10 Best No. 4's In Gaming History
The fab fours.
A few weeks back, WhatCulture looked at the 10 Best No. 3's in Gaming History. It was a fun article to write, allowing us to look back at gaming's storied past and wax lyrical about our favourite hobby. It was so much fun, in fact, that we were inspired to write a follow-up. Six weeks of intense research later, we figured out that four follows three and got cracking on this list.
The number four often gets a bad rap (infamous pop-culture repository tvtropes.org literally has a section titled "Four Is Death"), but thankfully each game on this list avoided the curse of the quad. Whether putting the player in the shoes of a pirate, a regretful father or the president of the United States, each entrant on this list delivers some of the best moments in video game history.
Before we discuss our first entry, we should mention one small caveat: to stretch our wings, sequels from franchises discussed in the "Best No.3's" article were automatically disqualified. So the likes of Super Mario World, Link's Awakening and Quake 4 won't be making an appearance. (Although the latter would only have had a shot if we changed the title of the article to "10 Sequels That Learned Absolutely Nothing From The Prequel").
With that out of the way, let's get started!
10. Saints Row IV
The above photo shows the player character of Saints Row IV, giving the player a cheeky thumbs up after assassinating a terrorist leader and dismantling a nuclear warhead in mid-air. After this, you become president of the USA, and you're done with the tutorial.
Yes, the tutorial. Saints Row IV starts where most would finish, going full Spinal Tap in its desire to fit in absolutely every idea the developers had. Alien invasion? Sure! Superpowers? Go for it! Biz Markie? Damn right!
SR IV is a glorious playground of a game, where the most fun to be had is in simply exploring the world with your superpowers. If you've had a bad day, leaping from skyscraper to skyscraper while Aerosmith's "I Don't Want To Miss A Thing" plays in the background is sure to lift your mood.
Saints Row IV's playground is further bolstered with some of the best playmates in gaming. SR IV is a culmination of the bonds forged by the Third Street Saints over the course of the series, and features some brilliant character moments: Car-singing with your bestie, watching your friend move on from a toxic ex and, of course, the best romance in video game history. (Warning: NSFW language).
After the debacle of the 2022 reboot, treat yourself to a replay of Saints Row IV and remember why you fell in love with the Third Street Saints in the first place.
9. Gran Turismo 4
In the video spin-off of the "Best No.3's" article, one of the most common comments was "Wot, no Gran Turismo 3?" (or words to that effect).
Fret not, petrolheads - we didn't forget about PlayStation's greatest racing series. We just thought that GT 3 was trumped by its sequel, which remains a triumph of the Frasier Crane philosophy of video game design: "If less if more, just think how much more more will be".
Gran Turismo 4 isn't so much a love letter to automotive racing as an epic saga. After setting the stage with Gran Turismo 3, developers Polyphony Digital pushed the PS2 to its limits with the follow up. With over 50 tracks to race on and more than 700 cars to drive (each with their own unique handling model), all powered by the best graphics seen on Sony's system, GT 4 is a game of astonishing depth.
You may never see the end of it - after a hundred hours, my game completion percentage was still under the halfway mark - but if you have even the slightest amount of petrol flowing in your veins, exploring Gran Turismo 4's raceways is time very well spent.
8. Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag
You know a game mechanic is successful when it keeps cropping up in later instalments of the series. Case in point: Black Flag's sailing, which has shown up in numerous Assassin's Creed sequels following its debut in 2013's piratical adventure.
Honestly, though, none of the subsequent Creeds have managed to match the high-water mark (har har) of the fourth entry in the series. Black Flag was the perfect marriage of theme and gameplay, with protagonist Edward Kenway's nautical lifestyle perfectly feeding into the game's systems of loot-upgrade-loot again. The game simply wouldn't have worked had Kenway been anything other than a pirate, so it's a good thing Ubisoft made simply being a pirate so damn fun.
Raiding other vessels, looking for sunken treasure, stabbing at sharks from hell's heart; all of these activities breathed life into the pirate fantasy Black Flag was selling, and it was glorious.
As the Assassin's Creed games become ever-more bloated, once again Frasier Crane's previously-stated belief that "more is more" comes to mind. The good doctor's maxim may have worked wonders for Gran Turismo 4, but there are some games where less really is more. In Black Flag, Ubisoft found the happy medium between the two philosophies and delivered the best game in the series to date.
7. Metroid Fusion
Some of you may be raising an eyebrow at this entry, wondering how Metroid Fusion made it on a "Best Of" list when Super Metroid, its much-vaunted predecessor, didn't.
Simple - Metroid Fusion is the better game,
Apologies for the slightly confrontational tone there, but Samus Aran's fourth adventure is, a successful evolution of the Metroid formula - one that takes everything that made the previous game great, then builds on it. The level design is tighter, the boss battles are more memorable and the plot actually exists.
Samus' inner monologue gave gaming's most famous bounty hunter a welcome dash of personality, and the introduction of the terminator-esque SA-X - essentially a superpowered Samus clone - further humanised the formerly inscrutable protagonist. Watching Samus go from literally cowering in a ball to hide from her nemesis, to being able to fight it on equal footing and eventually overcome it, provided a strong narrative thread that had been missing from previous entries in the series.
Granted, Fusion's follow-up - the disastrous Metroid: Other M - showed what happens when Metroid's designers spend too much time focusing on the plot. But that just makes Metroid Fusion's achievement in perfecting the balance between gameplay and story all the more impressive.
6. Final Fantasy IV
The tale of how gaming's most inaccurately-named franchise came to be is the stuff of industry legend.
The original Final Fantasy was intended to be exactly that - one last hurrah from publishers Squaresoft before they went under after one too many failures. Except the game sold like gangbusters, Squaresoft was saved, and there was much rejoicing.
Having said that, Square didn't exactly get everything right first try.
The first FF was a solid JRPG, but a bit light on plot. The second game was more narrative-heavy, but with a wonky, game-breaking levelling system. And the third game offered entertaining combat, but a dull story.
FF IV, though, was the game that finally nailed the Final Fantasy formula.
FFIV contained many of the tropes that would come to define the series - a conflicted hero turning on his former masters, the death of a party member, and a villain with more shades of grey than a spinster's library. It also introduced the series' trademark ATB battle system - an elegant fusion of real-time and turn-based combat - and was arguably the game where composer Nobuo Uematsu announced himself to the world, with "Theme of Love" and the game's pulse-pounding Boss Battle theme signifying Uematsu's immense talent.
(Also, "You spoony bard!" is still the best insult ever written in a video game)
5. Persona 4
Sticking with JRPGs, we come to Persona 4 - the world's cheeriest murder mystery.
Since Persona 3, each game in the series has cast the player as a high school student dragged into a world of supernatural intrigue. As such, it's easy to visualize what each game would be like as a real-life high-schooler.
The moody, downbeat Persona 3 is the class goth, the impeccably stylish Persona 5 is the school stud, and Persona 4 is the one student everybody likes - an irrepressibly cheerful, upbeat force of nature impossible not to be friends with.
And really, friendship is the beating heart of what makes Persona 4 great. P4's cast of misfits, idols and weirdos are, hands down, the most entertaining group of party members yet seen in a video game. There are multiple 20-minute cutscenes where player interaction is limited to pressing X to advance the dialogue, but the strength of the characters' personalities - and the sheer quality of the writing - will have you tapping away with delight, a contented spectator laughing alongside gaming's greatest circle of friends.
Throw in some wonderfully compelling combat and one of gaming's best soundtracks (arguably only surpassed by its sequel), and Persona 4 is a lovely, 80-hour bubble bath of a game.
4. Doom (2016)
If Persona 4 was content to take agency away from the player in service of its (impeccable) story, Doom's 2016 reboot takes very much the opposite approach.
From the off, Doom makes its intentions clear - grab guns, shoot monsters, GO! An ever-escalating carnival of shootery, the Doom reboot returned the seminal franchise to its roots after Doom 3's turgid foray into survival horror. Learning from its predecessor's mistakes, Doom makes the player the most powerful monster in the game and gleefully offers them the tools needed to carve their way through its iconic bestiary.
Pinballing through Doom's many encounters as a whirling nightmare of guns, chainsaws and sheer animal rage is satisfying as ever, even in the glut of "boomer shooters" that have followed in its wake. Many have tried, but none have rivaled the sheer "Wow!" factor of 2016's reawakened titan.
It may have taken id Software 22 years - and one giant misstep - to craft a worthy follow up to Doom 2, but the end result was more than worth the wait.
3. Call Of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
Speaking of monumentally important FPS games...
Doom may have been a triumphant return to old-school values, but Modern Warfare was the game that made those values fall out of fashion in the first place. The fourth Call of Duty's towering success spawned a host of imitators in the decade that followed, but none came close to Modern Warfare's imperious heights.
To be fair, CoD 4 set a very high bar to reach. The perspective-hopping campaign felt genuinely revolutionary at the time, and led to some of gaming's most iconic moments. Levels such as All Ghillied Up, Death From Above and Aftermath carry the same heady weight as a vintage wine label, and evoke much the same sense of satisfaction - that of experiencing a perfect exemplar of the craft.
Oft-imitated but never bettered - even by its own sequels - Modern Warfare 4 remains a staggering triumph for its campaign alone. The fact that it also contains a generation-defining multiplayer frankly feels like cheating from Infinity Ward.
2. God Of War (2018)
Have you played the original God of War trilogy recently? If not, best keep it that way.
Kratos' Grecian odyssey has aged terribly. From the simplistic combat to the embarrassing edge-lord attitude (best highlighted by GoW III's infamous segment where you kill an innocent woman and use her body to prop open a door), Kratos' Greek adventures are the gaming equivalent of the crappy poetry you wrote in high school - an embarrassing relic of an immature mind.
Which makes the stunning success of 2018's reboot all the more surprising.
Kratos himself is the best symbol for why the reboot succeeds where the prequels failed. The Kratos of this game is markedly different from the one-note psychopath of the original trilogy. Here, he's a world-weary father, ashamed of his past mistakes and desperate for his son not to follow in his blood-soaked footsteps.
Neatly, Kratos' maturation as a person mirrors the series' evolution as a game. The combat is given a much-needed overhaul, keeping the series' signature spectacle while offering much more depth to the player. And the linear levels of old are abandoned for a Metroidvania-style world, filled with upgrades and optional bosses for players to explore at their leisure.
God of War is a triumphant reboot of a once-stale franchise, and arguably the second-best franchise reinvention in gaming history.
Which begs the questions: Which is the first? Oh, we think you know the answer...
1. Resident Evil 4
It couldn't be anything else.
We've talked a lot in this article about how these games influenced their franchises, but Resident Evil 4 influenced an entire console generation. Damn near every action game in the Xbox360/PS3 era paid homage to/blatantly stole from Resident Evil 4, copying everything from RE4's revolutionary over-the-shoulder camera to its use of Quick Time Events.
Sadly, many of those same copycats failed to recapture RE4's lightning in a bottle. QTEs, for example, are often derided as a deservedly forgotten game mechanic because developers strewed them about haphazardly in misguided attempts at player engagement. But if any of those attempts had managed to come close to the nail-biting tension of RE4's QTE-driven knife fight, they would be remembered a lot more fondly.
If you want further proof of RE 4's brilliance, check out the discourse surrounding the upcoming remake. Before Capcom assuaged fears with the latest (stunning) trailer, the general opinion was: why try to improve upon perfection? Because while the original Resident Evil trilogy may have aged with all the grace of an early 2000s D-Lister, RE 4 remains cracking fun to this day.
Resident Evil 4's romp through possessed villages, creepy cults and Napoleonic terrors is still a wildly entertaining ride, and even now you can see how an entire generation of developers were inspired by Capcom's greatest game.