10 Best No.3's In Gaming History

When three really is the magic number.

the witcher 3 wild hunt
CD Projekt RED

In 2016's X-Men: Apocalypse, X-Teen Jean Gray drops the line "the third movie is always the worst one" after watching Return of the Jedi. This immediately sparked a few thoughts:

1) Wait until she sees Rise of Skywalker.

2) She has a point.

3) Does that rule apply to videogames?

Fortunately for our favourite hobby, video games tend to fair better than their cinematic counterparts when it comes to this particular rule of three. Sure there have been a fair few duds in the land of three (Driv3r immediately springs to mind) but overall, third entries in games tend to be among their series best.

Whether it's because developers have figured out what their customers want or simply because practice makes perfect, most game series are firing on all cylinders by their third iteration. As this article will show, this remains true both across genres and through the years - the oldest game on this list came out in 1988, while the youngest was released only a couple of months ago.

Our first entry, however, was released sometime in between...

10. Mass Effect 3

Mass Effect 3 Combat
Bioware

No game has had a more deletrious final act than Mass Effect 3.

The internet backlash against ME 3's ending has gone down in video game folklore. Millions of gamers vented their frustration that an entire trilogy's worth of decision-making was rendered pointless by an ending that ignored all the player's choices and simply asked them to pick between a red pill or a blue pill (with a bonus green pill thrown in on top).

Was it frustrating? Absolutely. Did it wreck the 50 hours of fist-pumping, fan pleasing action that took place before it? In this writer's opinion, absolutely not.

Ending aside, Mass Effect 3 is a glorious celebration of Bioware's seminal sci-fi series. It's a game made by designers who clearly fell in love with their creation, and a generous thank you to the fans who made it possible. Fan-favourite characters get their moment(s) in the sun, series-long plotlines are gloriously/horribly resolved (depending on how much you screwed up along the way) and the combat is not just great for an RPG - it's great, full stop.

Packed full of sharp writing, great characterization and so much heart you can practically hear the game's pulse, Mass Effect 3 is a glorious celebration of the much-beloved series.

Even with the abrupt ending.


9. Far Cry 3

Far Cry 3
Ubisoft

Watching Ubisoft try to recreate the magic of Far Cry 3 across all their IP has been like watching a junkie try to recreate their first high - more than a little depressing, and leaving you wishing someone would stage an intervention to get them back on track.

Still, that doesn't change the fact that Ubisfot absolutely nailed the open-world formula first time round with Far Cry 3.

It's hard to overstate just how big a deal FC3 felt upon its launch in 2011. FPS games had dabbled with open-worlds before - most notably in Ubisoft's overly-punishing prequel Far Cry 2 - but Far Cry 3 was the first game to truly make its open-world sing.

Waging a one-man war against the psychopathic Vaas and his army of goons across the Rook Islands felt like a revelation back in the day, and it's no coincidence the number of open-world FPSes shot up in the years following FC 3's release.

It's a shame that Ubisoft have spent the past decade in thrall to the blueprint Far Cry 3 lay down, but that just shows how special a game it was.


8. The Legend Of Zelda: A Link To The Past

Zelda Link to the Past Guards
Nintendo

The only game here not to include a "3" in its title, this list would be nevertheless incomplete without discussing the third entry in the Zelda series.

This was the game where Nintendo cracked the Zelda code. After the charmingly basic original and the deeply weird Zelda II ( a game best summed up with its memetic "I AM ERROR" line), Link to the Past lit the path Zelda would follow for the next 20-odd years.

Many of the series' mainstays - travelling through parallel worlds, the Master Sword, cucco-baiting - were introduced here, creating a journey that still regularly cracks many peoples' "best Zelda game" polls. It's an accolade richly deserved - while the first two Zeldas are only worth playing in a historic sense, Link to the Past is still an endearing, richly rewarding game in its own right.

Not many games entering their fourth decade hold up as well as Link to the Past, and if you've yet to experience the wonders of Light and Dark Hyrule this is still an adventure worth undertaking.


7. Quake 3

quake 3 dreamcast
iD Software

This writer is old enough to remember scoffing at Quake 3 upon its release.

"A multiplayer only game?", 12 year old me said. "Who the heck buys games just for the multiplayer?"

12 year old me, it turns out, was an idiot. (A trend many would say has continued to this day).

Quake 3 is as close to perfection as games have ever got. Not in the sense that it does everything brilliantly, but in that it focused on one aspect of gaming - the deathmatch - and delivered as pure a distillation of that experience as possible.

Whereas Quake's great rival Unreal Tournament offered a bevy of modes - including, shock horror, a single-player campaign - Quake 3 put all its energies into creating the best online deathmatch experience possible. The result was a gloriously frenetic, furious FPS that still holds up today in all its hyperkinetic glory.

Many multiplayer games offer more, but few have ever come close to usurping Quake 3 as king of the deathmatch. Playing it is like watching a master artisan at work - it's a highly specific kind of genius, but genius nonetheless.


6. Halo 3

halo 3
Bungie

From one multiplayer behemoth to another, we turn our gaze to Halo 3 - a game that somehow managed to live up to its impossibly large hype.

With Halo's importance in the gaming landscape having drastically diminished over the past decade, younger gamers may not realise what a huge deal Halo 3's release was. Launch parties were held all over the globe, where celebrities such as Zac Efron and Pharell Williams could be found geeking out alongside regular customers.

Halo 3 felt like the moment gaming finally became accepted in the mainstream, and thankfully it showed the medium off in a positive light.

The single-player campaign showed Halo at its bombastic best (nothing in the series since has come close to that dual Scarabs battle), but it's the multiplayer that cements Halo's legacy as an all-time great.

The best proof of that came earlier in the year, when Halo 3's Xbox 360 servers were finally shut down after 14 years of service. The outpouring of articles and fanposts that lamented the passing of one of gaming's cornerstones was genuinely touching, and showed the importance Halo 3 held in the hearts of so many.

Halo holds a special place in the hearts of many gamers of a certain age, and Halo 3 saw the series at its peak - both as a game, and as a cultural phenomenon.


5. Street Fighter III: Third Strike

Street fighter 3
Capcom

As the third game of a third game, we were tempted to include Street Fighter III: Third Strike on this list on principle alone. Fortunately, Third Strike has more than numerology on its side to warrant its inclusion in any "Best of..." list. Over 20 years since its initial release, this is still one of the greatest fighting games ever made.

Admittedly, this writer came late to the Third Strike party, having only played it for the first time a few months ago. But playing it in 2022, two things are immediately apparent:

1) For a game old enough to drink across the globe, this is still a staggeringly good looking title.

2) Third Strike is plain old-fashioned fun.

For a game that's idolized as the zenith of skill-based fighters, Third Strike is still a good time for those of us whose fighting style remains "mash the buttons and hope for the best". The wonderfully fluid animation and crisp sound effects make each fight a joy to experience, whether you're dishing out a 10-parry counter or desperately spamming hadoukens.

If you've yet to dabble, don't let Third Strike's intimidating reputation put you off - this is still peak Street Fighter, and Street Fighter has always been a treat for even the most casual beat-em-up fan.


4. The Witcher 3

The Witcher 3
CD Projekt RED

If charted on a line graph, the Witcher trilogy's rate of improvement would look like a steep slope that transforms into a brick wall at the end.

The first Witcher was a decent RPG held back by a myriad of bugs and a tedious first act. Witcher 2 was a huge improvement, but hobbled by a needlessly high level of difficulty that made protagonist Geralt feel less like a hardened adventurer and more like a Renaissance Faire enthusiast in way over his head.

Witcher 3, however, was the baby bear's porridge to its developer's Goldilocks, as they finally got one that was just right.

Alongside ironing out the numerous technical quibbles and foils of the previous games, Witcher 3 saw its writers at the peak of their powers. Characters such as the Bloody Baron and Gaunter O'Dimm earned CD Projekt their reputation as creative powerhouses, and the main cast all shined equally bright across the game's 100-hour runtime.

Hell, part of the reason Cyberpunk 2077 was seen as a crushing disappointment was due to the incredibly high bar set by the Witcher 3. Cyberpunk is a good game, but the harsh truth is that "Good" always looks bad next to "GOAT".


3. Super Mario Bros. 3

super mario bros 3 Airship
Nintendo

Speaking of GOATs, Super Mario Bros. 3 still holds up as a pinnacle of platforming perfection to this day.

Much of what we said about Link to the Past applies here - after a charmingly straightforward first game, and a bizarre mis-step of a sequel, Nintendo struck gold with the third entry of an iconic franchise.

Again, much of what would come to define said franchise was introduced in its third iteration - in this case, the overworld map, Bowser's nieces and nephews and some of gaming's greatest power-ups. (There's a reason Nintendo chose Tanooki Mario to be the game's cover star).

Obviously, the animation isn't as tight as today's pixel art wonders but the chunky, cartoony graphics still retain their charm, and Nintendo's signature blend of playful level design - where every level feels like a playground built specifically for Mario himself - and challenging gameplay remains as gripping as ever.

There's a reason every mainline Mario game feels like an event, and that tradition arguably started here. If you're looking for a gateway into retro gaming, then Mario Bros. 3 really is as good as it gets.


2. Xenoblade Chronicles 3

xenoblade chronicles 3
Monolith Soft

What a relief it is to be able to include this game on this list.

After redefining the JRPG with the masterful Xenoblade Chronicles, developers Monolith Soft seriously screwed the pooch with the follow up. Xenoblade Chronicles 2 was a bloated, poorly written mess of cringeworthy characters and overwhelming feature creep that threatened to spoil the series' legacy.

Needless to say, it was with some trepidation we booted up Xenoblade 3 for the first time. Could Xenoblade recapture its former glory, or was the original game merely lightning in a bottle?

Well, let's put it this way:

One hour in, our fears were assuaged - were back at the top of their game.

Ten hours in, we were hopelessly addicted and loving every minute of it.

Over a hundred hours in, we're squeezing in every last sidequest to postpone the dreadful moment we'll have to say goodbye to Xenoblade 3's wonderful world and the characters that inhabit it. (Especially Eunie, who now dons the mantle of gaming's greatest Cockney).

More than a much-needed redemption for its developers, Xenoblade 3 is a masterwork that deserves to be spoken of in the same hallowed tones as genre greats like Final Fantasy VII and Chrono Trigger. An unmissable triumph.


1. Metal Gear Solid 3

Metal Gear Solid 3
Konami

Metal Gear Solid 3 is the best the series ever got, and we will die on this hill/overly long ladder.

Much like Xenoblade 3, Metal Gear Solid 3 was a chance at redemption after a disappointing sequel. And, much like Xenoblade 3, MGS 3 didn't just redeem the franchise - it elevated it to drastic new heights. Much like an overly long ladder.

OK, you may be wondering why we keep bringing up the ladder. Simply put, MGS 3's (in)famous ladder sequence is a succinct, beautiful encapsulation of what makes it great.

What other game would force you to climb a ladder, alone, for over two minutes? What other game would make you do so after a heart-poundingly tense boss battle? And what other game would soundtrack it with one of the greatest songs ever recorded for a video game?

Equal parts baffling and brilliant, MGS 3's infamous ladder climb remains lodged in the memories of every gamer who experiences it, and is the perfect example of the game's idiosyncratic genius. And that's just two minutes! Two minutes of a 12 hour epic stuffed with great boss fights, heart-wrenching drama and enough wildlife consumption to make Bear Grylls nauseous.

We're starting to gush now, so we'll sign off with this: In a world of completely unnecessary remakes, this is one game that deserves to be experienced by a new generation of gamers.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Hello! My name's Iain Tayor. I write about video games, wrestling and comic books, and I apparently can't figure out how to set my profile picture correctly.