10 Best Super Mario Fan Theories That Explain Everything

There are some fan-theories about Super Mario that make too much sense to dismiss.

King Boo Bowser
Nintendo

Super Mario is the most celebrated video game franchise of all time. Despite its legacy, the premise is very simple; an Italian plumber living in the Mushroom Kingdom must rescue Princess Peach from the Koopa King, Bowser. That is the entire plot to about 80% of the mainstream Mario games.

Because the characters and plot are so basic, very little is known about the Mario universe. This has caused many gamers to try and fill in the blanks with their own theories. Like most speculation, a lot of these fan-theories simply don't stick and thus, are dismissed.

But there are handful of fan-theories that make too much sense to be discarded. Even if they're not true, some of these ideas should be explored.

Who was King Boo when he was alive? Why does Mario act completely different in his debut game? How does Nintendo's moustachioed mascot have time to have hundreds of adventures? And most importantly, what does a Shy Guy look like? (Okay, that one isn't important, but it's definitely the one that keeps me up at night.)

Here are some Super Mario fan-theories that explain everything.

10. Super Mario Bros. 3 Is A Play

Super Mario Bros. 3
Nintendo

The most popular theory revolving around the Mario franchise is how Super Mario Bros. 3 is a play.

The game starts with a curtain raising like in the beginning of a show. Most of the backgrounds are bolted to the "set". Some physical objects (including the hills on the opening screen) cast a distinctive shadow to further highlight that the background is fake.

All of the main levels conclude with Mario dashing into a black area on the right side, which resembles the "wings" of a stage. In some levels, the titular character can run around the wings as if he is going behind the set.

The reason why this idea has become so prevalent in recent years is because... it's true. During a 2015 interview, Mario creator himself, Shigeru Miyamoto, confirmed the game is meant to be a show put on by Mario and his friends.

You'd assume that Nintendo fans were thrilled to learn that this theory was confirmed by Shigsy himself and could finally be put to bed.

But no... instead, it created a brand new theory that's so insane, there just might be some truth to it.


9. None Of The Games Really Happened (Apart From The First One)

Super Mario Bros. 2 Ending
Nintendo

The conclusion of Super Mario Bros. 2 reveals our hero's entire adventure was nothing more than a dream. When Shigeru Miyamoto confirmed Super Mario Bros. 3 was a stage play, fans asked themselves, "Which Mario games actually happened?"

Some theorists took it one step further, suggesting NONE of the games happened save for the first one. The theory goes that Mario felt so powerful after saving the Mushroom Kingdom, he dedicated his life to reliving his glory days.

He dreams about new adventures and makes his friends act out his heroics because he misses being the depicted as a saviour. It would also explain how Bowser keeps returning, despite being dropped in lava or being sucked into a black hole.

But it doesn't stop there. Mario is followed by a cameraman in Super Mario 64, hinting he's making a movie. In Super Mario Sunshine, the levels are called "Episodes", implying he's starring in a show.

How else can you explain Mario's boundless skills? Have you ever met a plumber who's an expert in tennis, go-karting, Olympic sprinting, and can shoot fire, turn into paper, and jump five times his height? Even if this theory isn't true, Mario's god-like capabilities are conventionally unexplainable.


8. A Child Created The Secret Levels In Super Mario Sunshine

Mario Sunshine No FLUDD
Nintendo

In Super Mario Sunshine, Mario's water pack, FLUDD, allows him to hover, clean up goop, and spray enemies. However, there are secret areas in each level that begin with the antagonist, Shadow Mario, swiping FLUDD, forcing Mario to navigate through complex platform sections without his water device.

These secret areas stand out since the aesthetic has no resemblance to the rest of the game. Sunshine's level designs are colourful, smooth, and bouncy. The FLUDDless zones are composed of platforms that are asymmetrical and clunky.

The reason why these sections appear so sloppy may be because they were designed by a child. And not just any child either. They could've been made by Bowser Jr. (which is Shadow Mario's true identity).

Bowser Jr. could've concocted these mini-levels with his primary weapon; the Magic Paintbrush, which has proven to have incredible powers such as generating Gatekeepers and creating portals.

This would explain why Shadow Mario lies in wait when Mario enters these areas. If he created these zones, he knows Mario will have great difficulty manoeuvring around them without FLUDD, which is why he steals it the instant he enters.


7. King Boo's Identity

King Boo Bowser
Nintendo

Boo is a ghostly enemy in the Mario franchise that chases the player but stops dead (pun intended) if anyone makes eye-contact with him.

Now, Boo isn't a ghost in the traditional sense. He is more like a will o' the wisp; a spirit who never lived as a mortal. But real ghosts do exist in the Mario franchise, especially in the Luigi Mansion spin-off.

In these games, Luigi must battle his nemesis, the ruler of the Paranormal Dimension, King Boo. Because this self-crowned phantom is one of the most powerful entities in the world, it's clear he is not a random will o' the wisp, suggesting he was once alive.

It's assumed he is called King Boo because he is the leader of all supernatural forces. But what if he is called King Boo because he was a royal figure in his past life? Because he often allies with Bowser (who is a king), some people believe he could be his father's ghost.

Another idea is that he is Princess Peach's dad. After all, if Peach is a princess, her father must be a king. So how come we've never seen him?


6. Doctor Mario Is Not Mario

Dr. Mario
Nintendo

Dr. Mario is a Tetris-inspired puzzle series where the player has to line up MegaVitamins to destroy viruses. Upon it's release, gamers were a little confused by Mario's sudden career change. Why did the Italian plumber suddenly decide to practise medicine?

Better yet, when did this happen? You need eight years of training to achieve a medical degree. How does he have the time when he's saving the world?

When Dr. Mario appeared as a separate character alongside the regular Mario in Super Smash Bros. Melee, a new fan-theory was born; what if Dr. Mario is Mario's brother? His skin is more tanned and his hair is auburn, not brown. If he is the real Mario, wouldn't he look the same?

At first, you might think "If this is true, why is his name also Mario?". Well, it's implied that Mario's surname is also Mario. (This was the case in the Super Mario Bros. movie.) Why else would Luigi and him be called the Mario Bros unless that was their last name?

Also, how come Mario NEVER demonstrates his medical abilities outside the Dr. Mario series? When he gets injured, he heals by collecting coins! What kind of medical remedy is that?!!!


5. Wario Is A Mario Fanboy

Wario BF
Nintendo

The Super Mario Land 2 instruction manual states that Wario has been jealous of Mario since they were children, which spurred him to become his arch-rival. But that doesn't mean Wario hates him.

In more recent games, he acts more like an anti-hero rather than an outright scoundrel. One theory suggests that the real reason why Wario is obsessed with Mario is because he wants to be him.

When the player first enters Wario's estate in Super Mario Land 2, you can see he has a colossal statue of Mario. Why would he have this unless he has absolutely crazy about him? He also seems to copy everything about the Italian plumber. Not only does he have a similar hat, overalls, and moustache, the final battle has Wario copying all of Mario's abilities, insinuating that he's trying to emulate him.

The sequel, Super Mario Land 3: Wario Land has Wario going on his own adventure to further imitate his supposed-rival. The fact he calls his brother "Waluigi" may be an unsubtle sign he is mocking Mario's sibling, Luigi.

Considering his name literally translates into "bad Mario", it's possible "Wario" isn't his real name and he chose it to tease his idol.


4. What Does Shy Guy Look Like?

super mario shy guy
Nintendo

Shy Guys debuted in Doki Doki Panic, which was reskinned into Super Mario Bros. 2. Excluding Birdo, Shy Guy is the only character from Doki Doki Panic to become a mainstream character in the Mario series.

Despite the fact his battle strategy in the original game was... walking, Shy Guy became popular due to his cute appearance and his enigmatic mask. Mario fans have speculated for decades on Shy Guy's true appearance.

In Yoshi's Island DS, the Shy Guy's "eyes" close when he sleeps, suggesting his "mask" is actually his face. Then again, there are some enemies like Bandit who have the ability to change the expression of their mask so Shy Guys may have the same ability. In Paper Mario: Color Splash, Mario is told he would not make a good Shy Guy because he has a face, implying these critters don't have any.

When he wins a trophy in Mario Power Tennis, Shy Guy trips, knocking his mask off. When Luigi gazes upon his true form, he is horrified by what he sees. This scene has popularised the idea that Shy Guys were created through genetic experimentation, which has left them hideously deformed.


3. Who Is Jumpman?

Jumpman Carpenter
Nintendo

Mario debuted in the 1981 game, Donkey Kong. This character is considered a prototype Mario since he has some key differences. Instead of a plumber, he is a carpenter. Also, his original name was Jumpman and his love interest was Pauline, not Peach.

Because he looks like Mario, surely it has to be the same character, right? But what if Jumpman is actually Mario's dad? The instruction manual states his name is Mario but, as has been mentioned before, there's a lot of evidence that "Mario" might be his forename and surname. As a result, his father would be called Mario as well.

Also, this incarnation of Mario has a completely different personality. According to the plot, Donkey Kong was Mario's pet who turned against his master after he was mistreated. In the sequel, Donkey Kong Jr. Mario imprisons the ape and attacks his son, who is trying to rescue his father. Does that sound like the same loveable character that's served as Nintendo's mascot for decades?

Also, this version of Donkey Kong is actually Cranky when he was young. Since Cranky is now much older, this would imply ten or twenty years have gone by. So why hasn't Mario aged a day?


2. The Coins Are Souls

New Super Mario Bros. 2
Nintendo

If you destroy an enemy in most Mario games, they will drop a coin. This is such a staple to the franchise, most gamers don't question the logistics behind it. But you know who does question it? Fan-theorists. Why are all these baddies holding coins in the first place? How does a Goomba hold onto currency? It doesn't have any arms!

At first, this inconsistency may sound like I'm overanalysing (which is a common problem with most fan-theories). But some gamers have suspected the coins are more significant than they seem.

What if all the coins contain souls? Why else would a baddie drop a coin upon their immediate death? It's common knowledge that Mario will obtain an extra Life when he obtains a hundred coins.

Maybe Mario is capable of cheating death because he is collecting an abundance of souls. It would also explain how Mario can collect thousands of coins at once without ever dropping any. He is not carrying them; he's absorbing them.

Now, you might be thinking, "But there's tons of coins in the Brick blocks and ? Blocks? Surely, they can't contain souls as well, right? Sadly, this opens up a far more horrifying theory...


1. Mario Is A Mass Murderer

Super Mario Bros 1 1
Nintendo

He may be the most popular video game character of all time but make no mistake, Mario is a killer. He has slain countless Goombas, Koopa Troopas, and Buzzy Beetles throughout his lifetime. No one is going to debate that.

But Mario hasn't just killed thousands of baddies; he's murdered innocents too. At first, you'll think, "Surely not! Mario is a true hero (who happened to kill millions of defenceless Goombas").

But according to the instruction manual of the original game, there's some truth to this claim. In Super Mario Bros., Bowser kidnapped Princess Peach, forcing Mario to traverse through the Mushroom Kingdom to rescue her.

Now, this information is common knowledge to all gamers. But even die-hard Mario fans may not know that Bowser used his sorcery to transform all the Toads of the kingdom into Brick Blocks.

Now, I don't know how many blocks Mario bashes in the first game alone but it's at least a few hundred. It's uncertain whether Mario knows the kingdom's inhabitants have been turned into blocks (although he's probably wondering where everybody is). If this part of the story is canon, Mario has taken more innocent lives than I dare count.


Watch Next


The Impossibly Hard Super Mario Quiz!

Mario Donkey Kong 1981
Nintendo

1. In Which Game Did Mario Make His First Appearance?

In this post: 
Super Mario
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

James Egan has been with Whatculture for five years and prominently works on Horror, Film, and Video Games. He's written over 80 books including 1000 Facts about Horror Movies Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about The Greatest Films Ever Made Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about Video Games Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts About James Bond 1000 Facts About TV Shows