10 Best Video Games We Never Got

Just Cause's jetpack DLC started as an Iron Man game.

iron man just cause
Avalanche Studios

Making a video game is no small feat.

In fact, whilst the numbers are impossible to source, video game cancellations are more common than one might think. Months, sometimes years, worth of work can be ripped apart by just a single issue or decision, leaving every bit of progress made in the 'what if?' category.

Time delays, poor receptions after the announcement, creative differences, technical limitations, and legal disputes - all extremely common reasons why a game might not make it very far along the development path.

Sadly though, once a video game ends up with the 'cancelled' tag, it's often very difficult to know exactly what had been going on in the background, how far along things were, and how good the title could have been.

Nevertheless, a cancelled video game isn't the same as a bad video game, and often this sense of 'what if?' gives a title more hype amongst the community than even those that did make it to the shelves. With that in mind, here are 10 of the best video games we never got to play.

10. Insane

Insane cancelled
Volition

The first in what was supposed to be a trilogy of titles, Insane was scheduled to be a survival horror for the seventh generation of consoles. Developed by Volition and slated to be published by THQ, the game was notable for being directed by Oscar winner Guillermo del Toro.

Insane was initially unveiled by Volition and del Toro in December 2010 at the Spike Video Game Awards with a thirty-second teaser trailer. Speaking about the game, the Mexican director claimed: "With this new series of video games, I want to take players to a place they have never seen before, where every single action makes them question their own senses of morality and reality."

By August 2012, however, the game was officially cancelled by THQ, who handed all the rights over to del Toro.

A full reason was never given, besides the usual corporate reshuffling, though the fact THQ were filing for bankruptcy five months later is a pretty good hint.

Del Toro still owns the property, but it's just a shame that a game that had all the possibilities of reimagining the horror genre is doomed to remain on the shelves.


9. Gotham By Gaslight

Gotham By Gaslight
Day 1 Studios

Gotham by Gaslight is a 1989 comic that marked one of the first instances of DC completely deviating from the standard universe. Set in 1889, it was a Victorian-themed story detailing how Bruce Wayne became the Dark Knight attempting to stop Jack the Ripper rampaging through Gotham.

The story would later become a 2018 movie, but it's first on-screen appearance was actually slated to be in the world of gaming.

Developed by Day 1 Studios, best known for F.E.A.R., Gotham by Gaslight was set to be a third person action title for the Xbox 360 and PS3, and slated to be released on the heels of Batman: Arkham Asylum which had come out in 2008.

It's fair to say Batman has been one of the more inconsistent franchises for gamers over the years, however, the glimpses that have been leaked of Gotham by Gaslight make the game look incredibly promising. The cobblestone streets and gothic look of Gotham make for a unique setting, and the detailed visuals on Batman showcased THQ had a solid idea on what they wanted this title to look like.

Unfortunately, this was always going to be a project the company would have a hard time getting off the ground. Without the rights from Warner Bros., THQ were forced to leave this steampunk Batman title in their 'what could have been' section.


8. Aliens: Crucible

Aliens Crucible
SEGA

Another title set for a release with the seventh generation of consoles, Aliens: Crucible was announced by SEGA in December 2006. Set to use an earlier version of the Onyx engine that would later be used on games like South Park: Stick of Truth, Crucible was going to be the first third-person RPG set in the Aliens universe.

Crucible would have followed the story of a group of workers (all of whom would have been customisable and with their own sets of strengths and weaknesses) landing on a mysterious planet called Caldera.

Writer Chris Avellone claimed the game was going to be: "It would be like basically Mass Effect but more terrifying." There would have been a lot of similarities between the game and the premise of Prometheus, and the idea of having a Mass Effect-like title with some added horror elements would have been fascinating to see.

Unfortuantely, the strained relations between developers Obsidian and SEGA, and aggressive pitching of what would become the superb Alien: Isolation, meant that Crucible was publicly cancelled following the release of Alien vs Predator in the summer of 2009.


7. Star Wars Battlefront III

Star Wars Battlefront III
LucasArts

It's in the air whether or not there will be a 'Star Wars Battlefront III' coming out as the next entry in the DICE x EA partnership, however, it's the cancelled third entry in the original LucasArts series that the fans are still clamouring for.

The two original entries in the series were released back in 2004 and 2005 respectively, and both still stand as one of the most legendary titles from the sixth generation.

Battlefront II in particular been an incredibly ambitious title for its day, bringing a new campaign, space battles, Jedi and Sith heroes and an updated range of weapons and classes, and developers Free Radical Design were keen to keep the ball rolling.

Battlefront III would have allegedly allowed players to transition from space to land battles without loading screens, a huge moment for the hardware it was set to run on.

There's been a fair amount of mud-slinging going around since Battlefront III's cancellation sometime in 2008. Developers Free Radical Design have claimed the change in creative direction from LucasArt, the need to jump on a new generation of systems and the poor reception of their previous title Haze led to the decision to put the stoppers on the project.

Steve Ellis, co-founder of Free Radical, has also claimed that the game was '99%' finished when it was canned, though this has been disputed by some.


6. Super Mario 64 2

Super Mario 64 Sequel
Nintendo

Super Mario 64 is a defining point in gaming history, and speculation over a possible sequel remains one of the most talked about topics in the industry.

Because hardly anything is known about the game, it's proven to be the number-one source of some major conspiracy theories from the Nintendo faithful over the years.

The big gimmick allegedly around Super Mario 64's sequel would have been the inclusion of multiplayer, with Luigi possibly being playable across a set of new open worlds, accessible in the same manner as the original.

New power-ups, a specific multiplayer game mode, and a rideable Yoshi were all other features that were rumoured to be in development for the game. 'Super Mario 64 2' was intended to release on the Nintendo 64DD sometime around 1999, but the commercial failure of the product meant that it was scrapped with just one stage being developed.

There were rumours that Super Mario 128 was lining up to be a sequel to Super Mario 64, however that was later shown to be a simple tech demo later used on games like Pikmin. So, whilst the likes of Sunshine, Galaxy and Odyssey especially have plenty of tie-ins to the 1996 classic, gamers are still unlikely to ever get a true Nintendo-made Super Mario 64 follow-up.


5. DOOM 4

doom 4
iD Software

Doom 4 was an interesting project that many still looked back on as the big 'what if' moment for the franchise. Following the release of Doom 3, which had ripped up the series' rulebook with a survival-horror tone and a slower pace, its sequel was announced in August 2007.

Once again developed by id Software, Kevin Cloud would prove to be one of the individuals with the most creative say behind the game's early stages. He would claim that the development of Doom 4 had emphasised 'story and scope' rather than the tried-and-tested formulas players were more used to.

Allegedly, the term 'Call of Doom' was a common tag attached to the game, referencing its similarities to Activision's Call of Duty franchise, and it was the subversion away from what fans would have wanted that would prove to be the decisive nail in the coffin for the game.

Nevertheless, from what has been leaked of Doom 4, it looks an incredibly interesting entry in the making. The game's emphasis on immersion can be seen in the clips released, with the added realism marking what could have been a fairly unique theme in the series.


4. Mega Man Universe

Mega Man Universe
Capcom

Production of Mega Man Universe first began in March 2010, however it was until April that year that rumblings of a new title began when Capcom registered the trademark. A teaser trailer was later leaked online which featured Mega Man, Ryu from Street Fighter and Arthur from Ghosts 'n Goblins, showing that Universe was intending to bring the series back to its 2D side-scrolling roots.

Taking inspiration from Mega Man 2 in terms of its story and presentation, Universe would have been Super Mario Maker, five years before it had been released. Players would have been able to build their own levels, customise existing ones with a variety of different platforming tools. They would have also been able to customise different versions of Mega Man and share their created levels online with other players.

However, following this initial teaser, communication surrounding the game dried up leading to some believing it had been canned. Capcom initially denied this, but eventually announced its cancellation in March 2011 due to 'various circumstances'.

No official reason has ever been given for the game's cancellation, but some have wondered whether the departure of Mega Man artist Keiji Inafune a few months before might have triggered a reassessment at Capcom.


3. Open-World Iron Man Game

Iron Man Open World
Marvel

Iron Man is arguably the face of the Marvel juggernaut but, even on the back of Robert Downey Jr's iconic performances, his appearances in the world of gaming have been fairly sparse.

But, this could have all been very different.

Turns out, between 2010 and 2012, Avalanche Studios - developers behind the Just Cause series - were working on an open-world Iron Man game. According to Avalanche's co-founder, Christofer Sundberg, the game would have seen players be able to "take off and just fly anywhere", before the project was ultimately pulled by Disney and Marvel.

A fan-made teaser from August 2022 using Unreal Engine 5 showed Iron Man flying about in his Mk 1 suit, with Downey Jr's likeness being used for Tony Stark. The flying mechanics look incredible in theory, and there's no doubt Avalanche would have delivered another vibrant and expansive open world for players to navigate through.

Sadly, the nearest we got was Just Cause 3 and 4's weaponised jetpack expansions, coming from Avalanche years later and playing very much like the Iron Man game the team have described.


2. Silent Hills

Silent Hills
Konami

Silent Hills is perhaps the most infamous video game to never see the light of day.

In August 2014, Konami published a free interactive demo on the PlayStation 4 Network called P.T. Designed and directed by Hideo Kojima in collaboration once again with Guillermo del Toro, it was easily one of the scariest games released at the time and served as a teaser for the upcoming latest title in the Silent Hill series.

The game was intended to be a reboot for the franchise, bringing in classic horror elements on a new generation of technology. The Walking Dead star Norman Reedus was also signed on to star in the game, and the acclaim P.T. achieved following its release made it a viral sensation.

But, it would be a game no one would ever be able to get their hands on. After three years in development, internal strife between Kojima and Konami led to him leaving the company in 2015.

Guillermo del Toro announced at the San Francisco Film Society event in April that the game had been cancelled, and P.T. was removed from the PlayStation network later that month.


1. Sadness

Sadness Wii
Nibris

The Nintendo Wii had a particular demographic in mind regarding its target audience, becoming infamous for pumping out colourful and easy-to-grasp party games rather than the triple-A spectacles on other consoles.

That is what makes Sadness still one of the most exciting games that could have joined the Wii's library, had it ever been released.

The game was announced in March 2006 by developers Nibris, and instantly stood out with its black-and-white graphics, emphasis on psychological horror rather than violence and gore, as well as its unique pre-WW1 Russia setting.

However, what followed was four years of development albeit without anything Nibris were able to show for themselves. The team were always on hand to claim more was coming - different endings and an interactive environment being the main two, but there were never any trailers, teasers or demos ever released for players to experience for themselves.

Accusations of vaporware began to be labelled at the project on the regular, though Nibris were always quick to claim it was artistic differences and a failure to meet deadlines were what was causing the game's delay. By February 2010, the project had effectively been terminated, closing one of the most interesting chapters in the Wii library's history.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Iron Man
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Horror fan, gamer, all round subpar content creator. Strongly believes that Toad is the real hero of the Mario universe, and that we've probably had enough Batman origin stories.