10 Best GTA Games - Ranked

Over 20 years with some of the most popular games of all time. Which is best?

Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas - CJ
Rockstar North

As one of the most culturally resonant and generation-defining franchises of all time, GTA is not just a video game; not just a series of titles talked about across now two decades, but a bonafide phenomenon that routinely makes Rockstar and Take Two around $5 million dollars a day.

GTA V alone is STILL in many best-selling top ten lists, some five years and counting after its initial release. So inviting, playable and addictive are its various gameplay loops that to millions of us, a few police chases, drug-runs or mountainside races around its labyrinthine pathways are as common as breathing.

Interestingly though, GTA has had one hell of a trajectory if you go all the way back to its top-down 2D incarnation.

Starting life as "Race n' Chase", a more family-friendly arcade racer in the vein of Micro Machines, one chance glitch during development saw the police car models begin to ram other players. This sparked one of the most profitable lightbulb moments in gaming history, as wanted levels and general anarchy-fuelled gameplay soon followed.

GTA now has a plethora of main instalments and just as many spin-offs. It's up there with McDonalds and Disney as one of the most well-known properties of all time... but which game is the best?


10. Grand Theft Auto Online

GTA online
Rockstar

Though it's become increasingly impossible for newcomers to hop in and have a good time without devoting hours to grinding or even resorting to microtransactions, GTA Online is still an astonishing new precedent in game design.

Literally one giant sandbox of communities, power struggles, skill sets and unlockables, many groups of people live entire digital lives inside the confines of this revamped San Andreas.

Rockstar have continually bolstered this with an insane amount of DLC, too. Taking GTA Online far away from what you'd expect out of its namesake, awesome innovations like land, sea and air races, level packs that let you construct daredevil speed runs, in-depth heists and more properties to invest in than ever before have truly capitalised on the notion of "role play" that San Andreas first started.

Defying single genres, GTA Online might be the greatest achievement of Rockstar's career from a pure coding standpoint, but when it comes to Grand Theft Auto there's more to its appeal than just open-world experimentation, and that's where the rest of the franchise comes in.


9. Grand Theft Auto: Episodes From Liberty City

Gta 4 Iv The Ballad Of Gay Tony
Rockstar

Completely overlooked thanks to GTA IV being the first notable dud in the series, both sizeable DLCs "The Lost & Damned" and "The Ballad of Gay Tony" include all the character and personality that was lacking from the base game.

Released as a two-part standalone combo, Episodes is WELL worth checking out - especially if you discarded them because of the attitude towards GTA at the time.

Where GTA IV focused on Niko Bellic's satisfying-enough revenge tale that doubled as a comment on how manufactured the "American dream" can be, Lost & Damned is essentially Rockstar doing a Sons of Anarchy tie-in. Main-man Johnny Klebitz is a tough-talking hog-rider with a heart of gold - someone who fits the GTA protagonist mould, but allows for great story and character beats, too.

The Ballad of Gay Tony is essentially Rockstar teasing out what a modernised Vice City might feel like. There's everything from all-new radio stations to a story that takes you from neon-lit night clubs to the tops of towers - only to base jump all the way back to the bottom again.

That sense of freewheeling, cartoonish anarchy that Vice City and San Andreas revelled in, yet was missing from GTA IV? It's all right here.


8. Grand Theft Auto: Liberty City Stories

Gta liberty city stories
Rockstar

One of the smartest decisions Rockstar ever made, revisiting the iconic, industry-shaking Liberty City on PSP was a masterstroke. Not only because of how they found a way of packing a full GTA game into a handheld, but because many lessons learned from future instalments were retrofitted.

Bikes on the streets, better controls and shooting - not to mention a wider vehicle set overall that brought across Vice City and San Andreas' various rides.

Best of all with this "no harm, no foul" spin-off was it allowed Rockstar to experiment with what a GTA multiplayer mode could be. Slaughtering each other in the six-player Liberty City Survivor deathmatch using any means necessary, ramming players into the scenery when street racing, blowing up bases and commandeering tanks - it was brilliant.

Granted this could only played in local ad-hoc with an assortment of PSP-owning friends, but as a furtive step towards GTA IV and V's online modes, it can't go unnoticed.


7. Grand Theft Auto: Vice City Stories

Gta Vice City Stories
Rockstar

Coming one year after LCS and doing for Vice City what that did for GTA III, Vice City Stories cast us as Lance Vance's tougher older brother, Vic.

Rockstar were clearly listening to the "Why can't we swim?!" complains of Liberty City Stories too, because VCS came complete with even more retroactive improvements. Basic control and vehicle variety upgrades were standard, but finally being able to survive getting knee-deep in water was a godsend.

Vice City Stories continued the original's stellar soundtrack, but what really stood out was this neat Empire Building mechanic. Like San Andreas' respawning turf wars, Vic would have to look after a number of different properties that could be upgraded and staffed with lower-level goons.

Interacting with your crew provided missions that improved the buildings themselves - all while you went out and secured more turf, ensuring your daily take was always on the rise.

Bonuses like clothing sets and better weapons came from maximising your time micro-managing all this stuff, and it remains one of the only times Rockstar put such a mechanic in a GTA game, that didn't feel like a meaningless distraction.


6. Grand Theft Auto: Chinatown Wars

gta chinatown wars
Rockstar

From distracting add-ons to a game that was all about getting lost in minigames and new mechanics, Chinatown Wars was Rockstar's second attempt to make GTA "work" on lower spec hardware.

With GTA Advance being solid enough as a reminder of just how long ago 1997's original was and felt, Chinatown Wars returned again to Liberty City, yet played from a top-down perspective, with tons of The Warriors-esque minigames bringing general gameplay to life in fresh ways.

Rockstar knew that "traditional GTA" as it was post-Vice City, San Andreas and GTA IV wouldn't work, and playing Chinatown Wars is almost like they thought, "Hmm what would GTA be like, if it was developed by Nintendo?"

Seriously, it almost channels Warioware with all the cutaways, seeing you manually fill molotov cocktails, kick open a door if you've fell in a body of water, assemble a sniper rifle, crack safe codes and more.

It being such a drastically different GTA did put many people off, but go in knowing what to expect, and this remains a great shakeup of the standard formula.


5. Grand Theft Auto IV

GTA 4 IV
Rockstar

As mentioned earlier, GTA IV represents Rockstar trying to force the franchise to grow up - completely misreading that the reason so many of us adored playing it, was because of how ridiculously OTT and fun the 3D trilogy was.

GTA IV swapped the majority of that tonality for a remade Liberty City that was awash in a sea of brown and grey. Niko Bellic was witty and sharp enough, but his comments and attitude towards the criminal life were forever at odds with the way we wanted to play him.

It gave birth to the critical term, "ludonarrative dissonance" (when playing a game in a certain way breaks the character as they're established), and is at the heart of why this instalment just didn't click.

Still, Rockstar's debut of the RAGE engine powering everything did make for some brilliant physics-based fun, with driving that was very skid-happy, factoring into brilliantly 70s cop chase-esque vehicle sequences.

Gunplay is some of the best in the franchise and you still have to admire what Rockstar were trying to do - it just didn't hit home.


4. Grand Theft Auto V

Gta v
Rockstar

Speaking of not hitting home entirely, GTA V feels like something of a course-correct to GTA IV. Back with a vengeance was a far whackier goofball tone, mixed with some tabloid headline-chasing scenes like a protracted torture sequence and - in GTA V's remaster - a first-person mode so we could see all sorts of kills through the eyes of the characters.

Straight gameplay-wise this is the best of the lot, with the idea of switching between a trio of protagonists letting you drop into all sorts of in-progress crimes and sequences. It stumbles and falls regularly in the script department as you can tell Rockstar were struggling to match their idea of what GTA "is", with that of the baying public.

Grand Theft Auto was bigger than Jesus after over a decade of great reviews and positive buzz (many critics still cite GTA IV as not a roadblock, but a one-off masterpiece), meaning that whatever the next numbered instalment was going to be, somewhat had to "please everyone".

Thankfully, Rockstar playing it safe delivered a sales hit like nothing else, though going through it side by side with the earlier games and even GTA IV, there's a lack of purpose and passion that ultimately defines how this lands.


3. Grand Theft Auto III

GTA III cops
Rockstar

Like some punk rock garage band finally affording amps big enough to shake the trees of a neighbouring cul-de-sac, GTA III was all the pugnacious, America-satirising spirit of GTA's 1, 2 and London, done bigger and better than ever.

Playing today you'll encounter a few hiccups with a finicky lock-on and a complete lack of checkpointing for some awkward lategame missions, but mostly this is just as playable and enjoyable as ever. With one of the finest open-worlds ever designed - teeming with stunt ramps, hidden weapons, shortcuts and power-ups - there's something to be said for less being more in hindsight.

Millions of us could draw out a map of Liberty City from memory right now, and it's down to every inch of its three island structure being so much fun to take in. There's a definable attitude to GTA III; an aura of midnight fog, nigh-on constant rain and flickering streetlights punctuating its darkest moments.

They're complimented by some of Rockstar's best characters and character moments, hilarious radio banter and a mission progression that steadily introduces new elements at the perfect clip.


2. Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas

GTA San Andreas
Rockstar

Like splitting the atom and deciding on a favourite half (or something, I'm not a scientist), Rockstar's output after GTA III was in another galaxy of incredible. Both games took huge leaps in all the right directions, with the teams themselves only growing, maintaining their youthful rebellious spirit but being able to expand what GTA "was" entirely of their own accord.

In San Andreas' case, two prior games saw them devote more time to role-playing elements, amping up customisation through body types and clothing options for protagonist CJ. There were more weapons, cars and items than ever, with the biggest open-world gaming had ever seen.

Not content with only bombing around cityscapes, San Andreas also took us to a number of forest and wilderness areas, peppering them with secret vehicles and truly embracing the lampoon-inviting qualities of the American midwest.

The downside to all this rampant expansion was an absolutely ludicrous story. One that was fun and memorable, sure, but saw CJ go from gang-filled suburbs to the tops of mountains, down into science labs and even into the depths of high-rolling casinos.

San Andreas is very much Rockstar throwing every single idea at the wall and forcing them to stick. Many - including myself - love how completely insane the full picture of San Andreas looks, but there is a better overall Grand Theft Auto game.


1. Grand Theft Auto: Vice City

GTA Vice City
Rockstar

You can break into a garage in Portland and make off with a Banshee, base-jump off Mt. Chiliad. You can take part in one of the most intense bank heists ever seen or fly a tiny plane into the back of an in-flight cargo plane.

You can do all these things, and it won't compare to the career-best heights that embody and reinvigorate every aspect of GTA: Vice City.

It's the pitch-perfect tone that knows just how much to poke and prod at 80s American ephemera. It's the cast of celebrity cameos having fun with some fantastically OTT characters. It's being given a chainsaw and then chasing down a handful of goons who betrayed your employer.

It's the finest soundtrack in gaming history.

It's the sun-kissed beach as your shirt billows in the wind and you tear down the strip, pursuing the next part of a story you actually want to see through.

What Rockstar tapped into when setting GTA in the 80s, was the perfect match of an already extravagant game, with a time period that in itself, was cooked and glazed in excess. You'd be hard-pressed to find a more masturbatory decade - where bright primary colours, perms and leather pants were deemed cool - and make it more loveable. Yet, they found a way through both indulgence, commentary and gameplay in equal measure.

Vice City is funny, biting, enjoyable mechanically and perfectly-sized when it comes to how its missions and content is spread across the map. Taken as a whole, it is the best Grand Theft Auto so far.


Watch Next


In this post: 
GTA
 
First Posted On: 
Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.