10 Awful Plot Twists That Completely Ruined Great Games

Ending on a whimper, not a bang.

While 'The Shocking Twist' sounds like an EDM remix of a Chubby Checker song, its actual purpose is to deliver something unexpected to film-goers or book readers or game players. When done right, these moments are iconic - be it the end of The Sixth Sense, Reservoir Dogs or the death of Aerith in Final Fantasy VII. They can also be really dumb, and pose countless questions about the plot points that came before - like in The Dark Knight Rises, or in many of the games on this very list you're about to read about and hopefully enjoy. A plot twist, like what your Facebook feed says about handguns, is a tool. In the right hands, it can make a great game legendary, in the wrong hands, it'll massacre any and all positive feelings you have toward a title. Twists must be used responsibility and with much care, or find themselves the subject of internet vitriol and scorn. This list contains twists that were not responsible, nor were they presented with much forethought, instead shoehorned in to set up a sequel, re-engage the player in a wonky narrative, or worse; seemed like a good idea at the time. You can still enjoy many of these titles and have fond memories, but these supposedly shocking developments tarnish the experience in such a way that it's somewhat impossible to rave about a game as much as you would like, especially when the final reveal feels like getting socks on Christmas.

10. Condemned - Your Mouth Turns Into Jowls

Have you seen the ending to Michael Jackson's Thriller? Where you think everything is A-okay, and the whole torturous affair, Vincent Price narration, red velvet jacket, and all - was just a dream. Then Mr. Jackson turns to the camera and his eyes glow yellow and a sinister laugh is heard. If you've played and beat Condemned: Criminal Origins, the above scene will flash through your brain. In the cheapest of cheap twists, upon beating Condemned, it's revealed your character, Ethan, has become infected by the very same demonic power that created the enemies in the game.The problem with this is that it feels woefully cheap and overdone. Dude looking into a mirror, then a shock-scare? What is this, 1998? Up until the ending, Condemned was masterful at building suspense and terror without a ton of cheap scares. In fact the biggest take-away from the game, spook-wise is just how terrifying clothing mannequins can be in the dark. Condemned was great at zagging when you expected it to zig, and it's unfortunate that that many player's lasting image of this fairly unique game will forever be the cheesy, been-there-done-that ending.

9. Far Cry 3 - Win Or Lose, You're An A-Hole!

Far Cry 3's narrative is pretty incredible. For starters it had the gall to present generally unlikable characters, including the protagonist Jason Brody, and then force the player to associate with them. As the game goes on Jason becomes tougher, edgier, and more assertive as his power grows and the player's skills increase. Eventually Jason is forced to choose between his path - the way of the warrior - that has brought him confidence and a fullness to his empty life that he used to placate with club drugs and partying, or saving his friends and leave the island with them. Choosing to stay on the island results in you slaughtering your girlfriend, getting treated to some digitised boobies while impregnating Citra, then getting killed by her as she claims the child you've now sired will go on to lead the tribe to greatness. That's great, but doesn't he need a Dad? If you choose to stay with your friends, a whole bunch of crazy stuff goes down, a few supporting characters end up dead, and you make it off the island as Jason narrates how he's changed and worried he could never go back to the way he was. The problem with both these endings and the twists contained within them is that they feel rushed and constrained, especially for a game that was so wide-open otherwise. While the shock value of both options is real and will give you pause, there's an underwhelming nature to it all, and you can't help but wonder if perhaps there was another, more logical way, to end Jason Brody's journey. As a result, the wonderful game feels ruined at the end, like they had ball in their court and decided to pass it out of bounds.

8. Final Fantasy IX - Kuja Gets Fab-i-fied.

Final Fantasy IX is a favorite among Japanese RPGs fans for a few reasons. For starters it was less deadly serious than Final Fantasy VII or VIII, and as a result felt a lot more whimsical, fun, and flat-out enjoyable than the previous two games in the series while still harboring quite a bit of heart and drama via the stories of ViVi, Dagger, and Xindane. One of the fun in the not-so-good way elements of Final Fantasy IX was its villain, Kuja - specifically at the moment he enters 'Trance' mode. Up until that point Kuja was a wonderfully menacing presence. He wasn't grim or gritty, he was an over-the-top, giddy, mass murdering sociopath that was frightening because of how left-of-center he was - it's not every bad guy who can call someone a canary and rock a feather in their hair, get away with it, and still be a terrifying presence. But the problem with having such a strange villain is that it's a fine line between menacing and comical. When Kuja enters his 'trance' state toward the end of Final Fantasy IX, you may just start to wonder if the Golden Saucer is having a rave and you weren't invited. At this moment Kuja goes from a menacing and kinda / sorta sympathetic character to something resembling a cartoon, and what was supposed to be an important moment in that character's development was met with laughter. Did this twist 'ruin' Final Fantasy IX? Yeah, in that the game's villain was suddenly a joke. Kuja becomes essentially a cartoon character and loses quite a lot of his imposing nature. It seemed Square was aware that Kuja seemed far less scary once he entered 'trance' as he wasn't even the final boss of the game, that particular honor going to Necron, whose quote from Yoda in Star Wars Episode One is a twist that belongs on another, weirder, possibly more positive list.

7. Mass Effect 3 - Shepard, Please Select Your Ending Button

No one would be so entitled to demand a director or writer go back and change the ending to their work so it would be more satisfactory. It's impossible to imagine Steven Spielberg, or Paul Thomas Anderson, or David O. Russel going back and giving the climax of their film another shot because the response was "it's not what we wanted!". But of course, gamers continue to break down barriers, and in this case, found the final creative vision for Mass Effect 3 to be so appalling, they took to their keyboards and through vitriol and complete misunderstanding of how film, creativity, and narrative work, got the ending to the game changed. This sound like Stephen King's Misery to anyone else? But gamers were not...wrong about their reaction to Mass Effect 3. For a game that was all about making dozens of choices and then having their implications play out over the course of three games, for the finale to involve a simple "choose one of these three options" felt a little cheap (and familiar, Deus Ex: Human Revolution did the same thing). See, the twist Mass Effect 3 presented is that, in the end, sometimes the choices you make don't matter. Sometimes it comes down to the here, the now, and the 'get to it already!'. It was a ballsy choice - ultimately disregarding dozens of gameplay hours to make a very specific point about the nature of choice. But it still stung, as there was very little in the way of follow up or closure, regardless of the ending you picked, which, again, is creative and daring, but can understandably leave a bad taste in the mouth of players who dropped 180 dollars for the entire series over the years. For many, Mass Effect 3's ending ruined all that came before, and while the release of extended edition DLC to placate the fan base was a nice touch, by the time it came out, players had moved onto other games, and left only with their soured feelings toward a wonderful franchise.

6. Metal Gear Solid 4 - Big Boss Is Still Alive. Again!

Lets get one thing out of the way. This list could be entirely Metal Gear Solid-related. More than any other game franchise, MGS seems to take wild and insane turns that rarely pay off. The bad guy is the President, Somehow Ocelot *becomes* Liquid Snake when he attached his arm, Metal Gear Solid 2 is a simulation designed to recreate Metal Gear Solid's conditions, and the less said about the ending of Metal Gear Solid 4, the better. So lets say a few things about the ending of Metal Gear Solid 4, specifically the idea that Big Boss is alive and fully capable of coherent thought, despite Snake supposedly killing him in "Metal Gear" and the fact we saw his body burned to a crisp midway through Metal Gear Solid 4 AND the fact the dude's 74 years old and is dressed as sharp as a Ginsu knife. This was the straw that broke the already frail camel's back. For every flight of fancy or logic defying twist the game asked you to take, this moment, this big reveal, was one too many. It's like finding out Darth Vader is Luke's Dad, and also a clone of an Ewok. Worse, Big Boss, like every other character in the game, is there only to provide exposition and wrap up the countless loose ends from the prior games in the most annoying way possible. He's also, literally, a Frankenstein, made from parts of Ocelot, Liquid Snake, and Solidus Snake (from Metal Gear Solid 2) to 're-assemble' his body. Really. This is not something that happened in a fan-fiction write up, this is how they explain the 79 year old Big Boss is alive and well, and capable of kicking the crap out of Solid Snake if he so chooses. If this doesn't ruin any and all positive feelings a person had to this game's narrative, what does? Look, it's not like Metal Gear Solid had very much credibility left after bizarre mushroom trip that was Metal Gear Solid 4, but this final twist was so strange and so out of left field that it became impossible to take anything Metal Gear Solid did seriously again. A point emphasized by the next game where you fight a teenage girl in her underwear who's piloting a giant mech. Really.

5. Bioshock Infinite: You...ARE The Father

"No! Deep is good! People are going to say "what the hell just happened?" and I'd better say I like it because nobody wants to seem stupid!" - Mae Bluth, Arrested Development The above quote, ladies and gentlemen and those in between, seems to be the general reaction to the ending of Bioshock Infinite. A twist so mind-bending, so confusing, so difficult to follow and hard to understand, that you damn well better like it or find yourself kicked off the 'cool gamers' table. The problem with alternate universes, specifically *ahem* infinite universes is that whatever story you're currently playing suddenly feels wildly less important. If there's literally infinite other worlds, and Booker DeWitts, and Elizabeths, what makes YOUR specific universe so special, ya know? There's also the pesky problem of Infinite's other twist, where it turns out Booker is both Comstock, and Booker, and Elizabeth's Dad, and that the timeline split in such a way to make that possible. While there is a logic to what happened, and it's certainly creative, most of this information comes out at such a speed, not unlike the ending of The Matrix Reloaded, that you're essentially left with your controller in hand, mouth agape, head cocked the side, with your eyebrows raised in an arch and your mouth possibly drooling from all the crap you just had to process. Which stinks because the first Bioshock had one of the greatest twists in gaming history, and if you haven't played it, would ya kindly check it out and report back? You'll agree. The twist in Bioshock was good not because it had insane implications about the very fabric of the world, but because it made the player feel like a dope in the best way possible. You felt *played*, and never had a game done that so eloquently. Meanwhile, Bioshock: Infinite opted for a bigger is better approach, with enough metaphysical mumbojumbo to fill at least a two part episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation, and it fell flat because it was so complex - Yes, there are multiple universes and such, and that's a massive reveal, but its not nearly as visceral as the one in Bioshock - which ultimately came down to an office, a golf club, and a brutal series of events that left the player's mouth agape. Unfortunately Bioshock Infinite leaves the mouth agape, too, but only long enough for you to form the words "What..The...Fruit...Was...That...?!". Many gamers bought this game explicitly for the story. Gamers who don't like shooters and don't like hyper-violence, and found themselves forced into both in order to experience a story that climaxed with the cinematic equivalent of a big, wet, fart noise.

4. Grand Theft Auto V: The Obvious "Happy Ending" Mission

Man, you almost had it, Grand Theft Auto V. Right up until the very end. Grand Theft Auto is about our better natures. Michael is a reformed criminal who finds himself stifled by his cushy suburban life - and ultimately finds himself alive and happy and virile for the first time in over a decade because he goes back to his life of crime, despite bemoaning it all the way. Meanwhile, Trevor is a criminal, lives in a crappy trailer, but of all the characters is seemingly the most happy simply because he knows what he is - a monster, and has some great fun with it. Thus at the end of Grand Theft Auto V it's up to Franklin to decide which of these two ideologies is worthwhile - Michael's "this is so much fun but I definitely shouldn't be doing this," hedging of the bets, or Trevors "This is so much fun, why wouldn't everyone do this" mentality. if handled correctly, this moment would make Grand Theft Auto V's plot masterful - having the player decide what purpose Grand Theft Auto itself serves - is it a mass murder simulator you dink around with (and that's okay), or is it something more? Are the chaotic elements players engage in just a piece of the actual experience, or the entirety of the draw? And Grand Theft Auto V offers a cop-out, with a 'suicide' option that results in the happiest of happy endings, with all the characters ultimately making amends, taking out the guy who set them all up, and riding off into the sunset, presumably until the next DLC pack. The twist of having a third 'happy ending' option for the game's final mission ruins the point the game was trying to make spectacularly. That point? That there's a reason you can play golf or tennis see a 20 minute french film in Grand Theft Auto. That reason? You won't. There's a reason why you've given a car and the number of a taxi service at the start of the game too - so you have the option to be a mostly law abiding citizen when not on a mission. But you won't. See, Grand Theft Auto V, more than any other game in the series, is deliberately deconstructing itself and the people who play them. What draws a person to massively violent game where you engage in murder, slaughter, theft, torture, and drug use? Is it fun? Is it escapism? And if yes, what's that say about a person? Are the people playing and buying Grand Theft Auto like Michael? Who hypocritically turn their nose up at the 'offensive' elements while still engaging in the actual game? The kind of folks who bemoan Grand Theft Auto's sexism and racism, but are somehow okay with a game that has you shooting countless cops and murdering dozens of human beings? Or are the people that play Grand Theft Auto more like Trevor? Life's a party, bring beer, ya know? Grand Theft Auto is fun because it's about things we shouldn't do. It's a marijuana cigarette or pirated movie or porno on your big screen TV. Who cares if it's not what you 'should' do, it's what you want to do. And to say that only 'certain' parts of the game are 'okay' is essentially woefully hypocritical, considering, again, the game is literally a sandbox of destruction. Thus when it comes down to Franklin, dead in the center of the spectrum, the choice he makes ultimately informs you as a person, and adding the third, cop-out option, ruined what was a very interesting and startlingly creative subtext that many gamers simply didn't really pay attention too, and the disappointing nature of the ending ensured they never would.

3. Nintendo Thinks You're Stupid, So No Super Mario Bros. 2 For You!

While you may think this twist is about how Mario Bros. 2 is all a dream, the reality is that the big twist contained within the game is that its very existence means Nintendo thought you were stupid. The 'real' Super Mario Brothers 2 wasn't released in America because Nintendo thought it was too hard, and too similar to the first Mario game (though it eventually saw release in Super Mario All Stars on the SNES as 'The Lost Levels'). Instead, America got a re-purposed Doki Doki Panic, resulting in a really, really, strange, Arabian themed, Mario game that didn't sit quite right with players, especially young players who couldn't quite figure out what happened to the Mario game they played to death and loved, and were particularly upset about the lack of their beloved fire flower power up. The fact that Super Mario Bros 2 wasn't actually Super Mario Brothers 2, flat out ruined the game. It's regarded as something of a redheaded step-child of the series, as this thing Americans' got instead of the real game because they weren't tough enough to handle its challenges. When confronted with this revelation, any and all appreciation for Super Mario Brothers 2 fades away and is replaced with scorn and resentment. No-one likes being called stupid, and in this situation, Nintendo was calling an entire country stupid - and regardless of how good a game is, if the reason it exists comes from such a sour place, it's ruined before its even played.

2. Halo 2: Master Chief Finishes The Fight...Sometime Later

You may have heard of this one. Halo 2 is interesting in that it has two pretty big twists. The first is that it does the Metal Gear Solid 2 thing where you expect to be one specific character for the entirety of the game, then get shoehorned into playing as another, different, less cool character. For whatever reason, game developers continue to think this is a good idea despite the fact it has never worked, ever, in the history of everything ever. Considering Halo's relatively complex plot - across books, comics, and various websites, adding a second character was not the thing Halo needed to make its story digestible. But the twist that ultimately 'ruined' the game and left the bad taste in the mouth of pretty much everyone with a mouth is how the ending of the game felt like the start of the final level. With Chief's "I'm Finishing The Fight", then smash-cut to black, players couldn't help but feel they got jobbed out of, well, finishing the fight. This would be like ending The Avengers on "Hulk...Smash!". It's a cool moment, but unless that moment delivers something awesome after it, it's a tease. Obviously Halo's reputation wasn't too harmed by these changes, but the scars still sting, and folks still remember the action / adventure blue balls that were the final line of Halo 2.

1. Assassin's Creed 3 - Haytham Kenway: Cool Dad

Did you ever have a math teacher who would take you aside, go through how to do your homework, fill in all the answers, then erase them all so you could 'do it yourself'? You know that punch in the gut you got after the final correct mark was erased and you were literally back to square one? That is the feeling you get upon completing Assassin's Creed III's opening missions. You're given control of Haytham Kenway, a debonair, well spoken, confident, talented, and possibly well meaning character, and engage in a bunch of really creative and exciting missions in virtual Boston. "Gosh," you may think, "Did Assassin's Creed III get the bait-and-switch right?!". And no. They did not. You thought wrong, and that's what you get for having optimism, you doink. Assassin's Creed III does tries to do the reverse of Metal Gear Solid 2, and it still sucks. Yet again you've given a character far more personable and interesting at the start of the game, only to have control of him yanked away as you're introduced to Connor, the game's 'proper' protagonist. Worse, the game spends quite a lot of time tutorializing the Connor sections despite the fact you've been playing the game for hours up to that point - and the things it teaches you do are ultimately unimportant to the major missions and side contents. And yeah, this 'twist' ruined Assassin's Creed III, in that playing as someone competent and driven like Kenway, then being thrown into the shoes of the novice Connor, felt like a horrible cop out. You spend the rest of the game waiting for Connor to be as cool or personable or flat-out bad ass as his dad, and it never, ever happens - he's blander than particle board, performance-wise having the most in common with Hayden Christensen's take on Aiken Skywalker than any actual Native American person. Eventually Kenway pops up in the game later - and yet again is the coolest person on the planet. Until you kill him. Bummer.

 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Paul is a writer, video producer, gamer, lover, and tie-fighter. E-mail him at MeekinOnMovies@gmail.com.