid reviews, the title failed to sell.

As a result, publisher Take-Two confirmed that the studio was disappointed by the sales of the game, with the director of developer Firaxis leaving the company shortly after.


9. Deathloop

deathloop game
Arkane Studios

Deathloop seemed like a surefire hit.

Aggressively pushed as a console exclusive by Sony (to the point where it got shown so much some players actually got sick of it being marketed so hard) and releasing to a whole bunch of 10/10 scores promising a GOTY contender, it felt like Arkane's latest was guaranteed to find an audience.

The title itself had as much style as substance as well, with a timeloop framing that had you experimenting with a wealth of weapons and powers in order to coordinate the assassination of a bunch of targets all before the day is up.

However, despite its quality the inventive first-person shooter struggled out the gate. Its rave reviews ultimately meant little, as launch day arrived with many people asking the question: is Deathloop overrated?

As this discourse started to dominate in online spaces, it meant that players were skeptical, and Deathloop ended up with the lowest sales in the developer's history. Now, part of that is of course down to it being a PS5 console exclusive, but even with that in mind it's clear the game underperformed for such a critical darling.


8. The Evil Within 2

The Evil Within 2
Tango Gameworks

The Evil Within 2 is one of the best survival horror games of its generation.

Everyone talks up Resident Evil 2 and the recent Dead Space remake, but Bethesda's sequel absolutely deserves to be remembered for its genre innovations, managing to blend scripted horror set-pieces with a more player-driven open world design.

Leagues above its admittedly shaky original, The Evil Within 2's tight shooting and creative narrative delivered some of the genre's most memorable moments, and yet didn't reap the same rewards that the other aforementioned horror games did.

Why? It's not entirely clear. Perhaps it was the tepid reaction to the original that led many to assume a sequel would just be more of the same. Maybe it was a lack of marketing from Bethesda (a publisher notorious at the time for letting great games come and go unannounced). Or maybe it was simply released a few years too soon, before classic survival horror experiences were repopularised.

Whatever the reason, it's a damn shame it sold a mere quarter of the original, and didn't make enough money to guarantee a sequel.


7. Batman: The Telltale Series

batman telltale joker
Warner Bros.

We have no shortage of great Batman games these days. Whether it's the Arkham quadrilogy (yes, Origins rules), Gotham Knights or Lego Batman, fans of The Dark Knight have been eating well.

But one of the best titles starring The Caped Crusader was, unfathomably, a flop. Telltale's The Batman is maybe the only one of the bunch to really deliver on the idea of playing not only as a superhero, but as the human being underneath the mask. Splitting its time between crime fighting and navigating tricky political and personal dramas as Bruce Wayne, this game lived up to the promise of being the DC equivalent of Telltale's own The Walking Dead.

While you might think the popular DC Universe and the developer's beloved narrative-driven games joining forces would be an excuse to print money, Batman: The Telltale Series was a colossal sales disappointment, selling far below the studio's other games, including Game of Thrones, Tales from the Borderlands, The Wolf Among Us and Minecraft: Story mode.

It still received a second season... which sold even less despite keeping the quality high.


6. GRID Legends

GRID Legends
Electronic Arts

You have to feel bad for the GRID franchise. No matter how many great games come out baring its name, no matter how many times the franchise has tried to do something different and attract gamers, it has consistently failed to reach the lofty heights of its peers.

And unfortunately, the latest entry, GRID Legends, is the biggest casualty yet. Despite maintaining the series' signature and satisfying blend of arcade and sim racing and adding an ambitious story mode on top of it, it released last year to little fanfare and even worse sales.

According to Steam data (as reported by GameRant), the title's peak concurrent player count amounted to a measly 455 players, a far cry from the tens of thousands some of its predecessor managed to attract.

With numbers like that, don't expect to see a follow up to this long floundering franchise anytime soon.


5. Silent Hill 2

Silent Hill 2 Remake
Konami

Now it might be shocking to hear, but Silent Hill 2 was considered a flop when it first released. A game that's cited as one of the best of all time today, one due a lavish new remake set for 2023 and one that sits firmly in the hearts of players everywhere was initially considered something of an embarrassing misstep.

Confirmed by series artist Masahiro Ito on Twitter in 2019, the designer admitted that the initial sales of the game were so slow and disappointing - and the fan response so mixed - that the initial plan for Silent Hill 3 was to scrap the established mechanics and tone for something completely different. In fact, if you can believe it, Silent Hill 3 initially started development as an arcade rail shooter.

Of course, this initial 'flop' eventually won fans around and became successful enough to warrant a proper sequel, but that wasn't the case initially.


4. Guardians Of The Galaxy

guardians of the galaxy
Square Enix

As promised, we come to the second Marvel game on this list, and another one that on paper did everything right, yet was crushed by dodgy choices outside of the developer's control.

Guardians of the Galaxy is a great, single-player focused shooter set in the world of Marvel's ragtag heroes. Though it may be disappointing that you only get to play as Peter Quill, the character writing for the whole team is so strong it's easy to overlook. Just getting to hang out with the other Guardians on their ship would be enough to sell this alone, but throw in some visually stunning levels, surprisingly emotional plot turns and an as-expected charming soundtrack, and Guardians of the Galaxy really is the full package.

Unfortunately, the title sank like a stone due to the failure of another Square Enix game called The Avengers. You might have heard of it?

That notorious release was one of the biggest gaming disappointments of the decade, and as such many players were rightly skeptical about picking up Guardians, not helped by marketing that didn't totally make it clear what kind of game it even was.

As a result, despite deserving way more, Square Enix's title came in well under expectations sales-wise, and is unlikely to get a sequel.


3. Sunset Overdrive

sunset overdrive
Insomniac

When you think of Insomniac as a company, you think of hits. Whether it's Ratchet and Clank or Spider-Man, the developers have been cranking out great games for Sony consoles for decades, so it's perhaps fitting that the one foray onto the rival Xbox didn't manage to spark the same interest.

Sunset Overdrive is an inventive, anarchic open-world game that mixes the wacky weapons of the developer's own Ratchet and Clank series with the grinding system of Tony Hawk's Pro Skater. It sounds like a strange mix but it actually worked wonders, making for an addictive gameplay loop bolstered by an interesting and colourful sandbox.

But, that wasn't enough to make it a hit with Xbox players. Admittedly, as an Xbox One exclusive back when that machine was the laughing stock of the industry, it might never have stood a chance, but a wonky reveal trailer which emphasised the title's cringey, meta humour didn't help endear the game to fans either.

So, it's not surprising that the title has never received a sequel, and Insomniac was sold to Sony a few years after this title's launch.


2. Need For Speed Unbound

need for speed unbound
EA

We've talked already about a great racing game that didn't deserve to die already on this list, but 2022 featured another casualty in Need for Speed Unbound.

Similar to Midnight Suns, the latest entry into the identity crisis-ridden NFS franchise was a case of amazing game, wrong time. Dropping in late November after a quick announcement-to-release turnaround and little marketing, the excellent racer struggled out of the gate.

The title's stylistic flourishes perhaps didn't help, with cartoon-y overlays punctuating the otherwise straightforwardly photo-realistic arenas and vehicles. Nor did the general state of the series, with previous instalments coming and going without great reviews or sales.

But Unbound was a brilliant return to form and a treat for fans of arcade racers. Reviews and impressions reflected that too, but it didn't stop the game from debuting at a dreadful no.17 in the UK charts the week it launched, making it an undeniable flop. Or as one report put it, a "mega flop".


1. Alan Wake/Alan Wake Remastered

Alan Wake
Remedy

Now this one hurts.

Remedy's Alan Wake is a beloved horror game. Inspired by the works of Stephen King, The Twilight Zone and Twin Peaks, this odd title is about a pulp writer whose latest story (which he doesn't actually remember writing) is coming to life.

Originally envisioned as the next big Xbox exclusive, the game notoriously had a troubled development. Development started on the basis that Alan Wake would be an open world title, before internal reboots scaled that right down to a regular, third-person shooter experience.

Perhaps fitting considering the title's inspirations, while Remedy's game was well received, it wasn't the major smash hit the company nor Microsoft were expecting. Despite receiving DLC, it didn't make enough to justify a sequel, becoming instead a cult classic.

In a case of history repeating itself, an eventual Alan Wake remaster similarly disappointed in the sales. Still, Alan Wake 2 is finally coming in 2023 - let's just hope it isn't the third strike for this excellent franchise.


Watch Next


Contributor

Josh has over 11 years of experience as a published writer, having worked nine of those years as a full-time content producer at WhatCulture. In that period he has created hundreds of articles, videos and podcast episodes for multiple WhatCulture channels, specialising in gaming, horror and film & TV. He now primarily works as a senior content producer and presenter on WhatCulture Gaming where he co-hosts the WhatCulture Gaming Podcast, a top 3 UK most listened to gaming podcast that he co-created in 2018. Over the years he has reviewed several high-profile gaming releases, covered industry events with on-site reporting, opined on breaking news, and even kicked off his interviewing career by chatting to childhood hero, Tommy Wiseau.