10 Best Serial Killers In Open World Games

Killer open-world gaming secrets! Assassin's Creed, Fallout, GTA...

gta 5 serial killer
Rockstar

Serial killers are both some of the scariest and most interesting stories in the world. Maybe you've read about a few yourself, or maybe your partner watches Forensic Files on repeat (check your dinner for poison). Serial killers make good TV, that's just a fact. Hannibal Lecter and Buffalo Bill from Silence of the Lambs, Marco Amoretti from the chilling 'jungle cruise' episode of Ghost in the Shell: Stand-Alone Complex, and of course Norman Bates in the classic Hitchcock thriller Psycho. Anything about Ted Bundy, Jeffrey Dahmer, Ed Gein, or any number of other real serial killers will get eyes on it pretty easily.

Games are no different - you'll find a lot of serial killers in your favourites. Not the least of which being you, of course. Sure, you may be the 'hero' and all that, but let's face it... a lot of what you do in games is very serial killer-esque.

Murder three or more people, usually in the service of abnormal psychological gratification, taking place over a period of time longer than a month, often with time in between. But enough about you, let's talk about some serial killers in games - who aren't the player.

10. Vincent, The Whytechurch Murderer - Arcanum

Arcanum Steamworks Magick Obscura
Sierra

Arcanum: Of Steamworks & Magick Obscura is a 2001 isometric open-world RPG with one hell of a long title. In Arcanum you play as the lone survivor of a zeppelin crash in a realm toeing the rift between magic and steampunk technology being the dominant force in the world.

Within Arcanum you can be tasked with investigating a series of deaths in the city of Caladon. The killer is an elven wizard named Vincent who is secretly possessed by a demon, L’anamelach. In order to successfully complete the quest you must research demonology, acquire an ancient dagger, and then kill Vincent with said dagger before he can transform into L’anamelach and flee - causing you to fail the quest.

Vincent, under L’anamelach's influence, manages to kill two people before you arrive on the scene and then he kills a third while you're in the process of investigating him. Similar MO in each of the first two cases - he used demon strength to force open trap doors and then climbed into their homes to get his murdering done.


9. Neb, The Child-Killing Gnome - Baldur's Gate

Baldurs Gate
Bioware

Baldur's Gate isn't exactly a bright, cheery world to begin with. You and your companions must traipse around Sword Coast completing quests to, ultimately, stop a demon-spawn.

Within the world of Baldur's Gate and its sequel you can come across Neb, a gnome with a penchant for murdering children. When find him while imprisoned at one point in the game he will offer his secret plans of escape in exchange for solving a riddle of his. The riddle ultimately comes down to: how many children has Neb murdered? The answer is a chilling 33, by the way.

In the sequel, Shadows of Amn, you come across Neb in the course of another quest and can fight him. In this battle he summons the trapped spirits of his child victims to protect him and you must fight your way through them to kill him. In a heroic moment you get bonuses for each child spirit you spare, and you also get Neb's head and the quest item. Well, aren't you the little hero, now?


8. Quentin And Kelder - Dragon Age II

Dr. Stanley Gimble Vampire Masquerade Bloodlines
Activision

Dragon Age II's Hawke gets two chances to deal with serial killers in their outing as protagonist. Arguably the lesser of the two is during the Magistrate's Orders quest where a Magistrate, Vanard, will task Hawke with capturing a murderer alive.

Only after arriving where the murderer is holed up will they learn the killer is Vanard's son, Kelder, who has been killing elven children for years. When confronted he admits that he's sick in the head and can't stop himself; the elven children are just 'too beautiful' to live and he begs the player to kill him.

Hawke's other run-in with a serial killer is Quentin, the charismatic blood mage, who woos Hawke's mother, Leandra. Unfortunately for the player, they are too late to realize that Quentin is a murderer, and that Leandra has already been taken by the crazed mage and mutilated. Quentin lost his mind when his wife died and he's been piecing a new version of her together with parts from other women - Leandra is the latest piece. Hawke can't save their mother, but there's a touching scene that plays out between mother and child after you kill Quentin to avenge her.


7. Pickman's Gallery - Fallout 4

Pickman Gallery Fallout 4
Bethesda

Where to start when it comes to serial killers in the Fallout series? Of course you have the Nuka-Killer who committed at least three confirmed murders before the nuclear events that put the series in motion, called so because of his interest in placing Nuka-Cola bottlecaps over the eye sockets of his victims. Then there's the Disciples from the Nuka-World DLC which is a whole group of serial killers living together. One must question how they didn't just kill each other?

Clanden from Fallout: New Vegas is violent choice - making snuff films of the atrocities he commits against his victims. Oh, and of course the Fens Street Phantom, whom you only find skeletons and notes about.

But Pickman from Fallout 4 is probably the best example. You can come across a few signs of a killer picking off raiders and taunting them to come after him - in an attempt to pick more of them off, of course. In the end you'll find a charismatic artist named Pickman whom you can kill, or rescue, or both. It quickly becomes clear that Pickman murders people and turns their corpses into grotesque pieces of 'art'.


6. Infinity Killer - Grand Theft Auto V

Grand Theft Auto V Infinity Killer
Rockstar Games

The main argument against calling Trevor, from Grand Theft Auto V, a serial killer is that... he's really just a constant killer. It's more an anger and psychosis issue than an obsession. Though having once been the San Andreas Strangler does show he has an obsessive side.

But the most famous serial killer in the Grand Theft Auto series has to be the Infinity Killer. A man you never meet, but you can find numerous clues about him and his killings, ultimately culminating in finding the bodies of his victims.

Merle Abrahams developed an obsession with the number 8 and decided to murder 8 people, figuring that "8 is just infinity stood up". This caused police at the time to dub him the Infinity Killer. Abrahams died while in prison, awaiting trial for his murder before the game takes place, so you never get to meet him.

You do, however, get to find the creepy nursery rhyme he wrote about his kills: One is done. Two was fun. Three tried to run. Four called 'Mom'. Five's not alive. Six is nix. Seven's in heaven. Eight won't wait.

The rhymes are a little weak though. Merle's slant rhyming must make him a terrible rapper.


5. Morinth, The Ardat-Yakshi - Mass Effect 3

Morinth Bioware
EA

Mass Effect 2 has a series of special 'loyalty missions' for each character and in Samara's case it is to chase down a deadly killer named Morinth. Your target is known as an Ardat-Yakshi, a name that in Asari means 'Demon of the Night Wind', which sounds like a badass ninja nom de guerre. But it's no ninja, it's actually a genetic defect that causes her to become a succubus - she kills partners she becomes intimate with and absorbs their strength.

Liara, in the third game in the series, warns Shepard that Ardat-Yakshi who kill often leave behind astronomical numbers of victims and can live many years to do so. Morinth has only been in the game for about four centuries, though. As Samara's daughter, the Asari Justicar has made it a bit of her life's quest to hunt down her hedonistic daughter and stop her.

When push comes to shove and Shepard stands nearby while Samara and Morinth battle to a standstill, the player has the option of aiding either one. If they aid Samara in killing Morinth, they secure Samara's loyalty. Or they can aid Morinth in killing Samara and the fugitive will take her mother's place on Shepard's crew, ultimately enabling the player to kill themselves by shacking up with her.


4. Dr. Stanley Gimble - Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines

Dr. Stanley Gimble Vampire Masquerade Bloodlines
Activision

Dr. Stanley Gimble is a friendly philanthropic doctor who runs a prosthetics shop in Santa Monica, California in the cult classic Vampire: The Masquerades game Bloodlines - a sequel to which should be coming out this year. As he says, he just wants to "make things a little easier for those who find themselves, erm, disadvantaged. Giving a helping hand, you might say – a leg up. Uh, eh... bloody clever, that one."

Aside from hoisting his own petard, he also severed his own limb - cutting off his arm to experience what a real amputee goes through. He also enjoys turning other people into amputees. There's no telling how many people he kidnapped or tricked into his lair underneath the prosthetics shop he runs, though you are sure of at least two people, one of whom you can rescue.

Aside from those two you can find evidence of a lot more, what with all the blood-covered surgical tools and tables in Gimble's basement lair. Not to mention the fact that he attacks you with a severed arm, likely that of his latest victim, because he wants your arms for himself.

Can I get a second opinion, Doc?


3. Seymour Fishburn - Vampyr

Vampyr Game
Dontnod Entertainment

The game Vampyr is not one for the faint of heart, like many vampire-related games. There are numerous people in the game that you can feast upon as the titular neck-biter, but you get more life essence from them if you learn their secrets.

One such potential meal is Seymour Fishburn, described in the game as "highly aggressive in nature". Seymour's known for getting into fights, but dotes on his mother. Some of the secrets you can find out about Seymour are that his mother is helping cover up his violent nature and that he dislikes the street urchin she has taken in.

Oh, also that he's a serial murderer and has left a pile of corpses in a sewer pipe just beneath his home. Some of the folks you can 'embrace' - that is eat - are hard to justify: The hard-working nurse who deserves better, the soldier having trouble openly confessing his adoration to his gay lover, or the woman you rescue from another vampire.

But Seymour? Oh boy is there plenty of reason to 'put down the mad dog' and end his killing spree. Though you can also cure him of his own desire to kill by eating his mother and the urchin, weirdly enough.


2. Cannibal Butcher -    Assassin's Creed: Unity

Assassin's Creed Unity Cannibal
Ubisoft

Arguably the weirdest one, but definitely the best serial killer in an open-world game has to be the cannibal butcher from Assassin's Creed Unity. How good is he at being a serial killer? You find him, dead-to-rights, cutting up bodies in a culvert with a group of people locked in a cage nearby - and you actually get punished by the game if you stop him.

That's right - since he's just a weird Easter egg, he's still considered a 'civilian' and you aren't allowed to assassinate him. Some of the killers on our list have allies willing to give them aid or alibis, such as Seymour or Kelder; some of them have good cover to hide their crimes such as Dr. Gimble or Morinth. But none of them have complete mechanical immunity to the player getting revenge on them. Even the Infinity Killer dies off screen.

So beware men in sewers wearing tricorn hats, else you might be the next meal in some sort of cistern stew!


1. Edmund Lowry, Jr. - Red Dead Redemption 2

Red Dead 2 Serial Killer
Rockstar

Rockstar's certainly got a thing for putting their players up against serial killers as Red Dead Redemption 2 proves with the mission American Dreams. Much like the similar named mission from the first game, American Appetites, you're tasked with finding three missing victims.

In the case of the sequel they're headless corpses that have been strung up to highlight their butchery at the hands of an unknown assailant. But after finding maps tucked into their heads you can not only find out who the assailant is - but hell, you can even join his victims if you're not quick enough.

Lowry sneaks up behind you after you discover his lair and he knocks you a little senseless. Wait too long to hit him in the face with the skull of one of his earlier victims and you'll get treated a scene where you're tortured to death. If you stop him, though, you get to take him captive and turn him over to the Sheriff to collect a bounty.

At that point, of course, there's a hiccup in the plan - at his first opportunity he attacks the Sheriff. You've got to finish him off to get yourself that sweet, sweet bounty.


Watch Next


In this post: 
GTA 5
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Author of Escort (Eternal Press, 2015), co-founder of Nic3Ntertainment, and developer behind The Sickle Upon Sekigahara (2020). Currently freelancing as a game developer and history consultant. Also tends to travel the eastern U.S. doing courses on History, Writing, and Japanese Poetry. You can find his portfolio at www.richardcshaffer.com.